News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:36PM (#39059253)
I do not really understand why we are obsessed with energy independence. It only matters if we were to ban exports which is an absurd thing to do.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by markerz on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:02PM (#39059559)
Isn’t energy independence more about other countries exports? From the perspective of Germany, their reliance on Russian oil caused a high spike in cost of energy during the current Ukraine invasion. For the US, we don’t really want to be at the whim of OPEC. The 1973 Oil Crisis is a historical example of OPEC taking a religious and political stance and using their oil exports to coerce the US against Israel. Another way of looking at it is that oil production has largely been an effective monopoly for a long time by authoritarian states (many OPEC, China, Russia), many that are politically unstable (Venezuela). There are only a few oil rich countries and many of them are allied with each other so there isn’t strong competition or incentive to keep prices competitive. Many of them view the US negatively.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by ethbr1 on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:11PM (#39059685)
Exactly. Large parts of the economy require oil as feedstock or energy.

Parts that cannot be down for more than a week, or bad things happen, and which by virtual of volume have limited storage capacity (at normal consumption rates).

Consequently, US energy independence is about creating a credible detachment of the US from global market oil prices, such that countries thinking of using an oil embargo to pressure the US... don't.

In reality, oil embargos obviously impose immediate and intermediate term costs on the exporters as well, so doing a painful thing that the US might be able to blunt anyway becomes less attractive.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:35PM (#39060760)
No, it's about what the US exports - because the US produces more oil than it needs domestically. We will always be at the 'whim of OPEC' as long as we are in a market-based system because OPECs actions impact global oil supplies.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by FrustratedMonky on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:52PM (#39060973)
'market-based' is the key here. Without competition there is no market.

In the 70's when the US was NOT producing enough.

Then OPEC had a 'monopoly' or at least an outsized influence. A large enough % of the market that they could dominate the price.

Right now we are NOT at the 'whim' because we can produce more if we need it. IF we stopped, then we would return to being at their 'whim'.

Solar, Wind, anything, is all very important for National Security. See Germany.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by ZoomerCretin on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:00PM (#39060314)
Germany's plight is entirely owed to their own political malfeasance in shutting down their nuclear power plants. With them, they would have managed just fine without Russian oil and natural gas.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by edgyquant on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:29PM (#39060668)
There is still a bulk of our modern economy which relies on combustion engines and oil. You are out of touch with this reality if you think Nuclear is a quick replacement for anything but basic power generation. We are generations away from electrifying everything.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by megaman821 on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:37PM (#39060797)
Can you explain that thought more? The bulk of oil and natural gas don't go to electricity generation. How would more electricity generation help?
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by FrustratedMonky on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:55PM (#39061025)
But that was kind of bad luck in timing.

They started shutting down nuclear, to make switch to wind/solar, before Russia invaded. (or at least being very trusting of Russian supply, so that is error in hindsight).

You could make argument that the switch to wind/solar should have been more gradual, or with more ability to roll back. But don't think it is a good argument to not switch to wind/solar. Just about how to do it.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by ClumsyPilot on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:02PM (#39061135)
Nah, it was actual stupidity.

The same wind turbine in the scotland produces 3 to five times more power than in Germany

The same solar panel produces 3 times more power in Spanish winter than in German winter.

This is basic information available to anyone

https://globalwindatlas.info/

https://globalsolaratlas.info/

But fine, you decided to do energy transition inefficiently.

At least don’t switch of nuclear while you are still relying on fossil fuels!

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by FrustratedMonky on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:16PM (#39061306)
Yes. I agree. That is better way to put it. Sure, switch to wind/solar. But at least mothball nuclear so they could be ramped back up (i'm not sure if that is possible with nuclear like with other power plants).

But yes, have a better fall back position.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by panick21_ on Saturday January 20, 2024 @12:02PM (#39069689)
Or you know. Invest your money smartly, don't actually mothball nuclear, simply build more. And then you save a huge amount of money and you have reliable energy. Crazy how that would work.

Simply take the price of a typical modern 1.5GW electric reactor from somebody like South Korea. Calculate how many you need in Germany, add up the cost. And that's not even taking into account the cost savings you could get from building a large number of the same plants.

You end up with a number significantly less then what Germany has spend over the last 25 years, will spend the next 20 and has spent on energy subsidies because of their high electricity prices.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by spacebanana7 on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:11PM (#39059681)
Export bans of politically sensitive commodities are not that uncommon.

For example, India banned onion exports this year [1] & the US has restricted oil exports before. [2]

Moreover, without officially banning exports a similar result can be achieved by mixing exports taxes with consumption subsidies.

If international oil prices got too high, like over $200, the political pressure for an oil export ban / restriction than made domestic prices $50-$100 would be hard for congress to tolerate.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/asia-feels-sting-...

[2] https://ballotpedia.org/Crude_oil_export_ban#:~:text=The%20c....

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by rectang on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:57PM (#39059510)
Strong US domestic energy production disempowers petro-state dictatorships such as Russia, Venezuela, Saudi Arabia etc. whose interests and values are not aligned with ours.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by Aerbil313 on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:08PM (#39059643)
Burning and bombing their countries down to the ground works pretty well too.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by rectang on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:17PM (#39059758)
The sharp ramp up of US oil production happened under the "all of the above" energy policy of Obama, who famously opposed that burning and bombing.

Energy independence is vastly preferable to waging war, and may be worth making some environmental tradeoffs for — even if we would like to see cleaner alternatives to fracking in the long run.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by ClumsyPilot on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:05PM (#39061170)
> Energy independence is vastly preferable to waging war, and may be worth making some environmental tradeoffs

Environmental collapse will lead to wars, so this statement is self-contradicting.

In fact the sooner we run out of oil, the better - high oil prices mean that any alternative will get huge investment. France built out nuclear due to an oil price shock.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:38PM (#39060815)
We really are in a jingoistic moment right now.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by Aerbil313 on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:27PM (#39064374)
It is satire.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by jon_richards on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:08PM (#39059646)
Soft power.

“European countries are estimated to have spent additional 792 billion euros in the last year just on the status quo system to protect consumers from the effects of the energy crisis introduced by the Russian invasion into Ukraine”

Honestly I think building solar and wind farms in Europe would do more for America’s military power than more tanks.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by pi-e-sigma on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:36PM (#39060772)
You have a flaw in your reasoning. More solar and wind farms in Europe make it more independent from both Russia and the US.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by politician on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:35PM (#39061526)
The EU is dependent on the US for nuclear deterrence, so the dependency relationship will continue even after they choose to use less imported US LNG.

That’s probably a long time from now though, as they are expanding LNG regasification terminals (6 projects that I’m aware of) since the pipelines from Russia became unavailable.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by edgyquant on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:27PM (#39060641)
This is because you’ve been living a very comfortable life with no real foreign threats thanks to US hegemony and the globalization it allowed. Due to other countries growing and wanting to have a say, this can’t be expected to continue going forward and so we have to think about things from a strategic perspective and not from a purely economic one.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:37PM (#39060786)
We have more than enough significant allied countries in the Americas that we never have to worry about energy security ever again - in the sense of literally getting enough electricity to meet domestic demand.

If it is about getting low price energy, then integration with the global system is unavoidable, no matter how many domestic export bans you enact, etc. - you will be impacted by global energy prices.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by FrustratedMonky on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:03PM (#39061144)
"independence" means we don't have to buy energy from the outside. Send money to someone, so they give us Energy. It is super important.

Think of it like this. How many oil producers do we have a problem with? That are dictators, at war, or generally bad. Every time we buy gas, we give them money. We send trillions of dollars to our enemies.

It is such an overwhelming National Security issue, that I'm frankly surprised Republicans fought renewable energy for so long. Oil isn't going to last forever. We should have been throwing resources at our own internal energy R&D. .

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by rayiner on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:27PM (#39059895)
Why would you want to be dependent on other countries if you didn’t have to be?
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:39PM (#39060822)
Because comparative advantage means that we all get richer collectively? Like - the basic principle driving better living standards over the last 80 years?
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by rayiner on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:18PM (#39061330)
Define “better living standards.” Obviously has been great for third world countries. But folks in the west don’t seem to happy about the situation. I don’t think the widespread availability of cheap Chinese crap offsets the downside of hollowing out the industrial base and non-college jobs.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by astrange on Friday January 19, 2024 @06:14PM (#39062698)
That was caused by bad US monetary policy. You've confused cause and effect.

(Americans hate inflation so much they preferred the Volcker recession in the 70s, which is what caused the deindustrialization, which is what caused things to move to Asia.)

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by whimsicalism on Sunday January 21, 2024 @11:08AM (#39079700)
volcker recession was in the 80s
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by FrustratedMonky on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:48PM (#39061680)
Ah. I see.

You are going back to old Adam Smith.

Let places/people that can make things more efficiently, do them.

Example: Don't give subsidies to car companies in countries that aren't good at making cars, it is inefficient. Better to focus on what you are good at.

There are exceptions:

National Security. See Energy, Semi-conductors.

or

To protect an industry while it grows, gets up to speed. Japan didn't become industrial power house out of nothing, they were very protectionist. Now they are dominant, but they aren't dominant because they let anybody at all come in and compete. They subsidized and protected their industry until they could stand on their own.