News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The business of check cashing by patio11 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:25PM (#39197426)
A thing I try to keep as a through line in discussing legacy infrastructure, and checks in the U.S. are definitely legacy infrastructure, is both a) how we ended up here despite later-generation systems getting to leapfrog off what earlier-ones learned and b) why people still use wlog checks instead of going with other methods that they could also choose to use, in 2024.

For example, in this issue, a major reason why some people don't do value transfer through banks directly is the banks don't really like them (for reasons), the feeling is mutual (for reasons), and other people who do not have the same POV re: banks want to give those people money in a scaled fashion, which (unless they orient their operations around a solution) will frequently involve sending out checks.

Re:The business of check cashing by Terr_ on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @08:02PM (#39198342)
> why people still use wlog [?] checks instead of going with other methods that they could also choose to use, in 2024.

Anecdotally, I wrote a check to my landlord yesterday, because a few months back they claimed they never got the automatic bill-pay from my bank, and my bank said it was already sent, and weeks later my bank said the recipient refused to take it... Anyway, no party was ever able to tell me why an automated process that worked unattended for months suddenly stopped working for no discernible reason.

Re:The business of check cashing by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @08:27PM (#39198535)
I write checks to my handyman, because he takes either check or Venmo. And Venmo refuses to validate my bank account. I never see the test deposit show up, and on the Venmo side it just says "try again later". So, checks it is. Say what you will about writing checks, but they are reliable in a way that digital payments aren't.
Re:The business of check cashing by supertrope on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:20PM (#39199881)
Bill pay adds several middlemen. Before there was each party’s bank and the postal service. Now there’s the bank’s bill pay department which is sometimes contracted out. The actual printing and mailing of the check is usually contracted out. The bill pay service sometimes tries to be smart about binding an address to a name and sometimes autocorrects to the wrong address. Finally checks always have human error on the part of the two meat bags that are the payer and payee (threw out envelope or let it fall off their table and under a couch).
Re:The business of check cashing by niij on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @12:09AM (#39200204)
Bill Pay systems just mail checks?
Re:The business of check cashing by ZekeSulastin on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @12:15AM (#39200243)
That's usually the fallback method in case they can't find some way to do an electronic transfer.
Re:The business of check cashing by JoshTriplett on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @01:17AM (#39200600)
That's the last-ditch method for making sure they can pay anyone. My bank lets me pay anyone via online bill pay, some of whom have registered with the bank in a manner that allows fast transfers, and some of whom get mailed a check that may take up to 5 days to arrive.
Re:The business of check cashing by JoshTriplett on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @01:16AM (#39200593)
WLOG means "without loss of generality". Originally from mathematics; a proof by division into cases may say something like "assume, without loss of generality, that X is even ..."; WLOG flags a statement that applies just as well to other cases with obvious analogous changes. As generalized to non-mathematical writing, WLOG means "I could make an obvious analogous statement here about similar things for similar reasons".
Re:The business of check cashing by patio11 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @06:06AM (#39202384)
“Gremlins.”

All financial infrastructure is a patched-together collection of systems spread across multiple different firms made of multiple suborgs with vastly different levels of observability into and understanding of their local part of the total system. For many routine problems, the cost of having a rigorous answer to “What just happened?” is far, far greater than the dollar amount at stake in the transaction. You’d need the equivalent of a federal agency doing an after-accident investigation to make headway, at the cost of millions.

So we chalk it up to gremlins and move on, for better or worse. (This is one reason why financial institutions have an operational losses budget. Sometimes the gremlins eat someone’s money. So you just charge it to Ops Losses and move on.)

Re:The business of check cashing by eep_social on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @08:03PM (#39198353)
The banks didn’t do themselves any favors with Zelle either. All they had to do was make a nice copy of paypal/venmo/cashapp/etc but they inexplicably did not, and now we have the meme that Zelle is mostly fraud. In my experience the implementations are horrific and don’t integrate with anything else my bank is doing so I do t feel comfortable pushing people to use it rather than paypal or venmo.
Re:The business of check cashing by bombcar on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:41PM (#39199554)
As a payment method approaches irreversibility it attracts more and more fraud.

The main thing Zelle gives us normal plebs is the ability to pay via routing numbers to businesses without incurring fees.

Possible before, easy now.

Re:The business of check cashing by ggm on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:36PM (#39197547)
"for reasons" is doing all the heavy lifting here. I think the whole point of this series is to lift the tablecloth a bit and look at the dust bunnies underneath.
Re:The business of check cashing by Swizec on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:35PM (#39198099)
Just in case you didn't notice: patio11, author of the comment you're replying to, is also the author behind BitsAboutMoney, the source of this article/series.
Re:The business of check cashing by ggm on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @09:53PM (#39199202)
Thank you I did not realise. But, noting that I don't think it alters the intent of my comment much. For reasons
Re:The business of check cashing by adolph on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:05PM (#39199297)
Heh, I didn’t notice it was him but when scanning through the comment noticed the “(for reasons)” and was wondering if that was some subcultural or regional dialect that so perfectly mimicked patio11.
Re:The business of check cashing by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:42PM (#39199561)
He does that. He's simply eliding the explanation in his comment here, because he explained both of those things in the article. The "reasons" he elided are:

* Banks don't want to do business with these particular people because they know them to be a bad business risk. They often know, via credit reporting methods, that the specific individual human standing before them has a history of cashing bad checks/committing fraud/whatever it is. Therefore, they decline to work with that person.

* The people who are bad risks for banks get rather tired of dealing with banks, both because constant rejection is tiresome and because bank employees make it very clear (though unspoken explicitly) that they are persona non grata there. By contrast, the people at the check cashing shop treat them better, so they would rather take their financial business there.

I get why you want the explanations and not just "for reasons", but both of these points are quite clearly spelled out in the article. So I don't really think the author deserves the grief you're giving him in this case.

Re:The business of check cashing by shiroiuma on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:13PM (#39199818)
>They often know, via credit reporting methods, that the specific individual human standing before them has a history of cashing bad checks/committing fraud/whatever it is.

This wouldn't even be an issue if America didn't still rely on the utterly archaic check scheme for transferring money.

Re:The business of check cashing by JoshTriplett on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @01:12AM (#39200572)
> This wouldn't even be an issue if America didn't still rely on the utterly archaic check scheme for transferring money.

It still will be for as long as many people cannot get and maintain a free bank account that is usable for transferring funds via whatever scheme you envision replacing checks. And the property that checks have, namely that some percentage of them get unwound for various reasons and that percentage varies substantially by customer, is very hard to get rid of. As long as that property exists, access to a bank account that provides that mechanism will be an extension of credit and thus not universally available.

It's possible that a system for instant payment clearance, like FedNow, might reduce the problem of insufficient funds and similar clearance issues. However, that doesn't eliminate the possibility of bad/fraudulent/etc checks, just reduce it.

Re:The business of check cashing by shiroiuma on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @03:28AM (#39201403)
>whatever scheme you envision replacing checks.

You're acting like this is some kind of futuristic concept. Are you not aware that everyone in every other country manages just fine without checks? They're only used in the US. If I went to my bank now and asked them about "cashing a check", they'd probably look at me like I had two heads. They simply don't exist.

Re:The business of check cashing by Symbiote on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @04:06AM (#39201634)
Oh, your bank knows about cashing American cheques (or British or I think French ones, though they're much less common). It's on their table of fees, and costs €20.
Re:The business of check cashing by nottorp on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @04:32AM (#39201807)
I would never accept to be paid by an American cheque because it will take months to get the money.

Oh, why? Because they actually wait for it to clear. Zero fraud then.

In the US you seem to like living with options for fraud.

Re:The business of check cashing by sveiss on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @12:07PM (#39206277)
Less fraud, not zero fraud.

Even if your bank sends the cheque for collection and waits for the payor bank to confirm there’s funds there.

The cheque could have been stolen and forged, or a legitimate cheque could have been altered. There’s even an example up-thread of a bank recycling account numbers. The owner of the bank account it’s drawn against can take weeks or months to notice that the fraud has happened, and when they do the transaction can be unwound leaving your bank liable to return the value of the cheque.

When I used to deposit US cheques regularly in the UK, I’d be offered the choice between “negotiation” (we assume the cheque is good and will pay it this week) and “collection” (we’ll send the cheque back to the US and only pay you when we collect the money weeks later), but in both cases there was language on the form making it clear that they could pull the money back up to years later if something went wrong.

There’s literally no way of implementing cheques—-or most other payment rails—-without someone, somewhere choosing to extend credit and deciding to take on that risk.

Re:The business of check cashing by nottorp on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @01:17PM (#39207312)
Maybe. I've never taken one and only one client ever asked me if i can take one.

Tbh I think you can still pay by (local) cheque even here but you need to go to the bank and sign something in blood to get them. And not sure if anyone actually takes them any more.

They may have been used for B2B with 30-60-90 day payment terms 15-20 years ago.

Re:The business of check cashing by JoshTriplett on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @05:07AM (#39201992)
> You're acting like this is some kind of futuristic concept.

No, I'm not. I'm well aware of how other countries operate, as well as proposals for upcoming systems in the US.

I'm observing that the article we're currently discussing talks about multiple sources of issues with checks, and immediate-clearing electronic systems solve some but not all of them.

Immediate clearing systems eliminate NSF issues: a check will never bounce, it'll get cleared immediately or rejected immediately. This is a great thing and I'm looking forward to it. It'll be a massive reduction in fees and hassle for many people.

Immediate clearing systems do not eliminate the problem of the purported originator of the check disputing/rejecting/etc the check payment and the originating bank clawing back the payment. There are any number of reasons for that, some of them legitimate. The article mentions some of them, and there are more.

I am not making an argument against immediate clearing systems; on the contrary, I think they're an incredible good idea. I'm observing that they are not, in fact, a panacea that on its own will completely eliminate the reasons why people are unbanked or underbanked.

Re:The business of check cashing by quickthrower2 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @06:35AM (#39202576)
But the dust bunnies are with cheques. There is no bounce risk with a bank transfer. There is no identity risk. The money goes or it doesn’t. There is fraud risk, money laundering and terrorism etc. “risk” (airquotes because, HSBC) But most of the shit it is gone with a bank transfer.

The problem is poor people would need to pay for their bank (as banks need to make money other ways and from the middle class that will be credit cards and mortgages etc.)