News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:11PM (#36802677)
Temporarily.

In the long run? Nah. Eventually the APCs roll in.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by livueta on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:24PM (#36808986)
You're not wrong that small arms won't help individuals much against armor, but by focusing on individual incidents I think you're missing part of the broader picture. It's very much like how the xkcd $5 wrench meme is true, but also largely unhelpful and misleading when considering the impact of a technology on a society.

If you're a person of interest and they can get to you, encryption won't save you from the $5 wrench, just as small arms won't save you from the APC. However, that doesn't mean that ubiquitous e2e encryption doesn't change the envelope w.r.t. law enforcement capabilities writ large. It's the difference between being able to find $5 wrench targets via dragnet surveillance of message content vs. needing more gumshoe techniques, just as an obvious example. You can't simultaneously wrench everyone at once.

An armed populace functions similarly: while getting Waco'd is certainly possible, you can't simultaneously Waco half of the country, which is what would be required in any attempt to enforce truly unpopular policy door-to-door. Imagine a Shanghai-style lockdown* in the US: it'd be a mutual bloodbath on day one. Imagine those Australian running street battles, but with firearms. The inability to do such things cleanly definitely changes the envelope of law enforcement capabilities, regardless of who'd win X arbitrary individual/small-group level engagement.

We can argue all day whether either of those developments is positive for societies, but the dynamic itself definitely exists.

* I have heard the take that legal rights, rather than dynamics of enforcement, were behind avoiding that scenario. I don't find that very convincing as plenty of measures were ultimately shot down by the courts, indicating that concern for possibly encroaching on legal rights wasn't a primary motivating factor. Besides, the fact that enforcement mechanisms of most such policies targeted financial flows by going after employers, rather than individuals at the physical level, seems like a pretty good indication that real-world enforceability was a limiting factor. Furthermore, real enforcement of some pandemic policies would have been quite popular in some areas: in my quite liberal city, there was nonstop baying at LE to "do something" about e.g. mask compliance, a legally-grounded policy. The fact that at no point did they do anything has a lot more do with practicality of enforcement than with legality of policy.

Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:52AM (#36813771)
In the long run they will run out of jackboots willing to risk not coming home to their families at the end of the day.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by ceejayoz on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:22PM (#36815740)
Not unless "group of armed citizens" refers to a large-scale rebellion or civil war, no.
Re:The Crazily Unconstitutional New Laws Trying to Criminali... by baremetal on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:52PM (#36816245)
Correct, a single individual or small group would get clobbered.