News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:04AM (#38566193)
I never broke a phone, not even scratched the screen but I feel force to buy a new one every 3 years because they become obsolete (I guess apps require more and more memory to the point I cannot have two open at the same time, which kills my ability to pay online).

I bought a Framework laptop for the same reason and I successfully managed to upgrade it, not repair it!

Is there a phone that allows me to upgrade over time and not only fix it?

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rglullis on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:59AM (#38566812)
This is the one thing that is makes me feel a bit scammed about the Fairphone. When I bought the Fairphone 3 plus, they gave the impression they were going to stick with form factor and make the modules upgradeable. Those hopes were shattered when they came out with the Fairphone 4.

I am just hoping now that I cling to this FP3 until frame.work gets bold enough to expand into phones as well.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by k__ on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:20AM (#38566276)
I noticed two ways.

Either you don't get any updates and at one point you can't use any app because it's outdated.

Or you get all updates and at one point you can't use any apps, because your phone became unbearably slow.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rekoil on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:09AM (#38566529)
The problem is really that the SoCs aren't maintained for long, and the complexity of the SoC concept makes maintaining it yourself as the device manufacturer at best impractical, maybe even impossible if the SoC manufacturer won't release necessary source code to you.

They want it this way because then they can sell more SoCs because users end up upgrading more often, and device manufacturers (besides Fairphone) don't complain because their interests are aligned.

On the Apple side you see devices getting support for much longer as Apple designs and maintains it's SoCs in-house, and at least to a degree value device longevity because that keeps second-hand prices relatively high, and that aligns somewhat with Apples interests.

Not quite 10 years, but we've seen feature updates for just under 7 years with the iPhone 6s (released 2015), and it's still receiving security updates and bug fixes.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by fsflover on Friday December 08, 2023 @12:30PM (#38571617)
> The problem is really that the SoCs aren't maintained for long

Why is this not a problem with laptops?

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rekoil on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:22PM (#38573782)
Because laptops don't use SoCs... A SoC (system on chip) is a whole lot more than just an application processor.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by fsflover on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:58PM (#38576602)
I don't think it's the actual reason. My Librem 5 phone will have lifetime updates just like a laptop, thanks to free drivers. Proprietary software is the reason for the planned obsolescence.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rekoil on Saturday December 09, 2023 @12:57AM (#38579062)
I hope it does!
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:24AM (#38566301)
Yup, that's what I'm dealing with and it sucks.

I am typing this from a phone that I am already considering replacing for this very same reason although it does everything well and I looks brand new (rubber case, screen protection, etc.).

I understand phones are harder to upgrade because space is very limited but the e-waste we're generating (and the money impact) seems something that needs to be addressed.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by zelphirkalt on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:28AM (#38566632)
I think it is also about the use cases and apps you use. For example: I have 1 phone older than 10y serving as a music player, almost never having Internet connection, almost always being in airplane mode. Another phone as my normal phone, also nearing 10y old, with a screen that is partially broken, but still accepts touch input fine everywhere, inherited from someone else, used usually only for Signal and Hackernews reading, rarely browsing in Firefox, nothing really feeling slow. Then I have one much newer phone, but waaay cheaper phone and it felt terribly slow right from the start, got it only to separate concerns, and as a throwaway. Not sure what its issue is really.

My point is that with reasonable apps old phones work just fine. Just don't install crap apps or facebook or something like that, stick to well working apps. Use a phone as a phone, not as your universal computing interface and you should be OK for a long time.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by xnickb on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:07AM (#38567243)
> Use a phone as a phone, not as your universal computing interface

Sounds limiting. Nowadays there are plenty of phones that can handle reasonable workloads at a reasonable price. Especially if you don't care about the camera.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by zelphirkalt on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:26AM (#38568200)
What is limiting is, to rely on a smart phone to do computing. A vast majority of the phones is locked down and steering people away from general computing ability. Can you do whatever you want on your phone? No. Not with the usual OS on them. Need to root it, jailbreak it, whatever. Then you have a phone with a bad input device. Yes you can improve it with something like hacker keyboard and whatever, but it is far far from being productive like a normal computer.

I am aware more and more people only use smart phones and don't own a general computer any longer, but that is a really sad development. A smart phone will usually not encourage experimentation and getting into general computing. It is a dumbed down device.

Yes, one should be able to use a phone for computing, but generally that's not available out of the box and it takes effort to make it somewhat OK to use it for computing.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by robertlagrant on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:01AM (#38566484)
> and the money impact

I imagine if this is something that lots of people want, it will result in more alternatives, but also raised prices. So it might not save money, but it might well result in less waste.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by Levitz on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:11AM (#38569238)
Depending on how comfortable you are with tinkering with your devices (in terms of software) I recommend you take a look at LineageOS and check if your device is supported.

I used a motorola moto g (the one with 1 GB of RAM!) from 2015 until last year.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by onion2k on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:15AM (#38566248)
Is there a phone that allows me to upgrade over time and not only fix it?

Turning off app updates would have the same impact if you're right about the increasing memory requirements.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:20AM (#38566279)
I wish I could simply run 3 year old apps. In many cases I am not allowed, especially the bank ones, which are the ones that I cannot run in the background as the OS kills them.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by br3d on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:35AM (#38566353)
Sorry if this is obvious, but have you tried the options in Settings to avoid the OS killing certain apps? On my Pixel it's Settings > Apps > App Battery Usage > (choose app) > Unrestricted
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:48AM (#38566422)
Not obvious at all, my friend, or at least not to me. Unfortunately, I don't have such option in my Redmi but I'll look for something similar, thanks!
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by digging on Friday December 08, 2023 @11:18AM (#38570706)
Bank apps seem to be a bottleneck in many aspects of phone development.

Are you not able to use your bank's mobile or desktop website in your phone's browser? I don't think I've ever installed a banking app. I also use a credit union though, maybe they're less incentivized to force people onto their apps.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by abdullahkhalids on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:13PM (#38572903)
My Canadian bank occasionally will block a bank transfer if done from my computer. I have called customer support, and they can't even tell why the transfer is being blocked. Possibly because there is some opaque ML algorithm at the backend.

Customer support has requested that I use the mobile app, and that usually allows the transfer.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rekoil on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:52AM (#38566439)
When the modular phone concepts appeared online (in the early '10s?) I was convinced that this was where it would take us, so when I heard about Fairphone, I really thought it was going to be that.

Slightly disappointed it hasn't happened yet.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by trenchgun on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:29AM (#38566331)
There should not be a need. There is enough performance, and it has plateaued.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by ratg13 on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:14AM (#38566935)
I also don't understand their comment. I've been buying either a flagship Android or iPhone every upgrade and don't remember not getting at least 5 years out of a phone.

Even at 5 years I only ever felt like I was upgrading because it was 'time', not out of a direct need.

I can only imagine a person getting 3 years out of a phone if they are buying junk.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by johnnyanmac on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:40AM (#38567089)
They talk about online games. Mobile gaming has become night and day in the last 4-5 years, so if you're trying to play the newest ones you may not even meet minimum specs.

I feel it's a temporary problem like PC's, where eventually they will plateau on performance and a 10YO potato will (eventually) be able to play 99% of "high end" games in some capacity, similar to how a Steam Deck can play most games (even most AAA) without special accomadations. But I imagine there will be at least 5-6 more years of moore's law before it falls off (like it did on PC around... 2015-6?)

----

could also just be a low end phone. My Asus ROG 5 lasted 2.5 ish years before it literally died (sent it in for repairs to the motherboard based on online symptoms, for 3 weeks. paid $100 for shipping... died 2 months later) and instead of buying a brand new phone I just purchased the same model for half the price I bought it at launch. Still chews through pretty much every game despite being 3 years old.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by doublepg23 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:57PM (#38587927)
I'm not sure if you've built a PC recently but 2016 is about when Ryzen was truly the better choice and gave Intel a swift kick in the butt. CPUs since then have gotten very nice gains YOY.

Granted, GPUs are the usual bottlenecks for gaming yes.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by cogman10 on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#38570506)
I truly only upgrade my phone because it has fallen out of security support. I'd still be using my old Pixel 2 if it had security support.

Fairphone looks mighty tempting with a replaceable battery as the only annoyance I have with my current phone (Pixel 6) is the battery is starting to lose steam.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by lopis on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:54AM (#38566452)
I really really hope FairPhone has a plan to start making their phones upgradable. They gave us a taste of it with the 3T. The FP5 is so similar to the FP4. I imagine they will eventually be able to estabilize the design and start offering backwards compatible parts. Until the 4, the hardware was just not up to industry standards.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by whazor on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:11AM (#38566544)
You would not upgrade from the 5 to a 6, as it would be a small upgrade. You would likely want to upgrade from a 3, but the design is too old, the cameras are too small, and probably other problems. I think we need a very stable upgradable base.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by lopis on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#38570509)
But that's what I mean. In 3-4 years I don't want to upgrade my phone, but if I need to replace some broken parts, it would be nice to be able to upgrade them. I replaced my FP3 cameras at the time with the better ones in that exact scenario.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by ilkke on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:43AM (#38566389)
I have the same problem and no real solution. FWIW I've been able to make my (mid-range android) phone last for 7+ years now by uninstalling some apps whenever memory becomes an issue. Also I update apps only when forced.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by tetris11 on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:57AM (#38566457)
Samsung j3 mini, running Android 11. I think there's even a 12 Lineage available, but the current one is so stable as a daily driver that I don't feel the need.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by llamaInSouth on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:59AM (#38566472)
You are one of the rare people that never broke a phone, probably.... or you just started using a cellphone... or you dont really use it or armored case, or something similar
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by zelphirkalt on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:31AM (#38566654)
Is it that rare? I also use smart phones for over 10 years and have never broken one, only inherited a broken screen one. And I have never even used protective hulls or anything. I sometimes do consider myself even rather clumsy and yet I still did not break a phone.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:12AM (#38566547)
I lost one 20 years ago, that was the closest I've been to breaking one.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by DamonHD on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:45AM (#38567495)
I have been using mobile phones since at least the 90s and have never broken one.

(Motorola Sapphire was my first, 1G, and I still have it somewhere. Powering it up would probably break several laws at this point. The SIM was an entire credit-card size also...)

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by projektfu on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:10AM (#38568042)
StarTAC? MicroTAC? Sapphire seems to refer to Motorola dashboard radios.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by DamonHD on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:36AM (#38568274)
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by have_faith on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:26AM (#38567726)
I think I cracked a screen on a single phone. Maybe some small scratches on others. Historically I haven't used a case, but my current one uses one of those Apple ones that doesn't cover the screen.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by mrweasel on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:36AM (#38567789)
The worst thing I ever did to my phones over the years is ever so slightly scratching the screen because I put it in the same pocket as my keys.

To be fair my first smart phone was a Nokia Lumia 720, that thing did some damage to anything it hit.

Some people just seems to smash phones left and right and claim that they're just using them normally. I think it's just how some people interact with the world. Put an iPhone in a case and they aren't that brittle, I dropped mine plenty of times.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by nicoco on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:41AM (#38566382)
I honestly don't think you have to. If banking apps are a bit slow, so what? I know that individual actions have limited impact, but do you realise what's at stake when it comes to environmental issues? FWIW I run a 6yo xiaomi and I avoid crapware, it's working fine, I can AV call, message, browse HN and other forums/links aggregator, navigate, track my sports and calories... The resources (some) apps and websites use are the issue. You're part of the educated crowd, resist, FFS.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:45AM (#38566403)
It's not that they are slow. When I pay online, I need to confirm the payment through my bank app. When I switch to it, the browser or shop app closes and I cannot complete the transaction.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by nicoco on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:05AM (#38566872)
Wow. Without a < 3 yo phone, it's not possible to switch between 2 apps without one of them being killed?

When I think about my atari 1040ST and what it could do with a single core running at a few Mhz and a few hundred kilobytes of RAM, it makes me realise how wrong we've gone with smartphones.

(before someone mentions it, I know that my atari didn't have wifi, couldn't play full HD videos, etc, and that it was harder to develop software for it, but still, something's off IMHO)

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:08AM (#38566899)
At least not with vanilla settings.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by 2muchcoffeeman on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:22AM (#38566984)
What phone and bank app is this? I have a 6 year old phone. I've never come across such issues.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:49AM (#38567140)
Spanish BBVA and Triodos bank apps combined with Brave browser on a redmi with 4+2 GiB of ram.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by nicoco on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:38AM (#38567800)
I have a redmi note 4 (mido) and can definitely switch between apps just fine. About banking, since the law in France doesn't require you to have a smartphone (yet?), I pretended I have a dumbphone to my bank, so 2FA is SMS-based for payments, which is not awesome (why not standard TOTP?), but still better than having their crapware in my pocket all the time.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by guraf on Friday December 08, 2023 @11:57AM (#38571181)
What does 4+2 GB mean? I tried googling Redmi 4+2 GB but it only returns Redmi 4 from 2017 that has only 2GB of ram. Surely that's not what you're talking about?
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by wryanzimmerman on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:57AM (#38567549)
That seems kind of odd, my iPhone 12 Pro has zero issues with things like that and it’s three years old.

I did upgrade a few weeks ago because the iPhone 15 cameras are amazing and I care a lot about that but I honestly had zero performance reasons to upgrade. I’ve never had an issue with a 5-6 year old phone and I always keep my old phone as a backup specifically for banking.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by pachico on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:13AM (#38567645)
Trust me, I only use browser, travel apps, Slack, bank apps and nothing else and I've been having issues for a year, I'd say. Maybe that OS is crap and I the phone too, I don't know.

Somehow, I thought 4+2 GiB of ram would suffice.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by KronisLV on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:21AM (#38566975)
> I honestly don't think you have to. If banking apps are a bit slow, so what?

Many phones are essentially abandoned by the manufacturer and don't receive any security updates not too long after release, which might just be an issue: https://source.android.com/docs/security/bulletin/2023-12-01

Not only that, but many apps won't run on the older versions of the OS either, due to the API level deprecation in Android: https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...

In other words, you don't really get much of a choice, unless you are buying a flagship device and not everyone will be able to do that. The same goes for the comparatively expensive iPhone devices, the cost also being a factor there for many.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by nicoco on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:36AM (#38567788)
Fair point. For android, choosing a phone from https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/ or https://www.replicant.us/supported-devices.php helps getting security updates for longer.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by wryanzimmerman on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:01AM (#38567573)
But based on this it seems like the right comparison is between a three year old iPhone and a brand new mid-level android because they’ll last you the same amount of time, and three year old iPhones aren’t very expensive (though it depends on where in the world you live. In plenty of countries ~2yo iPhones cost the same as brand new iPhones at US prices, because you can use them for so much longer than local market android phones).
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by sspiff on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:46AM (#38567119)
Is this still the case? It certainly was in the early days of smartphones, where every update it felt like you needed double the memory to keep up.

But I've been using devices with 4GB-6GB of memory for the past 8 years almost, and they don't feel that bad to use. My phone still has 6GB of memory and does all I want it to just fine.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by cassepipe on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:02AM (#38567575)
I am only buying second hand galaxy s7 (2106) and they work fine. If needed battery replacement is rather easy to do if you follow a tutorial.

I use it watch youtube videos, browse the web (probably not the fastest but fast enough), use Google Maps, take pictures, listen to music. Basic phone usage you know.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by wkjagt on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:28AM (#38568210)
I’m using my original iPhone SE (2016). I replaced the battery a couple of weeks ago, and I’m often at 80% by the end of the day. For regular phone use, I find this phone is perfect. So small you don’t feel it in your pocket, and still does the basic things really well.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by cheese_van on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:47AM (#38570384)
With WI-fi and all connection turned off (except simple texting with no images), and with all apps deleted that can be deleted, I have 80% remaining after a couple of weeks or more.

I suppose its somewhat of a privilege to use a modern phone only as a phone, but there's a certain smug peace of mind to be had - as well as security.

I'm also tempted to politely ask you to get off my lawn in the off-chance you are wondering about my demographic.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by rexreed on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:48PM (#38576509)
I also have some s7 but the version of android won't support the latest banking apps so it's becoming rapidly obsolete. What are you doing about app support on the android on s7?
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by cassepipe on Sunday December 10, 2023 @05:56AM (#38590722)
I haven´t had any problems with any app, even my banking app
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by lucb1e on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:22AM (#38567701)
> I feel force to buy a new one every 3 years because they become obsolete

Nowadays that's plainly not true anymore because chips hardly get faster year-to-year, but also my 2012 phone lasted 5 years before software support started to get mediocre for Android 4.4 (the hardware was still fast enough and the battery you could still replace in 20 seconds). I've only ever bought new phones for software support reasons (scheduled obsolescence) or because the GPS chip broke after they stopped supporting rooting and so I couldn't get it repaired (out of warranty) without forfeiting that.

What phones do you buy that you feel they're unusably slow after only 3 years?!

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by q0uaur on Friday December 08, 2023 @09:06AM (#38569174)
my asus zenfone 6 was a really great phone, but all updates stopped after just 2 years. It still has plenty of power, but due to not getting security updates since 2021 i feel i have to upgrade. getting the fairphone soon.

it's really crazy how wasteful we're being with electronics in general. my old work laptop became unusable with windows 10, just extremely sluggish for even simple tasks. putting linux on it, its working great again (in fact writing this comment on it right now.) I wish we could put more focus on performance in the more mainstream products, but at least there's FOSS for people like me. can't wait until i can put an alpine linux on my phone someday.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by maga_2020 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @11:24AM (#38592626)
>it's really crazy how wasteful we're being with electronics in general.

Indeed. from non-replaceable batteries, to weak headphone and charging port connections, to breaking cables, to mobile phone OSes. Most of consumer-oriented hardware manufacture seems to rely on obsolescent-by-design to get consumers to spend on the same type of device, in short cycles.

Probably similar to the big pharma that may appreciate the economic benefits of a chronic diseases.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by Night_Thastus on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:51AM (#38570429)
Part of why people think they need to still swap phones is because of either battery degradation, or software bloat.

Generally, a battery swap and a factory wipe would bring most people's phones back to an acceptable performance.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by neurostimulant on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:10PM (#38572132)
While chips probably won't get significantly faster, apps memory requirements are still steadily increasing to the point of current flagships are starting to have 24GB or RAM.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by sunshine_reggae on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:59AM (#38568470)
My solution is to get rid of all but 1-2 apps. It's a truly liberating feeling.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by suslik on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:43PM (#38572601)
Interesting. I have iphone xs max which was made in 2018. It doesn't feel obsolete at all. Works great, in fact.
Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by ksec on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:08PM (#38572850)
I mean if you are on an iPhone. Replacing the battery every 2 years would have be enough for it to last 4 - 6 years before buying it for a new one.

My only problem is replacing an iPhone battery is now $99.

Re:Fairphone 5: Keeping it 10/10? by majani on Sunday December 10, 2023 @04:18PM (#38595151)
Unfortunately this company would be hated by component manufacturers and they would actively sabotage it