Deloitte calculate the per day impact of a temporary shutdown would be on average $23.6 million per 10 million population. Not that bad actually. But that figure seems based on the immediate hourly estimate from places like The Uptime Institute and LSE. Other estimates puts it at between $11Bn per day for the whole USA [0] and only $10Bn for the whole year. In reality the impact quickly compounds, making day 2 (24-48 hours) significant worse, and so on []. I am quite sure the aggregate downtime of AWS, Azure, Google and other cloud services in the past year has exceeded 24 hours per capita civilian use.
Being able to take cash, as a "flywheel", makes or breaks businesses in those times.
[0] https://bnn.network/finance-nav/unraveling-the-impact-of-glo...
[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/07/internet-shutdow...
[] According to studies I got masters students at York Business School to undertake.
That seems very low, surely the transaction volume of the average person is more than $2.36 a day?
But most businesses do. The main issue is there: why should a business be forced by law to accept cash if they absolutely need electricty and cables to work as a business ?
It's one step below forcing them to accept hand written checks. Those are also extremely resilient, you just need a pen and paper. But god no I wouldn't want to deal with them at a car rental desk.
Sure cash should be accepted in shops selling essential goods. But other shops should have the choice.
Ummm, for quite small values of "most" :)
I have a handle on this because I set a resilience assignment to a cohort of about 20 MBAs at a business school. Specifically I asked for a representative range of businesses;
- fast food - gymnasiums and sports - nail bars and hairdressers - auto-repair and mechanic/garages - child and day-care
.... you get the picture, _loads_ of variety.
They did 1 hour, 12 hour, 24 hour and one week case models.
As tech people, we are probably biased to think too heavily about digital and electronic systems. Many businesses can function in "survival mode" during a tech outage, including electricity in some cases.
As I recall, after "telephone", it was payment systems that were the real killer. Interestingly many access control systems fail-safe simply locking everyone out of the buildings!
"survival mode" is just that, you can accept cash during a hurricane, and refuse it for the rest of the year when you operate nromally.
That said, I can also understand businesses wanting to do away with it - no need to dealt with it; secure it, count it, deposit it, … etc.
Asking these people to handle cash instead feels like an undue burden on something that is a very selective side gig. I've seen this a lot in mildly remote locations, and I'd assume they wouldn't be doing it if it was more of a burden, like having to deal with the cash flow.
Forcing all businesses to follow a model that is already getting phased out doesn't make sense.
tax office has very little similarity with a retail store, idk what you are advocating here.
* Elderly people who struggle with technology.
* People fleeing coercive situations like domestic abuse where their abuser controls their finances.
* People with mental disabilities, for whom cash might be the only thing they know how to use.
* Homeless people, who might literally rely on cash to survive.
* Poorer people who prefer cash because it helps them budget and limit their spending.
* People so poor or otherwise disadvantaged that they don't even have a bank account.
That last group is much bigger than you think: by one estimate, 6% of American adults don't have a bank account and another 13% are "underbanked".[0] That's tens of millions of people in the US alone who don't have access to the basic financial services that you and I take for granted.
I have no idea how they do it. I'm not sure how it's even possible to navigate modern life without a bank account, but then I'm an educated, affluent professional who has no idea what it's like to be poor. Just because I don't need cash doesn't mean that no-one else does.
So basically, I think that asking "why should a business be forced by law to accept cash?" is like asking "why should a business be forced by law to provide wheelchair ramps and elevators?" If you don't think the answer is obvious, then you need to check your privilege.
[0] Source: https://usafacts.org/articles/who-is-the-least-likely-to-hav...
Check cashing stores. And you pay a very steep fee for not having a bank account.
> Sure cash should be accepted in shops selling essential goods. But other shops should have the choice.
That basically covers you whole list, except if your argument is that gaming PC parts shop should absolutely accomodate cash in case homeless people need an RTX3060 over the weekend.
Also fundamdentally a bank account should be a legal right (it is in many countries, if it's not in yours it's a more critical debate than cash), and with it should come a debit card. Sure some people won't be able to use it for a reason or another, but they can get help. The same way not everyone benefits from cash.
My partners mum fits the bill of "underbanked". She lives in an area where cash is king (near the border of a country that uses a different currency). She has a bank account, but doesn't use her debit card or online banking.
The answer to "how it's possible" is that she relies on other people who do have bank accounts to do things that require online payments.
If you don’t think the answer is the federal government should be providing the necessary infrastructure, then you want retail business operators to pay for fixing the problems taxpayers should be paying to fix.
It is a tried and true tactic for politicians to be able to claim they did something, but also keep taxes low. It really screws the smallest and poorest businesses/communities.
IDEA 2004 - Feds mandate each and every kid get an “individual education plan” and make it very hard and expensive for school leaders to expel kids who cause problems. And of course, Feds provide no money.
So what happens? Poorer towns with insufficient resources for paraeducators to manage problematic kids just let the kids stay in class and cause disruptions. Poorer students who want to learn get punished.
Richer areas that can afford complying with all regulations are even better off than before, except their residents get lower taxes and their leaders get to say they did something to help people.
Legislating a minimum standard is easy and cheap. Funding it and executing it is expensive, so everyone tries to avoid it.
You can have all the tech for proving that a dollar is legit, but it nobody cares if the dollar is legit, then it doesn't matter
and it's superior because it usually cannot be circumvented with math or will accumulate known insecurities over time.
So yes, a bulletproof cage is security technology, it works sufficiently well most of the time, there aren't many low-effort innovations to break it (bombs and such have been around forever but aren't used to rob convenience stores often), and if it does get broken it's obvious. Whereas a software exploits can be harder to detect and can be much easier to replicate and scale
Edit - Innovations in physical theft: That Kia/Hyundai car trend, which is really software. The trick bums use to steal blue bikes from docks. Writing threatening notes to bank tellers without any way of making good on the threat because tellers are directed to not fight back. Any more examples?
(And to add a cherry on top, this is usually not disturbing to actual customers, because they're busy doing usual bullshit paperwork while the safe is unlocking.)
This is about money being able to function with crippled infrastructure, not about someone stealing dollars stashed inside a mattress.
But nowadays cash is hard currency, while electronic payments are fiat currency, or like NFTs.
I think of this after all the stories about paypal/square/etc withholding payments and destroying an individual or a business.
In Hungary currently it is mandatory to use networked cash registers for cash transactions and centralized digital reporting system for issuing invoices. There are some minor exemptions, for farmer's markets and some similar specific niche very low volume cash transactions.
I know about no disaster protocols. (though the Hungarian mindset wouldn't give a damn about law forbidding sales without digital invoice in case of a slightly sustained emergency situation, possibly an outage longer than a day.)
So basically even with cash you might need electricity. (until nobody starts to give a damn)
I support using cash, for the several reasons outlined in the comments and the article. Yet I think when the trust in government/public services starts to break down (as ignoring laws banning non digitally accounted transactions), the trust in cash might also start to break down (though it takes longer imo)
Something that I've learned when I worked with those devices in the past is that the tax authorities do have strong contingency plans.
I don't know about the implementation details of the system, it is working since about 8-10 years ago without any major noteworthy issue/outage apart from some minor hiccups in the initial deployment. It sounds logical that some similar disconnected operation should be available here as well.
Put another way, it's always a good idea to avoid hard dependency on a working Internet connection whenever possible. Be it your "smart" toaster, or your payment methods.
There are a lot of scenarios where having cash as a fallback is great.
I don't think it makes sense to argue we should all use cash in case some small section of D.C. loses power for 10 weeks.
The advantages to the cashless society far outweigh that small benefit to the average person.
You present that as a fact, but it is far from. The jury is still out. And I would also question whether this is a case where "average" is even the relevant metric - is it ok if a chunk of the population looses access to shopping, because VISA or MASTERCARD decided do cut off their access? Cash is controlled by the state, but digital payment systems are not, and unlike cash, do not ensure equal treatment.
And partial function is better than no function.
I disagree with this. There are great advantages to having a cashless option, but I see no real advantages that are greater than the disadvantages to having a cashless society. What are they?
Experience has shown an even more prosperous outlook from having cash as the mainstay and credit as a fallback.
If the power goes out, I can't get any cash. I don't keep any meaningful amount cash on hand and neither does anyone I know, including my elderly relatives. Most of the stores I shop at won't actually be able to sell me anything, because none of the products have price tags and I sincerely doubt that any of their staff are trained to revert to pen-and-paper accounting. Even if they did manage to keep things running, they'd likely run out of change by the end of the day. The grocery stores are JIT and have no more than a few days of stock of anything; again, I doubt there's a manual backup to their reordering system.
Maybe things are different in countries with less reliable infrastructure, but I just can't think of a scenario in which cash would gain you any appreciable amount of resilience without much wider systemic changes. So much other stuff beyond payments is wholly reliant on technology. I'm not sure that would be a wise investment versus improving the resilience of power distribution and network infrastructure.
Maybe my experiences are atypical, but my impression is that consumer banking in the US is quite dysfunctional.
IMO you need the cash more to make the first day or two easier, or if there is a card payment outage as happened last year here in Canada,
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Rogers_Communications_o...
Plurality of payment methods is always more desirable and more robust. If one is serious about business, why would you not take, cash, cheque, credit and debit cards, contactless, NFT phone, and bitcoin? Even if some of those are suboptimal, a sale is a sale.
The ability to negotiate and adapt is what makes the world go round.
One example; I was caught in an emergency needing to get a taxi to an airport. On the way I explained the situation to the driver, and ended up negotiating the fare as a mix of US dollars, Danish Kroners, and a good bottle of wine, where the official expected currency was Euros.
The problem comes with cashiers and managers who are not business owners and are terrified to do anything unusual. They are tied to procedural rote and unable to think dynamically. It's all about what they can't do even when evidently agreeable and favourable options are on the table.
For some businesses, the overall cost of accepting some of those methods may be higher than the expected revenue from customers who won't use another method. Buying new payment readers. Having to convert the bitcoin immediately to currency to avoid losing money due to its constant price fluctuations. Higher per-transaction fees for some types of payment. Increased susceptibility to fraud (for cheques in particular).
> The problem comes with cashiers and managers who are not business owners and are terrified to do anything unusual. They are tied to procedural rote and unable to think dynamically.
You would be too if you were barely making ends meet, the expected outcome for "a customer asked me to accept an unusual form of payment" was almost always "it was a con, the 'customer' got the merchandise/service for free", and you'd most likely be fired as a result.
Just the millionth example of why trust is a critical component in society. Its presence allows things to be flexible and efficient. Lack of it makes things suck for everyone.
Well, all other significant concerns aside, NFTs are not fungible, it is literally in the name. Transactions are made through fungible methods.
Example: a $10 bill is exactly the same as any other $10 other bill or the same as having a $10 in your bank account. Same applies to BTC, any bitcoin is an equivalent of any other BTC.
This fungibility is what gives them the baseline feasibility as a common transaction method. Fungibility is just one of the many requirements for something to be useful as a common transaction vehicle, but it is one of the most fundamental ones, and if it isn’t satisfied, the rest of it doesn’t really matter. Sure, BTC is too volatile to be useful for transaction purposes in a lot of cases, but volatility is further up the chain of concerns, and BTC indeed satisfies the fungibility requirement. Sure, common AAPL shares are fungible as well, there is exactly zero difference between shares of AAPL that you can buy and the ones i can buy, but they aren’t fit as a common transaction method for many other reasons too.
Meanwhile, any given NFT is not an equivalent to any other NFT. They are explicitly intended to be unique and non-fungible/non-replaceable. There is no price for 1 NFT, just like there is no price for 1 painting, each NFT and painting is their own non-fungible entity. So everything else aside, NFTs are explicitly and by their definition are hard-disqualified to be a common transaction medium on the very fundamental level. In contrast, BTC doesn’t have such fundamental problems, but more in terms of practical problems (transaction speeds, transaction costs, high volatility, etc.)
It wasn't that they couldn't think about creative solutions, it's that we generally didn't want them to. There were serious implications for wrong decisions. For example, we couldn't sell a product for less than wholesale. The staff had no idea what the markup was and so couldn't know if a discount was above or below wholesale. If a product was sole for less than wholesale, the owner could have lost his license.
The wildest we got was when the computers crapped out. I told the staff to write down every transaction. Each transaction included the cost of the item, bottle deposit, and tax. On a Friday/Saturday night, we knew the top 10 item totals by heart and we were also good at counting back change.
When I was a regular run of the mill staffer at the store, I was happy to stay in my lane. The expectations were clear and that was good for everyone even if we, or customers, were sometimes inconvenienced.
I also was in your similar example. In US I have a car, so very rarely I use public transport which is not Bart. I landed in Toronto at 2am, got into Bus Google Maps told me, Bus driver said $2.50 fare, cash only. I gave him American 3 dollars, and he gave me Canadian $0.50 change back.
If a store's CC reader is down, then I'm just plain not transacting their that day. That's fine: there are other stores.
Now that many cards no longer use raised numbers I expect such mechanisms wouldn’t work as well.
They said their payment terminals were down so they could not take credit cards. I said oh... I don't have any cash, oh well no coffee for me. They said well... we can comp you one drink per person if you don't have cash.
Neither I nor they considered the option of me walking over to the nearby bank ATM and withdrawing cash.
And, as others note, CC readers in an individual store do go down though I probably won't have much cash in my pocket even if I have some at home.
Another side effect of this DC rule will be to ensure that more are prepared too.
Also funny is losing your id card/passport and your bank card/credit card simultaneously. You then need to get a new card from your bank that requires a valid id and you need to get a new id card which costs money. And no driving! "Gladly" this process takes so much time you can usually borrow money or pay it for you.
Weirdly enough, replacing my Chase debit card is so much easier with an Apple Wallet because it instantly gets a new card number while I wait three or four days for a card to show up in the mail. I can tap to pay in the interim and it's so much less of a pain in the ass in the interim.
> It seems pretty useless for spending on supplies and food if you ask me.
Seem pretty useful to me. At least historically, you can generally exchange gold for goods even in a total disaster scenario. You won't be weighing anything out or getting change, of course. You'll be seriously overpaying by the standards of a functioning economy. But nonetheless, you'll be able to engage in enough commerce to help you survive.
That said, I don't keep gold around. I do keep cash -- but if things have devolved to the point where cash isn't useful, then I'll have much larger problems than figuring out how to buy stuff.
You could carry some Goldbacks: https://www.goldback.com/
I think South Africa has had power problems in recent years, might be good to look at how they've dealt with it?
Well, that is well on your single data point, here is mine: I live in a bad weather prone area of the united states. I do not know _anyone_ that does _not_ have a meaningful amount of cash in the house for bad weather. Yes, stores here operate with low/no power or communications and use cash. I agree with the poster who noted that it provides a localized resilience. It is your fault, not anyone else's, that you do not have some currency.
Truth be told, I have kept about a weeks worth of spending in cash for decades in the house, just in case, and I have indeed had to use it during long term power outages. Heck, in my area just last week, all of my banks ATMs were down for the entire week due to a software issue after an upgrade (I am not making this up). While I might not have needed cash, it shows the fragility of our systems we rely on.
At least he had his canned fish. I gave him some candles.
That's your choice, not a problem with cash
> Most of the stores I shop at won't actually be able to sell me anything
But many other stores will
> ... by the end of the day
Often, it is all that is needed
Not all outages are apocalypse scenarios. Sometimes, it is just about finding something to eat for the night, the kind of small things that add up in an emergency situation.
Take the 2011 Sendai earthquake and tsunami for instance, it caused big problems like flooded cities and the Fukushima disaster, but it also caused small problems for millions of people, power outages, stopped trains, etc... These people had to eat, sleep,... while most of the infrastructure was down, it got better the next day, but in the meantime, it is good not to have to worry about millions of people being able to buy their meal when thousands are in need for immediate assistance.
You need trusted cashiers, need to check every received note to see if it's genuine, then you need to safely deposit that somewhere, the boxes of cash have to be transported likely in an armored truck.
And you still need communications networks for all the checks and balances and automated systems to handle the cash.
It's a massive logistic effort to shuffle around little certificates of value.
Back in 2018, Visa's network crashed:
https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2018/jun/01/visa-outa...
It was absolute chaos. Most shops and restaurants lost a ton of business due to customers not being able to pay for products (many people here don't have cash in their wallets at all), and many of them couldn't sell even if they wanted to, since the card reader (and other parts of their point of sale systems) also relied on said network.
Having cash as an option at least means things won't completely shut down whenever this sort of error occurs.
To be fair, credit cards also don't. At least didn't need to, up until very recently, when most issuers stopped embossing their credit cards.
Imprinters exist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_card_imprinter
Sure, the risk here is that the charge would get declined later on, but you get the same risk if you accept personal checks.
So in some scenario where electricity is unavailable, credit cards will be just as worthless in most cases as apps and gift cards.
Card present or online transactions only prevents you as a seller to make any money when the internet is not working.
But I am somewhat curious as to why nobody in my experience has implemented this on ground. Because if the customer pays with an actual credit card, the risk that the transaction won't go through when the internet comes back up is near-0, provided the card is valid. It is theoretically (and I assume practically too, given that every credit card agreement I've ever signed--and it's a lot of agreements, considering I was churning a lot for airline points--specifically outlined extra fees for "overcharging" your account) possible to overcharge the account this way (i.e. the transaction would still go through even if it'd blast past your credit limit, up to some limit though, probably)
I don't expect any store anywhere to have an imprinter, but it's definitely an option.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
You have no idea what I do or do not understand, and my comment provides additional context which makes it pretty clear in what context I'm using the word "understand."
It is vulnerable to counterfeiting which mean citizens lose out regularly as they don't have the means to check all cash is valid as shops or banks do.
Physically it is vulnerable to destruction and cannot be replaced if burned for example, unlike a bank card or other token of identity linking you to your funds.
It is vulnerable to devaluation (in has this in common with electronic cash)
In the event of societal collapse or degradation it becomes worthless fairly quickly, which is the opposite of resilient.
Cash is not at all resilient compared to electronic money therefore, and people are voting with their feet to get rid of it, laws like this will just delay the inevitable for a decade or so.
Bank cards will also disappear pretty quickly IMO (next couple of decades), as they're just a physical token of ownership and not really required if you can rely on say a combination of biometrics to assert identity.
No but dollar bills are a lot less advanced. They're also all still the same size and color so it's very hard to differentiate them.
For me the privacy point is the most important though.
There's a completely different take; Civic resilience
From an operational and strategic security POV, cash is a vastly superior technology. It doesn't need electricity, a network of cables, satellites and routers.
Therefore cash in circulation acts as a buffer that provides economic stability and continuity of operations.
Also, take a look at a modern European bank note, like we have in the UK. It's a sophisticated technology. It's not like we still have Roman coins that any blacksmith can forge.
There are many good, but more subtle reasons for preserving the use of cash, and regulating business practices if necessary to do so.