Re:The business of check cashing
by alright2565 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @08:19PM
(#39198476)
In situations like this, where it's me and a small business, I very explicitly ask how the recipient would like to be paid.
I've never been told cash, but if I was, I would be happy to pay in cash.
I have rarely had individuals who want to get paid in cash (off the books). But although some businesses like my furnace company are slowly switching over to having portable terminals, in my experience, checks are still the default around where I live in the US for service people and the like. (And, as I wrote elsewhere, even things like local tax payments can have outsourced third-party websites which charge a fee so it can be materially cheaper to pay by check.)
Even as a receiver of checks, I don't care. It's easier to deposit than cash or PayPal. Zelle is nicer, but if I can't wait three days for the money, I already messed up in my financial management.
As the article describes, it may be convenient for you, but for many people it's inconvenient and costly to cash a check.
Also, saying that those people messed up in their financial management is sort of blaming their poverty on them, while we can't know (in general) whether that's their fault or not.
If I'm paying them in person and a check is a problem I expect them to tell me and I'll pay them in cash is that's reasonable such as for already-completed work. But I'm not mailing cash or diddling around with other random payment mechanisms.
Nobody is asking you, specifically, to do anything. But your original point was that checks aren't a problem for you. My point is just that as the article describes, for those without a bank account it does pose problems, and so assuming you do have a bank account, "worksforme" is not a very substantive comment, since the article also already acknowledges that.
So paying in cash seems the most straightforward mechanism in that case. Which is fine in-person if checks don't work for some reason.
Sure, I use them myself as a consumer. Not frequently but I get refund checks etc. for various reasons. They take a minute to deposit with my banking app. Would I want to go back to doing bills every week with checks and mailing them? Of course not. But dealing with one now and then just isn't a problem.And for the generally small amounts involved, a few days of clearing generally just doesn't matter.
Re:The business of check cashing
by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:25PM
(#39198019)
> make other people wear the 3 day clearing delay
This is only applicable to the unbanked, for the most part. Regular banks make funds immediately available when a check is deposited. Unless you're already on their radar for kiting.
You don't care because you're an issuer, and a net beneficiary of retention of the funds in your control for those extra days of clearing.