Hate crime is a fucking stupid term; a crime is a crime is a crime. That said, if targeting one group deserves special treatment, then targeting any group should get the same. Equal application of the law, y'know?
Edit: It also looks like they were NOT charged with a hate crime for vandalizing a pride crosswalk.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2023/04/14/fac...
This thread is a menagerie of legal misunderstanding and buzzword abuse.
You don’t think general vandalism and targeted vandalism should be handled differently?
Also, citation needed!
Is a crime a crime? Why are there first degree murder, second degree murder, and voluntary manslaughter? They are all the act of killing someone intentionally, with the only difference being the person's thought process and motivation. Most crimes involve taking into consideration the reasons for the act as part of what makes a crime a crime. So, hate crimes are not some outlier in how crimes are defined and differentiated.
> if targeting one group deserves special treatment, then targeting any group should get the same. Equal application of the law, y'know?
Hate crimes (and protected classes in general) are not “one group” nor are they randomly picked. At the federal level, they are race, religion, ethnicity, disability, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, and/or gender identity, which basically fall into two different categories; what you are and what you believe. None of them are for what job you happen to choose to do. The “special treatment” statements is particularly fallacious, since most hate crime laws came in response systematic violence committed against these groups and them not receiving equal protection under the law. We don’t have anti lynching laws to give black people special treatment.
Put another way, why is it better if I murder someone because I hate vegans, or meat eaters, or poor people, or rich people, or car drivers or pedestrians than someone of a protected group?
Adding new laws doesn't make them be enforced any better, so I don't buy the "systemic" argument. Either someone is tried and found guilty or not.
If people started attacking other people for being Gluten-free, and the government saw that there was a large amount of cases, they would create regulations trying to curtail the amount of crime targeting those people. They are creating regulation with the intention of lowering crime targeting a small group because it is atypical.
Fortunately lawyers can not win trials with that argument in particular.
> Equal application of the law, y'know?
The context here is that we have a group (the Police) already enjoys special privileges (like monopoly on the use of force legally) and want to expand those privileges even further. I don't think your argument works the way you seem to think it works.
Without hate crime legislation, it would be easy for bigots to harass people via what the law would see as minor crimes.
So I'm not necessarily opposed to getting rid of hate crime legislation. However, we would need some other way to protect people.
The concept of mens rea is not new, it’s a vital factor in the defining, charging, convicting (and dismissing and acquitting) of crimes.
Of course mindset matters. You don't murder out of love, generally. I'm sure a few have. Putting these artificial rails on it, saying that it only matters for race or whatnot, that's the silly part and it was bound to be broken through. And so it has.
Prejudice, to be dangerous, requires power. Prejudice + Power = Danger. In a world of of 95% Martians and 5% Venusians, if a Martian calls all Venusians corrupt and evil, it's a danger - the Venusians may be at risk; their future - career, safety, status, etc. - depends on the goodwill of the Martians. If a Venusian does the same about Martians, it's easily dismissed because the Martians can continue to live and study safely.
IOW, punching up and punching down are entirely different things. Criticizing the government is punching up; criticizing (e.g.) homeless people is punching down.
Please show precedent for anyone being prosecuted for rendering an “intimidating smirk” in any other context. Or for filming someone working in public, for that matter.
Office workers don't have a monopoly on violence. Unfortuntely there are quite a few examples of cops treating anything other than obsequience as harassment.
The problem with good police officers is that if you actually try and stand up to the institution of policing, your buddies will throw you in the psych ward on false premises and make a challenge coin to commemorate doing it.
That's a very easy civics question: no one has that right. No American has a right to not be verbally diminished by strangers in a public setting.
I disagree with your "some bad apples" analogy though. That would be easy to fix relative to the problem we have which is systemic. "Good" cops are in the exact same situation as the bad ones. Policing is required yet fundamentally causing the problems at the same time.
>> And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street?
As stated in the article all 50 states already have laws on the books that prevent interference with police while doing their job. If you are in a public facing role like a police officer you most certainly do not have the right to being shielded from observation and interaction - that's a huge part of the job and probably part of the solution too.
Is it not dangerous enough to give officers pretty much unlimited authority, and expect the people around them to forfeit their first amendment right?
Police officers, being enforcers of the law, cannot reasonably be protected from people exercising their rights.
There are plenty of other professions that have tough jobs that I absolutely wouldn't want to do. But that doesn't mean I'm going to start letting garbage collectors get away with murder
For sure there's bad people, but most people are good. Those people that give cops crap are just some bad apples.
Right or wrong, call it what it is. Don't drop info off the event, and focus on one part of it.
And if someone has a right not to be harassed, when doing their job in an office, why doesn't a cop, when doing their job on the street?
Note, I said "doing their job", not "doing it wrong".
For damned sure there are bad cops. But by god, there are a load of good ones, and some of them spend all day, dealing with people at their absolute worst, taking crap you or I wouldn't be able to handle for 5 minutes.