News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:43AM (#38164904)
I can narrow it down to three critical problems with our society.

1. Car dependent cities.

2. Housing crisis

3. Wage suppression

Young people can't go anywhere because they can't afford a car because all their money goes to rent. Even if they WANTED to go somewhere, there isn't anywhere to go because car dependent infrastructure has killed all the places that young people used to hang out.

They don't make enough money to survive, much less thrive. I know a lot of GenZ people living in rotting camper trailers, sheds, tents, and cars. Many of my millennial friends are going through the same thing. They have no savings, no house, and they could never afford to start a family. A child is a ruinous event instead of joyous. There is no safety net and the tight rope is made of silly string.

But what they can afford are cell phones and Instagram/TikTok where they talk to each other.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mixdup on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:03PM (#38165218)
Did you actually read the article? The three things you cite were literally never mentioned. We've been heavily car dependent since the 50s. Most of the places teens have been hanging out for the past 40 years are built around cars--malls, theaters, etc--you drive to all of them

Teens are not sitting around sulking because they can't ride the train somewhere. They're all glued to their phones doomscrolling until they can't take it anymore

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by macNchz on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:32PM (#38165715)
So while cars became popular in the 50s, it look a long time for us to basically build everything around them. As late as 1969, 48% of kids walked or biked to school, which declined to 13% in 2009^. This has been the result of a combination of real and perceived dangers, and subject to somewhat of a feedback loop as we've made roads wider and faster.

I was lucky to be able to walk to school as a kid in the 90s, and found that time to be a delicious moment of early freedom each day as kids from my neighborhood and I chose our route and cut through backyards and patches of woods to pick up other kids. I lived in a small town without wide or fast roads, so this was largely safe, but I understand why it's not possible in most suburbs today. I loved my ability to ride my bike to friends' houses and down to the town beach in the summer, without having to ask my parents for a ride.

I think I would have been a very unhappy kid growing up in the typical American suburb of today, shepherded between structured activities and constantly monitored by adults. Retreating to a private online world may be an unhealthy coping mechanism, but it makes sense.

^ http://guide.saferoutesinfo.org/introduction/the_decline_of_...

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by 0max on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:24PM (#38166539)
I grew up around SF and was a free range teenager taking buses everywhere knowing the trunk lines across town would show up every 5 minutes, glad there were large shared spaces and affordable places to hang out and eat with friends.

Pieces from the New York Post would prolly make parents not want their kids to take MUNI regularly.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mintplant on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:12PM (#38165363)
foxyv's comment is much closer to how my friends feel about the world than the convenient list of conservative talking points presented in the article.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by brightball on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:22PM (#38165531)
Every item on that list is popularized online and is definitely not uniform across the country.

I live in a low cost of living area, that's car dependent. Yes, houses are expensive because _everybody_ is moving to these areas and there's construction everywhere. House prices went up here because so many people started fleeing dense areas when remote opportunities became common. But even 2 miles from my current house you can get a big 3 bedroom apartment for about $900 / month in a good location. Get 2 roommates and your rent is $300 / month.

But the flip side of this should be cause and effect. If people are leaving other areas in higher numbers then there should be deals in those areas.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by xboxnolifes on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:57PM (#38169609)
> If people are leaving other areas in higher numbers then there should be deals in those areas.

Only if people are leaving for reasons other than housing availability.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by brightball on Monday November 06, 2023 @06:11PM (#38170534)
The people dropping $700,000-$1,000,000 on a house in this area aren't doing it for housing availability.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by dingnuts on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:17PM (#38165426)
Jon Haidt is a conservative now?? good lord, if that is what you think you must be so far left that anybody to the right of Stalin is a Republican. Jon Haidt is about as even-tempered and desiring of reconciliation as anybody out there. We could all stand to be a little more like him.

Please, talk to the people in your lives about politics, or the polarization will only continue to intensify. Common ground is found through dialog, not through cutting everyone in your life out because they fall to one side or another of an arbitrary ideological goalpost that you've decided is the critical opinion everyone needs to agree with in order to be blessed with your presence.

I say this because Jon Haidt started this website, among other things:

https://civilpolitics.org

If Haidt and those like him are getting lumped in with the MAGA election-denying types, we're all screwed.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by vore on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:21PM (#38165496)
Are these not literally a laundry list of conservative talking points? And, by the way, you can be conservative without being MAGA.

  Love — “Monogamy is so outdated.”

  Community — “I have enough friends online.”

  Country — “I’m embarrassed to be an American.”

  Work — “I’m quiet-quitting.”

  Family — “I’m not bringing kids into this melting world.”

  Faith — “My parents are such naive Bible thumpers. By the way, what’s your star sign?”
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:52PM (#38165994)
Quiet-quitting is a conservative value? I thought the conservative value was that hard work and having dedication to your employer is the way to get ahead in life. That's what conservatives have always told me.

And you certainly don't have to be a conservative to become dissatisfied with internet dating. It genuinely sucks for a lot of people who just want to find somebody who understands them. Getting your dick sucked is great but wanting something more than that doesn't intrinsically make you a conservative.

I think you're just seeing what you want to see. These are the kind of things anybody with liberal or progressive political opinions can find themselves feeling.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by vore on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:55PM (#38166042)
Did you read this backwards? These are examples given in the article of society’s alleged ills. Having the entire grab bag of them listed like this is undeniably conservative.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:49PM (#38166942)
It's a list of things young people are dissatisfied with. They're dissatisfied with work and don't believe they can get ahead by working harder. They're dissatisfy with app dating and don't believe they can find lasting happiness with it. These are not conservative concerns; they're anybody concerns.

> Having [an] entire grab bag of [concerns] listed like this is undeniably conservative.

Ridiculous. Anybody who has multiple concerns in their life will have a list of concerns. Articulating this isn't a conservative trait, it's just basic self reflection. If you don't have a list of concerns with your own life then you're obviously doing very well. But just because you can't relate to people who's lives aren't as great as yours doesn't mean those people are conservative.

(You see I swapped out "the" with "an". Because that list is not The entire grab bag of characteristically conservative concerns. There's no mention of immigration, guns, abortion, voter IDs, crime rates, fear of carbon taxes and corporate regulations, drag-queen story hours, critical theory and progressive school teaches or really anything like any of that. It's clearly not "The" list of conservative concerns. You're characterizing it that way because that's what you want to see for some reason. Maybe you tripped over the mention of religion, but if you put stereotypes aside and look at public opinion polling, you will find that religion in America is largely bipartisan. Even the denominations that lean strongly one way still have millions of adherents who lean the other, e.g. 28% of evangelical protestants who lean Democrat. 55% of American Democrats report that their belief in God is absolutely certain and an additional 21% say their belief is fairly certain.)

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by vore on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:51PM (#38166967)
I think you're just seeing what you want to see.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:00PM (#38168937)
I am certain the list of concerns in the article is not the entire grab bag of conservative concerns as you claimed. It's not even most of the bag, most of the things in that list don't even have a conservative tint. If I'm wrong, then point me to the worries about abortion or gun control in the article. If you can't do that, then what's your basis for saying this is the entire grab bag?

I don't think you can give me a substantive response to this, but give it a shot. You could at least try.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by NoGravitas on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:19AM (#38177766)
No, it's a list of things this young person is dissatisfied with about what their peers believe. And most of them are stereotypically conservative concerns.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by red-iron-pine on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:00PM (#38180388)
> talking about society's ills is conservative
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mintplant on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:25PM (#38165581)
You've made a lot of assumptions about my personal life from a single sentence.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by 303uru on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:44PM (#38165866)
You're the one lumping traditional conservative with MAGA types. And yes, many of these talking points are traditional conservative as is your appeal to "even tempered reconciliation" which is classic stop fighting and just accept my conservatism talk.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mikestew on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:13PM (#38166350)
Jon Haidt is a conservative now?? <snip> If Haidt and those like him are getting lumped in with the MAGA election-denying types, we're all screwed.

There's only one person that I see in this branch of comments trying to lump Haidt in with the MAGA-hat-wearers. One can be a conservative without a red hat. To put it another way, what, you're going to argue that Haidt is progressive? It doesn't much of a glance at the URL you listed to determine that just isn't the case.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by maxdoop on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:42PM (#38166839)
Can we not ruin HN with political stuff and claims like this?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by brightball on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:15PM (#38165403)
I've long wondered why we haven't had a federal level (or even some state level) bans on social media for minors at this point? It seems like the effects are well established, more widespread than any drug has ever been and probably more severe.

My kids aren't allowed to use social media and we are "the mean parents" now because of it since "everybody else's parents let them." Some of these kids were on Instagram in 4th grade. It took years of explaining what we were protecting them from before they started to really get it, seeing their friends at school who's entire life is on a 4 inch screen.

They understand now, but the pressure is very real.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:39PM (#38165797)
The Supreme Court has generally allowed certain limited restrictions on media content targeted towards children. But an outright ban would probably run afoul of the First Amendment.

I expect the vagueness doctrine would also present an obstacle. How could legislators even define social media in a sufficiently precise way? Is email or group chat social media?

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:46PM (#38165887)
We already have an outright ban for children under 13 and that hasn't been shot down on First Amendment grounds. I don't see why that number couldn't be bumped to 18.

(Technically it's not a complete ban because it has an exception for parental permission, but it's a de facto ban because companies don't want to deal with it.)

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by Der_Einzige on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:38PM (#38167725)
It’s a de jure ban because everyone lies about their age. Defacto means that they do real actual age verification
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by bedobi on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:17PM (#38165439)
the devices are no small part of it, but neither is car centrism and the resulting lack of agency - it was lost gradually but is now complete, at least in the US

vs kids in Japan, Europe etc who are meaningfully independent from a far, far earlier age and have far, far more opportunities for socialization than kids in the US do

this is not to say they do not also have their own issues (in many cases device related), but yeah, let's not pretend like car-centrism has nothing to do with it, because it absolutely does

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by colechristensen on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:22PM (#38165520)
They're sitting around doomscrolling because they can't afford to do anything else.

I had a medium-range breakfast the other day... waffles coffee and a mimosa with bacon on the side: $66. Jesus that's more than 4 hours with the local minimum wage before taxes. Realistically the take home from an entire shift -- for a standard breakfast.

If I go out to a bar, every drink is $10.

If I want to go visit a friend, there's no parking anywhere on a Friday night unless you live miles and miles away from the city center. And people keep getting shot/stabbed on public transit. You can laud it all you want but it feels unsafe for a tall dude in his 30s... a lot of young people aren't going to feel comfortable with the local public transit.

The rent is too high, there's nothing to do that's affordable. What the fuck else are young people supposed to do?

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mnky9800n on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:27PM (#38165613)
How to move to Denmark as a software developer

https://matduggan.com/developers-guide-to-moving-to-denmark/

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by colechristensen on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:49PM (#38165945)
I'm not talking about my costs or the costs of an entry level developer. I can afford stupidly priced breakfast even if I don't want to spend that much.

I'm talking about waitresses, cashiers, shelf restockers, CNAs and whomever else on the bottom scale of pay not being able to afford anything but rent.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:43PM (#38165857)
Come on. If you're drinking mimosas that's not a "medium range" breakfast. I don't know what kind of hipster cafe you're brunching at but you can eat a lot cheaper at Denny's or the local greasy spoon.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by colechristensen on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:52PM (#38166000)
No, I wasn't eating the cheapest breakfast.

I also don't think orange juice with a little bit of cheap sparkling wine should be an unattainable luxury for anyone with a job.

I don't think my breakfast was worth a day's labor for a big chunk of the society I live in.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @03:38PM (#38168624)
I still don't understand your complaint. There are many cheaper breakfast options available for price sensitive customers. The fact that some restaurants charge ridiculous prices to affluent consumers so that they can signal their social status doesn't tell us anything about economic prospects for youths.

Any kind of wine at breakfast has always been considered a luxury reserved for special occasions.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by glimshe on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:42PM (#38166837)
I dont' want to be judgemental about your choices. They are yours to make. But we can't really complain that life is unaffordable based on what sounds a luxury breakfast with a mimosa/champagne. I've never had a mimosa for breakfast in my life! The same breakfast at a highly-rated, non-chain, brunch place in my large US city would cost around $15+tip without the mimosa.

No person is entitled to have others serving them on the cheap; if we want servers and cooks to be well paid, then restaurant food will have to cost a pretty penny.

By the way, you can make the very same breakfast at home for less than $10/person, including the mimosa, and barely $5/person without it.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by HDThoreaun on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:50PM (#38167915)
I'm 25. My friend group mostly consists of highly educated white collar workers. We can afford to do pretty much whatever we want other than quit our jobs. We still mostly spend our time doom scrolling. I think the "they can't afford to do anything else" argument misses how addictive social media is, especially when you grew up with it.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by red-iron-pine on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:07PM (#38180462)
where the hell are you eating for 66 bucks?

hell, i'm in Canada in a big city with high COL and my quick in-and-out breakfast on Saturday was 15 bucks for a brekke and 3 for coffee. even with a tip i'm just over $20 for pancakes, bacon, and a couple of refils of diner coffee.

are you paying for the table of 4?

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:46PM (#38165889)
The comment you replied to was an attempt (IMO a fairly successful one) to go one "why?" deeper on the question.

It takes as a given the article's point that the proximate cause of the issue is phone / social media centrism (IMO this is also right), but then it asks why? Why is youth culture so centered on devices and social media?

It wasn't phones or the contemporary version of social media for me (missed that by just under five years), but I already felt this when I was an adolescent. For me it was the late-90s wave of internet-connected video games, and the forums about the ones I played - absolutely a form of social media. And I very much relate to, "well what else would I be doing?". Everything else I could do required a parent to do it with me, and while they spent a huge amount of their time on involvement in fruitful things for me to do, in the form of things like sports and organized group activities (boy scouts, etc.), they also very reasonably had their own lives and couldn't just chaperone their kids all night every night and all day every weekend day. And then, what in the world else was I going to do? Where could I go to just hang out with friends, when I was 13, and what could we do on our own? Nowhere and nothing. My impression is that this has only gotten worse.

The respite from this was college, and I'm convinced this is why pretty much everyone fortunate enough to go to a residential college looks back on it very fondly. Colleges have everything their students need, within short walks, and like an infinite number of places for young people to just independently hang out with each other, without having to pay for anything. It's such a revelation! But you do that for just a few years, and then you discover that it only worked because it was absurdly subsidized, either by someone else - parents, taxpayers, wealthy scholarship / grant funders - or by your own future earnings. And out in the real world, all the gathering spaces - bars, coffee shops, restaurants - suddenly become impractically expensive, and all the distances between people become impractically large.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mixdup on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:14PM (#38167335)
>It takes as a given the article's point that the proximate cause of the issue is phone / social media centrism (IMO this is also right), but then it asks why? Why is youth culture so centered on devices and social media?

Do places in the US and other countries with good public transit or are walkable like New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, etc somehow not have any of the problems the article is referring to? I kind of doubt it

There's plenty wrong with how car dependent we are in most of the US but it's both not new to the latest generation and not uniform across the entire country yet there IS something that is uniform across the entire country AND new for this generation. Spoiler alert: it's not suburban sprawl.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:10PM (#38171763)
For what it's worth, I'd love to know the answer to this. But I'm not as doubtful as you are, based on the (few) kids I know who do live in more walkable areas where they can see their friends in person without requiring an adult.

But your last paragraph seems to be once again missing the "takes as a given ... that the proximate cause of the issue is phone / social media centrism" part. Nobody in this thread has argued against that problem.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:08PM (#38171738)
Well I don't know about that. I was very fortunate to be able to attend a residential college paid for through a mix of parents, scholarships, loans, and part-time jobs. Even at the time I was never under any illusions about how the funding model worked. I didn't have to "discover" anything.

Having a bunch of friends within walking distance was nice, but I certainly wouldn't want to return to that lifestyle even if it was free. It was ultimately very limiting and insular.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:02AM (#38177531)
Well, I think single family home suburb-style neighborhoods are even more insular, but I do think this is a good criticism of the residential campus model.

I guess I think the common immediately post-college model of moving to a small apartment in a dense city with a mix of people smushed together is a better way to get out of a bubble.

But I wish it was more common to go back to more like the campus model for family-raising, with kids of all ages around each other with lots of common spaces they can walk and bike to, with shared lighter touch supervision by all the adults.

But I recognize that this is largely just utopian wishful thinking :)

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#38193678)
Of course I read the article! But it ignores the problems that have plagued three generations before Gen Z and focus on stuff that is unique to them. Sure, cell phones kinda suck for mental health, but why are kids even using them if they suck so much? What prevents kids from doing anything else?

> Parents ask me: Why are my kids so anxious and depressed? Where do they go all day on their devices? How can I get them back?

The answer is to give them somewhere else to go!

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by toomuchtodo on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:58AM (#38165146)
Conversely, here is an example of the concerns of older generations that just happened to strangely present itself in my Google News feed today.

https://www.villages-news.com/2023/11/05/do-not-buy-a-home-i...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Villages,_Florida

https://www.thevillages.com/

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by switchbak on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:09PM (#38165312)
But be fair, he couldn't secure tee time until 4pm! The injustice!
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mnky9800n on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:29PM (#38165650)
I cried tears for him.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mikestew on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:16PM (#38166389)
The concerns of older generations that live in The Villages. That's bordering on finding someone that complained about the quality of the wine served at the country club, and then using that as your basis of what "older generations" are concerned about.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by HDThoreaun on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:56PM (#38167989)
The villages is actually pretty affordable. If you have a nice house, even in a low to medium cost of lviign area you can sell it and buy a place in the villages with the proceeds. It's not like south florida where everything is a million plus. The villages was specifically put inland and designed to be affordable for blue collar workers that have been working for 45 years. Excluding children allows the government to save a bunch of money on schooling and the like.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by jedberg on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:41PM (#38166821)
That post is satire, right? It has to be.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:05PM (#38165256)
And the three problems are all each exacerbated by the other two.

For fuck's sake, there's a complex near me [0] that has STUDIO apartments that start at $1,690. This is a suburb. It's not even close to anything. Even the metro line is about a mile walk. The nearest grocery store is over a mile away.

Granted, our minimum wage is somewhat high at $15.45/hr. But even at that rate, it would take 110 hours of pretax wages to pay for it. Post-tax, it'd be at least 75% of your monthly pay.

[0] https://maps.app.goo.gl/EYCy2kvXsRYCjz4J7

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by seiferteric on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:18PM (#38165452)
A mile on a bike isn't exactly that much...
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by ryukafalz on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:21PM (#38165512)
It's not when the infrastructure is well-designed for it. There's a new grocery store a little over a mile away from me that I've biked to a few times now and that's not so bad, though there are thankfully some quieter back streets that can take me to it. Looking at that Google Maps view GP posted though I'm not sure I'd feel safe riding there.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:00PM (#38166126)
A mile on foot isn't far either. The people living in those much vaunted walkable European cities think little of walking a few kilometers in a day; it's the American tourists who balk at that.

If you want a walkable city lifestyle but you also think walking a mile is unreasonable, your need a reality check. I'm going to walk to the park today to see the ducks, it's 1.5 miles away one way. I'm going to get groceries on the way back. I do this often, it's literally no big deal.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by orwin on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:11PM (#38169065)
> I'm going to get groceries on the way back.

If you have a park and a grocery store both on the same path, and sidewalks, i'd argue that your neighborhood is already walkable.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:51PM (#38169535)
Well yes, that's precisely my point. A grocery store being a mile away doesn't make a neighborhood unwalkable. This is contrary to what Sohcahtoa82 said, citing a grocery store a mile away making that neighborhood unwalkable.

> "It's not even close to anything. Even the metro line is about a mile walk. The nearest grocery store is over a mile away."

If you want to take advantage of a walkable neighborhood, then you shouldn't be complaining about a mile. A mile is nothing. Before WFH I was walking two miles to work and two miles back every day, and that doesn't count all the other places I walked to every day (another one or two miles for lunch, and another one or two miles in the evening.) And I still managed to gain weight with that routine.. Somebody complaining about one mile sounds like a joke. If you actually want a walkable neighborhood, you should be prepared to walk.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by hondo77 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:12PM (#38165356)
> Even the metro line is about a mile walk. The nearest grocery store is over a mile away.

The horror.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by bmitc on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:18PM (#38165447)
It's not the distance; it's the time. Walking 20 minutes to a subway station only to wait 10-20 minutes on an unreliable train to take a 10-45 minute subway ride only to finish with another 20 minute walk is not remotely efficient. I've calculated in my city that for some routes, it's only barely twice as fast to take the subway over walking the entire way. Spending over an hour one way is not acceptable when it takes less than half that time to just drive, even in heavy traffic.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by hondo77 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#38165543)
Sometimes life isn't efficient.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by bmitc on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:36PM (#38165754)
What is your point?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by jonwest on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:17PM (#38165440)
You ever walked a mile carrying two armfuls of groceries? That’s brutal without a car, and without public transit nearby, that makes it incredibly inconvenient and difficult to have food in the fridge. Get outta here with your feigned sarcasm, it’s a legitimate problem.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by hondo77 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:22PM (#38165527)
Yes, I have. That's why I switched over to a foldable shopping cart. Cutting-edge 20th century technology for today's modern problems.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by SirMaster on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:25PM (#38165578)
Grocery stores?

I thought all the young people are doing things like DoorDash, Hello Fresh or Amazon Fresh etc.

Not saying they should be doing that so much, but seems like they aren’t interested in shopping at a Grocery store.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by tyg13 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:41PM (#38165835)
The smart and motivated ones will try to get to the grocery store. Unfortunately, for most, those services do so much more harm than good. What makes sense for a wealthy professional to pay for the convenience of food or grocery delivery ends up being a small fortune for a lot of young people who can't afford a car to go to the grocery store.

It's a clear short- vs long-term thinking issue, but the reality is most young people are living with so little hope for the future that denying immediate pleasures in search of a future payoff seems naive and pointless.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:51PM (#38165980)
Yep, a mile is too far for a grocery store. We need more, smaller grocery stores. But the economics don't work out in most places. No idea how to solve this kind of issue.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:40PM (#38172040)
The small grocery stores in dense cities have limited selection and high prices (in order to cover high rents). So, everyone with a car drives out to larger supermarkets and big box stores outside of the urban core in order so save money (even though it might cost a little in terms of time and fuel) and have a better shopping experience. And then the only customers who shop at the smaller grocery stores are poor people who can't afford a car.

I don't think this is really a solvable problem short of giving explicit city government subsidies to grocery stores in certain neighborhoods.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:54AM (#38177428)
Indeed.

But of course the "driving out to a big store" is also subsidized. It's only cheap because of all the roads that have been built, all the subsidies over the decades that have made fuel so cheap, and the ability to freely "socialize the externalities" of burning fossil fuels.

But what I want is the ability to do a trip to a "big box" store further out once or twice a month, but be able to go somewhere close for smaller things day to day. But I definitely understand why the economics of this don't really work in most places. I just lament it.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:14PM (#38166368)
Others have already talking about the time and trouble of carrying things...

But something else worth mentioning is weather. This is the Pacific Northwest. It rains a LOT here. From mid-October to April, the rain feels non-stop.

Walking two miles in the rain nearly every day for six months starts to take a mental toll.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by ZoomerCretin on Monday November 06, 2023 @03:40PM (#38168668)
There's an apartment in Portland proper with a studio at $1,310/month: https://www.live230ash.com/floor-plans/?floor_plans_list

It's odd to me that at these prices, roommates (the kind you share a room with) are not more common.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by xboxnolifes on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:14PM (#38169838)
> Even the metro line is about a mile walk. The nearest grocery store is over a mile away.

I feel like you need to be a bit more precise when it comes to walking distance. Is "over a mile away" closer to 1 mile, or 2? A mile walk isn't far, but a 2 mile walk can be if you're doing it both ways without much in-between.

That being said, that apartment building (and area) is clearly designed with driving in mind. Parking spaces, right next to a 7 lane highway, more asphalt than rooftop.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:08PM (#38165291)
>1. Car dependent cities.

Do you think that cities used to be less "car dependent"? What point in American history are you imagining where people weren't taking cars around?

You could look back to maybe the early 20th century, but what that meant is that you had to live right next to the factory where you worked, which was obviously terrible. Cars meant that you could have separate areas for living and working, and this was considered a good thing.

edit: people keep making the same point, so I'll reply to all of you at once: do you think you could find a single person on any public transportation anywhere in America who wouldn't take a free, brand new Tesla model X with free charging and a free place to park it over riding the bus? Or if they had that brand new Tesla: would any of them trade it straight across for a free lifetime bus pass? Of course not. Having your own car is objectively better in every meaningful way.

The reason people take public transportation is because they can't afford a car, and yes owning a house with a garage is part of affording the car.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by BytesAndGears on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:15PM (#38165399)
I agree with you that car dependency is not the only problem that young people are facing. But it definitely exacerbates the other problems they’re facing.

Financial insecurity, and needing to spend 30 mins and 2 gallons of gas just to see a friend, means that it is prohibitively expensive and hard to see people.

Community has become fractured in many ways, like what’s specifically referenced in the article, but the requirement to drive just to meet up with anyone just compounds the issue further.

I had this same problem when I lived in the US as a young millennial. You could never just accidentally run into your friends, you all had to plan and commit to a whole drive just to see each other.

I moved to Europe, and now I can just ride my bike over to a friends place in 10 mins, or take an approximately free tram/bus. I think this would greatly help those in the US as well

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by chlodwig on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#38165545)
From early 20th century until the 1970s people lived in very walkable neighborhoods and took the subways and street cars to work. Read this post of excerpts from a memoir of growing up in West Philadelphia circa 1968 -- https://devinhelton.com/lost-world-of-west-philadelphia Or better yet, read the book: https://www.amazon.com/Philly-War-Zone-Growing-Battleground-...

Here is a small quote:

Around this time of day, I’d be taking my time walking home with my friends from Most Blessed Sacrament School, or “MBS” as everyone called it. Once home, I’d quickly get out of my school clothes, put on my play clothes, and be on my way to my favorite place in the world, Myers playground.

I always felt so safe on Cecil Street. On warm summer nights, lots of adults would sit on soft cushions on the top step of the four concrete steps that led from the edge of our front porches down to the sidewalk. Neighbors would sit out for hours, talking with other neighbors, many of them enjoying a cold beer or some other cold drink. At least one neighbor would have the Phillies game blasting on their transistor radio. So we’d be able to keep track of the Phillies game while we were running up and down the street having fun. I knew everybody on Cecil Street, and they all knew me. In fact, I knew almost everybody in our section of the neighborhood. And I felt safe no matter where I went. All us kids knew that most parents around here looked out for all the kids, not just their own.

The way I heard it: right after I was born, Dad simply didn’t renew his license, sold his big black Chevy, and never drove again.

Years later, when I asked Dad about it, he said, “Kev, I could take the “13” trolley on Chester Avenue to work. I could walk to the grocery store. I could walk to the bar. And I was tired of driving your mom and Nonna all over the city. What the hell did I need a car for?”

I have heard personal anecdotes from family relating similar stories.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by ripply on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:30PM (#38165668)
I disagree, having properly densely designed cities means you don’t need that car. I stayed in a slum in Paris for a week, I was able to walk to the grocer and take the bus to the train station to go into downtown Paris. Car ownership doesn’t work in Paris because it’s designed to be walkable which necessitates less parking lots. Parking lots and parking spaces are things you have to walk past/through and are a big reason car dependent cities in America don’t work.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by jmyeet on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:11PM (#38165351)
Quite literally all cities before the 1950s.

Los Angeles, now a car-dependent hellscape, once had a robust and far-reaching street car network.

Post-WW2 we went full car-dependent suburbs. Why? Racism has a lot to do with it.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:16PM (#38165412)
Can you give some examples of this pre 1950s los angeles that you wish you lived in?

I'm trying to find photos or accounts, but most of them seem to be people talking about or showing off how happy they are about having their own cars.

Los Angeles has busses that go absolutely everywhere, and even has a subway system, and yet people happily pay tens of thousands of dollars to own their own car so that they can go wherever they want.

I've never heard of somebody intentionally selling their car to take public transportation instead, certainly not in an American city. People take public transportation because they can't afford a car.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by KittenInABox on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:17PM (#38165442)
A friend of mine who lives in los angeles made a sad laugh when I complained "ugh, my subways are 12 mins apart". So I suspect public transport in los angeles forces people into cars because the other options suck.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:21PM (#38165515)
So there is some non existent idealized theoretical public transportation system you are imagining that is better than having my own transportation system that takes me wherever i want whenever i want and with whoever i want?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by KittenInABox on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:29PM (#38165653)
Yeah, actually. I want to be able to read, study, catch up on work, get wasted with friends, nap, and not worry about insurance, parking, or killing anyone. All for cheaper than gas, repairs, tires, etc.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:32PM (#38165711)
Yes that sounds great. Maybe each of us could have our own dedicated self driving waymo?

As it exists now, however: public transportation is terrible, and having a personal vehicle to take you where you want safely is universally preferable.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:01PM (#38166147)
I didn't want to make assumptions, but as I've read more of your comments, I've found it increasingly implausible that you have ever traveled outside the US. If that's right, you really should do that sometime! It is useful to have a broader perspective on how the world lives.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:28PM (#38167564)
Hey man if you wanna compare passports let’s go for it!

In the meantime: google image search photos of some of the Indian commuter trains I’ve ridden on and ask yourself why everybody with even a tiny bit of money hired a private driver.

Your comment about “broader perspective” is insulting, and I guarantee you that my perspective is quite a bit broader than “traveled to some glorified Disney land parks in Western Europe.”

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by BytesAndGears on Monday November 06, 2023 @07:11PM (#38171213)
These things that you call Disney land parks, are where I’ve been living for the last year. It’s not Disneyland at all, though, since there is a bustling and productive economy (that I work in), even in the cities with minimal tourism.

Actually some of the nicest walkable neighborhoods that I’ve visited since moving here, I was the only tourist that I saw.

If you’re genuinely curious, I’d love to give you more information about my city (as an American that moved to Europe). Let me know.

But I have 5 grocery stores within a quarter mile of my home, I take public transit and bike for all of my daily errands, and haven’t driven a car once since moving here. I see my friends whenever I want, often by either walking or taking transit depending on distance.

Just last weekend, I took a train to another city to buy a new racing bike, and took the train most of the way home before riding it the last mile or two. It was easy, and I went all the way to a neighboring town to shop for it (since they had a model that I wanted to try).

You can minimize it by calling it a glorified Disneyland park, but then you’re basically just skipping over the hundreds of millions of people who work non-tourism jobs (engineering, law, business, farming, medicine) and live within these generally well designed places.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:05PM (#38171709)
It might be insulting, but it still seems accurate based on all your comments here. Your perspective seems incredibly narrow to me, which is why I - rather gently - suggested that traveling to more places might broaden it. But sometimes things are unflattering to people and there isn't really a way to point that out without the person feeling insulted. :shrug:
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:45AM (#38177317)
Sorry that my comment above was peevish. I was peeved by the tone of your comments, but I regret that now.

You're right, of course, that unpleasant public transportation is very common worldwide. But it's not universal, which, to me, suggests that it's possible to learn from those success stories.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by KittenInABox on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:18PM (#38166426)
Public transportation can be good or bad, depending on execution, unlike car-centric infrastructure which never scales and becomes more expensive and results in more deaths from everyday distractions, drunk drivers, etc. If I could live in the infrastructure of large Japanese cities, that would be awesome, because it means I could live out in the quiet of the burbs and still get smashed deep in Tokyo and go home at 4 am asleep with my suit tie wrapped around my forehead without a single concern.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by tyg13 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:47PM (#38165912)
Just because you haven't experienced it, doesn't mean it doesn't exist; in much of the world outside of America, public transport is not unpopular.

And your own transportation system is vastly inefficient in the task of getting you and thousands of other people where they need to go. In a world where people's destinations are wildly divergent and travellers are few, cars make more sense. But when you see a clogged interstate filled with cars all mostly going to the same or similar destinations, whose occupants could easily fit into a couple of buses, you start to see the logic behind public transportation.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:50PM (#38166955)
> Can you give some examples of this pre 1950s los angeles that you wish you lived in?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_Electric

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_Railway

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by lainga on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:08PM (#38165302)
The 1920s?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:11PM (#38165344)
The cities of the 1920s where absolutely horrific places to live. They were filthy and polluted. People fled them to the suburbs for a reason: because they were terrible.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by malcolmgreaves on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#38165547)
Racism: that's the word you're looking for. Not "filthy" nor "polluted." They, which we mean white people, because they're the only ones that fled, left because of racism. The well documented white flight from urban centers to suburbs of the 50s & 60s was 100% because of racist white folk that didn't want to live next to Black people. That's all it is.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:32PM (#38167613)
This is…factually incorrect, and honestly insulting.

No I mean actual measurable particulate counts in the air around factories, and the industrial vehicles moving goods in and out of those factories. When people talk about “environmental racism”, that is: making poor people live in the worst parts of town, they’re talking about the environmental aspects of those parts of town.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:02PM (#38168955)
They left as soon as it became practical to leave (introduction of cars and suburbs) because of crime. The crime rate back then was inconceivable to anybody living in America today.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by bmitc on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:23PM (#38165552)
That doesn't have anything to do with transportation though. You could also die of a kidney stone in the 1920s, but it isn't relevant to the public transportation that existed.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by mcpackieh on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:03PM (#38168974)
All of the reasons cities sucked are relevant to the decisions people made to leave cities as soon as cars made it practical for them to live outside of cities.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by morkalork on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:15PM (#38165406)
Housing was a lot denser in cities back then. Lots of low rise appartenant buildings, tall skinny houses built right next to each other, and trams running on the major boulevards. Appently modern fire codes killed those building designs though? And lobbyists killed the trams.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:58PM (#38166089)
> Having your own car is objectively better in every meaningful way.

I'm honestly curious: Have you ever spent much time traveling or talking with friends in Europe or other places with much lower car ownership, about this particular point?

I have met while traveling or known socially or through work quite a few people who, sure, they would gladly accept a nice free car (who doesn't want $50k for free...), but would still prefer to walk or ride their bike or take the train most days, because it is actually a lot more convenient than lugging around a vehicle while going about their daily business.

Even in the US, there are tons of wealthy people in our cities who don't own a car (or keep it in the garage nearly all the time), not because they can't afford one, but because it just isn't as convenient.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by em-bee on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:37PM (#38172012)
i have lived in san diego, los angeles and auckland for the greater part of a year each, without a car, and i didn't live downtown in any of those places. before i moved to san diego i thought this is it, i'd have to get a car now. but no, i was able to arrange my life around public transport and avoid a car.

a car is not objectively better. the greatest pain point from my perspective: parking.

do you know how ridiculously expensive parking is in los angeles? it's insane.

public transport, even as bad as it was in those cities gave me a lot more freedom to go to the places that i wanted to go to within the city at least.

the only benefit for a car would have been to go on road trips, explore the rural areas, etc, but that's not something i'd have wanted to do on my own anyways.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:43PM (#38172070)
Now try it with a spouse and multiple small children who can't walk long distances.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by em-bee on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:09AM (#38176318)
fair point, but i don't see much difference. we still have to pick a location with some public transport, shopping and ideally work nearby.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Thursday November 09, 2023 @06:15PM (#38212762)
The best part about building our neighborhoods at human scale is that you don't have to constantly act as a taxi for your children and family members. They can just walk to where they want to go. It's also much friendlier for disabled folks because they don't have to worry about getting destroyed by a Mercedes while crossing the street in a mobility scooter.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:47AM (#38192032)
> Do you think that cities used to be less "car dependent"?

Absolutely, yes.

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/2/20/the-history-of...

> Having your own car is objectively better in every meaningful way.

Only if it's free. Also, consider the tragedy of the commons. Maybe it's great for the one person getting a free Tesla, but not so much for the taxpayers that pay for the road, the parking, the noise, and the danger to others.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by morkalork on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:09PM (#38165321)
Beyond wage suppression, it feels like there isn't competition any more. Instead of one company undercutting another to offer a better deal, both or all just raise prices for maximum revenue extraction. For example telecom companies and cell phone plans in Canada. They know its an essential service and charge exhorbently for access, because what are you going to do, not have a cellphone? If every "mandatory for living" service (housing, medical, food, utilities, telecom,...) does that, what's left?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by emmanuel_1234 on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:12PM (#38167316)
I feel Canadians get particularly shafted: lower wage, higher cost of life on essentials, stupid high rent in first tier city (where the jobs are!).

On the wages only, I wonder what justifies that Canadians make so little in comparison to their American peers living just an hour away across the border. Taxes alone don't seem enough to justify that gap. My take is that Canadians just... accepted it.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:50AM (#38192089)
Monopolies and Cartels are definitely a huge contributor to wage suppression and increased cost of living.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by lupyro on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:19PM (#38165459)
I'm a millenial myself, and not a parent so parents please correct me. 4. Modern parenting is torture for children.

Up until the teenage years kids need to feel useful. They need to be able to help fix things, etc. They need to get into a little bit of trouble and get dinged up a bit.

Teenagers need a lot more freedom. Every ounce of their body is pushing them to distance themselves from their family, have sex and take risks. Instead parents insist on this "no drugs, no sex" policy. Of course both of those things can present major problems, which is why they should be discussed but not forbidden. Even sex ed today is maximizing fear and pushing waiting until marriage which is just as bad.

As the parent points out, living in a car dependent city with nowhere to go and no way to get there leaves you no choice but to stay home. Staying home means tv, internet and video games. Parents are out on a holy war against that as well.

Are you suffocating yet? Now remember that in addition to everything above your texts, location, browsing history, grades, etc. are all being tracked and reported for your parents to further control you. Could you imagine if you were treated like this as an adult. You'd have a civil war.

Let them fuck. Let them work. Let them do drugs. Let them make mistakes for christ sake. All of these things have consequences and are worth keeping in mind. But coddling them until 18 and expecting them to be functional is like raising an elephant from birth isolated until adulthood then releasing them to the african savannah. They'll be dead before sunset.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by chlodwig on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:28PM (#38165630)
Instead parents insist on this "no drugs, no sex" policy. Of course both of those things can present major problems, which is why they should be discussed but not forbidden. Even sex ed today is maximizing fear and pushing waiting until marriage which is just as bad.

My impression is that there is far less of this now than there was thirty years ago or fifty years ago.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by smt88 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:03PM (#38165211)
Your list is three angles of the same problem, which is financial insecurity.

I'd say it's actually just two things: financial insecurity and climate change.

Both feel hopeless and both make them feel like there is no future no matter what they do.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by itsoktocry on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:20PM (#38165491)
>financial insecurity

I think financial expectations are warped, too.

Look at the viral TikTok video from a few weeks ago, where a recent marketing graduate was wondering why she wasn't making $100k right out of school. Or I recently saw a Twitter discussion where someone said, "Sure you can raise a family on a $100k, but you'll have to do it in 1000sqft. Who wants to do that?". We, I am, and I'm as happy as I've ever been.

Financial inequality has completely skewed what is seen as "normal". We need to fix both that perception, and the actual inequality.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by smt88 on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:14PM (#38169107)
It's perfectly realistic to want more than 1,000 sqft to raise a family because we live in a country where all previous living generations were able to do that for far less than $100k.

It's not the absolute quality of life that's infuriating. It's seeing how previous generations plundered the country and then pulled up the drawbridge behind them.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nradov on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:54PM (#38172160)
There is no factual basis for your claim. The average size for a new house in 1950 was 1000 ft^2. People made it work, and many of the children who grew up in those houses are still living today. Somehow though people's expectations have inflated and they now feel entitled to a larger home, or like a failure if they can't afford one.

As for previous generations, the Boomers are steadily dying off or moving into retirement communities. Lots of homes are coming on the market, although you might have to be flexible on location if you want to buy one.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by smt88 on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:36PM (#38172492)
> There is no factual basis for your claim.

Go ahead and cite yours, then.

Medium home size in the US has never been under 1,000 sqft. In 1960, it was ~1,500 sqft[1].

1. https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/programs-surveys/a...

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:03AM (#38192316)
Keep in mind that $100k in 2023 is about $50k in 1995. This doesn't take into account that housing inflation has been significantly higher that CPI.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by hotpotamus on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:12PM (#38165358)
As a millennial, I'm pretty sure I've only seen those problems get worse; I wonder if it feels like there is no hope because there is in fact no hope.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:26AM (#38192705)
I think it's important that we all identify these issues so that, when we have the power to enact change, that we do so. Eventually Millennials will be in the driver seat. Same as the Baby Boomers and eventually Generation Z after us.

Just because there is no hope now, doesn't mean an opportunity won't eventually fall into our laps. There is already a lot of change underway in our cities to address these issues because they MUST address them to survive. It will happen, hopefully in time for our children to experience a better society than we did.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:57AM (#38192222)
You are certainly right! However, I find that addressing a problem as vague as financial insecurity leads to non-solutions being proposed that kick the ball down the road a little and make the problem worse. By identifying the systemic issues that cause the financial insecurity we can address them properly.

We have solutions to wage suppression, car dependency and housing costs. We just need the political will to implement them.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by emmet on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:09PM (#38165317)
100% correct here. Young people have been robbed of public space, and her solution to them finding even a facsimile of one to replace it is to... rob them of that too.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:13PM (#38165371)
>Young people have been robbed of public space

What do you mean "robbed of public space"? What public space was taken away? The only public space which seems inaccessible to me that used to be is: parks and sidewalks, both of which have become open air drug markets/tent cities. The city where I live has no parks I am comfortable taking my children to, and we actively avoid walking on the sidewalks because it's dangerous.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by fzzzy on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:35PM (#38165740)
Didn't you answer your own question?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:29PM (#38167578)
No? What does turning my public parks into drug dens have to do with car ownership?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by emmet on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:55PM (#38167976)
my guy you literally brought up the parks problem unprompted so you clearly understand the issue being presented here
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by thepasswordis on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:36PM (#38182456)
No I absolutely do not see a link between turning parks into fentanyl use zones and cars. I live in a super walkable city with two grocery stores and a million restaurants and coffee shops within walking distance. Many many people don’t own cars here.

The parks are unusable and the sidewalks are campgrounds for drug addicts. What is the link to cars here?

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:38AM (#38192880)
Housing affordability is directly linked to car dependent infrastructure. It's like the four horseman of the financial apocalypse. They all feed into each other.

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/10/21/the-other-rea...

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by LesZedCB on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:59PM (#38166111)
https://medium.com/illumination/the-death-of-third-places-an...

you have to pay exorbitant prices to be somewhere (the third place) in society with people. it's expensive to socialize.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by itsoktocry on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:15PM (#38165402)
>Car dependent cities.

This doesn't make sense to me.

Generations previous were equally car dependent but got by. The current generations are choosing to not go anywhere because they believe they can get the experience by phone. I think the assumption that "if they could get there, they would" is incorrect; they don't want to.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by marssaxman on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:45PM (#38165880)
> Generations previous were equally car dependent but got by.

Only a couple of them! You are aware that the mass adoption of cars was a mid-20th-century phenomenon, yes? US cities were radically reshaped around interstate highways during the '50s and '60s. This car-dependence is quite a recent thing in the human experience.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#38193055)
> Generations previous were equally car dependent but got by.

How much more prosperous would our nation be if we had not invested such a significant amount of our time and wealth into cars? We could have built colonies on the Moon with the amount we spent on building more lanes for people to be stuck in traffic.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by next_xibalba on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:19PM (#38165456)
When, to your estimation, did cities become “car dependent”? Most cities have been car centric since long before Gen Z.

Real wage growth has been stalled out since the 1970s, several generations before Gen Z.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:07PM (#38166233)
By my estimation, the problems highlighted by the comment you replied to indeed started around the 70s. I think what happened recently is that the internet and social media came along as the perfect, but also terrible, solution to those problems.

I think the couple generations in between experienced the problems more as boredom and ennui. Indeed, "gen x" is pretty famous for this, and I think "millenials" are just a mish-mash of the late stage of "gen x" and the early stage of the "zoomer" generations.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:33PM (#38197414)
I would estimate that it started with Brown v. Board of Education in the mid 1950s. As racial integration started we saw "White Flight" from city centers. Naturally, those people exiting the cities wanted a way to enter the cities for jobs, education, entertainment, etc... So then we saw the construction of Urban Freeways in the 60s and 70s.

Before then, cars were unaffordable for almost everyone. It was kind of like owning an airplane nowadays. It was doable, but most didn't bother unless they really needed one since there were more affordable alternatives and you could walk everywhere you needed to go anyways.

Since then, things have only gotten worse as we slowly make cars the only viable method of transportation through land use requirements and neglected infrastructure.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by KittenInABox on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:00PM (#38165181)
> there isn't anywhere to go because car dependent infrastructure has killed all the places that young people used to hang out.

I think it's way more than car dependent infrastructure. It's also the pressures of monetizing everything including social spaces. The only place I know in my town where you will be unharassed for hanging out in the open free of charge for hours out of the weather is the library. The mall will encourage you and your group to leave with security. The coffee shops and lounges require purchases of drink. Even my local makerspace requires at least one purchase to hang out in their scheduled "free" hangout meetups.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by gen220 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:04PM (#38165235)
I think if we fixed the housing crisis and wage suppression, requiring nominal purchases wouldn't be such a significant barrier.

Nominal fees are like congestion pricing. If you don't have them, the space loses its ability to fulfill its original purpose.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by KittenInABox on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:07PM (#38165274)
I strongly disagree with this for children & community buildings. Children shouldn't be subject to congestion pricing. Teenagers should be free to rove a mall and be harmlessly loud and messy without being pressured to buy something-- chances are they will buy something eventually but it shouldn't be a requirement just to participate in community. I also wish my local makerspace didn't require a purchase. They should be funded by a government grant or wealthy donor such that impoverished people can learn skills and find community as equally as those with the spending money to chuck 5$ on a doodaad they'll never use.
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by stcredzero on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:55AM (#38165097)
But what they can afford are cell phones and Instagram/TikTok where they talk to each other.

On top of the physical impoverishment, young people are being starved of meaning and face to face social interaction. Online "communities" are not real communities. Hell, many face to face ones aren't either, at this point.

Substituting online interaction and faux "community" for the real thing is like giving a baby Karo syrup and water instead of milk. It seems sweet and it's even addictive. Eventually, it will harm or even kill the subject.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:01PM (#38195220)
> Substituting online interaction and faux "community" for the real thing is like giving a baby Karo syrup and water instead of milk. It seems sweet and it's even addictive. Eventually, it will harm or even kill the subject.

Agreed, but what community do they have as an alternative? Especially after they leave school.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by xwdv on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:02PM (#38165192)
It gets worse: in a society where children are a luxury requiring careful investment and sacrifice to conceive, child abuse will be far more rampant, as there will be growing pressure from parents to make their children some sort of positive ROI, otherwise why even bother having them?
Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by lettergram on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:10PM (#38165337)
> 1. Car dependent cities.

> 2. Housing crisis

Ugh… you can improve the situation by spreading out. Cheaper housing requires cheaper, less dense, populations. Using cars enables cheaper housing.

If you want cheaper cars and transportation in general, it’s cheaper energy & cheaper vehicles. Both require less regulation.

You can’t save in a city, where your paying a landlord and the wages are perfectly at market equilibrium. You can only get ahead by moving out, living cheaper and making decent pay.

It’s exactly what the older generations realized.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by Arelius on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:21PM (#38165505)
We've already spread out a lot. Should young people be living acres away from the next house and an hours drive from their friends? I'm not sure that'll solve loneliness and disconnection.

Not to mention that these days, even doing that won't save you much, or in some cases, post pandemic you'll be paying a premium.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by throwawayqqq11 on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:32PM (#38165705)
Total BS.

Cars and their supporting infra take up space.

Less regulations will never get rid of increased cost of individual transportation. Public transportion is the only way to push energy demand significantly.

Advising your boomer strategy "to just save" in the current era is so ignorant. This ignorance combined with the ever prospect of passive growth is imo the reason why rent extracts much more out of a life since the golden 50s.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:09PM (#38166264)
> Cheaper housing requires cheaper, less dense, populations.

This could not possibly be more the opposite of the case.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:08PM (#38193443)
You may want to consider why cities are so unaffordable right now.

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/10/21/the-other-rea...

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by ctoth on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:45PM (#38165884)
Remarkably, these issues you've articulated perfectly-capture the progressive bugbear zeitgeist and yet do not seem to have much (if any) support in the original article.

Is it possible it actually might be the phones somehow as she argues?

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by sanderjd on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:49PM (#38165940)
The comment you replied to agrees that it's the phones (well, the social media accessed by the phones)... But then it asks, why? It's not orthogonal, it's additive.

And I might suggest that the author of the essay very likely hasn't considered this next level deeper, because "this is water".

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by foxyv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:03PM (#38193353)
If you think car dependency is an imaginary problem (bugbear), I would invite you to walk or ride a bicycle more. You may find that the bugbear is just a bear.

As for housing affordability and wage suppression, these are just established facts. One visit to Zillow to look at a place you used to live is enough. My old apartment that cost $800/month is currently going for $2400/month 8 years later. Minimum wage hasn't changed since 2009 and is currently $7.24/hour.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by nunez on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:54PM (#38167014)
> Young people can't go anywhere because they can't afford a car because all their money goes to rent. Even if they WANTED to go somewhere, there isn't anywhere to go because car dependent infrastructure has killed all the places that young people used to hang out.

This is a big one IMO.

We moved to a Northern NJ suburb in the late-90s. However, NYC Metro suburbs are very different from the "suburbs" that are a dime a dozen here in Texas.

The town was small --- about a mile in square area. You could walk pretty much everywhere within it, even though some points were far. Almost every street had a sidewalk that was maintained by the city. Since the city followed a grid system, routes from one persons house to another could be done on foot. I spent a lot of time walking in my teens because of this, though not being allowed to have a car played a big part in that.

(Walking a lot comes naturally to me because of this; in fact, a big reason why I hated living in these suburbs was because of how difficult it was to walk somewhere interesting instead of "mandatory walking" around a fake pond.)

By comparison, suburbs in Texas (or at least here in Houston, and definitely in Dallas) are gigantic. You could walk for miles before you hit literally anything. The nearest business in the suburb we lived in when we moved here was 1.5 miles away on foot. The first 0.5 mile within the neighborhood was fine since the neighborhood had nicely curated sidewalks. Once you left the neighborhood though, you were walking on the 45mph-rated streets that people definitely drive 15+ over on (usually on their phones, since we're on the subject).

None of these neighborhoods have a grid system, so going from one house to another within the neighborhood could take a shocking amount of time despite being a short distance away. This design is done on purpose to "increase safety," which is at best farcical considering how unbelievably spread out these communities are and how distant they are from anything.

I hope the next generation of parents opt for smaller, more walkable towns with smaller houses and proper city centers instead of gigantic, cavernous and mostly empty sets of endless houses. I think this can be done while also remaining affordable, but we, collectively, have to want it.

Otherwise, yeah, the screens will "win" because the Internet is cheap, immediate and has basically anything you can think of.

Re:A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older gener... by lamontcg on Monday November 06, 2023 @02:23PM (#38167474)
Seems like the problems are more:

1. Phones and social media 2. Anomie