News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inner Speech by politelemon on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:29AM (#38965540)
It's a bit odd reading this because I learned just a few months ago, right here, that I am aphantastic (no mental imagery). Shortly after that, while discussing with some coworkers, I also learned I am anauralic (no inner voice). It appears they do sometimes go together:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8551557/

I think for those of us who don't have an inner voice, section "3.2 The Semantic Content View" seems to be a somewhat match, but it also says

> Gauker’s style of pure semantic content view is not widely endorsed. This may be because it clashes with the widespread view that inner speech has a sensory character similar to that of hearing speech.

So I wonder if the people that wrote this article are unable to fathom that people without an inner voice exist?

Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:39AM (#38965598)
> So I wonder if the people that wrote this article are unable to fathom that people without an inner voice exist?

I asked myself the same. There was a famous Reddit thread a couple years ago from a person who recently learned they did not have an inner voice, which made myself realize I also don't have one. I don't have the link saved and there seem to be a couple of such posts, but this one was pretty impactful in my bubble.

Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:45AM (#38965634)
Do you 'randomly' replay memories?
Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Saturday January 13, 2024 @05:33AM (#38978723)
Not more or less than someone who verbalizes their thoughts more. I would think it is orthogonal to inner voice. Do you think otherwise?
Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @09:29PM (#38986844)
How would you know how frequently others do that?

I think people with an inner voice don't notice their 'random' memories as much because they don't fit the narrative. Like confirmation bias, the bits that don't fit get filtered out, yet visual narratives are more flexible than that.

When you dream, it's like a montage, right? Do you hear sound at all? The dream still makes sense when you're in it though. How is waking reality any different in that regard?

Re:Inner Speech by xwolfi on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:42AM (#38965615)
But then, by which mean did you "ask yourself the same" ? Or is it that you cannot imagine a conversation ?
Re:Inner Speech by Armisael16 on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:48AM (#38965654)
I imagine it’s just an ingrained use of language picked up from other people - no thought behind it, like an atheist who says ‘Christ’ as an expletive.
Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:19PM (#38974248)
It goes beyond that, I think, in that many of us have gone most of our lives believing others used this language metaphorically, and assigning a meaning to these words.

I was about 45 by the point I realized most people to varying degrees actually meant that they saw things when imagining them.

And so to me it's not that there no thought behind it, because I do something when I "imagine" something, just not the same thing. The word means something different to me, and most of the time you wouldn't notice even when it's staring you in the face.

E.g."I imagined her face" has a meaning to me even though I can't literally see a face when imagining it, but I can recall qualities and emotions and sensations of it anyway and to me those things add up to the meaning of that word, because nobody ever thought to assume it needed explaining that it was literal.

Opening that line of inquiry quickly makes it apparent that we assume a whole lot about how similar our inner lives are that just doesn't consistently hold up, but that we don't challenge without digging into precisely how people use various words.

Re:Inner Speech by jvanderbot on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:14PM (#38975462)
This is so earth shattering to me. I'm completely unable to actually "see" anything when I imagine it, but I think I can visualize in the sense of recalling or imagining how it would look.

Do people actually close their eyes and hallucinate or am I reading way to far into this?

Re:Inner Speech by jddj on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:35PM (#38975637)
I think there's some of that over-reading.

In these exchanges the language typically gets sloppy and one person's "see" gets translated and reacted to as whoa, with their eyes?.

If you can imagine a red car and see it in your mind's eye (fairly ephemeral, especially if you force it, and nothing like as vivid as a hallucination) I think you're pretty normal from having followed a few of these threads over the years.

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Saturday January 13, 2024 @03:38AM (#38978218)
If you have aphantasia, you can't "see it in your minds eye", but that does not mean I can't imagine what it looks like.

I know the distinction both from comparing with dreams, where I do see, and with a single experience during meditation (which I've tried many times but so far failed to replicate). They're nothing alike what it is to "imagine" for me.

Re:Inner Speech by jddj on Saturday January 13, 2024 @04:50AM (#38978516)
Most people seem to be able to recall memories with some imagery and with some effort explore an object / space with imagery.

It's not vivid like a dream though, and doesn't have that 1st-personness either.

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Saturday January 13, 2024 @03:41AM (#38978233)
Yes, people do, to varying degrees. Up to and including near picture perfect clarity, though most people have far less clearer images.

Only 2-4% or so see nothing at all.

Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:44AM (#38965630)
I don't have an inner voice myself. So I asked myself whether the authors of the Plato post can't imagine that.
Re:Inner Speech by yetihehe on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:04AM (#38965746)
I have inner voice, it's very hard for me to comprehend how can you think, but it's possible. How I understand it: you just write what you think, without rehearsing it before inside your mind. We all do it to some extent when writing, it's not like I actually need to replay everything before I write.

"I asked myself" by a person who has no inner voice sounds like a blind person saying "I see..." when he understands something. It's just a figure of speech, not used in some languages (like polish, we say "I see" ONLY when we actually see something).

Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:18AM (#38965850)
This may be surprising, but I indeed can "ask myself" (aka. think about) things, without explicitely verbalizing the question in my head. "Thinking" is more abstract, but it can be faster that way.
Re:Inner Speech by yetihehe on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:59AM (#38966137)
I also don't always explicitly verbalize things. The whole problem seems to be more of disagreement about a definition of inner voice and what it means for different people.
Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:56AM (#38966564)
Maybe not the whole problem, but yeah, I also wonder about what people mean with "inner voice" respectively.

I do think though that I verbalize less than other (maybe most) people.

Re:Inner Speech by bhaak on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:29AM (#38965936)
Thinking doesn't need words. Thinking for me is a process of ideas and concepts coming from different directions, colliding, merging, splitting, transforming, and then going into other directions to interact with other thoughts.

The translation between these concepts to words or sentences from my mouth or my fingers is effortless by the way. Which I myself find interesting. I think it should take some effort but it doesn't.

If you wonder how one can think without an inner voice then I wonder can you even think without your inner voice? And can your inner voice be faster than your vocal voice and if not, doesn't that slow down your thought process?

Re:Inner Speech by LesZedCB on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:54AM (#38966100)
> doesn't that slow down your thought process?

probably yes.

also, when being asked questions I rehearse and rephrase the answer in my head often stumbling or pausing uncomfortably long to actually get it out for fear of it sounding weird or wrong or dumb.

Re:Inner Speech by teamonkey on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:46AM (#38966047)
This is exactly how I would describe it, as someone without much of an inner eye or an inner voice.

I can have an inner voice. I use it to practice how things sound in my head, or if I want to be very specific about wording, or when trying to parse some complex text, or to work out a sum. That’s how I know that most of the time I don’t use an inner voice to think.

Most of the time it’s like I have thoughts without words, and turning it into words must be handled by some unconscious part of my brain, because it’s automatic and silent.

Re:Inner Speech by stavros on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:24AM (#38966305)
Same here, and the thought itself is basically instant, so why go through the long process of narrating the thought to myself? I just have the next one.
Re:Inner Speech by throwuwu on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:24PM (#38975554)
This is getting more confusing. Just because you can think in words doesn’t mean you enumerate everything in words. I think of myself as someone with an inner voice that I use often but not everything that happens in my mind is subvocalized. A lot of it is imagining or recalling images or movements, there’s spatial awareness when thinking about positioning things and manipulating objects, there are non verbal recollections like music or recalling a sound something made and there are thoughts that are more like pure concepts or feelings. Maybe there is some misunderstanding about how the inner voice is used or maybe I’m wrong and there are people who exclusively think in words?
Re:Inner Speech by stavros on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:27PM (#38975582)
There are people who have all their thoughts in words (most people, in fact). I don't think they actually have their thoughts in words, I think they just narrate them to themselves after they have them.

I used to do this, but I stopped at some point.

Re:Inner Speech by drupe on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:03AM (#38965740)
But what is the experience of "asking yourself something" like for you if you don't literally hear a question being asked in your head?
Re:Inner Speech by Epholys on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:08AM (#38965776)
I don't have an inner voice, it's just completely abstract thoughts. I "feel" the interrogation about a subject, just without words.
Re:Inner Speech by thinkingemote on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:20AM (#38965874)
So if I ask you to form an image of a song, (or recall it in your mind): the "happy birthday" song. How vivid or clear is it? Do you have no clarity, some, or lots? is it vivid as the actual sound as if you were hearing it in real life? Do you notice the tune as well as the words?

Now change this image of happy birthday so that it's now a childrens choir singing it. Now change it so its by a bunch of cynical unix grey beards singing it in a convention.

How easy was it to change this image? Did changing it affect the clarity?

Re:Inner Speech by Epholys on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:37AM (#38965992)
Wow, these questions are really interesting, I've never thought about it!

For my favorite songs, I can recall it perfectly... But I don't hear it at all as if I was hearing it in real life. In fact, I don't know how to describe how vivid it is. Maybe I don't hear it at all? But I can sing these songs (out loud) without a problem.

However, I seem to be incapable of changing some elements about it. I can't seem to be able to make it faster, slower, change the singer, or the instruments. But, when I sing it out loud, I can of course modify it.

For "Happy birthday" (well, in my native language), it's really weird. Because I don't have a specific song in mind, I can follow the words, the tune, but I don't "feel" the voice of a specific singer. And I'm incapable to change this recall to different voices, like children or grown men. But if I listen to a version sung by these people, I can recall it after (until I forget).

Thanks again for these questions, I was aware of my lack of inner voice, my difficulties of a "inner sight" (that's a whole other can of worms), but I never applied this interrogations to a "inner hearing".

Re:Inner Speech by thinkingemote on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:47AM (#38966058)
I got and adapted the questions from a survey about these issues but I've been trying to get the question right as we tend to use language which presupposes things.

I like this one as it asks to form an image and asks about clarity. The image is about hearing. So it crosses both parts.

Another example would be to form an image of a telemarketer on the telephone. Change the accent. Introduce line distortion.

For me it's in the middle. Happy birthday is clear to visualise and I can follow the tune. it's not very vivid but it's like I'm singing to myself with my mouth shut. I don't have a mental "visual" image of the song by default. When changing it the imagery appears a bit more but the focus is on the sound. I can easily change it to children's voices, the unix greybeards is more difficult as it requires me working out what they would sound like including spatial echoes from the auditorium. I find the resulting image (which is clearer than the children) is amusing.

Re:Inner Speech by Epholys on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:02AM (#38966164)
Ha, interesting! I don't have the control you have on my inner hearing. For a song I love, I can like sing along with my mouth shut, not only the voices, but also the instruments. Strangely, it's hard to have the complete song at the same time (voice + instruments), but I suspect it's more of a skill issue, as I seem to be able to do it faintly.

I'm not envious of the people who have an inescapable inner voice. I think it would hinder my thoughts, the speed of it, and the ability to think abstractly. It's not totally baseless, because I can force myself to have an inner voice, but it's a conscious effort. Sometimes useful if I need to clarify my thoughts. On the same note, not having a inner voice makes it really difficult sometimes to put my emotions and thoughts into words.

But I'm really jealous about anyone that can clearly conjure images, "videos", and sounds in their mind, I feel like I have a big disadvantage if I want to learn to draw, 3D model, or play an instrument.

Re:Inner Speech by im3w1l on Saturday January 13, 2024 @05:50AM (#38978823)
People speak of these things in term of identity, but I wonder how true that is. I could easily imagine (pun intended) these are more akin to skills, that can be improved with practice.

Actually now that I think about it, I do know that this is a well-known phenomenon in the chess world. Newcomers are unable to to play blind-chess. But experienced players say that they gradually learned how to do it. How it started as a really blurry picture of just a small part of the board, and how they gradually got better at remembering and visualizing the whole board at the same and were able to play full games with a blindfold.

Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:49AM (#38966062)
You're referring to thinking proactively. Is your inner narrative proactive or reactive?
Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:43AM (#38966033)
In Chinese, if you just put 'big' and 'small' together, you get 'size', and if you just put 'big' and 'not big' together, it means 'Is it big?'. By the same token, juxtaposed memories are questions or suggestions. I think it's the logic before logic.
Re:Inner Speech by bondarchuk on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:40AM (#38966942)
That's a really interesting tidbit about Chinese. Can't think of anything similar in any language I know, though. Does remind me of those primitive languages where the word for "forest" is just the word for "tree" repeated two or three times.
Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Friday January 12, 2024 @09:34AM (#38968414)
In English, we have 'oxymoron', and 'chiaroscuro' from Italian, but Chinese has a lot of words with contrasts, the yin and yang etc.
Re:Inner Speech by HKH2 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:16AM (#38977533)
> Does remind me of those primitive languages where the word for "forest" is just the word for "tree" repeated two or three times.

Come to think of it, Chinese does that too: 'forest' is '森林'.

Re:Inner Speech by bondarchuk on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:51AM (#38967030)
It's an interesting question, since learning that some people have visualization and internal monologue I've been paying attention to how writers/philosophers describe thought processes and based on that whether they are visualizers (and monologue-havers) or not, and whether they are aware that the other thing is also possible. One really gets the sense that a lot of writers/philosophers[1] are visualizers and monologue-havers and are completely unaware of the other possibilities. An exception was Musil (The Man without Qualities) who goes quite deep into the thought processes of his characters and describes both varieties. Also interesting to read in this respect is Julian Jaynes, who purports (quite controversially) to trace a development from a primitive type of mentality that obeyed something like command hallucinations to the current type of mentality that can think freely. But (even though his theory seemed deeply involved with internal monologue) I couldn't really get a grip on what he actually thinks of how people think these days.

[1] it does seem that it is much more common among "humanities-type" people and the general population, and more common to have no visualization among "exact sciences-type" people. This was also the observation of Galton https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Galton/imagery.htm (ctrl-f "men of science")

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:02AM (#38966167)
I have aphantasia, but I still say I "imagine" things (in the visual sense; I find it funny that this notion of visualising things in our mind is so ingrained that "imagine" has broadened to refer to the other senses) because I still clearly recall or imagine imagery in a way that means I can mentally operate on them.

E.g. I can draw things I imagine, or describe them, or "mentally navigate" spaces I remember with ease.

I also see images in my dreams, which seems to be pretty normal for people with aphantasia, so clearly a lot of us are not unable to see things in our mind, but something is - usually - preventing it from happening while we're away. Usually rather than always because some people see brief flashes, and I sometimes think I might but I'm not sure (it's surprisingly hard to determine). I've also had exactly one experience that seems to have been in a waking state where I saw clear imagery. I say seems, because while I don't think I fell asleep, I was meditating, and while I was aware and able to manipulate the imagery, it's possible it was lucid dreaming, but it was noticeable in particular because the imagery was far clearer than when I dream.

Re:Inner Speech by failingslowly on Friday January 12, 2024 @09:53AM (#38968665)
You said you have aphantasia, then you listed a number of ways in which you can mentally process images, so I couldn't really understand what you were missing. Then I went and did the aphantasia test, and apparently I have hypophantasia, so I guess that explains it.

I wonder if there's a link between engineering skills and aphantasia, given the prevalence of the "programmer art" meme?

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @10:50AM (#38969483)
> You said you have aphantasia, then you listed a number of ways in which you can mentally process images, so I couldn't really understand what you were missing. Then I went and did the aphantasia test, and apparently I have hypophantasia, so I guess that explains it.

This is similar to how I found out - I assumed what I experienced was what people meant when they talked about visualizing things, and it took a long time before I realised that a lot of them meant it very literally when they said they could "see" things.

> I wonder if there's a link between engineering skills and aphantasia, given the prevalence of the "programmer art" meme?

Ed Catmull, ex-president of Pixar, has aphantasia, and he found that artists at Pixar where not all that more likely to be able to visualize well [1], so the "programmer art" bit is far more likely to be down to practice and interest (on average, at least). I think it's more likely that the better you are in a field, the less time you're likely to have to devote to getting good in another field. Of course there are always exceptions.

But his sample was hardly representative, and so it's hard to tell whether it makes a difference. Maybe it does, and people who work at Pixar, including non-art staff are just more likely to be sufficiently interested in art to overcome extra difficulties.

That said, for my part I was decent at art when I was younger, but my drawing style was different when "imagining" things than when drawing something I had in front of me. But I also suspect I'd commit "programmer art" if I tried again now, at least without a lot of practice.

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-47830256

Re:Inner Speech by poopoopeepee59 on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:08AM (#38965773)
Can't say I'm surprised that NPCs (Non-Player Characters) tend to be ideologically attracted to, or lack thereof, curated echo chambers like HN and Reddit that tell them what to think.
Re:Inner Speech by cl3misch on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:20AM (#38965876)
The term "Non-Player Characters" for fellow humans is incredibly condescending. Please acknowledge that every human is a player character. Albeit with a different quest and skilltree than you.
Re:Inner Speech by red1reaper on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:45AM (#38966044)
There is also the other point of view, that every other human that is not you IS an NPC, we can only prove that we exist, and even then that is muddy, for all we know everyone else is just a figment of our imagination, we can neither affirm nor deny it, so it is not wrong that since the only one that you can affirm to some extent is a player character is yourself, to call everyone else an NPC, as you have no way to prove they are not an NPC, you can't see what they think, you can only assume that like you, they think and they are.

And yes, I am being pedantic with a philosophy I do not even endorse nor fully understand, just wanted to be a contrarian.

Re:Inner Speech by keiferski on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:53AM (#38965683)
Is inner voice the same thing as inner speech? I’m interpreting “inner voice” to be a kind of pseudo-personality similar to what people mean by conscience, while inner speech is simply the mental version of speech.

I can understand someone not having an inner voice, but I can’t see how writing is possible without inner speech. Otherwise, how can you have thoughts prior to writing them down?

Also note that the article is titled inner speech, not inner voice.

Re:Inner Speech by ithkuil on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:59AM (#38965709)
Luckily the text editor has been invented giving you the possibility of endlessly editing your sentence until it makes some sense.

Only half joking. I'm always impressed by those ancient people who could write long letters by hand in beautiful orthography, composing complex texts and make them just flow linearly. I'm sure here and there there would be a rewriting step involved but that can't have been always the case; there was surely practical pressure to get the output right at first try.

Perhaps this skill could be trained but perhaps it also leverages the ability to tap into your inner voice and inner speech

Re:Inner Speech by mmasu on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:20AM (#38965872)
i think it’s a matter of training/habit. Also, back then (educated) people used memory a lot more efficiently; this might have played a role too… i.e. compose and edit the whole text in your mind before writing it down.
Re:Inner Speech by ithkuil on Friday January 12, 2024 @09:23AM (#38968248)
> compose and edit the whole text in your mind before writing it down

yeah; doesn't that basically mean you have to have "inner speech"?

Re:Inner Speech by SuperHeavy256 on Monday January 15, 2024 @06:54AM (#38999800)
Perhaps only the letters which were 'really good' were preserved by historians, and most of the average human writing was not as preserved .
Re:Inner Speech by JaumeGreen on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:09AM (#38965783)
I can have thoughts without inner speech or text. Why? Probably it helps that I'm multilingual, I can use several languages (3) more or less indistinctively.

So when I have something to talk about I have the idea in my head, then I have to translate it to written or oral medium. Sometimes it's faulty and I use a different language for certain words, because they convey a more nuanced meaning that better corresponds to my idea, and I have a hard time finding the right word or phrase in the language I need to express myself with.

Inside my head I sometimes have inner speech, sometimes I just have a vivid imagination, sometimes it's concepts, and sometimes it's a mix of it all. For example, my first two paragraphs were translation from concepts, while the first line of this one came more from inner speech (half in Catalan, half in English), and this phrase has started as a mix of concept and inner speech.

Not using inner speech as my main medium also means that sometimes I find hard to understand puns that derive from pronunciation, if they come in the written form. When I read I don't imagine the sounds in my head, so I don't "hear" the words and the puns are missed.

Re:Inner Speech by boxed on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:36AM (#38965990)
> I can understand someone not having an inner voice, but I can’t see how writing is possible without inner speech. Otherwise, how can you have thoughts prior to writing them down?

The conscious experience of inner voice/speece/eye/nose/whatever is not really saying something about how the rest of the brain functions. Almost everything anyone does is indeed not projected in inner mind before being executed. The subjective experience is a post-hoc narrative of what the mind did, not really a part of the planning process itself. Think about running in a dense forest for example. There's no way to plan with inner mind where to direct your eye muscles first and then having received the visual input, plan with inner mind where to put your feet on the ground to not trip on a rock or root.

Re:Inner Speech by keiferski on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:51AM (#38966078)
I'm talking more about "thinking before you speak." As in, it seems to me that without some form of inner speech, it would be impossible to plan anything before vocalizing it, as you'd need to start talking/writing in order to actually think.
Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:13AM (#38966231)
Why do you think that?
Re:Inner Speech by keiferski on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:23AM (#38966304)
How could one "think about what they're going to say" without some level of prior inner speech or conceptualization? It may not be precisely the same as spoken speech, but it would still be a kind of speech.
Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:34AM (#38966384)
Why do you assume conceptualization requires verbalization?
Re:Inner Speech by keiferski on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:35AM (#38966399)
That's just how I understand the process, from my experience.

Can you elaborate why you think it doesn't, instead of writing single sentence replies?

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:53AM (#38966527)
I don't know whether it does or doesn't, but I just don't see any evidence that demonstrates that we do. E.g. how do you know from your experience whether the verbalization drove the conceptualization or whether it's effectively purely narration of non-verbal conceptualization? It's not even a given that they happen at the same time vs. being a post-rationalization of processes happening separately (e.g. we know from split-brain experiments that the brain halves are perfectly happy to verbalize explanations for decisions they demonstrably didn't make)
Re:Inner Speech by tacheiordache on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:17PM (#38975491)
I personally have a very hard time thinking out loud but have no problem thinking quietly. I'm for example terrible at explaining something while working on it but could easily explain it afterwards.
Re:Inner Speech by boxed on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:18PM (#38982829)
In a normal conversation I certainly don't do that. There's no way in hell I would have TIME to do that. It's too fast.

And anyway, why would that make any more sense? How would you plan the internal voice in order to produce it? An inner-inner-voice? That would need an inner-inner-inner voice?

It sounds like you have the homunculus idea of how human brain works. But this idea is nonsensical...

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:11AM (#38966220)
I definitely have both inner speech and inner voice in the ways you're using them, but when I write I don't verbalize things and then write down what I verbalize.

Consider that you've created an infinite regress problem. One might just as well as how inner speech is possible without preceding inner speech - clearly it must be possible for speech, whether inner, outer, oral or written to be formed from a non-verbal antecedent some way or other.

If you accept that, then there's no particular reason to think that it must be inherently necessary for writing to have a verbal antecedent rather than "hooking right into" the same non-verbal antecedent.

Re:Inner Speech by raducu on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:43AM (#38966032)
> I am aphantastic

Were you always like this?

I clearly remember as a child/teenager I had exquisite inner imagery, but around 17-18 anxiety set in and the imagery slowly faded away to the point that today I can only conjure faint images for fractions of a second

Re:Inner Speech by vidarh on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:23PM (#38974294)
Not the person above, but I believe I've always been like this. I can vividly remember (but not see) imagery from dreams that I know I see while dreaming, and I think I'd remember if I used to do that in my waking state. I've also had one incidence of seeing things as an adult, during meditation, and never managed to again, so I do have a clear idea of what is possible to compare to.
Re:Inner Speech by drcongo on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:54AM (#38966095)
Weirdly I'm aphantasic but hyperauralic. What I wouldn't give for it to be the other way around.
Re:Inner Speech by noduerme on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:17PM (#38974224)
If you're anauralic, what happens when you're reading and you hit a foreign word, or a word you don't know? Do you have to say it out loud, or can you "hear" the pronunciation in your mind by essentially speaking it sublingually? For me, I think my "inner voice" really is just sublingual speech wherein I don't move my lips, tongue or vocal chords. Although I can also "hear" the voices of other people I know if I think about them talking. (This would seem to be a requisite skill if you want to do impressions of people).

[edit: Maybe "sublingual" isn't the correct term for what I'm describing. I remember reading about some MRI experiments where they asked people to "talk" without making any sound, and this activated the speech parts of the brain as if they were using motor function to speak. But I can't recall the term used for doing this.]

Re:Inner Speech by RichardLake on Friday January 12, 2024 @08:00PM (#38976279)
For myself I can learn a written word without having any idea of how it is pronounced. Growing up there were multiple occasions when I was speaking and mid way through a sentence realize I don't know the pronunciation of the next word I was going to say.

Also I can read text and completely miss rhymes unless the formatting draws attention to it like how poetry is often written with lines split. (More likely to miss rhymes like half and graph where the word endings visually are different.)

Re:Inner Speech by prossercj on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:21PM (#38974274)
Okay, I'll bite. Pardon my ignorance, but this is a new concept to me. If you have no inner voice, how are you able to speak? Surely you formed those words in your mind before writing them. Is it that you only do so when speaking to others, and never to yourself?
Re:Inner Speech by wharvle on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:21PM (#38975995)
I dunno how it worked, but I went much of my childhood without an inner voice. Didn’t seem to hinder me at all.

One day I played around with imagining my thoughts as a voice in my head. Kept it up for a few more days. When I tried to stop, found I couldn’t, not entirely. Had one ever since.

I still wouldn’t say my inner voice forms my words for speech or much of my writing, even now. If I consider what I might say ahead of time, yes, if I’m just talking, no. And of course if I think about it (as I am now) then it gets more involved in that process.

Re:Inner Speech by pama on Friday January 12, 2024 @04:53PM (#38974644)
To people who have trouble with this concept I suggest the analogy to reading without voicing out words yet still internalizing the concepts, and often at a much faster rate than when vocalizing during reading (which in turn can be pleasant for some poetry). It is possible to read multiple lines in parallel and the mechanism is similar to sight reading piano music when you have two (or occasionally three) lines of information that immediately translate to actions in your arms, hands, and fingers. In a related sense, sight reading music does not involve any inner voice or chatter yet a lot of conscious decisions are being made and a lot of hard non-verbal thinking goes into optimizing technique. Human language is just too inefficient for most high performance thinking but it is the best tool we currently have for storing and transmitting thoughts.
Re:Inner Speech by riversflow on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:27PM (#38975000)
> how are you able to speak?

How are you able to walk? You don’t think about every muscle contraction.

Speaking, writing, drawing and walking are all about the same to me.

(I also have no inner voice and aphantasia)

Re:Inner Speech by jimkleiber on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:40PM (#38975163)
I have a lots of questions, as I find it hard for me to imagine:

1) When you read, do you ever say the words in your head or is it always more like an automatic recognition of the characters without voicing them?

2) Can you force yourself to have an inner voice, aka forcing yourself to say something like "I am thinking to myself right now"?

Also, it's ok if you don't want to answer but I'd be curious to learn more about your experience.

Re:Inner Speech by razerbeans on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:06PM (#38975379)
I'll answer from my own experience (with no inner voice):

1) I have to be very explicit when reading with an inner voice (which goes to your second point). Generally, it is a kind of recognition that a word has a meaning and I "feel" that meaning, if that makes sense?

2) Yes. It feels unnatural though.

Re:Inner Speech by jancsika on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:05PM (#38975875)
But then how do you do what I'd consider simple things like sanity checks?

For example, hooking up jumper cables. I suppose I could hook them up without an inner dialog.

But then at any point if I get confused or remember that dangerous things can happen, I can go back and compare against a list in my head of the steps to hook them up. E.g., don't let clamps touch, start with the dead battery, positive first, crank and rev the working car, etc.

How can you get the same type of sanity check without an inner dialog? Do you memorize an ordered sequence of "feels" that correspond to the steps?

Re:Inner Speech by razerbeans on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:40PM (#38976150)
You know, I've never really thought about it. Yeah, I guess I do just remember the feeling and know that it's a step that I've completed. And when I recall the steps that need to be done, it's not really a cohesive spoken thought. It's like impulses of sensations? My brain is just like "Order's important. Red red, black black." without the words.

For really difficult mental tasks, I'll actually talk to myself or write things down so that they are less chaotic since the feelings/impulses in my brain may not line up. Kind of like a buffer filling up.

Now what really bothers my wife is when we talk about how we have conversations with others. I don't necessarily think about what I'm going to say verbatim when I'm talking to someone. It's impulses like I mention above where things kind of "flash" into my brain the moment before I say it. The best way that I can think of it is that it's similar to playing a sport where you have moments to change your trajectory and movement to accomplish what you want. I know thematically what I want to say, but I don't actually build the sentence in my brain.

Hope that helps!

Re:Inner Speech by jancsika on Friday January 12, 2024 @08:02PM (#38976299)
> The best way that I can think of it is that it's similar to playing a sport where you have moments to change your trajectory and movement to accomplish what you want.

If I had to speculate I'd say a lot of people have the experience of both this and the inner voice, depending on context.

It doe make me wonder: are people who can't spontaneously "surf" sentences in realtime and instead rely wholly on an inner voice? :)

Edit: I've noticed that reflecting on this kind of stuff can wreak havoc on young musicians. I remember a colleague who learned the Grieg concerto but was having a small number of wrong notes (say, 5% or so) creep into various sections of the piece, seemingly at random. The teacher started to drill down on each section, having the student write down which finger plays what, subdivide tricky rhythms, and so forth.

What was wild was that each time the teacher asked the student to notate the chord at the point where a mistake occurred, this would generate a cascade of more mistakes. She'd essentially been playing mostly by feel without thinking about the harmony at all. The added anxiety about harmony increased her error rate for relying on feel; pretty soon she wasn't able to make it through the piece. They then went back methodically through the entire thing, having her notate each and every harmony and describe how each one relates to the next, which were primary vs. ancillary, and so forth. Only then could she play the entire piece with precision.

So sometimes to get from 95% to 100% you have to go back down to zero!

Re:Inner Speech by riversflow on Friday January 12, 2024 @09:26PM (#38976760)
Ironically, I have trouble imagining being able to think properly with an inner monologue. If I try to plan my words rather than just let them flow, I almost always stumble and become incapable of selecting the proper words.

If I'm reading something very very difficult, like a research paper in a field I'm only just getting my feet wet in, I will actually vocalize what I'm reading to help me figure out what I need to look up. But this is only when I'm confused.

To answer your question further down about sanity checking, I just know what know, so a sanity check involves me verifying that yes, indeed, black is the minus terminal on both batteries and red is the positive terminal on both batteries, that is my visual memory is correct. That said, a lot of people have remarked that I'm pretty deft in my actions. So maybe it's related?

It's hard for me to generalize about my experience as it seems very natural to me and I haven't really had a lot of exposure to others like me, so I don't know what parts are necessarily about me being me, and which are about me not having mental imagery(for lack of a better term). I get the feeling that an innervoice is kinda stressful though? I'm a very relaxed person by nature. The concept of "negative self talk" is completely alien to my brain.

Re:Inner Speech by firecall on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:27PM (#38976043)
There is a famously extensive and popular Reddit thread about this!

Which I'm sure someone will link to :-)

Re:Inner Speech by SuperHeavy256 on Monday January 15, 2024 @05:38AM (#38999316)
can you link to it? I'm interested in reading it.
Re:Inner Speech by z5h on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:38PM (#38975665)
Do you need an inner-inner voice before your inner voice speaks? To figure out what your inner voice will say before it says it?
Re:Inner Speech by earthboundkid on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:43PM (#38975695)
I find if I listen closely to my inner voice, it starts going in a circle for exactly this reason. This makes me think maybe the actual order is backwards and the voice comes second, but it feels first because brains are weird.
Re:Inner Speech by z5h on Friday January 12, 2024 @08:36PM (#38976499)
Right, my point is there is some point at which our "generation" of dialogue transitions from subconscious to conscious. This is true for people with or without inner dialogs.
Re:Inner Speech by earthboundkid on Saturday January 13, 2024 @04:23PM (#38984714)
Agreed. I don't need to be convinced because I definitely do some language related tasks without using my normal, chatty inner monologue. For example, when I try to speak Japanese via an English inner monologue, it's extremely slow. To be fluent I need to just go straight to Japanese, preferably without thinking at all.
Re:Inner Speech by eikenberry on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:52PM (#38975268)
> Is it that you only do so when speaking to others, and never to yourself?

For me, yes... when I'm thinking about words (spoken or written) I think in those words but otherwise not.

Re:Inner Speech by candlemas on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:13PM (#38974836)
Did thought bubbles in cartoons/comics confuse you?
Re:Inner Speech by tacheiordache on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:11PM (#38975433)
Im aphantastic to some extent and lack inner voice except for certain situations where there is a semblance of inner voice. Im learning for the first time about anauralia and am intrigued, seems I do to some extend have this. I'm just curious, do you present no inner voice whatsoever or do you have the occasional inner voice in some cases, when for example you attempt to collect some information when getting ready to write down something or in a very stressful situation you need to enumerate some steps to get out of it, etc...
Re:Inner Speech by endofreach on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:35PM (#38976109)
Not sure if it applies to me, i do have an inner voice, but it's way too slow for my thoughts. Never know how to explain it, but even though i am quick with finding the right words, it's so much slower than my thoughts. But i guess that's normal, so then, most people that have an inner voice, still don't use it for their thinking. It comes afterwards, at least that's how it seems to me.
Re:Inner Speech by kypro on Friday January 12, 2024 @08:14PM (#38976370)
That's exactly the same for me.

I use my inner voice when I'm reading or trying to construct sentences, but I don't think in sentences. I have to convert my thoughts to words so I'm an extremely slow and clumsy talker. I thought this was normal to be honest, but others have sworn to me that they think in sentences and I wonder if that's why some people are such brilliant speakers since for some thoughts and speech are linked instead of being two separate processes.

Re:Inner Speech by endofreach on Saturday January 13, 2024 @07:22AM (#38979316)
I just can't really believe people with that. But i just asked 3 more people and they sworn the same as yours. Sure, language had an enormous impact on human intelligence and "thinking capability", but structured and complex language has evolved much later than clever and intelligent thinking was important for humans.

I feel very often like the need of having the right words to describe thoughts to fellow humans is on one hand crafting reality at the same time it's holding it, and therefore all of us, back.

Maybe this way of thinking is more what people understand as intuition?