News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:45AM (#36802221)
And yet people still want to eliminate the right for private citizens to carry semi-automatic firearms! Generally, it's the the same people complaining that complain about police abusing their powers and vulnerable groups of people.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by whoknew1122 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:38PM (#36803086)
If you think that the left and marginalized groups don't also have firearms, I think you'd be rather surprised. Check out the John Brown Gun Club, for example. You can be for sensible gun control and still have firearms as a pragmatic measure.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:52PM (#36804141)
Where did I say any of that? I simply stated that many of the people who would like to restrict private citizens' access to firearms are the same people who complain about the brutalization of vulnerable groups by police. I never said it was a rule nor that exceptions did not exist.

Without defining sensible gun control and pragmatic measures, I'm not sure that statement is agreeable.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by mitt_romney_12 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:54AM (#36802354)
A gun isn't going to protect you from police violence, it's just going to give them a reason to become even more militarized and an excuse after they shoot you
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by dcow on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#36802428)
You might be surprised how much a group of armed citizens can do against a police squad. I don't think “you’ll never protect yourself from the gov’t” is an accurate angle.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802677)
Temporarily.

In the long run? Nah. Eventually the APCs roll in.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by livueta on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:24PM (#36808986)
You're not wrong that small arms won't help individuals much against armor, but by focusing on individual incidents I think you're missing part of the broader picture. It's very much like how the xkcd $5 wrench meme is true, but also largely unhelpful and misleading when considering the impact of a technology on a society.

If you're a person of interest and they can get to you, encryption won't save you from the $5 wrench, just as small arms won't save you from the APC. However, that doesn't mean that ubiquitous e2e encryption doesn't change the envelope w.r.t. law enforcement capabilities writ large. It's the difference between being able to find $5 wrench targets via dragnet surveillance of message content vs. needing more gumshoe techniques, just as an obvious example. You can't simultaneously wrench everyone at once.

An armed populace functions similarly: while getting Waco'd is certainly possible, you can't simultaneously Waco half of the country, which is what would be required in any attempt to enforce truly unpopular policy door-to-door. Imagine a Shanghai-style lockdown* in the US: it'd be a mutual bloodbath on day one. Imagine those Australian running street battles, but with firearms. The inability to do such things cleanly definitely changes the envelope of law enforcement capabilities, regardless of who'd win X arbitrary individual/small-group level engagement.

We can argue all day whether either of those developments is positive for societies, but the dynamic itself definitely exists.

* I have heard the take that legal rights, rather than dynamics of enforcement, were behind avoiding that scenario. I don't find that very convincing as plenty of measures were ultimately shot down by the courts, indicating that concern for possibly encroaching on legal rights wasn't a primary motivating factor. Besides, the fact that enforcement mechanisms of most such policies targeted financial flows by going after employers, rather than individuals at the physical level, seems like a pretty good indication that real-world enforceability was a limiting factor. Furthermore, real enforcement of some pandemic policies would have been quite popular in some areas: in my quite liberal city, there was nonstop baying at LE to "do something" about e.g. mask compliance, a legally-grounded policy. The fact that at no point did they do anything has a lot more do with practicality of enforcement than with legality of policy.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:52AM (#36813771)
In the long run they will run out of jackboots willing to risk not coming home to their families at the end of the day.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:22PM (#36815740)
Not unless "group of armed citizens" refers to a large-scale rebellion or civil war, no.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:52PM (#36816245)
Correct, a single individual or small group would get clobbered.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:10PM (#36802658)
They can't do nothing and if they try, they will go to prison forever.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:30PM (#36805546)
In the short term, any resistance is a death sentence. However, the gov agents always have to think about whether the person they're encountering is willing to throw their life away. If enough citizens become willing to be dead, real change happens. Sacrifice is required for such events, but clearly having an armed population helps reduce the power asymmetry.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:03PM (#36806720)
Gangs are that resistance and they are not winning.

In slums, drug cartels found enough of people willing to throw the life away. And as much as they are able to deal drugs, there is no symmetry between them and state. The Dead bodies just pile up.

Armed population does absolutely nothing except lynching here and there. And even those lynching happened with approval from state.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:36PM (#36807083)
The gangs clearly aren't trying to war against the state. If they were, I imagine the scenario would result in the national guard or a result akin to Mexico.

If the gangs wanted to make a stand against the state, they could. They would need to take and defend their territory while increasing their numbers, likely via kidnapping and child recruitment.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:18AM (#36810939)
> If the gangs wanted to make a stand against the state, they could. They would need to take and defend their territory while increasing their numbers, likely via kidnapping and child recruitment.

That is a pure fantasy. You know how I know? Because gangs historically and worldwide occasionally tried. This fails all the time.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:54AM (#36813793)
Tell that to the Mexican government.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by hellojesus on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:05AM (#36813912)
Revolutions have succeeded in the past. It is an unlikely outcome but possible.

My original point was that there is utility in having an armed populace because it requires government agents to evaluate the risk of infringing actions more heavily. Even if the citizens lose, nobody wants to be a casualty in they're resistance.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:23PM (#36815757)
> Because gangs historically and worldwide occasionally tried. This fails all the time.

It succeeds plenty. The list of successful coups by paramilitary groups is loooooong.

Hell, the Nazis started essentially as a gang.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by watwut on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:22AM (#36825018)
They did not won the way OP suggests.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by sangnoir on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:00PM (#36803402)
How are your guns going to help you when the police helicopters drop incendiary bombs on your house at 3AM?
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by wolverine876 on Sunday July 30, 2023 @02:42PM (#36934536)
When has this actually happened? I think you'd find only very rare exceptions.

It's a fantasy. And it's destructive for the community to replace rule of law with rule of whoever-has-more-guns.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by rascul on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:02PM (#36803422)
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by test098 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:41PM (#36805679)
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by kthejoker2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:44PM (#36808313)
Lol the Bundys only "survived" because 80% of the cops out there are on their side.

Give me a break, them having guns in no way prevented LE from doing what they wanted.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802665)
And in the most egregious case of police violence, the people who value their right to own & carry weapons are a strong base of police support.

There is actually nothing contradictory about either set of positions though. Guns don't protect you from cops. Guns are power and violence, and who we consider to have rightful access to it. So are police.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by moretrashplz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:56PM (#36804195)
An armed citizenry has acted as a deterrent to tyrannical governments and nation states for as long as the two have co-existed. I'm not really sure what point you're trying to make here.

And no, "we" don't get to consider who has lawful or rightful access to firearms - unless you got to vote for the last class of police cadets at your local precinct.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by giraffe_lady on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:24PM (#36804553)
That something has often been true in the past doesn't mean it always will be. These are trends not natural laws.

There is a clear development for at least 20 years in the US of more policing, more police surveillance, more sense of a right or prerogative of police to make their own decisions about violence without oversight or consequence.

These changes are for the most part supported by the people who self-identify as enthusiastic gun owners, or people who value their right to own and carry guns. I don't want to try to guess what constraints you may have on the definition of tyrannical here, but this confluence of forces is a negative for the material expression of rights.

What you can do on paper isn't very important when someone can shoot you for doing it and get away with that. That someone may be a cop in some cirumstances and they may be a lawful gun owner in others. This makes them natural allies in many political contexts because of that simple fact.