For example, in this issue, a major reason why some people don't do value transfer through banks directly is the banks don't really like them (for reasons), the feeling is mutual (for reasons), and other people who do not have the same POV re: banks want to give those people money in a scaled fashion, which (unless they orient their operations around a solution) will frequently involve sending out checks.
Anecdotally, I wrote a check to my landlord yesterday, because a few months back they claimed they never got the automatic bill-pay from my bank, and my bank said it was already sent, and weeks later my bank said the recipient refused to take it... Anyway, no party was ever able to tell me why an automated process that worked unattended for months suddenly stopped working for no discernible reason.
All financial infrastructure is a patched-together collection of systems spread across multiple different firms made of multiple suborgs with vastly different levels of observability into and understanding of their local part of the total system. For many routine problems, the cost of having a rigorous answer to “What just happened?” is far, far greater than the dollar amount at stake in the transaction. You’d need the equivalent of a federal agency doing an after-accident investigation to make headway, at the cost of millions.
So we chalk it up to gremlins and move on, for better or worse. (This is one reason why financial institutions have an operational losses budget. Sometimes the gremlins eat someone’s money. So you just charge it to Ops Losses and move on.)
The main thing Zelle gives us normal plebs is the ability to pay via routing numbers to businesses without incurring fees.
Possible before, easy now.
* Banks don't want to do business with these particular people because they know them to be a bad business risk. They often know, via credit reporting methods, that the specific individual human standing before them has a history of cashing bad checks/committing fraud/whatever it is. Therefore, they decline to work with that person.
* The people who are bad risks for banks get rather tired of dealing with banks, both because constant rejection is tiresome and because bank employees make it very clear (though unspoken explicitly) that they are persona non grata there. By contrast, the people at the check cashing shop treat them better, so they would rather take their financial business there.
I get why you want the explanations and not just "for reasons", but both of these points are quite clearly spelled out in the article. So I don't really think the author deserves the grief you're giving him in this case.
This wouldn't even be an issue if America didn't still rely on the utterly archaic check scheme for transferring money.
It still will be for as long as many people cannot get and maintain a free bank account that is usable for transferring funds via whatever scheme you envision replacing checks. And the property that checks have, namely that some percentage of them get unwound for various reasons and that percentage varies substantially by customer, is very hard to get rid of. As long as that property exists, access to a bank account that provides that mechanism will be an extension of credit and thus not universally available.
It's possible that a system for instant payment clearance, like FedNow, might reduce the problem of insufficient funds and similar clearance issues. However, that doesn't eliminate the possibility of bad/fraudulent/etc checks, just reduce it.
You're acting like this is some kind of futuristic concept. Are you not aware that everyone in every other country manages just fine without checks? They're only used in the US. If I went to my bank now and asked them about "cashing a check", they'd probably look at me like I had two heads. They simply don't exist.
Oh, why? Because they actually wait for it to clear. Zero fraud then.
In the US you seem to like living with options for fraud.
Even if your bank sends the cheque for collection and waits for the payor bank to confirm there’s funds there.
The cheque could have been stolen and forged, or a legitimate cheque could have been altered. There’s even an example up-thread of a bank recycling account numbers. The owner of the bank account it’s drawn against can take weeks or months to notice that the fraud has happened, and when they do the transaction can be unwound leaving your bank liable to return the value of the cheque.
When I used to deposit US cheques regularly in the UK, I’d be offered the choice between “negotiation” (we assume the cheque is good and will pay it this week) and “collection” (we’ll send the cheque back to the US and only pay you when we collect the money weeks later), but in both cases there was language on the form making it clear that they could pull the money back up to years later if something went wrong.
There’s literally no way of implementing cheques—-or most other payment rails—-without someone, somewhere choosing to extend credit and deciding to take on that risk.
Tbh I think you can still pay by (local) cheque even here but you need to go to the bank and sign something in blood to get them. And not sure if anyone actually takes them any more.
They may have been used for B2B with 30-60-90 day payment terms 15-20 years ago.
No, I'm not. I'm well aware of how other countries operate, as well as proposals for upcoming systems in the US.
I'm observing that the article we're currently discussing talks about multiple sources of issues with checks, and immediate-clearing electronic systems solve some but not all of them.
Immediate clearing systems eliminate NSF issues: a check will never bounce, it'll get cleared immediately or rejected immediately. This is a great thing and I'm looking forward to it. It'll be a massive reduction in fees and hassle for many people.
Immediate clearing systems do not eliminate the problem of the purported originator of the check disputing/rejecting/etc the check payment and the originating bank clawing back the payment. There are any number of reasons for that, some of them legitimate. The article mentions some of them, and there are more.
I am not making an argument against immediate clearing systems; on the contrary, I think they're an incredible good idea. I'm observing that they are not, in fact, a panacea that on its own will completely eliminate the reasons why people are unbanked or underbanked.
The problem is poor people would need to pay for their bank (as banks need to make money other ways and from the middle class that will be credit cards and mortgages etc.)
When this feeling occurs, why is the next step "wow the US sucks" instead of "there must be some good reason that I don't understand."
Same way that a country that never had anything before now won’t run copper telephone wires, and instead go directly to fiber backboned wireless.
Ironically India has a very significant amount of transactions cashless/electronic, pushed by demonetization and later covid. The government has been pushing hard for it for a while and I think they succeeded.
Uruguay is another economy which has gone all-in on cashless, shops and cafes had to offer 10% discount for card transactions when I was there 8 years ago, the idea was to beat out the tax-avoidance.
Of course, I don't try to pay by check in a store. (Though I did write about a $30K check when I bought my last car and that wasn't a problem either--assume they have back-end systems to verify.) Getting rid of checks just isn't a problem I care about or want to devote any mental bandwidth to.
You don't care because you're an issuer, and a net beneficiary of retention of the funds in your control for those extra days of clearing.
I've never been told cash, but if I was, I would be happy to pay in cash.
Also, saying that those people messed up in their financial management is sort of blaming their poverty on them, while we can't know (in general) whether that's their fault or not.
This is only applicable to the unbanked, for the most part. Regular banks make funds immediately available when a check is deposited. Unless you're already on their radar for kiting.
Seriously, I don't think people in this thread appreciate just how practical and efficient pix is. Adoption is essentially universal across the population, and we are talking about a poor country.
There are a variety of systems in many countries, the key difference with Pix is that it is very modern and relatively mobile-first. There are not many other such systems in the world yet. How easy is it to pay without a phone? Or without internet? I regularly make payments in places where there is nearly zero cell signal.
Pix charges fees, too, to merchants.
Is Pix guaranteed to be supported by every bank? The mandate certainly doesn't seem to require it, but I'll take your word.
I think the reason that people in this thread don't appear to "appreciate just how practical and efficient pix is" is simply because it's not very relevant. Sending and receiving money isn't particularly annoying in the US. Nor is accepting payments (merchant fees aside -- that's a whole different topic that I am sure patio11 has explored). I am sure that if Pix or something like it was widely available in the US, folks would be singing its praise too. But it's not particularly compelling when most people aren't even aware that something is or could be lacking in the current system.
I presume they do some basic checks, but it’s really all down to trusting it’ll all come out eventually.
They’d much rather have a check than 30k in hundreds.
There are already 400 participants who have signed on in less than a year of the network being live [3] (the list includes Chase Bank and the US Treasury), and the CFPB is already getting in front of financial institutions attempting to charge insufficient funds fees for instant payments when unnecessary [4]. There are substantial entrenched interests fighting it (The Clearinghouse and their competing private RTP network, credit card rails, etc) due to the revenue at stake (~3-5% of the economy running through this FinInfra), but as long as the infra uptake continues and it isn't sabotaged by policy and lobbying, it will deliver more efficient value transfer at scale. Also helps when merchants surcharge credit card rail payments when cheaper alternatives are enabled.
Tangentially, the unbanked stand at ~4.5% in the US per the Fed [5]. That should be driven to as close to 0% as possible, which instant payments contributes towards (getting funds to recipients faster with less float and necessitating less or no credit extension, depending on use case).
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36801491
[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
[3] https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/organi...
[4] https://www.pymnts.com/news/cfpb/2024/cfpb-proposes-banning-...
[5] https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unified_Payments_Interface
[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pix_(payment_system)
(humorously, you mention it's very "Indian" when UPI [India's instant payment system] is probably the gold standard success story [6] alongside Pix [7] in Brazil)
PayPal was around $290 / share in August 2021. Now $63 / share. Their business got larger in that time, not smaller. The market is front-running the end of the necessity (or general usefulness) of services like PayPal in the US. The stock is back to where it was in 2017, when PayPal was a far smaller business, and it's now trading for 14 times operating income. They better find a new, large business, fast.
Good riddance. Come for Visa and Mastercard next. $57B in combined revenue in 2023.
The belief must be that credit cards will retain their utility (purchase protection being one), both in the US and globally.
I would expect Visa's extraordinary margins to get damaged by FedNow.
“There's no particular reason why this kind of financial intermediation should be a $100 billion industry, rife with inefficiencies.”
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36012866
https://www.axios.com/2023/07/22/fednow-instant-payments-cre...
https://www.usbank.com/corporate-and-commercial-banking/cfo-...
https://www.moderntreasury.com/journal/bank-payments-as-a-cr...
Mastercard/Visa is a huge thing here in retail but PayPal is really niche. No app leveraging the instant wire transfers is getting much traction. The network effects are huge and the card fees apparently aren't that high.
They had to compete with banks and Zelle, and did fine. I think Zelle is doomed.
https://www.narmi.com/insights/getting-real-about-real-time-...
> Zelle is an example of a P2P option, but with one major difference from those outlined below; its transactions can be cleared via The Clearing House’s RTP rail. If both the payee and the recipient use banks that leverage the RTP rail, the transaction will settle instantly. If not, it will typically settle in a matter of minutes. Since users can send money to recipients outside of their bank and the funds settle in real-time (or nearly), it is considered to be an open (rather than closed) loop payment.
> Notably, Zelle has seen massive growth since its launch in 2017 and is now available to nearly 80% of the U.S. population, with adoption by over 1,600 financial institutions. Similar to The Clearing House, Early Warning Services (owner of Zelle) is privately held by 7 major banks.
https://danakivis.medium.com/the-state-of-faster-payments-in...
Catching up with 54 other nation states really sums it up. That flywheel has been revving up since 1871. Slow start.
And yes, it is unfair to compare US financials to Indian bureaucracy in the wide: Indian financials are innovative. They "got" money early on.
The what? I don't know what you're getting at with this.
> Checking for forgery, active forgery presumably underway
I learned just last week that forged cashier's checks are a risk, which you can get burned by even if your bank makes the mistake. Forged Cashier's checks! Insane. The whole purpose of those is to ensure the money exists before issuing.
I remember with some clarity the moment that Chase Bank suggested that a letter of reference from my bank in Canada might ease matters and they'd just hold my check some extra time for their troubles. And I thought: I don't need to continue at this bank. There is a better than even chance that I can find a bank that treats me better than this.
That's what "you're not from around here" looks like.
Problem is most business checks are written against business banks.
That does not universally eliminate "you're not from around here". Anecdotally, some banks will fingerprint people who show up with a check from that bank if they don't already have an account at that bank.
When I moved to a new place, I couldn't pay for anything with a check because I still had my old address printed on the checks and most stores wouldn't accept checks with an out-of-state address printed on it. This was ~18 years ago, so things may be different.
What systems to handle it?
The cashier puts the check under the cash tray like you do for $100 bills, and then you toss the check in the cash bag that you send to the bank that night or at the end of the week or whatever, and the bank handles the check.
I guess I was doing it to service providers rather than stores though - most stores would much rather have had a card payment even back then.
I have a neighbor with a hobby of accepting and depositing forged cashier's checks from people who want to "buy" a car from him or do some other scam. He knows the checks will be counterfeit, so he leaves the money in his account to cover the the deposit and the $5 returned check fee. Then he posts them here:
In some places its "keep money local" and in others its probably confidence they won't be left holding the baby in a scam.
UK check guarantee cards helped solve some of this by security pantomime.
Domestic checks barely exist either, the only way you'll ever see one is if the government owes you money for some reason but you haven't told them what your bank account number is.
You see a lot of people outside of the US try to talk about the US while having zero first-hand experience or real knowledge of it. It's very common behavior on HN and it's very common behavior on Reddit. They just repeat what someone else said as though it were automatically true.
My town charges a premium for tax payments on the web because they outsource it. So, yes, I pay by check.
Zelle? 2k+ banks and credit unions support it.
Even when cheques were used here, they often wouldn't accept cheques and would insist on cash because they didn't want the hassle of cashing cheques especially for such relatively low value transactions. Maybe if you were redoing your heating system they might take one, but a maintenence callout? Nah.
"By number, checks declined at a rate of 7.2 percent per year since 2018, dropping to 11.2 billion [in 2021]."
That's about 35 per person per year.
It seems to be around 1.2 billion in France (17 per person), around 100 million in Italy, and much, much less in the other EU countries.
Overall for the EU excluding France about 0.25 per person.
https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fr-payments-st...
https://www.statista.com/statistics/443677/cashless-payment-...
I don’t doubt that you can reduce risk by e.g. using novel infrastructure which looks up the account number on the check then uses (for example) a debit card network to check the account’s currently available balance. However, even if you were looking at someone’s balance on their mobile app while they were writing the check to you, that would not suffice to guarantee that the check would not be returned as NSF. The bank can choose to NSF it for a variety of reasons, for example if they prioritize “today’s” debit card transactions over “today’s” checks in the posting order, or a check previously deposited (and included in that available balance) gets NSFed and yanked back by another bank.
slowness is a feature, not a bug, in some social situations. Most modern Americans have not experienced that kind of situation. One of the elements missing here is control - who has control over the transaction, and what are the practical methods to resolve dispute.
Cash is not great at scale perhaps, but it is great for the individual in times when trust is gone, where there is unequal power relationship, and where there is real corruption inserted into ordinary transactions.
As an American with some knowledge of history, I support cash, paper checks, and electronic transfer. without a doubt.
At every scale from muggings to home robbery to retail store robberies up to bank robbery and knocking over armored cars, cash handling imposes a security and risk management burden, with a particular component of risk of physical violence that is much less of a factor in electronic security risk models..
Or perhaps you're saying which one to use depends on what you want? But if there's an unequal power relationship, the person with more power (probably the payer) will usually choose. So to fix that, it's not enough for cash to be an option, checks need to not be an option. (Electronic transfers can be an option, as long as they're set up so that the payer can't unilaterally take the money back.)
In my own experience I have negotiated sales or contracts with others for non-trivial sums. It feels like most modern people are just going along with systems that require an intermediary and working devices. I feel it is not only important, but crucial, to have the ability to negotiate directly with a peer or others. That means without electricity or cell phone coverage, too. YMMV
one surprising use of a check is that one could write five checks, each with an amount and further away date.. e.g. dated the first of the month for the next four months. Those checks are now a reliable source for a loan in cash, since you signed each one. there are many other examples..
that is absolutely false IANAL
they say a Federal Bank can do that. I was talking about contracts between private parties (see above)
you neglected to say "bank" .. you said it as if anyone can do it. Look at what you wrote
In America, it's not like Indian bureaucracy levels of insane slowness.
It has always confused me how simultaneously the US money system is operating in the most advanced interconnected economy imaginable which fosters innovation (bankruptcy laws in the US are designed to make it easy to try again, they encourage entrepreneurship) and yet.. the whole credit union, banking crash, over inflated economy has made them retain unbelievably archaic approaches to money on paper.
Checking for forgery, active forgery presumably underway, 3+ day clearing, "you're not from round here" risks, It's just insane.
Go to walmart, buy a stored value card, you can do dollar events with zero friction but present a cheque at the counter, and you're in the slow path.
It's positively ... Indian. It's like mainstream Indian bureaucracy levels of insane slowness. It's even had films with Whoopi Goldberg made about it (she is a cheque processor in some movie, doing it by hand at a 1970s vintage cheque processing machine. I think its "made in america" with Ted Danson)