News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by digging on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:04PM (#39061892)
So the rate of change of demand is decreasing. Decreasing rate of change is the definition slowing down. Although I agree that most people probably misinterpret the phrase as you say. (It seems other replies have had that interpretation.)
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by throwaway167 on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:15PM (#39064309)
Increasing less fast is not the definition of slowing down, it's the definition of increase increasing less fast.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by digging on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:32PM (#39094207)
> Increasing less fast is not the definition of slowing down

Increasing position less fast is the definition of slowing down, as I said. Increasing speed less fast is, of course, not the definition of slowing down, it's decelerating; we agree on this.

But you are equating demand to "speed" (rate-of-change of position), and I am equating demand to "position" (not a rate-of-change). If demand is analogous to speed, then what is is measuring the rate-of-change of?

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by thebruce87m on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:21AM (#39065662)
If you reduce acceleration, your speed is still increasing if you still have positive acceleration. This is still speeding up, not slowing down.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by digging on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:32PM (#39094213)
If rate-of-change of demand is acceleration, that means demand itself is speed and is measuring a rate-of-change. What is demand measuring the rate of change of?

Acceleration decreased such that it is negative. Negative acceleration is "slowing down."

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by thebruce87m on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:41PM (#39095873)
> demand itself is speed

Ok, let’s substitute that into the original comment, instead of:

> demand has slowed down recently

we get:

> speed has slowed down recently

Nothing to do with the rate of change of speed, just speed itself. In other words:

In terms of _speed_, this would indicate that _speed_ was once higher and is now lower.

Let’s translate that same sentence back substituting speed with demand:

In terms of _demand_, this would indicate that _demand_ was once higher and is now lower.

That statement cannot be true as 2023 demand was the highest ever.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by digging on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:00PM (#39096774)
I think you misread my comment. Demand is not analogous to speed, it's analogous to position. I was asking how you were relating demand to speed, in your comment. It may be easier if you start using "rate-of-change of demand" instead of speed.
Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by thebruce87m on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:38PM (#39097137)
When we talk about supply and demand for cars, it has a time element. Units per year, units per quarter and so on. It is analogous to speed. Doing anything else would make it impossible to plan the supply chain.

Where it could be different is in places like power generation. You might talk about peak demand in Watts, and daily demand in watt-hours.

Re:Thailand finds 14.8M tonnes of lithium by digging on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:25AM (#39105491)
I see. Then, if demand is the rate of... demand (?), it is analogous to speed and it's not appropriate to say "slowing down", as you say.