News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by anonym29 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:59PM (#37311528)
There are a LOT of things I'd trust more than a closed-source binary executable served by the FBI purporting to help me.

Gas station sushi, a drink from Bill Cosby, a childhood sleepover at Michael Jackson's place, a cup of Kool Aid from Jim Jones...

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by neovialogistics on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:03PM (#37311585)
I'd trust it a hell of a lot more than a binary originating from any other USG letter agency, except maybe OSHA and the NWS.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by galleywest200 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:05PM (#37311604)
NASA has a good set of open source projects available for public use: https://code.nasa.gov/
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by anonym29 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:11PM (#37311682)
Keyword: "open source", as in, you are permitted/encouraged to understand what it's doing.
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:53PM (#37312206)
And the big question is what if your machine is configure in a way that is incompatible with the FBI’s justice.exe and you lose irreplaceable data?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by shadowgovt on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:13PM (#37312454)
Legally speaking? While IANAL, looking at the warrant issued and signed, the nature of such a loss would be akin to any other loss incurred during a search and seizure.

In general, such losses are understood as incidental and the searchee is not protected from them. If the police smash your front door in, they aren't responsible for paying to replace the lock; if they think you hid drugs in your wall and take a Sawzall to it, they don't owe you drywall. In the extreme, it's been found that if a flashbang burns your house down during a raid, they aren't liable to replace your house (even if the target of the raid wasn't on that property). Warrants basically suspend some civil rights temporarily; that's why they require a judicial concurrence.

So I have no specific case citation for data loss due to a digital search and seizure, but my guess from analogy is that if you have an unusual configuration (cracked the botnet control program open and stored your private Bitcoin key in there?) and the FBI's counter-net wipes your data, you will not prevail in a court of law, much as if your front door was somehow load-bearing and the cops, upon hitting it with the battering ram, knocked your house over. But since I can't point to a specific case to give precedent, hey, whatever you and the lawyer you can afford can argue, I guess. ;)

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by jstarfish on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:47PM (#37312940)
> And the big question is what if your machine is configure in a way that is incompatible with the FBI’s justice.exe and you lose irreplaceable data?

Dude, this is just manufactured outrage. Come on:

> Qakbot delivered additional malware—including ransomware—to their computer

Bemoaning the possibility of the cops trampling your petunias while responding to the arsonist literally trying to take-hostage-or-destroy every square inch of your property is being petty.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by smaudet on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:12PM (#37313273)
The analogy is not apt.

In most cases the victims were not aware, meaning they still had ample use of their proverbial property. This is in fact the normally desired state of malware, to act like a pest or a leech - your estate suffers but not in a very noticeable way.

I think most people would object to their yard being turned upside down because some e.g. illegal grasshoppers were present...so in that sense yes they should provide notice...if able.

Which is where the concept of "estate" falls apart a bit. Unless you can positively map every node to a single responsible actor, then it is unreasonable to provide notice. Furthermore, there are so many components to modern tech systems that it is not reasonable that anyone would know or care the exact goings on of their systems (usually).

That is, if you use the web and execute from it, in some sense you cannot (or should not) hold fully liable any one entity, in some small sense the malware has turned your computer into public property anyways, so the actions of the FBI are not entirely unreasonable.

If you cry foul this action then even more so you should cry foul the actions of any public update service etc...vendor updates always carry a similar risk.

What I could say, if there were some common message format for indicating to the user what was to happen, then it would be reasonable to require notification of such. But likely there is no such thing so mainly this argument is rhetorical.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by dcow on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:18PM (#37313366)
I’m not outraged at all. I’m simply wondering.

You analogy isn’t accurate. The bot net wasn’t burning down or bricking machines. It was leeching bandwidth and cpu cycles. So a more apt analogy might be animal control sniping bunnies off your petunias and hitting a window with your family heirloom on display instead.

The only thing about this whole thing that makes me double take is that it happened without permission or notice. I really wouldn’t be happy if I found out tue FBI was rummaging around my machine removing files without my consent. It’s still my property and I’m sure I’d be happy to cooperate if the FBI raised to my attention that there was malicious software on my machine.

Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by pjc50 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:05PM (#37312352)
As compared to a closed source binary forcibly installed on your machine by criminals?
Re:FBI, Partners Dismantle Qakbot Infrastructure in Multinat... by micromacrofoot on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:11PM (#37312434)
To clarify a little, you mean criminals that aren't the FBI? because otherwise we might get stuck in a loop here.