News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by TheAlchemist on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:22PM (#37242626)
What's also pretty interesting that they actually didn't sell more chips this quarter - they ... just pretty much doubled the prices (hence the huge margin).

This is what having a monopoly looks like !

This is also why companies that manufacture their cards didn't report any uptick in profits. I'm wondering how this play out in some months ? Do they have any pricing power with respect to NVidia ? Or NVidia could just switch to another manufacturer ?

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by PheonixPharts on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:31PM (#37243297)
> This is what having a monopoly looks like !

As someone who has been in the AI/ML space for over a decade, and even had an AMD/Radeon card for more than half of that, I can't help but feel that this is partially AMD's own fault.

For many, many years it seemed to me that AMD just didn't take AI/ML seriously whereas, for all it's faults, NVIDIA seemed to catch on very early that ML presented a tremendous potential market.

To this day getting things like Stable Diffusion to run on an AMD card requires extra work. At least from my perspective it seems like dedicating a few engineers to getting ROCm working on all major OSes with all major scientific computing/deep learning libraries would have been a pretty good investment.

Is there some context I'm missing for why AMD never caught up in this space?

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by uluyol on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:39PM (#37244105)
Catching up in this space requires a significant, sustained investment over multiple years and competent software engineers. It's not a simple thing for a hardware company to suddenly become competitive with Nvidia in AI/ML.

Instead, they've been going after the CPU market (and winning), HPC/scientific computing (high FP64 performance, in contrast to Nvidia's focus on low-precision ML compute), and integrating Xilinx.

However, I agree that it's an unfortunate situation, and I hope AMD becomes competitive in this space soon.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by slashdev on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:10PM (#37244578)
I think their hardware is comparable with nvidia. The problem is the software is awful by comparison. It’s hard to run any of the AI workloads with AMD, and even when you can the performance is poor. The software investment just hasn’t been made. Until then they are not even in the game.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by ken47 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:43PM (#37243376)
Until very recently, AMD was struggling for survival. Rather than making the big bet on AI, they went for the sure thing by banking on revolutionary CPU tech. I'm sure if they were in a better financial position 5 years ago, they would have gone bigger on AI.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by xmprt on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:58PM (#37243481)
And arguable their bet on CPU tech worked! AMD is in a much better position today than they were 5+ years ago. They have some catching up to do but that doesn't mean their completely out of the game.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by xcdzvyn on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:56AM (#37246540)
"much better" is an understatement! "AMD predicted to go bankrupt by 2020"[0]

[0] https://www.overclock3d.net/news/cpu_mainboard/amd_predicted...

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by bornfreddy on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:08PM (#37253217)
Great achievement! Of course, they can also thank Intel for waiting for them to catch up.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by izacus on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:29AM (#37246049)
They also focused on game consoles, where they won contracts for both major platforms this generation.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by Toutouxc on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:51AM (#37246146)
Previous one too. Xbox One and Series and PS4 and PS5 are all AMD, and there’s several revisions of each (e.g. PS4 OG, Slim, Pro).
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by zirgs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:53AM (#37246169)
The other non-major Nvidia based console has higher sales numbers than both of so-called major consoles combined.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by mschuster91 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:13AM (#37246276)
It's ... difficult to compare a low-power SoC released in 2015 (so, design dating back to 2014 if not earlier) with high-power consoles developed in 2019 onwards.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by zirgs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @05:00AM (#37246574)
They belong to the same generation. Until Switch 2 is released.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by asddubs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @06:50AM (#37247330)
That doesn't mean they're meaningfully comparable (in the context we are talking about). A $100 budget android phone that was released at the same time as the latest iphone also belongs to the same generation, but that doesn't mean the chip manufacturers profit equally from the two (of course apple makes their own chips so in a literal sense this comparison doesn't make sense, but I'm sure you understand what I mean)

And I don't mean to disparage the switch, just point out that the way it's designed is very different which makes the comparison questionable

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by edgyquant on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:35PM (#37243332)
100% this. I, and many others, bought multiple AMD cards due to disliking NVidia and tried to get ROCm set up to no avail. It just never worked except under hard to maintain configurations. I switched to an nvidia card and within the hour import tensorflow just worked
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by fleischhauf on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:24PM (#37243667)
to be fair Nvidia drivers are also a nightmare under linux
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by jacooper on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:03AM (#37246207)
Not anymore
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by kristopolous on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:15AM (#37246287)
Until they are. When the system breaks it breaks real bad. Nvcc/gcc/cuda/kernel mismatches are a pain to match up right. It gets gnarly super fast.

All systems hit snags. In most, you skid the tires a bit, maybe lose balance. With nvidia you're flying over the handlebars on to the asphalt.

I got snagged by this just about 2 weeks ago. It gets nasty. Not as bad as CUPS, but probably #2.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by michaelt on Thursday August 24, 2023 @06:59AM (#37247393)
Eh, depends what you want out of them.

Do you want solid dependability and settings that are right first time, because you've only got one PC and if the graphics get broken you've got no browser to google for a fix?

Do you want the absolute most up-to-date drivers, to support the very newest GPUs, while running an LTS version of your OS?

Do you want to always run the latest driver version and upgrade without testing or worrying, like we do for web browsers?

Do you want to run CUDA and ML stuff, but also want to run Steam which for some reason wants 32-bit support available?

Do you want to run on a laptop with hybrid graphics, and have suspend/resume work reliably every time?

Do you have a small /boot/ partition, because you expected initrd.img to be 50MB or less?

Do you want to support Secure Boot?

If you want to achieve all these things at once, it'll take you a few tries to get it right :)

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by Dalewyn on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:11PM (#37243569)
What really strikes me is Nvidia's been working hard on doing practical work on their GPUs even just 10~15 years ago with PhysX, while both Intel and AMD just existed.

Nvidia's dominance today is the product of at least over a decade of work and investments to make better products. Today they are finally reaping their rewards.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by desiarnezjr on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:18PM (#37243621)
I remember meeting NVIDIA in the late aughts (2007?) first launching their CUDA efforts. Really the product was a re-branded 780GTX or whatever their high end gaming card was at the time more or less, but they already laid out a clear pathway to today (more or less).
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by dekhn on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:29PM (#37243692)
I remember meeting with them in the mid aughts when they were first talking to HPC folks about using their cards for science. I'll never forget what the chief scientist from nVidia said. "What is the color of a NaN? That is, when you render a texture with a nan value, what does it look like? I'll tell: it's nvidia green."
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by WanderPanda on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:46PM (#37243802)
That is a funny way to signal their commitment to HPC! But compared to other tooling (non GPU) CUDA is still really clunky. Way ahead of everything else in the GPGPU space but still surprisingly clunky. Also I don't get what they are fearing with all their "Account required for download" (e.g. for CuDNN) what are they fearing? And is it really worth the trade-off for the pain it causes for dev environments and CI pipelines? It really seems like Intel and AMD have to step in to break this monopoly to force them to improve the situation for everyone.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by jjoonathan on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:06PM (#37243944)
No, you're not missing anything, NVIDIA's software is super clunky by the standards of most of the software world. However, for the last decade, the competition has been much worse: OpenCL development on AMD would be riddled with VRAM leaks, hard lockups, invisible limits on things like function length and registers that would cause the hard lockups when you tripped over them without any indication as to what you did wrong or how to fix it, that sort of thing. Cryptic error messages would lead to threads scattered around the internet, years old, with pleas for help and no happy endings.

The thing that caused me to ragequit the AMD ecosystem was when I took an OpenCL program I had been fighting for two days straight and ran it on my buddy's Nvidia system in hopes of getting an error message that might point me in the right direction. Instead, the program just ran, and it ran much faster, even though the nvidia card was theoretically slower.

In terms of quality, I expect the competition to catch up in a generation or two, but then there is still the decade+ of legacy code to consider. Hopefully with how fast AI/ML churns that isn't actually an insurmountable obstacle.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by versteegen on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:09AM (#37247457)
Years ago I gave up on OpenCL (1.2 on an AMD card) because of those hard lockups, with no way to debug it. nVidia didn't even support OpenCL 1.2 (and IIRC didn't support the synchronisation primitives I wanted in CUDA either -- AMD was more capable on paper). Thanks, I feel better to hear just how bad it was -- so it wasn't just my fault for quitting.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by jjoonathan on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:44PM (#37243789)
It's a quality meme but I'm having trouble figuring out the settings that make it work. It looks like RGBA8 would be blue:

    >>> struct.pack('f',math.nan)
    b'\x00\x00\xc0\x7f'
maybe that becomes green if you composite over white or something? Or maybe there is a common type of NaN that fills some of the unspecified bits? ("Just use the particular NaN that makes it green" is cheating unless you have an excuse)
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by nealabq on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:22PM (#37244022)
They mean big-endian NaN, taking only the first 3 bytes. No alpha channel.

https://encycolorpedia.com/76b900 says Nvidia green #76b900.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by jjoonathan on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:10PM (#37244278)
Cool, thanks!
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by scns on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:14AM (#37245579)
Encycolorpedia looks like a great resource, thank you very much. A similar one would be Colorhexa. Not affiliated.

https://colorhexa.com

[Edit] Could not find it under the name, but it shows how color blind users perceive it. And it loads much faster.

https://www.colorhexa.com/76b900

[Edit] Encycolorpedia has a color blindness simulator too. Have to check on desktop.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by dekhn on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:59PM (#37243888)
It was an arbitrary decision by the engineers who made the early GPUs, they just mapped NaN to an RGB

It was a nice way to debug tensors: render them to the screen, the green sticks out.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by rasz on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:24PM (#37244349)
I remember uni course on GPGPU and only discovering during first lecture Nvidia donated hardware to make sure it would be Cuda only course.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by hinoki on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:39AM (#37246092)
32-bit NaN is encoded: s111 1111 1xxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx

Where both the sign (s) and the x bits can be anything and it will still be treated as a NaN.

There are lots of ways to encode colour, but there would be too much red with RGBA, and ARGB could be almost any opaque colour, but the red channel has to be at least 0x80, which is still too much red.

So NaNs are too red to encode nvidia green.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by andersa on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:05AM (#37246225)
I once ended up having nans get interpreted as 32 bit colors accidentally, and it made everything red and white, like Christmas decoration.

Wonder what caused the difference in the latter bits being all 1 or 0 together.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by rasz on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:08PM (#37244268)
>doing practical work ... even just 10~15 years ago with PhysX

practical work with PhysX 13 years ago: https://www.realworldtech.com/physx87/

"For Nvidia, decreasing the baseline CPU performance by using x87 instructions and a single thread makes GPUs look better."

Nvidia magically released PhysX compiled with multithreading enabled and without flags disabling SSE a week after this publication. But couple of days before release they made those funny statements:

"It's fair to say we've got more room to improve on the CPU. But it's not fair to say, in the words of that article, that we're intentionally hobbling the CPU," Skolones told Ars.

"nobody ever asked for it, and it wouldn't help real games anyway because the bottlenecks are elsewhere"

>Nvidia's dominance today is the product of at least over a decade of work

Nvidias decade of work:

Ubisoft comments on Assassin’s Creed DX10.1 controversy https://techreport.com/news/14707/ubisoft-comments-on-assass...

AMD says Nvidia’s GameWorks “completely sabotaged” Witcher 3 performance https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/05/amd-says-nvidias-game...

AMD Dubs Nvidia’s GameWorks Tragic And Damaging, Fight Over The Developer Program Continues https://wccftech.com/fight-nvidias-gameworks-continues-amd-c...

"Number one: Nvidia Gameworks typically damages the performance on Nvidia hardware as well, which is a bit tragic really. It certainly feels like it’s about reducing the performance, even on high-end graphics cards, so that people have to buy something new.

"That’s the consequence of it, whether it’s intended or not - and I guess I can’t read anyone’s minds so I can’t tell you what their intention is. But the consequence of it is it brings PCs to their knees when it’s unnecessary. And if you look at Crysis 2 in particular, you see that they’re tessellating water that’s not visible to millions of triangles every frame, and they’re tessellating blocks of concrete – essentially large rectangular objects – and generating millions of triangles per frame which are useless."

"The world's greatest virtual concrete slab" https://web.archive.org/web/20121002034311/http://techreport... (images "somehow" vanished from original article at techreport where Nvidia runs marketing campaigns)

"Unnecessary geometric detail slows down all GPUs, of course, but it just so happens to have a much larger effect on DX11-capable AMD Radeons than it does on DX11-capable Nvidia GeForces. The Fermi architecture underlying all DX11-class GeForce GPUs dedicates more attention (and transistors) to achieving high geometry processing throughput than the competing Radeon GPU architectures."

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by _gabe_ on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:46PM (#37244796)
> But GameWorks' capabilities are necessarily Nvidia-optimized; such code may perform poorly on AMD GPUs.

From the arstechnica article about Witcher 3.

How dare Nvidia optimize their game enhancing effects for Nvidia hardware and forget to do it for their competitors hardware as well! And as for a lot of these complaints, could it be that a lot of companies only optimize for hardware that has the largest market share?

According to the steam hardware survey in July of 2023, Nvidia accounts for 75% of the GPUs[0]. Nvidia and Amd have a lot of incompatibilities, and it can be hard to make the same code performant on both. It makes sense, as a game company, to prioritize optimizations for the largest market. No collusion and evil corporate mega lord scheming needed for this.

Edit: Also, Nvidia does put out a lot of research efforts for free. Path rendering on the GPU for example (PhysX being another). You can find research papers and videos published by Nvidia for these things. I would consider that practical work. You can hate on Nvidia for lots of things, but this is one thing I find weird to be combative over.

Second Edit: Also, why do you find the statements Nvidia said about the PhysX improvements funny? They’re right. Most games 13 years ago left a lot of idle time on the GPU while the CPU worked overtime to do logic, physics, sound, culling, etc. Lots of that stuff has also been moved to the GPU to minimize the amount of idle time on either the CPU or GPU. Nothing funny about what they said there.

[0]: https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by girvo on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:21AM (#37245314)
> could it be that a lot of companies only optimize for hardware that has the largest market share?

Yes, but also Nvidia partners directly with companies too (money can/does change hands).

Now the flip side is: so does AMD.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by Dalewyn on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:49AM (#37245810)
>Now the flip side is: so does AMD.

And their antics shutting out Nvidia (eg: FSR only, no DLSS) aren't being received well, not the least because their offerings are objectively inferior to Nvidia's.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by girvo on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:26AM (#37247989)
While Nvidia isn’t doing these silly antics today, they’ve absolutely done them in the past. None of the large consumer silicon companies have clean hands with respect to anticompetitive/anti-consumer behaviours. They’ve all got too much power frankly.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by paulmd on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:06AM (#37245222)
This is factually jot the case as confirmed by Crytek developers at the time. Wireframe mode turns off clipping and cranks up LOD to max, and normally neither the water table would be visible (under the ground) nor would that block be rendered at that LOD.

https://old.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/comments/3vppv1/crysis_2_t...

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by tho23iu423o4324 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:17PM (#37244313)
Yes, this is true.

However, a lot of this has to do with the fact that AMD was on the brink of bankruptcy before the launch of Zen in 2016 (when their share price was ~$10). They simply did not have the capital to the kind of things Nvidia was doing (since '08 ?).

The bet on OpenCL and the 'open-source' community failed. However, ROCM/HIP etc. really seems to be catching up (I even see them packaged on Arch linux).

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by slavik81 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:28AM (#37246366)
> However, ROCM/HIP etc. really seems to be catching up (I even see them packaged on Arch linux).

There are now distro-provided packages on Arch, Gentoo, Debian, Ubuntu, and Fedora.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by htrp on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:15AM (#37244940)
AMD gave up on the market for parallel compute entirely
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by xiphias2 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:12AM (#37247491)
Look at the good thing instead: they are catching up, and open source devs are starting to be serious about AMD because of its price/performance.

I believe it's a highly undervalued stock right now.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by FuriouslyAdrift on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:17AM (#37247924)
AMD has an entire line specifically for AI/ML... https://www.amd.com/en/graphics/instinct-server-accelerators

They just don't have those capabilities in their consumer GPUs.

AMD is also nearly 50/50 with nVidia for supercomputers in the Top500 (and dominates at the top)

It took a few years after completeing the massive purchase of Xilinx to get going, but they are picking up speed rapidly.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by paulmd on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:38PM (#37252052)
AMD should do a high-memory-density MCD variant of 7900XT/XTX with a MCD that has 4 PHYs instead of 2. You could get 7900XTX to 48GB with no clamshell and 96GB with clamshell, which is getting into H100 territory.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by JB_Dev on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:06PM (#37243532)
Nvidia and really all chip designers are limited by the fab companies who are trying to scale as fast as they can. But all the cutting edge fabs are limited by one single supplier - ASML. ASML make the lithography machines and have a total monopoly. Even they cannot make lithography machines fast enough to satisfy demand - their lithography machines are sold out 2 years in advance
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by paulmd on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:27AM (#37246354)
The current limitations are not about litho at all but actually about CoWoS stacking capacity.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by riow on Friday August 25, 2023 @03:19PM (#37265980)
``` CoWoS stands for Chip on Wafer on Substrate. It is a high-density packaging technology for high-performance chips. TSMC developed CoWoS in 2012. In CoWoS, multiple silicon dies are placed on a silicon interposer, which is an intermediate layer on the package board. The interposer acts as a communication layer for the active die on top. CoWoS is a 2.5D packaging technology. It is widely used in high performance computing. ```
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by thfuran on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:25PM (#37242675)
There probably isn't another manufacturer they can switch high end stuff to. They recently tried moving at least some of their cards to Samsung but switched back last generation due to yield issues.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by wmf on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:31PM (#37242729)
You have to distinguish between fabs and AIBs.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by thfuran on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:37PM (#37242790)
If they treat their AIBs for their enterprise stuff anything like they do in the consumer space, they don't really have anything to worry about there (aside from the rest of them giving up on dealing with Nvidia's BS, I guess).
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by kelvie on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:14PM (#37243157)
For my sake, what number did you look at to come to this conclusion? I'm not used to reading these quarterly reports.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by TheAlchemist on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:42PM (#37243777)
You can look at cost of revenue to get an idea.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by BbzzbB on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:44PM (#37243384)
Isn't this more a case of supply and demand? Huge ramp on chip demand by every FAAMG, every dev and their grandmothers for AI with a mostly inelastic supply (foundry constrained and very specialized atoms tech involved).

It's not like Intel and AMD don't exist, but if everyone is pushing each other at the door for Nvidia chips..

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by jfoutz on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:22PM (#37243651)
Amazon, Alphabet, Meta. Who are the F and G, and where is apple?
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by buzzerbetrayed on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:38PM (#37243752)
Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, and Google
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:24PM (#37244348)
While I hate using the stupid "meta" name, MAGMA is a much more fun acronym than FAAMG, or GMFAA, or MAGAF, etc.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by aiisjustanif on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:36PM (#37244723)
Meta Apple Microsoft Alphabet Amazon

MAMAA

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by BbzzbB on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:32PM (#37254179)
It's cornier and yet still technically incorrect by not using Alphabet. And MAMAA is even cornier without putting in another vowel; arguably Nvidia's N but I feel like it doesn't quite belong. So I stand by my FAAMG, it sounds right, and everyone uses Facebook and Google rather than Meta and Alphabet anyway.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by BbzzbB on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:28PM (#37254142)
You know, Meta and Alphabet which every one outside of their respective CEOs still call Facebook and Google.

And by saying FAAMG instead of FAANG I make the statement that Cramer was high as a kite when he put Netflix in there instead of Microsoft. Today you might make a case for an N, but not at Microsoft's expense.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by dekhn on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:27PM (#37243680)
nvidia deserves their monopoly and it's in the US's best interest to let it continue.

the other companies have to up their game to compete with a company that has been executing well for 20+ years.

[dead]
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by parthdesai on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:32PM (#37242734)
> Raising prices means you are a monopoly?

Not sure if you're intentionally choosing to ignore their point, but what they meant is Nvidia can unilaterally choose to raise the prices and customers can't do anything since they're a monopoly. You can't just say well, i'll go to the next shop and buy something for cheaper.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by Mistletoe on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:17PM (#37243177)
How does the Nvidia stranglehold on AI compare to US Steel, Standard Oil and Bell Telephone etc., other monopolies that were broken up?
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by zirgs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:14AM (#37246282)
There isn't a monopoly. Their competitors just are really bad at it.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by issafram on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:31PM (#37242727)
Not that it's much better, but wouldn't it be a duopoly considering that AMD is also a big player?

Hopefully Intel continues to improve it's GPU offerings

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by capableweb on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:56PM (#37242988)
> Not that it's much better, but wouldn't it be a duopoly considering that AMD is also a big player?

Not sure AMD would be considered a big player, what would be the percentage threshold for that?

According to the Steam Hardware (& Software) Survey (https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/Steam-Hardware-Softw...), ~75% of computers with Steam running has a NVIDIA GPU, while ~15% has a AMD GPU.

AMD is the closest to a competitor NVIDIA has, but they are also very far away from even being close to their market-share.

I'm sure in AI/ML spaces, NVIDIA holds a even higher market-share due to CUDA and the rest of the ecosystem, at least in gaming things are pretty much "plug and play" when it comes to switching between AMD/NVIDIA hardware, but no such luck in most cases with AI/ML.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by swyx on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:09PM (#37243105)
> ~75% of computers with Steam running has a NVIDIA GPU, while ~15% has a AMD GPU.

and thats the consumer market, which lets say is 30% of the B2B enterprise market, which is probably even higher % nvidia

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by User23 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:30PM (#37243291)
AI cloud is something like 95% Nvidia.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by izacus on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:31AM (#37246056)
And then there's the console market, with more units sold than PC gaming market, with 100% AMD GPUs.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by zirgs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:15AM (#37246292)
The Switch is based on Nvidia hardware.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by izacus on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:42AM (#37248100)
And the high budget consoles aren't.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by michaelt on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:48AM (#37247729)
> the B2B enterprise market, which is probably even higher % nvidia

I'd wager the enterprise market is 90% intel integrated graphics.

It's the cheapest option, the best for laptop battery life, and modern integrated graphics can run excel and a web browser at 4k just fine.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by tric on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:46PM (#37242891)
> wouldn't it be a duopoly considering that AMD is also a big player?

I don't think GPUs are commoditized. You can't swap a Nvida GPU with a AMD GPU, and get the same performance/results.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by midhir on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:55PM (#37242970)
AMD seem to be catching up quickly lately. I'm running Stable Diffusion, Llama-2, and Pytorch on a 7900XTX right now. Getting it up and running even on an unsupported Linux distro is relatively straightforward. Details for Arch are here: https://gitlab.com/-/snippets/2584462

The HIP interface even has almost exact interoperability with CUDA, so you don't have to rewrite your code.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by ABeeSea on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:28PM (#37243280)
Inference and training are not the same things. AMD has basically no market share in training.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by zirgs on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:17AM (#37246305)
Now try doing the same on Windows.
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by tomnipotent on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:24PM (#37244347)
> just pretty much doubled the prices

They prices were already double, it was just scummy resellers capturing that value rather than Nvidia.

Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by ttunguz on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:32AM (#37245022)
I'm curious where did you find the data point that they sold an equal number of units quarter over quarter?
Re:Nvidia Announces Financial Results for Second Quarter Fis... by hospitalJail on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:09AM (#37247463)
>This is what having a monopoly looks like !

Yep and we are suffering as a result. Want the best in computing and CUDA? Give M$ and Nvidia money.

Linux and Nvidia don't play well. Apple doesn't even attempt to try.

The absolute state of computing right here.