News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by firesteelrain on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:30PM (#37311141)
"To disrupt the botnet, the FBI redirected Qakbot traffic to Bureau-controlled servers that instructed infected computers to download an uninstaller file. This uninstaller—created to remove the Qakbot malware—untethered infected computers from the botnet and prevented the installation of any additional malware. "

That's pretty sweet that they healed hundreds of thousands of computers

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by pbronez on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:32PM (#37311179)
Pretty interesting. I bet there were a LOT of lawyer conversations about that.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by nickthegreek on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:36PM (#37311233)
FBI's been doing this for awhile now. So far no one has taken them to court. I do wonder how that would end.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by tw04 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:53PM (#37311452)
Given the infected folks in question likely had their machines involved in illegal activity, I'm not sure I'd want to test it. If someone starts running a meth lab out of your unlocked cellar, at what point do you become culpable for not knowing?

And are you really going to try to sue the police for shutting down the lab and locking the door on their way out?

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by anonym29 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:08PM (#37311643)
>If someone starts running a meth lab out of your unlocked cellar, at what point do you become culpable for not knowing?

Are you implying that the property owner is liable because they neglected to lock the cellar, or because they weren't aware a crime was taking place there?

If the former, isn't that as clear an example of victim blaming as telling people to carry firearms/protection if they don't want to be sexually assaulted?

In a civil society, it is not the responsibility or duty of the victim to set up security measures to prevent themselves from being victimized. It is the responsibility and duty of the culprit to not commit those unlawful crimes in the first place.

Bringing the analogy back to security - who is guilty of a crime when a ransomware attack happens, the victim, or the criminal (who obtained unauthorized access, and used that access to perform extortion)?

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by tw04 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#37311701)
>or because they weren't aware a crime was taking place there?

If someone is running a meth lab out of your cellar for a year, and you don't notice the smell, the power bill, the people coming and going, at what point are you no longer able to claim ignorance? If your answer is: you can claim ignorance indefinitely, what is preventing someone from just letting a meth lab be run from their basement and taking cash on the side? If the police can't find the cash, you're just not guilty?

>It is not the responsibility of the victim to set up security measures to prevent themselves from being victimized.

It is ABSOLUTELY the responsibility of the "victim" to not create an environment that FACILITATES crime. If you leave a gun unsupervised and unlocked on your front step, and a neighbor kid "steals" the gun off your front steps and proceeds to shoot and kill their friend, you are going to jail despite you being the "victim" of theft. Your internet connection in this instance is the loaded gun when your systems are being used in DDoS attacks.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:28PM (#37311873)
> and taking cash on the side

With this statement you’re arguing past the person you’re responding to. If you are taking cash on the side to feign ignorance when the DEA comes squawking about the meth lab in your basement then you are clearly in the know.

Nobody is talking about negligence here. Your rebuttal is essentially “well victims can be blamed if they’re being negligent”. Yeah, sure, by definition they’re not just a victim, they’re a negligent individual. (I mean I’d even argue they can be blamed for less—I’m not one of those 100% the victim is always innocent types, but that’s a different topic.)

The original question is if you are honestly unaware (and not negligent) that your property is being used to commit a crime, are you culpable for the crime? The answer is a resounding “no”.

If someone hacks your PC and installs botnet software, and it evades your OS antivirus heuristics and protections because it’s a sophisticated root-kit, then no, you’re not culpable.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by tw04 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:09PM (#37313234)
>With this statement you’re arguing past the person you’re responding to. If you are taking cash on the side to feign ignorance when the DEA comes squawking about the meth lab in your basement then you are clearly in the know.

Ironic that you're doing what you accused me of. I didn't say the person was taking cash, I asked WHEN op would consider the person to be culpable. You literally took an entire discussion and clipped four words then made up a bunch of stuff I didn't actually say or even imply.

>The original question is if you are honestly unaware (and not negligent) that your property is being used to commit a crime, are you culpable for the crime? The answer is a resounding “no”.

That was NOT the original question. The original question was whether or not someone could sue the police for removing malware and patching their system. My example was the cops shutting down a meth lab and locking the door.

Be my guest attempting to sue, and be prepared to have to defend yourself in a court of law that you were truly unaware. That's going to be a VERY expensive proposition - so who in their right mind would even start down that path?

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:27PM (#37311871)
Yes, and there’s plenty of case law to support that -

In fact, one of the most popular TV shows of all time had its finale specifically addressing the fact that a law needed to be made to discourage “bystanders” from actively ignoring crime.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by lelanthran on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:40PM (#37312036)
Which show was this?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by kevinh on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:46PM (#37312123)
Probably Seinfeld.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by nirvdrum on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:47PM (#37312139)
Seinfeld.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by shkkmo on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:39PM (#37312831)
Landlords can indeed be liable is many ways for some kinds of illegal activity that take place on their property (especially if it involves drugs.) There are a variety of local and federal laws that enable this.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:45PM (#37312097)
> And are you really going to try to sue the police for shutting down the lab and locking the door on their way out?

If the police enter your property without a warrant then sure. The potential presence of illegal activity does not grant the police special powers to skirt judicial process (unless there’s imminent danger to someone’s life or something, obviously). If the police unduly lock you out of your own property on the way out then doubly sure.

Obviously most people will be relieved that their machine no longer has malware on it (save willing participants, which is a different question altogether…). What would piss me off is not being notified, and not being given the chance to remediate myself (what if the police damage other pieces of property on the way and I could avoid the damage if I’m simply made aware), etc.

So let’s go back to the meth lab example: do you think it’s okay for the police to show up on your property unannounced in the middle of the night while you’re sleeping to silently shut down the meth lab without notifying you that they’re trespassing and then slap a lock on your basement door behind which you store your emergency cash, medical supplies, prescription drug refills, personal protection equipment, defensive firearms, etc. without leaving the keys or so much as a word?

Edit (two more things):

1. It’s possible someone might have been running a copy of the botnet for research purposes, so presumably this copy is not engaged in illicit activity and only installed on lab hardware. I wonder if the FBI’s program considered this scenario. Maybe they only targeted IPs involved in actual DDOS attacks? That’d be cool.

2. You can question something without implying it’s wrong. One can both believe the FBI is acting in a responsible and just way while also being curious how this would play out in court. The fervor in your responses seems slightly out of place considering the comment you’re responding to is simply raising a question.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by reaperducer on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:35PM (#37312767)
If the police enter your property without a warrant then sure. The potential presence of illegal activity does not grant the police special powers to skirt judicial process (unless there’s imminent danger to someone’s life or something, obviously).

I guess you've never heard of "probable cause."

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:22PM (#37313418)
I have, in fact. Probable cause is what police need to have in order for a judge to issue a warrant.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by mandevil on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:19PM (#37312533)
Oh hey, look at that, the FBI did get a warrant authorizing this action, and signed off by a United States Magistrate Judge: https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-08/23mj4244_application_reda...

Now, are judges sometimes too easy with warrants? Certainly. But this is definitely not the same as entering your house without a warrant, because the FBI did get a warrant. The warrant involves them promising to a judge under penalty of perjury that the Qakbot Uninstaller they are using makes no further changes and collects no additional data on any of the victim computers they are running on.

So, the FBI is aware of your concerns and is taking steps to alleviate them. Does that make you feel better?

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:28PM (#37312668)
> Oh hey, look at that (…) Does that make you feel better?

What? Why such snide?

I am aware of what happened in this case. I was responding rhetorically to GGP since they were presenting an abstract scenario where the police show up and shut down the meth lab in your basement and then lock you out of your property on the way out… My goal was to highlight the cases where it is and isn’t okay for the police to do whatever they want. It’s not clear if GGP is aware that there are in fact restrictions on what the police can do on your private property in the US. And that even with a warrant there are limits on how the warrant is conducted.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by tw04 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:16PM (#37313326)
>If the police enter your property without a warrant then sure. The potential presence of illegal activity does not grant the police special powers to skirt judicial process (unless there’s imminent danger to someone’s life or something, obviously).

So like a computer system actively participating in ID theft and DDoS attacks?

>If the police unduly lock you out of your own property on the way out then doubly sure.

But patching a system doesn't lock the owner out...

>What would piss me off is not being notified, and not being given the chance to remediate myself (what if the police damage other pieces of property on the way and I could avoid the damage if I’m simply made aware), etc.

So you're volunteering your tax dollars for the FBI to track down hundreds of thousands of people across the globe to let them know their systems were patched? I'm not. If this upsets you: don't put unpatched systems on the internet?

>So let’s go back to the meth lab example: do you think it’s okay for the police to show up on your property unannounced in the middle of the night while you’re sleeping to silently shut down the meth lab without notifying you that they’re trespassing and then slap a lock on your basement door behind which you store your emergency cash, medical supplies, prescription drug refills, personal protection equipment, defensive firearms, etc. without leaving the keys or so much as a word?

You're taking the analogy to a place you know doesn't exist. The police don't have a way to notify everyone that's infected, expecting them to do so before shutting down a major botnet is just silly and arguing for the sake of arguing.

Nobody said they were adding a lock, I said they were locking the door on their way out: the lock is already there, you already have the key. When they patched these systems it didn't somehow make the owner unable to login.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:30PM (#37313543)
> You're taking the analogy to a place you know doesn't exist. The police don't have a way to notify everyone that's infected, expecting them to do so before shutting down a major botnet is just silly and arguing for the sake of arguing.

I don’t think I am. If the FBI can remotely execute code on my machine then they could certainly drop a notification with a link to a page explaining the situation and how to remediate. Or they could use any number of emergency alert systems to make people aware of a potentially harmful botnet. Or they could email the owner of the machine instead of running their own malware.

Anyway as I’ve stated I don’t really disagree with the outcome here. I just don’t think your “let the police do whatever they want to people’s property it’s for the greater good” mentality is healthy, especially not in the US where we very carefully limit the power we grant over violence because we recognize property and privacy rights.

I’m not arguing for the sake of arguing. I think it’s fair to ask: “could this have been conducted in a manner where people were aware and could have provided consent or intervened if necessary and still achieved a similar result”?

(Misunderstood you about the lock part, thought you were saying they were locking the premises because it was a crime scene or something and not notifying you.)

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by tw04 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#37314010)
>I don’t think I am. If the FBI can remotely execute code on my machine then they could certainly drop a notification with a link to a page explaining the situation and how to remediate.

You're making a ton of leaps of faith that a user is going to both read and follow the instructions.

>Or they could use any number of emergency alert systems to make people aware of a potentially harmful botnet.

So... you want the FBI to reach out to all of the world's governments and have them issue an "emergency alert" to get people to patch their computers? And you think that's a reasonable stance to take?

>Or they could email the owner of the machine instead of running their own malware.

And they're getting these email addresses how?

>I just don’t think your “let the police do whatever they want to people’s property it’s for the greater good” mentality is healthy, especially not in the US where we very carefully limit the power we grant over violence because we recognize property and privacy rights.

And I think you're arguing for the sake of arguing. Literally nobody said "let the police do whatever they want with people's property". The machines in question were ACTIVELY PARTICIPATING IN ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES. This isn't some philosophical debate.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by nradov on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:23PM (#37313433)
Police can legally enter private property unannounced and shut down a meth lab if it presents an imminent safety hazard. This isn't trespassing. They will not be liable for any loss you suffer as a result as long as their actions are judged to be "reasonable". There is an extensive body of case law on this (at least regarding physical places, not computers).
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:46PM (#37312116)
> If someone starts running a meth lab out of your unlocked cellar, at what point do you become culpable for not knowing?

The problem with analogies is that they assume they are correctly "analogous" but 9/10 times they really describe an entirely different situation, making them unhelpful if not misleading

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:12PM (#37312444)
The problem with analogies is that people who disagree tend to just say "X is not Y" instead of "X is different from Y in this context due to Z". I'm not sure whether that is just a social behavior or if saying the second thing is especially hard.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by rzzzt on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#37312807)
A duck is not a horse due to... it not being a horse. You can macroexpand Z to "not having four legs", etc., but incomparable things will end up being different just based on their very essence.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:47PM (#37312935)
"Why can't I pull a small wagon with a team of ducks? I can pull a large wagon with a team of horses."

Useful answers: Ducks are not as intelligent as horses and aren't as easy to train. There is not a good way to strap a harness onto a duck for this task. Ducks waddle and this introduces turbulence. Ducks have substantially less pulling power. etc.

Useless answer: A duck is not a horse because a duck is different from a horse.

The person making the analogy knows that it is an analogy; it is not the source of confusion.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:49PM (#37313842)
It's not especially hard -- the burden of proof just isn't on the listener. Saying "X is not Y" is just saying "I'm not convinced, you must do better with your analogies". With enough context, one can infer as much

Letting someone run a meth lab in your cellar is pretty obviously not the same as "letting" some malware run on your box, for crying out loud

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:44AM (#37322917)
You're saying that it would be easy to address the point directly, but you won't because it is not your responsibility to do so? I'm not in love with that line of reasoning, but, taking it as fact, surely the analogy is not unhelpful (it successfully conveyed to you why the other person's mental model is wrong) and instead your response is (you do not feel obliged to pass that information along).

"I'm not convinced, you must do better with your analogies" is exceedingly unhelpful if you actually know what the issue is. What do you imagine is the correct response to that? Are they supposed to keep guessing at analogies while you say "Nope!" until they read your mind? Just because the important differences are obvious to you doesn't mean that they're obvious to them (and the fact that they used the analogy suggests very strongly that they are not).

"Obviously not the same thing" is generally applicable to all analogies, valid or otherwise.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:40PM (#37328755)
Choosing not to say what's wrong with the analogy is veiled criticism that the analogy is worse than just "not applicable" -- it's shit.

It expresses repulsion in addition to expressing rejection.

And, yes, they'll have to guess what's wrong... But the argument my veiled criticism is making is that their analogy is so objectively bad that it won't take them more than half a second to figure out what's wrong with it. I refuse to waste my time explaining because I value my time more than that (even if, perhaps ironically, I don't mind explaining to you why I chose not to explain myself to them)

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:43PM (#37329550)
It sounds like we're in agreement about the facts here (though I am not convinced this is a good thing to do).

For the record, it has been a day and I have not figured out what you believe is wrong with the analogy. Everyone else in the thread seems to be going along with it, except for one person who correctly points out that the 'lock the doors' aspect is irrelevant. I'm not really invested in the answer (my aim was just to defend the usefulness of analogies), but that feels like a data point I should pass along.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:53PM (#37331553)
Making sure someone is not using your cellar to cook meth requires nothing other than working eyes or a sense of smell one can reasonably expect the average person to have

Making sure you do not have malware in your computer requires specific knowledge that the average person likely doesn't have. Sure, you can take precautions, use antivirus, etc. but those are not foolproof and often involve specific tradeoffs like wasting CPU cycles, unlike the methlab in cellar scenario. They also require knowing you should take precautions to not be infected to begin with, which is rarely the case

The wine cellar exists in the physical world for which we evolved to inhabit. Malware does not.

[dead]
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Friday September 01, 2023 @09:50AM (#37350834)
Thanks. All fair points and a great comment very much in line with the HN guidelines as far as I'm concerned (not that I'm a moderator!): https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Your comment got was marked "dead", so I went ahead and vouched for it + upvoted, which I think now has marked it with the proper respect it deserves. You can vouch for comments after you reach a certain karma level (there are various unlocks for various levels of karma, but nothing that changes your experience here, really)

Welcome to HN!

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by airstrike on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:44PM (#37328819)
> "Obviously not the same thing" is generally applicable to all analogies, valid or otherwise.

This feels like nitpicking / grasping at straws / being needlessly obtuse but I'll follow the guidelines and quote-unquote "Assume Good Faith" -- fine, rephrase my comment as "obviously not analogous" rather than "obviously not the same as"

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by hinkley on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:43PM (#37312878)
Probably at the moment you try to sue them for taking away your volunteer meth lab.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by neodymiumphish on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:29PM (#37315561)
There's plenty of room for security researchers running infected machines to monitor for behavioral and developmental changes in the malware to be more than a little irritated by the notion that the FBI or anyone else abused the malware servers to remove the infection surreptitiously.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by pfdietz on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:56PM (#37311490)
I wonder if the FBI could legally brick the machines involved (particular if some were devices that had never been patched.)
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by ip_addr on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:42PM (#37311305)
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by doakes on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:33PM (#37312743)
I'm getting 403'd on these links
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by AtomicOrbital on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:36PM (#37312784)
Links work
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by libraryatnight on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:16PM (#37313323)
This was really interesting to read, thank you for the links.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by hanniabu on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:04PM (#37311598)
It's the government, since when are they concerned about legality
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by revscat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:10PM (#37311672)
More often than you’d think.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by verve_rat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:13PM (#37312458)
My question: how does a US warrant apply to computers outside US jurisdiction?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by paxys on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#37312801)
They didn't access any random computers outside of their jurisdiction, only Qakbot servers.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by paganel on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:40PM (#37312844)
I must have missed it, but does the article mention that those servers were all located inside the US? (where I supposed FBI has jurisdiction for stuff like this).
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by paxys on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:50PM (#37312968)
> As part of the operation, the FBI gained lawful access to Qakbot’s infrastructure and identified over 700,000 infected computers worldwide—including more than 200,000 in the U.S.

"Lawful access" is doing a lot of heavy lifting, but at least they specified it.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by rainsford on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:38PM (#37315652)
The first sentence of the article describes it as a "multinational operation" and the title credits both FBI and "partners". That makes it pretty clear it wasn't just a US agency operating with the authority of a US warrant.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by anonym29 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:59PM (#37311528)
There are a LOT of things I'd trust more than a closed-source binary executable served by the FBI purporting to help me.

Gas station sushi, a drink from Bill Cosby, a childhood sleepover at Michael Jackson's place, a cup of Kool Aid from Jim Jones...

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by neovialogistics on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:03PM (#37311585)
I'd trust it a hell of a lot more than a binary originating from any other USG letter agency, except maybe OSHA and the NWS.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by galleywest200 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:05PM (#37311604)
NASA has a good set of open source projects available for public use: https://code.nasa.gov/
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by anonym29 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:11PM (#37311682)
Keyword: "open source", as in, you are permitted/encouraged to understand what it's doing.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:53PM (#37312206)
And the big question is what if your machine is configure in a way that is incompatible with the FBI’s justice.exe and you lose irreplaceable data?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by shadowgovt on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:13PM (#37312454)
Legally speaking? While IANAL, looking at the warrant issued and signed, the nature of such a loss would be akin to any other loss incurred during a search and seizure.

In general, such losses are understood as incidental and the searchee is not protected from them. If the police smash your front door in, they aren't responsible for paying to replace the lock; if they think you hid drugs in your wall and take a Sawzall to it, they don't owe you drywall. In the extreme, it's been found that if a flashbang burns your house down during a raid, they aren't liable to replace your house (even if the target of the raid wasn't on that property). Warrants basically suspend some civil rights temporarily; that's why they require a judicial concurrence.

So I have no specific case citation for data loss due to a digital search and seizure, but my guess from analogy is that if you have an unusual configuration (cracked the botnet control program open and stored your private Bitcoin key in there?) and the FBI's counter-net wipes your data, you will not prevail in a court of law, much as if your front door was somehow load-bearing and the cops, upon hitting it with the battering ram, knocked your house over. But since I can't point to a specific case to give precedent, hey, whatever you and the lawyer you can afford can argue, I guess. ;)

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by jstarfish on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:47PM (#37312940)
> And the big question is what if your machine is configure in a way that is incompatible with the FBI’s justice.exe and you lose irreplaceable data?

Dude, this is just manufactured outrage. Come on:

> Qakbot delivered additional malware—including ransomware—to their computer

Bemoaning the possibility of the cops trampling your petunias while responding to the arsonist literally trying to take-hostage-or-destroy every square inch of your property is being petty.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by smaudet on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:12PM (#37313273)
The analogy is not apt.

In most cases the victims were not aware, meaning they still had ample use of their proverbial property. This is in fact the normally desired state of malware, to act like a pest or a leech - your estate suffers but not in a very noticeable way.

I think most people would object to their yard being turned upside down because some e.g. illegal grasshoppers were present...so in that sense yes they should provide notice...if able.

Which is where the concept of "estate" falls apart a bit. Unless you can positively map every node to a single responsible actor, then it is unreasonable to provide notice. Furthermore, there are so many components to modern tech systems that it is not reasonable that anyone would know or care the exact goings on of their systems (usually).

That is, if you use the web and execute from it, in some sense you cannot (or should not) hold fully liable any one entity, in some small sense the malware has turned your computer into public property anyways, so the actions of the FBI are not entirely unreasonable.

If you cry foul this action then even more so you should cry foul the actions of any public update service etc...vendor updates always carry a similar risk.

What I could say, if there were some common message format for indicating to the user what was to happen, then it would be reasonable to require notification of such. But likely there is no such thing so mainly this argument is rhetorical.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:18PM (#37313366)
I’m not outraged at all. I’m simply wondering.

You analogy isn’t accurate. The bot net wasn’t burning down or bricking machines. It was leeching bandwidth and cpu cycles. So a more apt analogy might be animal control sniping bunnies off your petunias and hitting a window with your family heirloom on display instead.

The only thing about this whole thing that makes me double take is that it happened without permission or notice. I really wouldn’t be happy if I found out tue FBI was rummaging around my machine removing files without my consent. It’s still my property and I’m sure I’d be happy to cooperate if the FBI raised to my attention that there was malicious software on my machine.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by pjc50 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:05PM (#37312352)
As compared to a closed source binary forcibly installed on your machine by criminals?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:11PM (#37312434)
To clarify a little, you mean criminals that aren't the FBI? because otherwise we might get stuck in a loop here.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by shadowgovt on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:36PM (#37311991)
One of my favorite tricks in dealing with botnets: if you can access the control plane, you can convince the network to do most anything... Including self-terminate.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by 1-6 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:19PM (#37312546)
Until bot operators learn to encrypt the control plane network.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by apstls on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#37312808)
This was the case here as well.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by georgeburdell on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:51PM (#37312181)
Imagine if a race condition in someone’s backend was fixed by being slowed down just a little bit by this malware, and then the malware issue was surreptitiously fixed by the FBI and it broke again

https://xkcd.com/1172/

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by m_0x on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:19PM (#37312545)
Using malware to combat malware.

Hopefully they aren't lying.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by debarshri on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:39PM (#37312832)
Anti viruses act like malware anyways
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by koolba on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:43PM (#37312876)
> Using malware to combat malware.

Though it’s only legal when they do it. Pretty sure it’d still be a crime if a good Samaritan tried it out.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by paxys on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:48PM (#37312941)
Why are you making it sound like that's some profound revelation? Law enforcement is allowed to run stings, serve warrants and make arrests, you aren't. The military is allowed to invade countries and drop nukes, you aren't. Yes it is legal when they do it and not some average Joe who wants to play hero. That's how the world works, and it is a good thing.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by koolba on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:39PM (#37313695)
> Why are you making it sound like that's some profound revelation?

I've never claimed any of my musings are profound revelations. That's an exercise left to the reader.

> Law enforcement is allowed to run stings, serve warrants and make arrests, you aren't.

Specifics matter. "The Government" is not some monolithic entity. Even "law enforcement" could be local, State level, FBI, CIA, or some other part of the executive branch. Each has its own restrictions on when and how it can operate.

> The military is allowed to invade countries and drop nukes, you aren't.

The military is expressly disallowed from interfering in civilian affairs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act

> Yes it is legal when they do it and not some average Joe who wants to play hero.

It's an untested open question whether it's legal for them to do it to US civilians or infrastructure that they know is owned by US civilians.

It might be the right thing to do. The world might be better for it. It might even be decided one day that they do in fact have that power (there's a pretty clear argument that stopping a botnet qualifies as "Hot pursuit": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_pursuit).

> That's how the world works, and it is a good thing.

There's plenty of "ends justify the means" situations involving the government that are not good things applied more generally. Hence, specifics matter.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by thghtihadanacct on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @09:01PM (#37316311)
I appreciate the point by point break down but > The military is allowed to invade countries and drop nukes, you aren't.

The military is expressly disallowed from interfering in civilian affairs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act

Is vice versa.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by KRAKRISMOTT on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:04PM (#37313150)
The state's monopoly on violence and the general social contract on exercise of force is more tenuous in america. If mainstream politicians can incite stochastic violence with songs about "small towns", there's no reason why similar vigilantism political doctrine cannot be extended to the cyberspace. The US is exceptional in many ways.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by fluoridation on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:20PM (#37313394)
I don't believe there's any laws that forbid individuals from invading countries and using nuclear weapons.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by glasshug on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:35PM (#37313619)
18 U.S.C. §960

> Whoever, within the United States, knowingly begins or sets on foot or provides or prepares a means for or furnishes the money for, or takes part in, any military or naval expedition or enterprise to be carried on from thence against the territory or dominion of any foreign prince or state, or of any colony, district, or people with whom the United States is at peace, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by fluoridation on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:43PM (#37313750)
So what you're saying is that it's legal for an American to nuke a country as long as the US is already at war with that country.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by glasshug on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:19PM (#37314278)
Ha! No, 42 U.S.C. 2122.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by fluoridation on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:29PM (#37314400)
Nanny state.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by civilitty on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:09PM (#37315925)
Thanks for ruining my weekend plans!
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by thghtihadanacct on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:59PM (#37316303)
The crazy part is how old those codes are. Someone saw shenanigans from a long time off.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by throwaway58480 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @10:15PM (#37316847)
Am I reading this wrong or are foreign heads of state that produce nuclear weapons technically committing a crime which the US considers itself to have jurisdiction over? If so why aren't they arrested when they travel to the US?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by 9991 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:39PM (#37315663)
The U.S. hasn't declared war since WWII, so it looks like the entirety of the U.S. military is in violation of this. It's looking more and more like what actually gets prosecuted is a political decision.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by afthonos on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:14PM (#37315953)
Yes, this is true, but in a far more boring way than you imagine. Prosecutors have huge latitude on what to prosecute, and the police on what to direct investigatory resources to. At every point, the unconscious and sometimes conscious politics of the people making those decisions are in play. That’s what makes reforming the system so hard.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:17AM (#37319070)
Where would this leave Elon Musk and his possible servicing of Putin? He'a got money so I know he'll be fine but still kind of shocked such a high-profile government contractor can get away with this kind of thing with no collateral damage to their business or personal effects
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by voz_ on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:49PM (#37312961)
Yeah, it's part of the social contract? This is a good thing. It's the same reason I cant just grab a gun and start arresting people as a "good Samaritan".
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by flutas on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:33PM (#37313596)
I mean, citizens arrest is a thing in many countries.[0] Immunity varies, laws vary, but it's definitely a thing...

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen%27s_arrest

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by jszymborski on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:43PM (#37313749)
Am I missing something or wouldn't the author(s) of Qakbot be able to avoid this attack by cryptographically signing commands and having clients check them?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by chilmers on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:15PM (#37314230)
From https://www.secureworks.com/blog/law-enforcement-takes-down-...

"To interact with infected hosts, the replacement servers required a certificate that can sign messages. It appears that the certificates were obtained and used for good intentions."

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by paxys on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:51PM (#37313878)
It doesn't matter. If you gain access to their servers you can sign the commands yourself.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by rcxdude on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#37314006)
Depends on where the key is. Command and control servers don't need to have the keys for the commands they are relaying.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by datadeft on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:54PM (#37313926)
I am pretty sure that is not their top priority.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by jagged-chisel on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#37314003)
Having been around during the 90s Cryptowars (and related culture and counterculture) I do wonder if in a few years we’ll hear that NSA piggybacked some “fun” toys on this uninstaller.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by neodymiumphish on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:23PM (#37315514)
Considering the (il)legality of what they did just by running the uninstaller without authority, and the obvious implications and attention this would have, I highly doubt they did any such thing in this particular instance.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by weird-eye-issue on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:39PM (#37316138)
They did something highly illegal so you highly doubt they did one extra illegal thing at the same time?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by neodymiumphish on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:10PM (#37328281)
I worked in federal law enforcement on these same kinds of cases. The approvals needed to authorize a plan like this are very heavily scrutinized. Any aside added in to leave a lasting effect directed toward monitored lawful activity would have blown this all up immediately.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by smfjaw on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @09:01PM (#37316313)
lol, seen the edward snowden documentry?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by jchw on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @09:19PM (#37316454)
The track record that U.S. government agencies have says otherwise. Was there any accountability at all for the Snowden revelations? I mean, aside from Snowden himself, anyway.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:22PM (#37314308)
Sometimes I wonder why the American public has to be subject to the all the evils of so-called "tech" companies when clearly the US government has the personnel to write safe, reliable software.

Unlike so-called "tech" companies that can safely ignore Americans' reasonable expectations of privacy in order to generate obscene profits, there are laws that prohibit the US government from engaging in similar shenangigans.

Even if hypothetical government-issued software might be "inferior" to whatever the so-called "tech" companies are producing, it would still be "superior" from a regulatory standpoint. Americans would have some enforceable rights as software users.

Someone is inevitably going to make a wise crack reply about government contracting. But I'm not referring to contractors. I'm referring to government employees.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by TylerE on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#37314404)
Government software is great if you have a decade and a billion dollars to spend.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by themagician on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:50PM (#37314616)
>"Sometimes I wonder why the American public has to be subject to the all the evils of so-called "tech" companies when clearly the US government has the personnel to write safe, reliable software."

It's not just the American public, it's every computer user—everywhere. The reason is because it's easy.

There's plenty of secure software and systems out there. It's hard to use. The costs outweigh the benefits for most people most of the time. We could all be running Qubes or openBSD but we don't because it's hard. It's hard to do simple things. Most of the world runs on Windows and people are logged in as admin. It's a point and click world.

I don't know if the government needs to write software, but I do think there is room for a vendor to step up, particularly in the business world, with systems that offer ironclad security.

IMO we are in an increasingly dangerous world. I'm surprised the internet connected world hasn't collapsed yet. Every day seems to be a new kind of scam or malware. It takes incredible effort to safeguard systems today. One wrong click and in 5 minutes your entire life can be destroyed. I'm curious what the stats are on malware that has completely destroyed businesses. Cyber insurance policies are almost necessary now even if you consider yourself a skilled user.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by bredren on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:42PM (#37315109)
> there are laws that prohibit the US government from engaging in similar shenangigans.

If the laws you’re alluding to are steadfast, provide true equal protection and are perfectly enforced I could see greater reliance on government software tools.

However, history is littered with government agencies failing to protect people. Not to pick on the FBI here but the organization’s own J. Edward Hoover wasn’t the most privacy focused person. The group’s HQ is still named after this person.

Perhaps other organizations could be relied on more. People have wanted free tax filing software for a long time.

However, even the IRS has been shown vulnerable to take actions based on pressure from political forces.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by kvetching on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#37314410)
"The FBI Supernode Module and the Qakbot Uninstaller DO NOT remediate malware that was already installed on the infected computer through Qakbot, such as ransomware or other malware that steals financial credentials. However, the Qakbot Uninstaller is designed to prevent additional malware from being installed on the infected computer through the Qakbot botnet by untethering the victim computer from the botnet. "

-https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-08/23mj4244_application_reda...

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by adolph on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:36PM (#37314470)
> That's pretty sweet that they healed hundreds of thousands of computers

The cynical part of me says that (1) they just installed an NSA backdoor in hundreds of thousands of computers; (2) the FBI probably didn't even realize it; (3) it'll all come to light some years from now when the NSA tooling is leaked by a careless contractor and used by various worse actors; (4) but the "leak" was NSA's plan all along to spy on said various worse actors.

The meta-cynical part of me says all that is way too convoluted and I should take off the tin-foil fedora and tip it to m'lady.