News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by whoknew1122 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:15AM (#36800776)
> "Many states have passed hate-speech laws that protect the police from verbal or symbolic abuse, such as stomping on a “Back the Blue” sign while “smirking in an intimidating manner” (the crime for which a woman in Utah was prosecuted)."

Wow... this is just... The police have a monopoly on the legalized use of violence. Police carry at minimum one deadly weapon (a handgun), but usually have multiple so-called less-than-lethal weapons such as tasters and batons. And often more lethal weapons such as a shotgun or assault rifle in their car. But they are so fragile that a smirk can intimidate them?

I'm not sure how someone wearing body armor and carrying multiple weapons that can incapacitate or kill someone can be intimidated by a smile.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by bamfly on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:26AM (#36800953)
> I'm not sure how someone wearing body armor and carrying multiple weapons that can incapacitate or kill someone can be intimidated by a smile.

They're wannabe military tough-guys with laughably worse training and culture, much of which tells them they should be pee-pants scared all the time (seriously—folks very-successfully sell some wacko training courses to cops; or, just look at the disconnected-from-reality-and-common-sense mythology they've built up, within their ranks, around fentanyl). That's the best-case explanation for that behavior. Sometimes they're literal machismo-fueled gangsters (yes, literally, as in, "involved in organized crime") and will punch down all day long to make sure they're feared.

[EDIT] Actually, school districts suffer from some similar problems, as far as being sold all kinds of ineffective and wrong-headed wacko programs and training, and too-frequently ending up corrupt little petty empires (OMG, the amount of money superintendents siphon off to pals...)—I think in both cases we may have opted for a level of devolution that's tipped at least a bit too far toward local autonomy, and could perhaps benefit from something like a professional management/officer corp that gets re-assigned every few years, like officers in the military, to prevent empire-building and make corruption and deviation into wacko-land much less likely. Though, I think that kind of thing's on exactly nobody's radar, so don't expect it to ever happen.

[EDIT EDIT] I mean obviously the problem's more severe and grave with cops, it just occurred to me that a lot of the problems in both spheres might be for organizationally-similar reasons.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by softfalcon on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:41AM (#36801177)
Yeah, this is becoming more and more the case. I have friends who are associated with or in law enforcement and if you ever end up at a bar with them they will endlessly talk about the "threats to their safety" on the job.

The problem is, I often hear stories where they're checking out a house that has supposed drug use (or similar) and they play it up like they're a marine in a war zone, going to have a man-down shoot out. In reality, they knock on the door, a very high college student answers, they provide the warrant, search through a house of strung out people, and they do their thing.

That being said, our area has a lot of rural patrols and we have had a few incidents where people fire back at the cops on their acreage and it turns into an incident. That being said, even when dealing with "crazy Billy with a shotgun", they're 2 people, who then call in backup, also have a shotgun and are armed, the power dynamic definitely still favours the cops even in that extreme situation.

I feel like there are a lot of rare incidents that get repeated over and over within the police force that keep the cops on edge and further the need for more and more budget increases for more and more military-style equipment. For instance, our local city police force just bragged on twitter that they bought a literal modified troop carrier and a ramming tank for SWAT-like break and enter operations. I'm not sure I want my police owning a literal tank when they already have me outgunned with assault rifles, shot guns, sidearms, and sheer numbers.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by wahnfrieden on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:23AM (#36801871)
Bullies and thieves seek the valor and respectability they think their position warrants
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by biomcgary on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:56PM (#36804191)
I have neighbor who was a police officer until last month. She was fired because she was trying to push back against an aggressive, corrupt culture in her small town police department. She and another officer had arrested a non-violent, mentally disturbed individual, who had been perfectly compliant in custody. (The guy shoplifted a beer occasionally to quiet the voices in his head.) Another officer walked in and immediately grabbed the arrestee (already in handcuffs) and threw him on the ground, fracturing his skull and causing seizures.

Our neighbor pushed for an investigation repeatedly (which would have taken her off the job until complete, since she was the commanding officer on the scene), but it was denied. She was fired shortly after. She is filing a lawsuit to get her job back and the family of the police brutality victim is also suing. I hope they both win, but I do worry about our neighbor's life expectancy if she gets her job back.

The tech industry has strong incentives to invade privacy, push inflammatory content, and for otherwise good people to look the other way. Nevertheless, I am opposed to broad brush denigration of employees in the sector, many of which do push back in quiet ways against dark patterns, even if not enough. I feel the same way about law enforcement. The biggest difference between tech and law enforcement is that police work involves stakes that are higher in the short-term and more visible, but tech is far more dangerous in the long-term through, e.g., inflammatory social media, persistent surveillance, etc.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by xtiansimon on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:46AM (#36812707)
> “… ramming tank for SWAT-like break and enter operations. I'm not sure I want my police owning a literal tank when they already have me outgunned…”

I have a family member in law enforcement. I asked them this very question. What do you need this monster vehicle for?

Their answer was they can approach a target house and communicate with the occupant without putting officers in harms way (as much as a bullet-proof ramming armored vehicle keeps its passengers safe ). The alternative is officers are much closer to the threat/danger, which makes for a situation which can escalate very quickly to deadly force.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by taylodl on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:32AM (#36814260)
What's the point of the 2nd amendment when the police has tanks and urban assault vehicles and your government has nukes, fighter aircraft, grenades and several other materiel? I've never understood how self-identified "patriots" support a militarized police force and the 2nd amendment. The government, at all levels, literally has the power to do whatever they want. We need to at least demilitarize the police.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by LanceH on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:25AM (#36801912)
> They're wannabe military tough-guys with laughably worse training and culture

Every time they shoot someone after serving a warrant when the subject of the warrant isn't there, it just blows my mind. Do they really just get warrant signed, then roll up and break in? No surveillance?

Who the hell wants to go into a closed room if you could just wait for them to walk outside and swoop in on them when they are in view.

But I guess if you have the gear, you must use it.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by Arrath on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:19PM (#36803645)
There's much less of an adrenaline rush in an extended stakeout and cuffing a suspect when they are walking to their car to go to work, or getting the morning newspaper.

The fun is to be had in the kicking in of doors, yelling at terrified residents, and so on.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by Supermancho on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:29AM (#36801982)
> they should be pee-pants scared all the time

Not to step out and defend cops too much but this narrative is unfair...I believe the right to bear arms includes guns and we pay for that as a society. The ones who pay the most are LE. They primarily have to deal with the worst elements of society and the most volatile of individuals. I don't envy the job. I would be scared all the time too.

Chances of me being shot at work are near zero. Chances that a street cop is shot are relatively high. However, they don't take too kindly to allowing threats to themselves or other officers to go unchallenged and are primarily interested with maintaining a sense of being in control of any situation they step into, as a matter of human psychology. People tend not to fuck with the people in charge, even if they don't see weapons. This is how the safety element is framed and it's not intrinsically foolish.

This naturally conflicts with various Constitutional rights, even in theory, so we get these crazy cases where it's a matter of reputation. You mess with the cops, it can come back at you. Americans expect, that almost everywhere, this holds true. This sounds like a lot of power structures in modern society, does it not? as bamfly pointed out.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:42AM (#36802175)
> The ones who pay the most are LE.

This is simply not true. Cops die via gunfire in sub-100 numbers annually. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_law_enforcement_office...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:15PM (#36802724)
As with crime statistics, you need percentages to make a point and not aggregate numbers. Also tell us which other professionals are murdered by guns on American streets for doing their jobs, at this rate.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by catboybotnet on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:40PM (#36803111)
From a quick google search, the number is roughly 660300. Divide 100 by that, you get .00015. A fraction of a fraction. 301 died to Covid in 2021.

Another question would be, of those 100 deaths to gun violence, how many were because somebody was further instigated into a shootout BECAUSE of the confrontations with police? What about friendly fire?

If police are quick to resort to violence, why should the people not be?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by Clubber on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#36804432)
>Also tell us which other professionals are murdered by guns on American streets for doing their jobs, at this rate.

Cab drivers are #1 last time I looked. Pizza delivery close. Cops didn't even make the top 10.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by Supermancho on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:46AM (#36802232)
I meant pay for the right to bear arms in being exposed to the consequences.

Might want to look at gunfire injuries that are not deaths. There is also the issue of how this happens despite training, their own weapons, armor, etc that are daily requirements. The general populace would probably see better survival rates with these things as well, right?

It's more than a little biased to just point at deaths.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by idiotsecant on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:01PM (#36802494)
Each year more than 250,000 civilians are injured by police. At least 600 are killed. between 2014 and 2019 there was an average of 245 officers shot per year, many of which were injuries only.

It's extremely clear that in an average encounter a civilian is much more likely to be shot and kileld or injured by police than the other way around. Gun violence against police is extremely rare.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:16PM (#36802748)
Uses aggregate numbers then transitions to relative probability as if the math logic follows. This thread is a clown show.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by bamfly on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:54PM (#36803325)
Probability in a given encounter, is how the post is written, which is fine. That is, in an encounter between police and non-police, it's much less likely that a police officer is killed or injured than that someone else is.

Now, police officers are obviously going to be involved in a lot more of these encounters than the average person, and there are fewer of them, which I think is what you're getting at, but this is valid from an "in a given encounter, which party is more-justified in fearing for their physical safety?" sort of way.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:59AM (#36802458)
> I meant pay for the right to bear arms in being exposed to the consequences.

The 50,000 dead annually via firearms would appear to be paying more. (Even when you adjust for relative populations; 800k cops with 50 deaths, 300M Americans with 50,000).

> Might want to look at gunfire injuries that are not deaths.

I went looking and was unable to find any particularly reliable sources on police-specific firearm injuries. I did find that cops are at higher risk of firearm death via suicide than via suspects as an additional data point.

Perhaps they could do with some therapy and anger management in addition to all the armor and weaponry?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hiatus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#36802430)
> It's more than a little biased to just point at deaths.

It's less biased than your argument, which pointed at no evidence.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by test098 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#36805646)
> I meant pay for the right to bear arms in being exposed to the consequences.

uh no, school-age children (including elementary school children) are the ones who pay the most for our gun-happy culture.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zapataband1 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:43AM (#36802191)
You are statistically more likely to die on the job as a delivery driver than a cop.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zer8k on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#36802292)
Another fun fact is when controlling for race and gender you are still more likely to be killed by a cop than almost anything else.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by leereeves on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:06PM (#36802580)
This is so far from true it's absurd.

Roughly 100k Americans per year die from drug overdoses, 30k from car accidents, while only 1k are killed by police.

And while everyone knows cancer and heart disease are the leading causes of death, few people realize they kill significant numbers of young Americans, more than 10k per year.

Even if you limit the discussion to violent crime, you're far more likely to be killed by someone you know than by an officer.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by diydsp on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:37PM (#36803077)
checks out: https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-de...

Although this is quite concerning:

> about 1 in every 1,000 black men can expect to be killed by police [1]

Also:

> Black people more than three times as likely as white people to be killed during a police encounter [2]

Also interesting to note:

> The average lifetime odds of being killed by police are about 1 in 2,000 for men and about 1 in 33,000 for women. [1]

[1] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1821204116

[2] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/blacks-wh...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by cratermoon on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:48AM (#36802255)
It's deadlier to be pregnant than to be a cop.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by diydsp on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:34PM (#36803017)
Evidences shows about 2-3x as deadly to be pregnant than to be a cop:

> For law enforcement, that rate was about 13 deaths per 100,000 officers. [1]

> overall maternal mortality rate of 32.9 per 100,000 live births in 2021 > 23.8 in 2020 and 20.1 in 2019. [2]

> The maternal mortality rate for 2021 was 32.9 deaths per 100,000 live births, compared with a rate of 23.8 in 2020 and 20.1 in 2019 (Table). [3]

Who knew fishing and hunter is so dangerous? > Fishing and hunting workers had the highest fatality rate at 132 deaths per 100,000 workers. [1]

[1] https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-police-officers-die-i...

[2] https://www.yalemedicine.org/news/maternal-mortality-on-the-...

[3] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hestat/maternal-mortality/2021...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zer8k on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:53AM (#36802328)
> They're wannabe military tough-guys with laughably worse training and culture,

A lot of them are ex-military which is why every incident is treated like a mini-fallujah. There should be better psychological evaluation of police. It's harder to get a gun as a citizen anywhere in the US than it is to become a cop.The very least we can do is treat them to a far higher standard than we do citizens given that they have a monopoly on violence and qualified immunity. But that would run contrary to their purpose. Cops aren't there to protect you and me. They are the HR of the local, state, and national Government. They're there to protect the interests of the state.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by bamfly on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:33PM (#36803008)
> A lot of them are ex-military which is why every incident is treated like a mini-fallujah.

The impression I get of the impression other ex-military folks have of veteran-cops, from the veterans I know, is that other veterans tend to regard cop veterans as very-likely to be a two-years-and-out sort (or similar) who jockeyed a desk state-side—and probably poorly at that—or maybe did go to a warzone but never fired a shot in anger, but act like they were In The Shit and can't wait to tell everyone they meet they're a veteran. I.e. not especially good soldiers, the kind who are in for the wrong reasons and had the wrong temperament & attitude for military service.

I'll never forget when Trump called in the military (reservists, I wanna say?) to guard DC during the protests. I stayed up that evening watching various live feeds. They looked so very chill. Relaxed stance with the rifles, not seeming at all tense even when totally surrounded by protesters. Didn't start no shit, and there wasn't no shit. Didn't "kettle" people, didn't act threatening, didn't posture and project an attitude like they thought were the Spartans from 300, and everything was fine. Armed like SWAT (rather, SWAT arms like them, but you get what I mean), humvees and shit, but it was such a different vibe. They projected an aura of authority without acting threatening. That's what confident power & professionalism look like. Go figure.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by idiotsecant on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:56AM (#36802411)
>It's harder to get a gun as a citizen anywhere in the US than it is to become a cop.

I'm normally the last one to be licking boots when it comes to discussions of the role of law enforcement in our society. With that said, this is hyperbole and obviously falsifiable. There are lots of places in the US where it is very easy to get a gun and at least somewhat difficult to become a cop.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by sangnoir on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:53PM (#36803309)
How about: It's harder to kill anyone (and get away with it) as a citizen anywhere in the US than it is as a cop

Some cops have bloodlust and/or are in cop-gangs that have initiation-rituals that demand commiting murder before you can join.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by idiotsecant on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:43PM (#36804005)
Probably more true, although I had to parse this sentence several times to understand what you were trying to say. We put a lot of trust in cops. It's probably unavoidable that some of them will turn out to be terrible people. I am in favor of trying to keep that ratio as low as possible but I don't have any particularly good solutions on how to do that. Do you?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by sangnoir on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:10PM (#36804361)
I have a couple of suggestions I've heard from others I think are decent.

1. Grand-jury-style civilian oversight of cop malpractice.

2. Make sure bad cops can't get reemployed as cops in the city 15 miles away.

3. Require cops get malpractice insurance as a condition of employment. Instead of paying out of the city's treasury, insurance will payout if the cop gets sued successfully

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by jaywalk on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:58AM (#36802451)
> It's harder to get a gun as a citizen anywhere in the US than it is to become a cop.

As a gun owner, I can tell you this is laughably false. I can't go into a police station and walk out as a cop 30 minutes later.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zer8k on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:29PM (#36802931)
Yeah, you'd have to do 6 weeks of PT first. But you can waiver that.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by sidewndr46 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:23PM (#36802835)
The comparison doesn't even make sense. You can make a gun in your own home. You can't make a police officer
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by lostlogin on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:33PM (#36802995)
You can, but not alone and it’ll take 18ish years.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by RickJWagner on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:20PM (#36830925)
I have a nephew that's a cop. I've had friends that are cops.

They do a hard job, protecting the public, for little pay. Every day they leave their home not knowing if some nut-job is going to try to kill them that day.

This is the truest view I know of.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by BLKNSLVR on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:26AM (#36800954)
Because some of the people attracted to the power of working as a police officer legitimately need all those weapons and all that body armour to project the power and confidence they just can't implicitly find within themselves.

I'm sad for root cause, but society seems to be increasingly paying for symptoms that the powers that be refuse to admit are even present.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by chongli on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:10AM (#36801662)
It's a vicious cycle. The police develop a reputation for toxic culture. People who might otherwise be attracted to policework for the right sorts of reasons (sense of duty, care for the community, responsibility etc.) become alienated by the toxic culture and are driven away. The people who remain develop warrior / siege mentality and toxicity increases. People who are attracted to policework for the wrong reasons (resentment, desire for power over others, greed) fit in among the other toxic misfits.

It's part of a wider pattern of institutional breakdown and the loss of trust in institutions.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by bbarnett on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:33AM (#36801063)
And yet it wasn't a smirk, now was it? It was a smirk and other things.

Right or wrong, call it what it is. Don't drop info off the event, and focus on one part of it.

And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street?

Note, I said "doing their job", not "doing it wrong".

For damned sure there are bad cops. But by god, there are a load of good ones, and some of them spend all day, dealing with people at their absolute worst, taking crap you or I wouldn't be able to handle for 5 minutes.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by matthewdgreen on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:39AM (#36801158)
Thanks to your comment I read through to the original article and it’s even more despicable than I’d thought from the description. She’s being accused of a “hate crime” for “intimidating the police” based on defacing a sign. It’s the most disgusting thing I’ve ever heard of, and I have no idea why any rational human being would defend it.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zdragnar on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:54AM (#36801383)
Several people have been charged with hate crimes for spinning their car tires over rainbow painted sidewalks, even though nobody else was present.

Hate crime is a fucking stupid term; a crime is a crime is a crime. That said, if targeting one group deserves special treatment, then targeting any group should get the same. Equal application of the law, y'know?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by harimau777 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:57AM (#36801451)
Police officers are given much more power than regular people; let alone a minority group like LGBT people. It makes sense for them to be held to a higher standard.

Edit: It also looks like they were NOT charged with a hate crime for vandalizing a pride crosswalk.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2023/04/14/fac...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by enragedcacti on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:08AM (#36801627)
Protected classes are part of the law and "Cop" is not one of them. Treating cops the same as minority groups would be ignorance of the law, not equal application of it.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:23PM (#36802846)
There are no protected class allowances for assault.

This thread is a menagerie of legal misunderstanding and buzzword abuse.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by tehwebguy on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:15AM (#36801729)
> Several people have been charged with hate crimes for spinning their car tires over rainbow painted sidewalks, even though nobody else was present.

You don’t think general vandalism and targeted vandalism should be handled differently?

Also, citation needed!

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by 542354234235 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:02PM (#36802507)
>Hate crime is a fucking stupid term; a crime is a crime is a crime.

Is a crime a crime? Why are there first degree murder, second degree murder, and voluntary manslaughter? They are all the act of killing someone intentionally, with the only difference being the person's thought process and motivation. Most crimes involve taking into consideration the reasons for the act as part of what makes a crime a crime. So, hate crimes are not some outlier in how crimes are defined and differentiated.

> if targeting one group deserves special treatment, then targeting any group should get the same. Equal application of the law, y'know?

Hate crimes (and protected classes in general) are not “one group” nor are they randomly picked. At the federal level, they are race, religion, ethnicity, disability, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, and/or gender identity, which basically fall into two different categories; what you are and what you believe. None of them are for what job you happen to choose to do. The “special treatment” statements is particularly fallacious, since most hate crime laws came in response systematic violence committed against these groups and them not receiving equal protection under the law. We don’t have anti lynching laws to give black people special treatment.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by zdragnar on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:59PM (#36805922)
That's not what first and second degree murder or manslaughter are. The result is the same for the victim, but the specific actions and intentions are different.

Put another way, why is it better if I murder someone because I hate vegans, or meat eaters, or poor people, or rich people, or car drivers or pedestrians than someone of a protected group?

Adding new laws doesn't make them be enforced any better, so I don't buy the "systemic" argument. Either someone is tried and found guilty or not.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by yamazakiwi on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:06PM (#36802575)
What sidewalks are you talking about... That is just one instance of misguided outrage to drive your confirmation bias. No one has context for your sensationalized news story.

If people started attacking other people for being Gluten-free, and the government saw that there was a large amount of cases, they would create regulations trying to curtail the amount of crime targeting those people. They are creating regulation with the intention of lowering crime targeting a small group because it is atypical.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by otikik on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:07PM (#36802607)
> crime is a crime is a crime

Fortunately lawyers can not win trials with that argument in particular.

> Equal application of the law, y'know?

The context here is that we have a group (the Police) already enjoys special privileges (like monopoly on the use of force legally) and want to expand those privileges even further. I don't think your argument works the way you seem to think it works.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by at_a_remove on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:55AM (#36801409)
Those of us who said, over and over again, how dumb it was to make up "hate crimes" as a thing are smirking. We did tell you what would happen. Nobody wanted to hear it. Now it's here and everyone is all "shocked Pikachu" from the middle of that slippery slope.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by harimau777 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:29AM (#36801980)
As I understand it, legislation defining hate crimes addresses a very real issue: By creating a threatening environment hate crimes can cause dramatically more damage than what the base crime itself would suggest. For example, the minor punishments associated with trespassing and vandalism don't seem proportionate to the harm caused by the Klan burning a cross in someone's front yard.

Without hate crime legislation, it would be easy for bigots to harass people via what the law would see as minor crimes.

So I'm not necessarily opposed to getting rid of hate crime legislation. However, we would need some other way to protect people.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:25AM (#36801895)
This isn't a problem with hate crimes this is a problem with the level of immunity cops are given. If hate crimes had never been "made up" (whatever that means) they would have just found another way to make it illegal to piss of cops.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by at_a_remove on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:56AM (#36802412)
Of course they were made up. It's a legal construct. "Hate crimes" did not exist as a legal charge fifty years ago. Why are you using language as if you did not know this?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by tehwebguy on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:38AM (#36802109)
Repeating Elon Musk talking points in public is wild!

The concept of mens rea is not new, it’s a vital factor in the defining, charging, convicting (and dismissing and acquitting) of crimes.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by at_a_remove on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:46AM (#36802229)
I wouldn't know, I don't follow the guy. If he said the sky was blue, would you be bothered by that?

Of course mindset matters. You don't murder out of love, generally. I'm sure a few have. Putting these artificial rails on it, saying that it only matters for race or whatnot, that's the silly part and it was bound to be broken through. And so it has.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by distortionfield on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:07AM (#36801613)
So much for “freedom of speech”
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:17PM (#36802755)
Someone scratched a slur onto the bathroom wall when I was in college and it became a campus wide hate crime and we all had a week of fishbowls and micro-aggression training. People actually believe that these things constitute hate crimes. It is absurd.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by wolverine876 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:54PM (#36912395)
It depends on, among other things, the relative power of the speaker and target.

Prejudice, to be dangerous, requires power. Prejudice + Power = Danger. In a world of of 95% Martians and 5% Venusians, if a Martian calls all Venusians corrupt and evil, it's a danger - the Venusians may be at risk; their future - career, safety, status, etc. - depends on the goodwill of the Martians. If a Venusian does the same about Martians, it's easily dismissed because the Martians can continue to live and study safely.

IOW, punching up and punching down are entirely different things. Criticizing the government is punching up; criticizing (e.g.) homeless people is punching down.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:39AM (#36801153)
> if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street

Please show precedent for anyone being prosecuted for rendering an “intimidating smirk” in any other context. Or for filming someone working in public, for that matter.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:41AM (#36802167)
They're being prosecuted for smirking at cops while destroying pro-cop signage, which can be read as assault. Ask yourself whether in today's age someone could get away with destroying an LGBT sign amidst a pro-LGBT protest, while staring down LGBT people, and get away with it. I don't agree with where the standards are, but most people would observe that this is the standard. Whatever anyone's personal rationalization for preferencing one group over another, in this type of enforcement, it is immaterial as far as the criminal code is concerned. There are no marginalized group allowances for assault.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by jgwil2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:08PM (#36802627)
If she tore it up and threw the pieces in their face then maybe it could be construed as assault. If she was tearing it up and smirking without physically threatening the cops then how could it possibly constitute assault?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:24PM (#36802862)
Read assault laws. As is common, you are conflating assault with battery.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by jgwil2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:29PM (#36803787)
I'm not. There has to be some kind of physical threat for it to be assault. Smirking is not that. Neither is tearing up paper.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by OGWhales on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:39PM (#36803935)
FYI, this depends on where you live. In some states a threat of violence can count as assault while in others that’s not true. Some states don’t even have a battery charge, they only have assault.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by angst_ridden on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:43AM (#36801223)
Spoken like someone who has never worked retail.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hooverd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:46AM (#36801264)
Crumpling a yard sign doesn't deserve a year in jail, or any jail time in my opinion.

Office workers don't have a monopoly on violence. Unfortuntely there are quite a few examples of cops treating anything other than obsequience as harassment.

The problem with good police officers is that if you actually try and stand up to the institution of policing, your buddies will throw you in the psych ward on false premises and make a challenge coin to commemorate doing it.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by perihelions on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:56AM (#36801435)
- "And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job"

That's a very easy civics question: no one has that right. No American has a right to not be verbally diminished by strangers in a public setting.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by respondo2134 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:22AM (#36801864)
First, I agree that ALL cops spend a large portion of their job dealing with the worst aspects of our society. This inevitably colours their perspective and puts them in a very tough situation, prone for very bad mistakes.

I disagree with your "some bad apples" analogy though. That would be easy to fix relative to the problem we have which is systemic. "Good" cops are in the exact same situation as the bad ones. Policing is required yet fundamentally causing the problems at the same time.

>> And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street?

As stated in the article all 50 states already have laws on the books that prevent interference with police while doing their job. If you are in a public facing role like a police officer you most certainly do not have the right to being shielded from observation and interaction - that's a huge part of the job and probably part of the solution too.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:27AM (#36801945)
> And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street?

Is it not dangerous enough to give officers pretty much unlimited authority, and expect the people around them to forfeit their first amendment right?

Police officers, being enforcers of the law, cannot reasonably be protected from people exercising their rights.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:34AM (#36802048)
> But by god, there are a load of good ones, and some of them spend all day, dealing with people at their absolute worst, taking crap you or I wouldn't be able to handle for 5 minutes.

There are plenty of other professions that have tough jobs that I absolutely wouldn't want to do. But that doesn't mean I'm going to start letting garbage collectors get away with murder

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by otikik on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802671)
> dealing with people at their absolute worst, taking crap you or I wouldn't be able to handle for 5 minutes.

For sure there's bad people, but most people are good. Those people that give cops crap are just some bad apples.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:56AM (#36801429)
Read assault laws. Most people think that assault is battery. It isn't. While I wouldn't comment on the event in question because I didn't see it, generally speaking people can't assault police anymore than they can civilians. What the police carry is irrelevant, and speaking to it as if it is implies a type of dissonance that will lead to someone being arrested.

Remember that this is the age wherein people are getting arrested for destroying LGBT, BLM, etc signs and art. To think that police won't get away with using a standard that approaches that isn't realistic.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mcdonje on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:39AM (#36802134)
>Remember that this is the age wherein people are getting arrested for destroying LGBT, BLM, etc signs and art. To think that police won't get away with using a standard that approaches that isn't realistic.

Black people and LGBT people are protected classes. Law enforcement is a job. People are getting arrested for hate crimes, the definition of which is a crime motivated by desire to cause harm to a protected class or members of a protected class.

You're saying it's unrealistic to think police won't get away with trying to apply protected class protections to an occupation. That's an extraordinary claim whether it's true or false.

If it's true, police can defacto make up laws. If it's false, it's reasonable to expect that police should have some oversight that prevents overreach.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:46AM (#36802236)
There aren't protected class allowances for assault.

This thread, more than others on HN, fatally suffers from abuse of jargon.

Your last two sentences are word salad. Between the double negative and hyperbole I have zero idea what you are trying to say.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mcdonje on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:07PM (#36802608)
Flippant response. I didn't abuse jargon and there is no word salad. My comment is clear.

You're describing hate crimes and saying police are trying to treat actions against them the same way they treat hate crimes. It's not hyperbole to say that amounts to them making up laws.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:57PM (#36803370)
Yes, a flippant response. The flippant response is well deserved.

It's audacious of you to defend unreadable grammar. An indecipherable double negative is word salad, as is the referential sentence that follows it. Again, because the sentence that it references is indecipherable. I'm not a pedant. I virtually never correct on grammar. I never use correction as a rhetorical device. I legitimately can't interpret your writing. Fix your sentence, if you choose to.

As long as laws have existed, their scope has been argued in court. To wit, we have strong equal protections law in this Nation.

As anti-protected-classes law and constitutional law activists have long argued, laws of this type will be used beyond their intended narrow scope and across the political isle. Also, see speech censorship efforts.

None of that means that law enforcement is conjuring laws. The part of this that you dislike was always inherent in the creation of hate crime enhancements. And, in part, this potential is why many have always seen the notion of protected classes as a terrible idea.

You're complaining now. Wait until they fully reverse the law to only apply to them. At that point, it will still be the fault of those who advocated for this unconstitutional nonsense to begin with.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by 542354234235 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:18AM (#36801775)
>Remember that this is the age wherein people are getting arrested for destroying LGBT, BLM, etc signs and art.

Do you mean vandalizing and/or destroying other people's property or pulling a sign away from someone else and destroying it, or do you mean being charged with assault for destroying their own LGBT sign? Because those are night and day different things. I would love to see a source if it is the latter, since you can legally burn the American flag, but you can't burn someone else's American flag.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by screwturner68 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:28AM (#36801970)
You can legally tell a cop to fuck off, the SC ruled on that years ago, that said if you did that where I lived (and were a minority) you'd likely get your skull cracked.

It's pretty sad that a civilian goes to jail for not knowing the law but a cop can make up laws that don't exist, arrest you for those laws and nothing can be done about it. Sure you can sue the city but that just means the residents pay for the cops ignorance and life goes on as usual for the cop.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:26AM (#36801937)
The former. People have been over-charged for destroying the property of others, in the example given. But my point was comparative.

Also, to clarify, it should be difficult or impossible to charge someone for assault simply for destroying property. But according to how I understand assault laws, and leaving room for jurisdictional interpretation, if you do it while doing something else that can be read as intimidation then you could be vulnerable to an assault charge.

Whether or not the other person is actually intimidated won't ever be considered. Cop or civilian. The intention is what will be charged.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:48AM (#36802258)
> The former. People have been over-charged for destroying the property of others, in the example given. But my point was comparative.

This is a inaccurate comparison. She didn't destroy any else's property

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:29PM (#36802938)
It would be inaccurate if the charges were limited to property destruction.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by 542354234235 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:26PM (#36802886)
These aren’t comparative in the slightest. They aren’t being arrested for destroying an LGBT sign, they are being arrested for destroying someone else’s property. If you steal something from a police officer and destroy it, that is a “comparative” crime. You added false equiveillance examples because your “understanding” of assault laws has very little weight on its own. Considering there are actually many examples of anti-LGBT protestors that come armed [1] obviously to intimidate, it seems you attempting to mislead people as to the nature of anti-LGBT crimes and paint anti-LGBT crimes as “overcharged” seems telling.

[1] https://www.opb.org/article/2022/10/30/eugene-drag-queen-sto...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by 5555624 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:25AM (#36801913)
> Read assault laws. Most people think that assault is battery. It isn't.

That's why you often hear"assault & battery." "Assault" is causing someone to (reasonably) feel in danger; while "battery" is the actual act.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by screwturner68 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:39AM (#36802124)
Let's take a step back, telling someone to F- off!, even a cop is considered free speech and has been verified by the SC. On the other have telling someone I'm going to rack your F-ing skull open could be considered assault -this is threatening language and is not free speech.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:49AM (#36802275)
Take a step back from what, exactly? What they stated was factual and generally complete.

The event in question was not someone telling a cop to F off. There are plenty of chargeable variations within the gamut of your polar examples.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by chmod600 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:57AM (#36801447)
You left out: “…Although some of these laws have been vetoed or deemed unconstitutional”
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by tppiotrowski on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:09AM (#36801634)
> The police have a monopoly on the legalized use of violence.

Is this true? I thought killing for self defense is legal.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by LanceH on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:29AM (#36801971)
When using that, it's not talking about self defense. The government has a monopoly on the use of violence in the sense that if you owe them money or some other obligation, they may go through paperwork, collections, all the normal resources. At some point, though, they will send people with guns and physically collect you. Don't pay the IRS for long enough and the government will use violence against you, generally in the form of locking you up against your will.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by enragedcacti on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:20AM (#36801817)
its kind of a term of art and applies more to the state than the police specifically - although the police are obviously the primary tool of doling out legalized violence and have in many ways usurped the power to determine what qualifies as legal.

> For the same reasons, "monopoly" does not mean that only the government may use physical force, but that the state is that human community that successfully claims for itself to be the only source of legitimacy for all physical coercion or adjudication of coercion. For example, the law might permit individuals to use force in defense of one's self or property, but this right derives from the state's authority.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by karaterobot on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:30AM (#36801992)
No, it's not true at all. It's just somebody who heard the phrase applied to the state and then forgot the context and decided it sounded smart to transpose that to the police. Even as applied to the state, it's an oversimplification meant to make a point rather than describe reality.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by harimau777 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:20AM (#36801824)
One difference is that regular citizens have to prove that they were acting in self defense while, in practice, police are almost always given the benefit of the doubt.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by wahnfrieden on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:28AM (#36801961)
Ticketmaster’s monopoly on venue event ticketing doesn’t mean it’s illegal to sell tickets if you’re not Ticketmaster, and doesn’t require laws the specifically say Ticketmaster gains the monopoly
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by lordfrito on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:18AM (#36801780)
> But they are so fragile that a smirk can intimidate them?

First let me say I'm not on the side of these kinds of laws. We can't be passing laws giving special privileges to (or removing privileges from) a particular group of people.

"Our constitution is color-blind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens. In respect of civil rights, all citizens are equal before the law." Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) [1]

It seems that more and more Americans feel intimidated by just about anything nowadays (microagressions, etc.). So much so that Hate Crimes and Safe Spaces are now a thing. People have lost jobs due to Cancel Culture fueled hate-mobs.

I don't buy into class warfare, in my worldview police are just as fragile (no more, no less) as any other human. Holding a gun in your hand doesn't make you any less fragile, just more hazardous/dangerous. I'm sure there are plenty of people that regularly carry guns, people that (based on class/race/etc) would be considered extremely fragile. The gun doesn't change that distinction.

Why wouldn't police officers be afforded the same kinds of protections from microagressions that are given to other people in this country? Doesn't a police officer have a right to a safe working environment, and aggression free interactions with 'customers' (citizens), and laws saying as much? If the answer is patriarchy or 'whiteness' (whatever that means) etc. then this is just more of the same toxic in group / out group stuff used to justify holding power over others.

Is a hard working police officer allowed to be offended by songs such as "Fuck The Police"? Is that "hate speech"? Should the creators of that song be cancelled for being filled with hate directed at a particular "out group"?

More and more I am bothered by the kinds of "distinctions" between people we're making in this country. You know, the kind based on race, class, education, wealth, etc. that just separates people into "this kind" and "that kind". This "this kind" gets special treatment, while "that kind" is afforded no protections, and is persecuted (don't get me started on the people who say "its OK they deserve it").

Laws like this are profoundly anti-American, going against the kinds of values we've collectively upheld for over 200 years.

"Fuck the police" indeed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_colorblindness

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by nathan_compton on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:27AM (#36801944)
I mean for one thing there aren't any laws anywhere protecting anyone else from micro-aggression. I work in a context where this stuff is taken very seriously and I've never seen anyone lose a job over it. I've never been asked to attest to something at all, to say nothing of some mandatory idea.

Look, what you reactionaries call "woke" and are so afraid of is the mere pointing out of structural racist shit. There is literally no legal force behind any woke policies. Governments everywhere are more conservative than ever and the supreme court is absolutely locked tight against these policies.

"going against the kinds of values we've collectively upheld for over 200 years." This is one of the most positively blinkered ass sentences. We had literal chattel slavery for nearly 100 years of that history and in that time displaced by force huge parts of the native population. Half the country didn't want to end slavery so badly that they went to war over it and after they lost they did almost everything they could get away with to continue to enforce racial segregation and hierarchy.

Look, I'm find if you want to hold the absurd belief that there isn't ant structural racism contemporaneously, although this is obviously wrong, but to suggest that the US has "always held" anything remotely like contemporary racial egalitarian ideals is absolutely wrong.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:39AM (#36802135)
"Governments everywhere are more conservative than ever" - do you have any sources / citations to back this up?

"There is literally no legal force behind any woke policies" - Politicians in Michigan have been attempting to pass a law to make harassing someone by misgendering them a felony.

There are plenty of laws and policies protecting groups of people that have nothing to do with "structural racist shit". If you're looking for racism everywhere and in everything, you're probably going to find it. I find that people who focus on race and class constantly, also end up exhibiting the most racist and classist views and behaviors.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by idiotsecant on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:06PM (#36802573)
Your only example is a law that is not currently a law? People propose crazy laws all the time. They get used by politicians to get attention and by media outlets to drive clicks from their outrage pornography addicted audience. In both cases it's all sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:13PM (#36802699)
https://www.lgbtagingcenter.org/resources/pdfs/StateLawsThat...

Is that better? Plenty of laws, on the books in multiple states, enforcing "woke" policies. I'm not even taking a side in the debate as to whether laws like this should exist, I'm just pointing out that the comment I replied to was factually inaccurate. In more way than one.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by nathan_compton on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:48PM (#36804078)
So you are saying that laws prohibiting discrimination against trans people are somehow woke tyranny? These lays basically just say that you can't deny someone a job or a house or similar services for being trans. They do not say that you have to "believe" in a persons gender identity. No one is marching you to re-education camps if you don't use the right pronouns. Conservative rhetoric on this subject is so detached from reality.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:22AM (#36801863)
> Why wouldn't police officers be subject to the same kinds of protections from microagressions afforded to others?

These are special protections afforded only to police officers. Normal people are protected from hate speech about their race or gender but cops are protected from "hate speech" about their race, gender, or profession. It's not hate speech to say "Fuck Lawyers" but it is to say "Fuck the Police".

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by lordfrito on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:31AM (#36802001)
I'm not sure I'm following you.

I agree, I'm against these kinds of laws (see previous post).

I agree with you, there are special protections given police offers, these are related to the power they are authorized by the state to wield that regular citizens cannot. I can sue you if you break down my door. But a kidnapper can't sue the SWAT team that broke down their door in the course of saving the kidnapped person inside.

Meanwhile, related to civil-rights issues, and workplace related issues, "Police Officers" are still just "normal people" and should have the same basic rights as normal people. Are you suggesting they shouldn't?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by semanticist on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:04PM (#36802537)
I think you're conflating someone's job with a protected characteristic in the context of anti-discrimination and hate speech law. If a cop gets special laws to prevent people smirking at them, or 'being a cop' is considered a protected characteristic, that is not "having the same basic rights as normal people", it's having extra rights that you can choose to opt-into by getting a certain job.

A person cannot choose their race, sex, sexuality, gender identity, able-bodiedness, etc, that is why discriminating against them based on those grounds is inherently unfair and thus not allowed.

No one is born a cop. Someone chooses to join the police, with an understanding of what the job represents and entails. If they choose to join the police when the police are widely considered corrupt and looked down upon by society (or at least some parts of it), that's on them.

Anti-discrimination and hate speech laws are about ensuring the people are not mistreated for a fundamental characteristic of who they are. No one has cop DNA.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:50PM (#36805824)
> Normal people are protected from hate speech about their race or gender but cops are protected from "hate speech" about their race, gender, or profession

What? There are no such things as criminal hate speech or am I misunderstanding 1A?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:51PM (#36806580)
You're right I meant to say hate crimes not hate speech. Although in the Utah case her actions where pretty clearly speech [1]

[1] https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016431004/a-woman-is-facing-...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:33PM (#36807050)
This case is not going to result in a criminal indictment. It is clearly a 1A violation. Much like how Florida has recently been nabbing people from other states for online posts[1].

In both cases, it seems the justice system is being weaponized to punish those via a lengthy judicial process. Hopefully the defendants will sue for civil rights violations.

[1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/what-does-in-minec...

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:56PM (#36808402)
They hopefully won't but the threat of arrest, even if they won't be indicted, is definitely enough to have a dampening effect on people exercising their rights. At the same time I wouldn't be confident in the courts protecting your first amendment rights [1] especially given the current court.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States (Note: this case has been overturned, but it took 50 years)

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mjamesaustin on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:29AM (#36801979)
A police officer is on duty, doing their job, and should have an expectation of professional behavior the same way ANY OTHER person doing their job does.

Look at how doctors handle unreasonable patients, or how people working in service handle angry customers. Even when people are provocative or rude, the expectation is to use your skills and intelligence to navigate the situation with grace.

In the case of (American) police, not only do they fail to de-escalate tense situations, they routinely escalate those situations into far more dangerous and violent ones, and are allowed to shoot and kill anyone they deem scary.

Yes it would be nice if Americans at large could be taught to act with grace and humility to those serving them, but no amount of microaggressions justifies murdering someone.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:31AM (#36801999)
> So much so that Hate Crimes and Safe Spaces are now a thing. People have lost jobs due to Cancel Culture fueled hate-mobs.

It is not "cancel culture", just good old fashioned "consequences".

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by tastyfreeze on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:41AM (#36802161)
When you lose your job simply for disagreeing with the mob it is indeed "cancel culture" not "consequences".
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:59AM (#36802453)
I would like to see examples of this.

Because I could disagree with someone about something dull and say something like "hotdogs are crap", and I think my job would be pretty safe.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:16PM (#36802737)
Some Boeing guy got ousted over a 30 year old opinion that women shouldn’t serve in combat roles in the military: https://nypost.com/2020/07/03/boeing-communications-boss-nie...
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:22PM (#36802833)
The headline itself clearly states that he resigned.

And where is that fabled "mob" here?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:48PM (#36803224)
Are you really that naïve?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:06PM (#36802578)
If you lose your job for disagreeing with the mob, all that means is that your boss is weak. That’s not the culture, that’s your employer.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by lordfrito on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:33AM (#36802037)
Ahhh the old "consequences" argument.

I can't tell when it's "cancel culture" or "consequences" anymore. Word seems interchangeable nowadays in the media.

Seems like when it happens to the in-group it's called cancel culture, but when it's experienced by the out-group it's just shrugged away as consequences.

The point I'm making is I'm tired of this kind of separation of people into groups. Bad behavior leading to "consequences" for one group should also be considered bad behavior for the other group, which doesn't get to complain about the same "consequences" as well.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:56AM (#36802395)
> Bad behavior leading to "consequences" for one group should also be considered bad behavior for the other group, which doesn't get to complain about the same "consequences" as well.

And it does.

This whole "cancel culture" debate is and always has been just a poor attempt at propaganda.

There is no such thing as "cancel culture", just this generational trend of using the word "cancel" interchangeably with "boycott". Boycotts have existed since the dawn of time, but there is no good way of personalizing a rival group as "boycotters", and that is the reason why we have this stupid "cancel culture" term.

Now, there are a myriad of reasons why a cop should not be treated like any other individual, first of all being that they are legally and factually protected from facing many of the consequences of the same bad behaviour that would put most other people behind bars.

But specifically and putting it into context, isn't having a government sponsored, paramilitary law enforcement group, that is immune to many law precepts by design, dangerous enough already?

In a world where cops have all their current privileges and conserve all their rights as individuals, there is no room for first amendment rights. There cannot be.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by idiotsecant on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:09PM (#36802643)
>Word seems interchangeable nowadays

You're so close to understanding.

This has always happened. When you have opinions people find objectionable it tends to make you less popular with those people. For some reason a few years ago we decided that if these ideas are coming from a particular group it's now a special thing deserving of a new term.

It's a dumb term. If you want to have soft power you need to not say all your vile opinions out loud, that's how the human animal has worked for millions of years.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by whoknew1122 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:54AM (#36802356)
Safe spaces aren't a new thing. It's just now there is a vocabulary for it. 20 years ago, before people talked about safe spaces, I would hang out at comic/gaming stores because I could be my nerdy self while playing Magic: the Gathering.

When I would go to bars, I'd go to gay bars. Because I could just be myself and not worry about running into the violence in the clubs that catered to teens.

A safe space is about finding a place where you find yourself comfortable to be your authentic self. They've always existed, even if they weren't called safe spaces -- or castigated as part of a culture war.

As an aside, I probably wouldn't use dicta from Plessy v. Ferguson, one of the worst decisions in US history, to buttress any argument. The constitution was never color-blind. It didn't explicitly reference color, but it didn't have to--everyone knew what it was talking about.

> Why wouldn't police officers be afforded the same kinds of protections from microagressions that are given to other people in this country.

Microaggressions are one thing. Criminalizing microaggressions is quite another.

> Doesn't a police officer have a right to a safe working environment, and aggression free interactions with 'customers' (citizens), and laws saying as much?

No. No cop goes into the profession expecting puppies and rainbows. Going into potentially unsafe environments with potentially aggressive people is what they signed up for.

As a retail employee, you have to put up with microaggressions from customers. It's just part of dealing with the public. And those microaggressions aren't criminalized. Why do cops get to criminalize their feelings getting hurt?

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:39PM (#36803099)
You could have had a safe space in your high school cafeteria, or anywhere you wanted, to play MTG or whatever other nerdy game. A person is responsible for creating their own safe space - one cannot control other people, but one can control themselves and their reactions to others and what they say. We were all intrinsically blessed with the gift of free will as humans, which allows us to decide how certain things, like the words of another, will affect us. We weren't intrinsically blessed with safe spaces.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mrangle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:20PM (#36802788)
>No. No cop goes into the profession expecting puppies and rainbows. Going into potentially unsafe environments with potentially aggressive people is what they signed up for.

That's not how law enforcement works at all. What you are suggesting is that cops have less protections than civilians. Putting on a badge doesn't remove assault legal protections.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by whoknew1122 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:43PM (#36803156)
I'm not suggesting that at all. Putting on a badge enhances assault legal protections. Assault on a peace officer is an upgraded charge from assault on a civilian.

Being a cop enhances your chances of being in a volatile situation. But you also have more leeway in how you address that violence, and have the backing of legislative branches (via legal enhancements such as assault on a peace officer) and the judiciary (via qualified immunity, among other things).

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by jimbob45 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:19AM (#36801794)
In fairness, Utah is arguably the most conservative state in the US right more by virtue of its hefty Mormon bloc.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by yamazakiwi on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#36802285)
Utah is definitely not the most conservative state.

Wyoming 69.9% West Virginia 68.6% Oklahoma 65.4% North Dakota 65.1% Idaho 63.8% Arkansas 62.4% Kentucky 62.1% Alabama 62% South Dakota 61.8% Tennessee

It's not in the top 10

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by cratermoon on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:44AM (#36802207)
That's nothing. Just whisper "fentanyl" and see the cops scurry away like roaches when you turn on the kitchen light.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:45AM (#36802221)
And yet people still want to eliminate the right for private citizens to carry semi-automatic firearms! Generally, it's the the same people complaining that complain about police abusing their powers and vulnerable groups of people.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by whoknew1122 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:38PM (#36803086)
If you think that the left and marginalized groups don't also have firearms, I think you'd be rather surprised. Check out the John Brown Gun Club, for example. You can be for sensible gun control and still have firearms as a pragmatic measure.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:52PM (#36804141)
Where did I say any of that? I simply stated that many of the people who would like to restrict private citizens' access to firearms are the same people who complain about the brutalization of vulnerable groups by police. I never said it was a rule nor that exceptions did not exist.

Without defining sensible gun control and pragmatic measures, I'm not sure that statement is agreeable.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:54AM (#36802354)
A gun isn't going to protect you from police violence, it's just going to give them a reason to become even more militarized and an excuse after they shoot you
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#36802428)
You might be surprised how much a group of armed citizens can do against a police squad. I don't think “you’ll never protect yourself from the gov’t” is an accurate angle.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802677)
Temporarily.

In the long run? Nah. Eventually the APCs roll in.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by livueta on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:24PM (#36808986)
You're not wrong that small arms won't help individuals much against armor, but by focusing on individual incidents I think you're missing part of the broader picture. It's very much like how the xkcd $5 wrench meme is true, but also largely unhelpful and misleading when considering the impact of a technology on a society.

If you're a person of interest and they can get to you, encryption won't save you from the $5 wrench, just as small arms won't save you from the APC. However, that doesn't mean that ubiquitous e2e encryption doesn't change the envelope w.r.t. law enforcement capabilities writ large. It's the difference between being able to find $5 wrench targets via dragnet surveillance of message content vs. needing more gumshoe techniques, just as an obvious example. You can't simultaneously wrench everyone at once.

An armed populace functions similarly: while getting Waco'd is certainly possible, you can't simultaneously Waco half of the country, which is what would be required in any attempt to enforce truly unpopular policy door-to-door. Imagine a Shanghai-style lockdown* in the US: it'd be a mutual bloodbath on day one. Imagine those Australian running street battles, but with firearms. The inability to do such things cleanly definitely changes the envelope of law enforcement capabilities, regardless of who'd win X arbitrary individual/small-group level engagement.

We can argue all day whether either of those developments is positive for societies, but the dynamic itself definitely exists.

* I have heard the take that legal rights, rather than dynamics of enforcement, were behind avoiding that scenario. I don't find that very convincing as plenty of measures were ultimately shot down by the courts, indicating that concern for possibly encroaching on legal rights wasn't a primary motivating factor. Besides, the fact that enforcement mechanisms of most such policies targeted financial flows by going after employers, rather than individuals at the physical level, seems like a pretty good indication that real-world enforceability was a limiting factor. Furthermore, real enforcement of some pandemic policies would have been quite popular in some areas: in my quite liberal city, there was nonstop baying at LE to "do something" about e.g. mask compliance, a legally-grounded policy. The fact that at no point did they do anything has a lot more do with practicality of enforcement than with legality of policy.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:52AM (#36813771)
In the long run they will run out of jackboots willing to risk not coming home to their families at the end of the day.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:22PM (#36815740)
Not unless "group of armed citizens" refers to a large-scale rebellion or civil war, no.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:52PM (#36816245)
Correct, a single individual or small group would get clobbered.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:10PM (#36802658)
They can't do nothing and if they try, they will go to prison forever.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:30PM (#36805546)
In the short term, any resistance is a death sentence. However, the gov agents always have to think about whether the person they're encountering is willing to throw their life away. If enough citizens become willing to be dead, real change happens. Sacrifice is required for such events, but clearly having an armed population helps reduce the power asymmetry.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:03PM (#36806720)
Gangs are that resistance and they are not winning.

In slums, drug cartels found enough of people willing to throw the life away. And as much as they are able to deal drugs, there is no symmetry between them and state. The Dead bodies just pile up.

Armed population does absolutely nothing except lynching here and there. And even those lynching happened with approval from state.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:36PM (#36807083)
The gangs clearly aren't trying to war against the state. If they were, I imagine the scenario would result in the national guard or a result akin to Mexico.

If the gangs wanted to make a stand against the state, they could. They would need to take and defend their territory while increasing their numbers, likely via kidnapping and child recruitment.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:18AM (#36810939)
> If the gangs wanted to make a stand against the state, they could. They would need to take and defend their territory while increasing their numbers, likely via kidnapping and child recruitment.

That is a pure fantasy. You know how I know? Because gangs historically and worldwide occasionally tried. This fails all the time.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:54AM (#36813793)
Tell that to the Mexican government.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:05AM (#36813912)
Revolutions have succeeded in the past. It is an unlikely outcome but possible.

My original point was that there is utility in having an armed populace because it requires government agents to evaluate the risk of infringing actions more heavily. Even if the citizens lose, nobody wants to be a casualty in they're resistance.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:23PM (#36815757)
> Because gangs historically and worldwide occasionally tried. This fails all the time.

It succeeds plenty. The list of successful coups by paramilitary groups is loooooong.

Hell, the Nazis started essentially as a gang.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:22AM (#36825018)
They did not won the way OP suggests.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by sangnoir on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:00PM (#36803402)
How are your guns going to help you when the police helicopters drop incendiary bombs on your house at 3AM?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by wolverine876 on Sunday July 30, 2023 @02:42PM (#36934536)
When has this actually happened? I think you'd find only very rare exceptions.

It's a fantasy. And it's destructive for the community to replace rule of law with rule of whoever-has-more-guns.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by rascul on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:02PM (#36803422)
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by test098 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:41PM (#36805679)
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by kthejoker2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:44PM (#36808313)
Lol the Bundys only "survived" because 80% of the cops out there are on their side.

Give me a break, them having guns in no way prevented LE from doing what they wanted.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802665)
And in the most egregious case of police violence, the people who value their right to own & carry weapons are a strong base of police support.

There is actually nothing contradictory about either set of positions though. Guns don't protect you from cops. Guns are power and violence, and who we consider to have rightful access to it. So are police.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:56PM (#36804195)
An armed citizenry has acted as a deterrent to tyrannical governments and nation states for as long as the two have co-existed. I'm not really sure what point you're trying to make here.

And no, "we" don't get to consider who has lawful or rightful access to firearms - unless you got to vote for the last class of police cadets at your local precinct.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:24PM (#36804553)
That something has often been true in the past doesn't mean it always will be. These are trends not natural laws.

There is a clear development for at least 20 years in the US of more policing, more police surveillance, more sense of a right or prerogative of police to make their own decisions about violence without oversight or consequence.

These changes are for the most part supported by the people who self-identify as enthusiastic gun owners, or people who value their right to own and carry guns. I don't want to try to guess what constraints you may have on the definition of tyrannical here, but this confluence of forces is a negative for the material expression of rights.

What you can do on paper isn't very important when someone can shoot you for doing it and get away with that. That someone may be a cop in some cirumstances and they may be a lawful gun owner in others. This makes them natural allies in many political contexts because of that simple fact.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#36802284)
I mean, they’re just emulating the zeitgeist. This is what happens when the prevailing worldview is inconsistent and hypocritical.

We’ve normalized the idea that words and subtle actions can be micro-aggressive and thus are violent. That’s literally the logic these days and instead of fighting it most people happily jumped onboard entertaining idiotic rhetoric in the name of social justice. So I’m not surprised at all to see this stuff try to make it’s way into laws.

Your responsibility as a citizen is to maintain a fair and just playing field. You don't get to cancel others for their word-violence and then turn around and complain when your peers try to put a stop yours. Time to grow up.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by Atreiden on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802675)
Are you really trying to suggest that police brutality is caused by cancel culture? That the natural consequences of attempting to address problematic language include the rampant murder of minorities by members of law enforcement?

> You don't get to cancel others for their word-violence and then turn around and complain when your peers try to put a stop yours. Time to grow up.

Hoo boy. This shouldn't need to be said, but there is absolutely no equivalence whatsoever between an individuals right to refuse to associate with "Stop the Steal" people, and LEOs being entitled to murder whoever they feel like without repercussion.

Is this sarcasm? The mental gymnastics here are so insane I have to question your sincerity in posting this.

> words and subtle actions can be micro-aggressive and thus are violent

This is not what the term microaggression means. Microagressions do not imply violence.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by throwmeouthn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:20PM (#36802799)
Except that microaggression includes the word aggression which is defined as:

> hostile or violent behavior or attitudes toward another; readiness to attack or confront.

I don't think they were suggesting police brutality is caused by cancel culture - I think that was you reaching. I think they were suggesting that laws being passed to protect police from being made fun of, are the result of people being overly sensitive and allowing the words of others to hurt them personally.

It appears that if anyone was doing mental gymnastics here, it was you.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:21PM (#36802805)
I think you misunderstood my argument. I’m not advocating for police brutality WTF?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by OGWhales on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:11PM (#36803534)
Cops have always been triggered by the mildest of disrespect, this has nothing to do with people worrying about social micro-aggressions.

What’s actually happening is that cops are being filmed and because of that people are losing respect for them faster than ever and the cops hate it and want to do anything they can to prevent people from disrespecting them.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:23PM (#36803708)
SJWs have always been triggered by the mildest of disrespect, which is why we’re here in the first place.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by OGWhales on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:03PM (#36804292)
Frankly speaking, it’s impossible for me to take the claim that this is the result of SJWs seriously. It’s just too ridiculous.

I think the growing discontent against cops due to their being filmed is a much more reasonable explanation for these kinds of laws. That’s why we are also seeing attempts to restrict people’s ability to film police.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dawnbreez on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:57PM (#36805895)
I feel like having video evidence of a police officer doing something they really shouldn't is neither "mild" nor "disrespect" (although, I guess you could argue that I rapidly stopped respecting the police when I realized just how little accountability there is for these incidents...)
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by CamperBob2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:20PM (#36802803)
The police have a monopoly on the legalized use of violence.

And it's impressive to see how quickly one gets shouted down on "progressive" forums when one objects to this inherently-illiberal state of affairs.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:43PM (#36803150)
Wait, arent policemen entitled to safe space to be protected from microaggressions with trigger warning?