Before, Lithium was important, but not nearly in the quantities needed for EV's. Now that EV's have picked up, more people will be looking for Lithium, and that will make all the difference.
There are plenty of known deposits of unknown size and quality. They are just by definition not included in the reserve. As demand grows those will be explored and included in the total count.
We just weren't looking very hard to find lithium compared to lead till very recently.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_elements_in_Earth...
If all of world's bauxite reserves ran dry, we would move to the next best sources, and this would impact aluminum prices less than typical yearly variations in electricity costs near smelters.
Nearly all aluminum minerals are potential ores for aluminum, the only question is how much other, undesirable material (mostly silica) you need to remove. Bauxite is nice because nature did a lot of the early separation process steps (slightly acidic rains washed away silica over millennia).
It's very hard to find anything volatile in nature, pretty much by definition. Exceptions are things that are continually generated, eg you can find reactive oxygen in nature because plants keep making more. That or things that are only volatile once you purify or transform them in some way.
In 1880 peak oil was expected to be 1910. In 1910 it was 1940. In 1940 it became 1970. Etc.
Basically we kept finding more and more as technology and practical prospecting experience advanced.
https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=PET&s=M...
EDIT: To be clear, I am responding to a specific, narrow idea implied by the parent comment: that there was a prediction of peak oil in 1970, and that that prediction failed. I wanted to clarify the history. I know that global oil production continued to increase.
It chaps endlessly that thousands of climate researchers spend decades of their live researching the problem, often going to inhospitable places for months at a time to collect data. Papers are written, conferences are held, and conservative summaries produced. Yet some dingleberry paid for by the Koch brothers (having done no research and having written no papers) will say, "Nuh uh, their predictions are wrong again, they are being paid by Soros" or some other BS, and a large portion of the pubic believes them over the tens of thousands of man-years of research.
EDIT: to make this more substantive, potholer54 is a youtuber who mostly debunks climate change denier claims. Why should you listen to him? In his own words, "Don't, you can do it yourself by reading primary sources." Unlike people like Anthony Watt (popular and influential climate denier) who spout claims and provide no sources, potholer provides links to all of his sources. He is a sober person, not a bomb-thrower. Not that it matters, but he has a degree in geology and has spent his life as a science reporter. He makes no money off his channel and spends the time researching because climate change denial is a severe problem.
Here is a good starter video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ugwqXKHLrGk
Not that it matters. If we burn what we’ve already discovered, we’ll already be completely fucked from a greenhouse gas perspective.
The holocene is an incredibly small period compared to the age of the Earth. Nature doesn't gaf, it'll cycle in and out and we'll have to adapt.
It's probable that very few species will be able to adapt to such an abrupt change.
See [1], that xkcd is picking a really biased starting point by using the last ice age as a baseline. Ice ages themselves being extreme abnormalities from the general historic trend.
1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Global-Temperature-and-C...
The rise of mammals happened almost immediately after the extinction of dinosaurs, when the average surface temperature was around 10°C hotter than today.
My understanding: At the moment, climate projections are that within the next few centuries we will reach temperatures not seen since the eocene. The mammals of the eocene were quite small, because larger mammals had trouble surviving the hot climate. While the broad categories of animals that still exist today also existed back then, in aggregate they looked very different from today. Given current trends, the majority of animals of today will be unable to adapt to the new climate, and will die off.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, and then also follow that up with correcting the scientific consensus of experts who are forecasting drastic and damaging changes to the earth caused by humans.
> At the moment, climate projections are that within the next few centuries we will reach temperatures not seen since the eocene.
That seems about right, see e.g.: https://www.marum.de/en/Dr.-thomas-westerhold/CENOGRID.html
> The mammals of the eocene were quite small, because larger mammals had trouble surviving the hot climate.
What makes you think mammal size was limited by the temperature differences we're discussing?
I think the predominant theory is that the asteroid impact killed off the larger ones, and it took a while for larger mammals to evolve. See e.g.: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7645244/
In any case, even if the Earth as a whole was much warmer on average that just means that you'd get the average temperatures that now occur closer to the equator (where some of the largest land mammals presently live) closer to the poles.
So higher average surface temperatures shouldn't preclude the existence of larger mammals.
> Given current trends, the majority of animals of today will be unable to adapt to the new climate, and will die off.
I think this has less to do with climate change per-se, and more to do with the widespread ecological destruction that's followed industrialization, and the reduction in wild habitats.
Although there's surely some species that'll go extinct mainly due to temperature changes, e.g. ones confined to a small atoll that'll get overrun by sea levels rising.
But some get pedantic and ask "But isnt number of Oil molecules in earth finite?"
Such pedantism can be easily blowm away by responding with pedantism. Oil molecules on "earth" might be finite but in universe they are infinite. Even if the molecules are finite atoms of Carbon and Hydrogen are vastly infinite in universe. We already know how to merge these atoms to form hydrocarbons.
These arguments then get into the saner territory of "but isnt it too expensive to bring water from Jupiter and turn it into Oil on moon and then ship it to earth?", yes it is compared to fracking but fracking was considered too expensive compared to drilling which was considered too expensive compared to using mined coal etc.
Ignore existence and focus on "production". As far as production is concerned we are not going to run out of oil ever. Unless we stop "needing" it.
Really, fracking was a second chance. A reprieve.
We'll just be behind 8-ball again if we don't take this reprieve and grow some other energy source.
Parts that cannot be down for more than a week, or bad things happen, and which by virtual of volume have limited storage capacity (at normal consumption rates).
Consequently, US energy independence is about creating a credible detachment of the US from global market oil prices, such that countries thinking of using an oil embargo to pressure the US... don't.
In reality, oil embargos obviously impose immediate and intermediate term costs on the exporters as well, so doing a painful thing that the US might be able to blunt anyway becomes less attractive.
In the 70's when the US was NOT producing enough.
Then OPEC had a 'monopoly' or at least an outsized influence. A large enough % of the market that they could dominate the price.
Right now we are NOT at the 'whim' because we can produce more if we need it. IF we stopped, then we would return to being at their 'whim'.
Solar, Wind, anything, is all very important for National Security. See Germany.
They started shutting down nuclear, to make switch to wind/solar, before Russia invaded. (or at least being very trusting of Russian supply, so that is error in hindsight).
You could make argument that the switch to wind/solar should have been more gradual, or with more ability to roll back. But don't think it is a good argument to not switch to wind/solar. Just about how to do it.
The same wind turbine in the scotland produces 3 to five times more power than in Germany
The same solar panel produces 3 times more power in Spanish winter than in German winter.
This is basic information available to anyone
https://globalsolaratlas.info/
But fine, you decided to do energy transition inefficiently.
At least don’t switch of nuclear while you are still relying on fossil fuels!
But yes, have a better fall back position.
Simply take the price of a typical modern 1.5GW electric reactor from somebody like South Korea. Calculate how many you need in Germany, add up the cost. And that's not even taking into account the cost savings you could get from building a large number of the same plants.
You end up with a number significantly less then what Germany has spend over the last 25 years, will spend the next 20 and has spent on energy subsidies because of their high electricity prices.
For example, India banned onion exports this year [1] & the US has restricted oil exports before. [2]
Moreover, without officially banning exports a similar result can be achieved by mixing exports taxes with consumption subsidies.
If international oil prices got too high, like over $200, the political pressure for an oil export ban / restriction than made domestic prices $50-$100 would be hard for congress to tolerate.
[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/asia-feels-sting-...
[2] https://ballotpedia.org/Crude_oil_export_ban#:~:text=The%20c....
Energy independence is vastly preferable to waging war, and may be worth making some environmental tradeoffs for — even if we would like to see cleaner alternatives to fracking in the long run.
Environmental collapse will lead to wars, so this statement is self-contradicting.
In fact the sooner we run out of oil, the better - high oil prices mean that any alternative will get huge investment. France built out nuclear due to an oil price shock.
“European countries are estimated to have spent additional 792 billion euros in the last year just on the status quo system to protect consumers from the effects of the energy crisis introduced by the Russian invasion into Ukraine”
Honestly I think building solar and wind farms in Europe would do more for America’s military power than more tanks.
That’s probably a long time from now though, as they are expanding LNG regasification terminals (6 projects that I’m aware of) since the pipelines from Russia became unavailable.
If it is about getting low price energy, then integration with the global system is unavoidable, no matter how many domestic export bans you enact, etc. - you will be impacted by global energy prices.
Think of it like this. How many oil producers do we have a problem with? That are dictators, at war, or generally bad. Every time we buy gas, we give them money. We send trillions of dollars to our enemies.
It is such an overwhelming National Security issue, that I'm frankly surprised Republicans fought renewable energy for so long. Oil isn't going to last forever. We should have been throwing resources at our own internal energy R&D. .
(Americans hate inflation so much they preferred the Volcker recession in the 70s, which is what caused the deindustrialization, which is what caused things to move to Asia.)
You are going back to old Adam Smith.
Let places/people that can make things more efficiently, do them.
Example: Don't give subsidies to car companies in countries that aren't good at making cars, it is inefficient. Better to focus on what you are good at.
There are exceptions:
National Security. See Energy, Semi-conductors.
or
To protect an industry while it grows, gets up to speed. Japan didn't become industrial power house out of nothing, they were very protectionist. Now they are dominant, but they aren't dominant because they let anybody at all come in and compete. They subsidized and protected their industry until they could stand on their own.
That said, even with process efficiency improvements like electrolytic cracking, the number of useful Calories we extract per Calorie of input has declined over time. More and more of the fossil fuels we produce are going into producing the next unit of fuel, which is a little harder to retrieve than the ones from last month.
what happens is that because the price goes up and the margins potentially increase, more investment is tolerable for more expensive extraction methods
That was certainly true of oil. As reserves got depleted, progressively more advanced techniques allowed people to extract from more difficult locations.
Maybe you meant that, but it’s worth stating outright, as no amount of money can fix that.
Let's not be fooled again!
However what's actually happening is that demand is going up, but at a rate slower than before. Imagine that in 2022 demand increased by 60% YoY but in 2023 demand only increased by 40% YoY (these are approximate figures). You are measuring the second derivative which is decreasing from a big positive value to a smaller positive value, which is not usually described by the word "slow". Intuitively "slow" means the second derivative has become negative.
Increasing position less fast is the definition of slowing down, as I said. Increasing speed less fast is, of course, not the definition of slowing down, it's decelerating; we agree on this.
But you are equating demand to "speed" (rate-of-change of position), and I am equating demand to "position" (not a rate-of-change). If demand is analogous to speed, then what is is measuring the rate-of-change of?
Acceleration decreased such that it is negative. Negative acceleration is "slowing down."
Ok, let’s substitute that into the original comment, instead of:
> demand has slowed down recently
we get:
> speed has slowed down recently
Nothing to do with the rate of change of speed, just speed itself. In other words:
In terms of _speed_, this would indicate that _speed_ was once higher and is now lower.
Let’s translate that same sentence back substituting speed with demand:
In terms of _demand_, this would indicate that _demand_ was once higher and is now lower.
That statement cannot be true as 2023 demand was the highest ever.
Where it could be different is in places like power generation. You might talk about peak demand in Watts, and daily demand in watt-hours.
https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/global...
> LONDON, Dec 12 (Reuters) - Global sales of battery electric vehicles (BEV) and plug-in hybrids (PHEV) rose 20% versus a year ago as strong growth in North America and China offset lower sales in Europe, according to market research firm Rho Motion.
Because turning resources into reserves is expensive only a limited amount is done before it is mined.
"What you think is out there" differs from resource in that a honest answer to the former would need to involve doing a lot of statistics on the 99+% of "empty space" of earth's crust that could potentially be exploited but that has not been explored, based on the data points you have of the areas that you have explored.
While resource refers to specific deposits that someone has done work on to show they exist, not the best estimate of how much material is there to be mined.
Sorry for being nitpicky, but people on the internet constantly get this wrong. No-one maintains a number for "how much lithium (or oil, or any other material) we believe there remains to be mined", and every number that occasionally gets misused to represent that is off by multiple orders of magnitude.
If Thailand has 14M and there are two others with >14M then total known resources must be at least 42M tons, no?
Those people are probably using different prices, and not communicating them.
YC Summer 24?
Lithium can be a lot more prevalent in some waters, they are already competitive commercial mining operations from briny lake beds. Utah's Salt Lake for example is 21ppm and is mined at $2/kg
World lithium resources are close to 100M tons, but usable part, reserves, is about 1/4 of it.
Notice how it is also stated in the article: “We are trying to find out how much can we use from the resources we found. It takes time,” Rudklao told The Nation.
So they don't know how big are the reserves.
Plus it's far away from the environment, so recovery will be uncomplicated.
Classic Clarke & Dawe
[0] https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2023/mcs2023-lithium.pd...