News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by damnesian on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:40AM (#36708947)
>Don't rely on proprietary infrastructure you have no control over for essential public functionality.

This. Love him or hate him, it doesn't matter- surely everyone can now agree Musk's personal, totally idiosyncratic treatment of the platform has rendered it completely useless for anything beyond pure vanity.

A public-owned twitter-type platform is the answer, imho.

We have publicly funded tv and radio- I think they have done a great job for what they are- what kid hasn't been improved by exposure to Mr. Rogers or Sesame Street?- but we live online now. It's time for a publicly-owned messaging system, whether that be federated or otherwise.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by tedivm on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:48AM (#36709063)
I publicly owned twitter platform is complicated and presents a lot of problems. I think the federated model has a lot of appeal here, as it allows governments to broadcast alerts out without requiring them to take on a large platform (and moderation responsibilities, which are really complicated for a government).
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by londons_explore on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:01AM (#36709297)
Most governments already have that... it's called a website.

Turns out they used twitter because that's where the users were.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:31AM (#36709737)
A website is not the same as having robust infrastructure for public notifications. And to be clear-- neither is twitter, but a website you have to visit isn't as convenient or useful in an emergency where you want people to receive an alert without going to a website.

So, the requirements are more than a website, but also not a private 3rd party platform w/o service guarantees, and preferably something that doesn't have municipality, department or agency rolling their own solutions, duplicating effort, etc.

In the US the traditional systems are Emergency Alert & WEA but those don't encompass all the public awareness & notification needs that drive organizations to use something like Twitter. I'm not sure if the right answer is to expand those or creating something similar for scenarios currently outside their scope, but we could do worse than starting the conversation with that question.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bobthepanda on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:37AM (#36709835)
Computers lack a protocol that drowns out anything and freezes your computer for broadcast alerts.

The online strategy so far, has to be where the people are, so most governments have multiple social media accounts, like Facebook and Twitter, and also websites and RSS. I’ve also seen, depending on the government, Instagram, TikTok, WhatsApp, etc.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by davvolun on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:51AM (#36710097)
And, if I may, I think the point is that is all well and good, but for reliability's sake, a publicly, not privately, controlled alternative to any of the above (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, WhatsApp, etc.) should be carefully considered. Mastodon is perfectly set up to be a valuable ADDITIONAL option for local governments using Twitter -- that doesn't mean "stop posting to Twitter," it means "also post to Mastodon" and be certain that, whatever shortcomings that may have, it's not entirely susceptible to the whims of a billionaire. Similarly, are Facebook posts by local government failing to reach users because of some change Zuck made to The Algorithm? Maybe we need to start looking into effective alternatives. If not, then we don't.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bobthepanda on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:38AM (#36710959)
Those self-owned things, the website and RSS, already exist; all governments I’ve interacted with have one, and the subject of the article is no exception: https://news.gov.bc.ca/connect

The reality is that when it comes to spreading info to citizens you can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by mcv on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:55PM (#36716607)
Netherland has something like that too. We had a big storm recently. Got three alerts on my phone. It works very well. Certainly better than Twitter.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by crote on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:14AM (#36709482)
Websites don't really work that well for push-based information, nor do they provide the automatic amplification offered by social media.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:19AM (#36709549)
Can I assume that you mean static websites, because there is nothing special about social media; Twitter is quite literally just another website.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:34AM (#36709771)
Twitter is not just a website, it is also a platform that facilitates push notifications so that people can receive information in near real time, passively, no need to visit a website. So neither Twitter or a website alone is the answer.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:43AM (#36709952)
But that is not entirely accurate. The website/app instance is running on the phone/device/whatever. It is not passive. The user opened it ( or opted to keep it open in background ).

In other words, 'website' is visited. Information is accessed and sent back to the requester.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by cesarb on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:01AM (#36710293)
> The website/app instance is running on the phone/device/whatever. It is not passive. The user opened it ( or opted to keep it open in background ).

That's not how it works. Unless it's the foreground application, the application is not running; it's not kept open in the background. Instead, what happens is that the application registers with a push notification system when the user first opens it and logs in. When the user should be notified, the website sends a message to the push notification system's central servers, which notifies the phone (the push notification system does stay open in the background, but it's shared by all applications in the phone), which then starts the application on the phone to show the notification.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:34PM (#36712945)
Thank you for this. It always helps to understand something better.

That said, does it change twitter's status as a website that just happens to have functionality X ( push notifications )?

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by djbusby on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:51PM (#36712255)
Can WebNotify (or whatever) work? That thing that some sites nag me with could have a purpose? Does it work on mobile?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:03PM (#36712449)
A user gets notifications without having to look at their phone. That seems passive? Sure, prior installation & configuration of the app days/months/years beforehand was an active step but once you give it permission to send you notifications all of those notifications are received without user intervention required.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by KineticLensman on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:26AM (#36709647)
> Twitter is quite literally just another website

Well, apart from the app

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:36AM (#36709828)
It is true that on the phone the way the information is presented is through an app ( and we can argue whether it is just a more restricted browser ), but definition of a website is:

related content that is identified by a common domain name and published on at least one web server

If that is the case, app is just a bastardized website.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by amrocha on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:04PM (#36711454)
Stop being facetious. Twitter is way more complicated to build than a static website, and even if you did you wouldn't reach the same amount of users.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:13AM (#36709470)
Pretty much. So you use a website and for people who don't use it that's their problem. My town also (used to have?) has an automatic phone system but I don't really pick up random calls and don't have a landline now so that's useless.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:40AM (#36709890)
>for people who don't use it that's their problem

You're evacuating, driving along a highway, and during the course of your trip the available evacuation routes change. A website is useless here.

The context of the conversation is emergency situations, that has to be taken into account when thinking about the required public notification infrastructure.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:47AM (#36710034)
But what is reliably useful at that point? Radio maybe? I'm not sure how Twitter or a Twitter clone is any more useful than a website. Phone alerts are probably the best choice at that point assuming you don't have them turned off.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bombcar on Friday July 14, 2023 @08:11AM (#36722726)
Twitter can’t be better than a website because Twitter IS a website!

What Twitter was is better than Facebook, the main other governmental alert platform.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by amrocha on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:07PM (#36711516)
How is it useless? You're in traffic, you check Twitter on your phone, you change your plans. I can't subscribe to an RSS feed on a phone by default
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:53PM (#36712296)
If you get a chance. You're not necessarily going to be in traffic so slow that you can safely do that. Maybe you will, maybe not. Getting an alert means you don't have to guess & keep checking. If there's an additional alert you get it and only then have figure out how to safely check it.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by slavik81 on Friday July 14, 2023 @06:04PM (#36730583)
> You're in traffic, you check Twitter on your phone

That is illegal in B.C.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bob-09 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:28PM (#36713900)
An elected official will not be satisfied with the “that’s your problem” response, because they fear those people will vote them out of office.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ryukafalz on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:54AM (#36709180)
Yeah, I think federated is the right answer. You don't need to run a public platform, but you can run the infrastructure for government staff and announcements while still reaching the broader network.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by zerodensity on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:51AM (#36709128)
What problems do you see with a publicly owned twitter variant?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:42AM (#36709923)
I don't see any social network as a good answer in the context of this story. What's needed is robust public alert & notification infrastructure.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by Chabsff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:02AM (#36709305)
A large social platform simply cannot survive without constant moderation that goes beyond strict application of the law. You need some form of community standards in place.

A government agency governing what is acceptable speech is a bad idea.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by flir on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:17AM (#36709528)
Sounds like it would work in pretty much every country except America.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by imwillofficial on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:53PM (#36712301)
Ah yes, the world, long known for its lockstep dance of harmony.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by intrasight on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:30AM (#36709713)
Why would such a twitter variant need moderation? We're talking about a government notification system. Only people posting would be government officials.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by viraptor on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:37AM (#36709842)
If you're saying Twitter variant, that implies a social network using text+image communication. If you want a notification system instead, there are much better and usable ways to implement that. See https://www.emergency.vic.gov.au/respond/ for example.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by Chabsff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:36AM (#36709829)
A pure one-way notification system is not a "twitter variant", but a completely different beast altogether.

The draw of the twitter-like approach is that the government messages are a portion of an existing stream of communication that people are already using/consuming.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by intrasight on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:43AM (#36709948)
The article is about governments using twitter to send notifications. Lots - perhaps most - use twitter exclusively this way.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by johaugum on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:52AM (#36710129)
> We're talking about a government notification system.

This exists, and is called Wireless Emergency Alerts. Every phone sold in the U.S. today supports this out of the box.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by mholm on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:04PM (#36713516)
Wireless Emergency Alerts are for emergencies. If you look at any government's twitter feed, the posts are either very much not emergencies, or in this post's context, too specific and numerous to use the system with. The government needs something besides a passive website and a highly active emergency alert system.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by wizofaus on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:35PM (#36715623)
So use the alerts to instruct users to view a website or similar platform where more detail can be posted? Unless it really is an emergency, why's there a need to push so many messages to a social media feed anyway? What are they mostly about and who reads them? During Covid there was certainly at least something interesting to post fairly regularly, though nothing that wasn't already plastered all over newspaper headlines or regular TV/radio news bulletins. Even then I can't say I ever felt an additional platform was needed, and that really was an exceptional period in history.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by dynamorando on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:38AM (#36710956)
Is NPR subject to these restrictions in the US?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by Chabsff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:52AM (#36711215)
Since when is NPR a government-controlled platform?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by dynamorando on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:18PM (#36711679)
It's not, though it does get partial funding from the US government. I've been for a few weeks now to try and unpack the ramifications of public funded social media.

Blog post here: https://dynamorando.pages.dev/blog/the-public-web/

The most common refrain that I get whenever this topic comes up is "First Amendment" - meaning that public funded social media should not be in the business of moderation; though I often wonder how come NPR, PBS, BBC and so on don't run their own social media websites (based on your deciding flavor of ActivityPub instances.)

I believe the German and Dutch governments run their own Mastodon instances, I don't understand at the moment why other governments don't follow this path.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by imwillofficial on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:55PM (#36712324)
It is.

You work for who pays you.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bob-09 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:42PM (#36714097)
Right. NPR works for the public.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by my123 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:58AM (#36709251)
In an international world, which govt should operate it becomes a complicated matter.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ebiester on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:06AM (#36709365)
Each government should own one. It doesn't have to be federated to be useful.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ncallaway on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:04AM (#36709329)
The problem where a platform that is truly bound by the first amendment would lose in the marketplace, because most people don’t want to be on a platform where Nazis can post as much as they want.

Platforms that censor are going to win in the marketplace, because that’s what most people want in a discussion platform.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by chiefalchemist on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:57AM (#36709233)
Once a week my phone buzzes with some sort of child-alert, abduction and/or storm warnings. How is what's needed in this case any different?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ncallaway on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:09AM (#36709404)
There are lots of things the government needs to disseminate that are important, but don't need to be push notifications for everyone.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by delecti on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:09AM (#36709403)
Those are very annoying and usually useless, so many people turn them off (everyone I know does). And if you miss one for any of the many reasons that could occur in an emergency, I wouldn't know where to go to seek out those alerts.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by chiefalchemist on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:17AM (#36709524)
So for that we blame...Twitter?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by delecti on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:54AM (#36710166)
Where in my comment did I mention twitter, or imply anything about it? I was just saying that the automated phone alerts aren't a great fit for something like wildfire evacuation instructions. At the very least they shouldn't be the only avenue for that information.

Twitter was fantastic for that kind of thing though.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by chiefalchemist on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:28PM (#36726220)
You didn't. But the topic is public notifications and Twitter. You seemed to imply the alternative to Twitter isn't effective, within a thread that starts with Twitter isn't effective.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:06AM (#36710358)
People die or get injured in my region annually during flash floods, snow storms, etc., so most people don't turn off these alerts. The ones who get hurt are the unlucky or disadvantaged or people who ignore the alerts.

Child alert systems find about 50 or 60 kids a year (US). Turning them off is a pretty shit move for the ~dozen per year that come through.

> if you miss one for any of the many reasons that could occur in an emergency(

"It's not perfect so why bother?" Is an odd attitude. Per the above, I keep on emergency weather alerts even though I might miss some.

>I wouldn't know where to go to seek out those alerts.*

You can fix that. I know where to go for such things during adverse weather events, and when an AMBER alert has been issue for a kid I'm often curious enough to see if it's been called off a few hours later.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:18AM (#36710589)
> Child alert systems find about 50 or 60 kids a year (US). Turning them off is a pretty shit move for the ~dozen per year that come through.

As far as I know, the only options on my phone for these alerts are "deafeningly loud alarm" and "entirely disabled." After my phone woke me up at 3 AM for some kid being abducted in some other town, it's now off permanently. I did the same for weather alerts after it destroyed my ears to tell me about some flash flooding alert on some street across town that I will never use.

There is literally no situation in which my phone making a deafeningly loud alarm is acceptable, so I turn all those alerts off to make sure it doesn't happen again. If the implementation were better, I might leave them on. But it isn't, so I don't.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by progman32 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#36712506)
No situation at all? What if you were on that street?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:17PM (#36712682)
Then it should vibrate like any other notification. There is no situation I can think of that is improved by someone at city hall having the ability to make every phone in the area scream at full volume, versus just behaving like a normal notification.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:43PM (#36713115)
>There is no situation I can think of

The horizons of your thinking appear to be truncated to somewhere within a few dozen yards and ~10 minutes of your current time & location. Can you think of no incident where there was an otherwise avoidable death or injury that could have been prevented with a timely alert?

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:48PM (#36713210)
Not one that couldn't have been equally well handled by a normal notification, no.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:56PM (#36713359)
I'm not quite clear on this-- are you maintaining that stance only with respect to yourself, or for all people across society in all situations?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:10PM (#36713608)
For me, it is unacceptable for my phone to ever make a noise that I did not ask it to make. I can't think of any situation in which this is not true. A normal notification will get my attention just fine. If I have to choose between deafening noise and no notification, I will choose no notification every time.

I think there should be a third option, which is to treat them like normal notifications. This is so obvious to me that I'm utterly baffled that it isn't an option. We probably wouldn't even be having this discussion if the option existed. But it doesn't, so here we are.

I would even OK with deafening noise being the default. I would argue that it shouldn't be the default, as I think the false-alarm problem is a serious one that will cause people to just turn it off. But I understand the other side of the argument.

My opinion is anything that causes a bunch of deafening noise from every phone in the vicinity should be treated with the same level of gravity as turning on the tornado siren. We don't turn on the tornado siren for every kid who gets lost or every flooded road. We shouldn't be blowing up every phone for those events, either. Tornado coming to town? Ok, blow up the phones. Missile coming down from the sky? Ok, blow up the phones. City-destroying wildfire coming in? Ok, blow up the phones. Kid got in the wrong car? Berry St is flooded? Sorry, those doesn't qualify for the tornado alarm, so they don't qualify for blowing up phones either.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:37PM (#36714017)
Okay, then it's just a matter of you & I drawing the line in different places, and maybe yours is further out due to less likelihood of dangerous weather conditions, or the thrill of potentially having an unscheduled white-water rafting experience through the town, or personal preference. I can see your point about the defaults. Cheers!
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:27PM (#36712840)
So you've determined that you are a exception in so far as never being in any potential danger from something covered in the contents of a emergency alert.

This does not counter argument that the GGP comment is incorrect in labelling these systems "mostly useless"

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:34PM (#36712953)
I interpreted their comment as saying the specific alerts that user receives are useless to them. I definitely agree with that. If enough people feel as we do and turn the alerts off, then yes, I think the system itself does become useless. I don't know how many people turn them off.

This could be avoided by making the implementation less terrible. I don't know how we arrived at the current situation where they're either deafening, or entirely off. It seems really stupid to me that those are the only options. I would prefer to receive them, but it's not worth waking me up at 3 AM for a flooded road 20 miles away.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:50PM (#36713245)
>If enough people feel as we do and turn the alerts off, then yes, I think the system itself does become useless. I don't know how many people turn them off.

That's like saying x = x. Of course if people don't use the system, the system isn't being useful. Contrary to that hypothetical, I am making the observation that people do use the system and often find it useful.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by coldpie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:55PM (#36713337)
Sure, that's a fair take. My comment was more responding to your comment saying that turning off alerts is a "shit move," by explaining why many of us choose to turn them off.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by addaon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:35PM (#36711980)
One challenge with AMBER alerts is that they don't provide enough information for the receiver to determine if the alert reflects a credible danger to a child, or if it's a nuisance alert where the system is being abused during a custody battle. Further, the very nature of a highly disruptive, high volume alert like this is to encourage the public to take extreme action -- e.g. following a vehicle -- that increases danger for both the involved child and everyone else in the area. While there are attempts to fix this very broken system (e.g. [1]), for now I very much consider the cure to be potentially worse than the disease.

[1] https://kutv.com/news/local/law-introduced-for-new-criteria-...

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ineedasername on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:12PM (#36712599)
>e.g. following a vehicle... the cure to be potentially worse than the disease

I'm not aware of citizen vehicle chases being a systemic problem. What other offsetting problems exist that negate the benefits of the system? I don't consider annoyance/disturbance to be sufficient to say it's worse than the disease (which implies it should be stopped, pending overhaul) especially considering the ability to turn the alerts off.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by MichaelZuo on Saturday July 15, 2023 @09:26PM (#36742615)
It's not possible to turn off alerts of the highest authority, "Presidential alerts", without turning off the phone. All basemodem and smartphone manufacturers selling in North America hardcode this into the black box part of the firmware. (Which is part of the approval process and why you'll never be able to buy a 'fully unlocked' phone.)

For example in Ontario, every alert is sent out at this authority.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by wizofaus on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:26PM (#36715485)
Surely SMS is more than sufficient as an emergency broadcast system. Which is one reason the increasing number of SMS spam/phishing messages is more than just a nuisance, it's seriously eroding trust in the system. I know people now that basically assume every SMS not from a known contact is spam. Governments should have a vested interest in actually doing something concrete to tackle it, I'm not even sure why it's so hard to solve.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by seventhson on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:50AM (#36709105)
We already have an emergency messaging system called Amber Alert. Just generalize that infrastructure a bit and you're halfway there.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by brewdad on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:02AM (#36709304)
Maybe, but it would need to be treated as a separate system. I turned Amber Alerts off after being blasted awake at 2am over a missing child five hours away from me. The chances of me ever being able to help in a missing persons case is already incredibly slim. It would be impossible at 2am unless the kidnapper hides under my bed.

The current system is used in a suboptimal way, at least by authorities in my state.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:20AM (#36709565)
Yeah I have Amber alerts turned off. I guess other alerts are still on on my iPhone which is probably as close to a government alerting system as you're going to get.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by criddell on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:52AM (#36709154)
I really hope they don't do this. I already turned off those alerts because there are too many of them.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by irrational on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:57AM (#36709238)
Why are so many children being abducted where you live?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by criddell on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:07AM (#36709381)
Do you know of a better source for adrenochrome?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by macksd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:15AM (#36709498)
In some places the system is overused and alerts get issued in custody disputes, claims of abuse, etc. It doesn't always mean abducted by a predator or stranger and that's part of the problem.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by gottorf on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:16PM (#36711652)
> It doesn't always mean abducted by a predator or stranger

The overwhelming majority -- over 90% -- of children being abducted are taken by family[0], usually as a part of a custody dispute.

[0]: https://safeatlast.co/blog/child-abduction-statistics/

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by macksd on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:44PM (#36713152)
Yup. And I wish they'd make it clear. Not that I think people should be allowed to take the law into their own hands, but as courts are imperfect, I get why a good and loving parent might do this. There's a world of difference in how I would respond if I saw a concerned parent with their child illegally than how I would respond if I knew I was seeing an actual child predator.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by COGlory on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:41PM (#36714089)
Near a half dozen extremely impovershed reservations..
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by kdmccormick on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:00AM (#36709274)
AMBER ALERT: Bike lane closure on State Street due to construction, use West Street for detour.

Yeah screw that haha, I'll take the Twitter clone for anything short of actual emergency.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by zodester on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:50AM (#36710081)
+1, this system should be improved with a topic based subscription so individuals can opt-in/out of lower level alerts, but keep the ability for local governments to blast everyone in an area for emergencies
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by namibj on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:45PM (#36716480)
That's already the case.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by criddell on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:51AM (#36709131)
> A public-owned twitter-type platform is the answer, imho.

I don't think this could work. Private companies like Twitter can enforce limitations on content that the a government run platform couldn't enforce due to the first amendment.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by kdmccormick on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:58AM (#36709252)
Can't speak for GP, but when I read that, I imagined a platform exclusively for official communications from government and municipal officials. The .gov / .gov.xx version of Twitter, if you will.

If it federated with Mastadon (or was a Mastadon instance) then others could seamlessly pull those official comms into their feed without having to ever navigate to the platform. Or, for those of us that don't care to have a centralized feed, we could just go to the instance directly for government comms. No more of this "get nagged by twitter ads while I try to read updates from my local government".

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:18AM (#36709543)
And I wouldn't bother to have such a site active on my laptop or phone any more than I would a website absent some emergency--in which case the website works as well as anything. And the government has no reliable way to push info out to me nor do I want it to have same--though maybe that's a US thing.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by seszett on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:34AM (#36709772)
Well for now I don't bother having Twitter open on my laptop just in case my government would want to tell me something, so I don't see how this would be much different.

The main difference I see though is that since Mastodon provides RSS feeds, I could at least follow the feed of my country's emergency services without needing a specialised app.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:44AM (#36709969)
RSS feeds are definitely an alternative but now you've covered ~1% (if that) of the population. I used to be an avid RSS consumer and even I don't really use it much any longer.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by seszett on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:56AM (#36710189)
Apparently Twitter is used by 11% of the population here in Belgium, so that's certainly better but... how many of those follow accounts of the government? I suspect it's very low and most people probably don't even know all the levels that might potentially emit emergency warnings. I know I don't.

Given the general trust in American corporations, it's not absurd to think some of the 89% of the population that doesn't use Twitter would be more willing to install an application to follow official communication on Mastodon than to use Twitter.

Anyway warnings are just broadcast on the mobile network here, which works fine.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:59AM (#36710250)
Yeah. Mobile phone alerts are probably about the best you can do these days beyond going house to house (and even then). You're never going to get to 100%. But, as you suggest, Twitter isn't even a particularly good channel. I use Twitter and I have no idea what my local government channels are, if any.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by amrocha on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:55AM (#36711286)
Even if you don't use it, you can check it during an emergency. Even if you don't check it, someone else else was checking it and relaying that information to you. You used to be able to search an account on an app you already have, and get the latest information. Now governments have to manage their own instances, you have to search their website, find the url, subscribe to it or download a custom app, and then you can finally see what used to be a search away from you.

That can only be described as a loss.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by seszett on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:07PM (#36714454)
I can't get used to either Twitter or the fediverse, but they don't work differently on the discoverabilty aspect.

One would likely just subscribe to your city's hashtag for large cities or to your town hall's account for small ones, and that's all. The rest works like Twitter (except there is less risk of important posts getting invisibilised by the feed algorithm).

In my fediverse test, I just subscribed to #Antwerpen (as well as #Antwerp and #Anvers but that's a whole other problem...) and I did get relevant and interesting posts. In their small town my parents are subscribed to the town hall's Facebook account (the only reason they signed up to Facebook) and it would work the same on any other app, except it likely would spy on them a bit less. Mastodon's Android app is not a "more custom" app than Twitter or Facebook's apps are, on the contrary I would argue.

I just can't get used to checking this thing more than once every few days and like Twitter it just doesn't work if you're not constantly reading your feed, because then you're missing most posts.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by 0cf8612b2e1e on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#36711080)
At least there would be a central location. You would always know you could go there to learn more about government affairs. There should also be nothing preventing someone from mirroring GovTwitter to Twitter/Threads/Mastadon where the people are.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:47AM (#36711136)
>At least there would be a central location

It's called a website.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by 0cf8612b2e1e on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:52AM (#36711219)
Whose website? Does my local city have one? Do they have the IT resources to ensure it is hosted? Do they know how to get a .gov domain? What about state news? Lot of friction and multiple potential locations vs a Federally run resource.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by addaon on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:25PM (#36711805)
> Does my local city have one?

It's hard to answer this question without knowing your local city. My town of < 5000 people has the appropriate .gov site set up and maintained; it's one of the responsibilities of the local government. I'd imagine that any local government structure large enough to have evacuation plans in place is also large enough to have a website to communicate those plans on...

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ghaff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:19PM (#36714645)
I live in about a 7,000 person town and they have a website as, I assume, most if not all of the towns in the state do. I don't know how good they are with emergency notifications on the site but then we don't have a lot of emergencies requiring notification.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by kodah on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:06PM (#36711496)
Yes, all of this stuff had normalized processes before Twitter emerged from SXSW.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by amrocha on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:52AM (#36711220)
Twitter is reliably real time. Yes, governments push information out in other ways, but it's unclear how real time it is. If you see a government account tweeting about a current event, you used to be able to assume that that was the latest information available.

This was especially useful for things like transit, or emergency situations. If there was a snowstorm, I would check the BC transit Twitter account. When there was an active shooter at my university, I checked the Ottawa RCMP Twitter account.

And I relayed that information to others, including people like you, making sure that even if you don't have Twitter you had the latest information. Now, Twitter can't be relied on for the latest information anymore. Government websites are not real time. There were millions of people using Twitter for this, and now they're no longer going to use the platform. This is absolutely a loss for the platform, no two ways about it.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by brvsft on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:28AM (#36710743)
I did not think this is what they meant from the comment, but I did immediately think it would be useful (and get around any 1st Amendment concerns) as you've suggested here: a platform exclusively for official communications from gov't at various levels / localities.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by jorts on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:05PM (#36711474)
Everbridge is used by lots of governmental offices for this purpose.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:01AM (#36709293)
Is PBS under first amendment obligations?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by belltaco on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:21AM (#36709585)
PBS isn't government owned or operated, I think it just receives some government funding?

Plus I don't see where members of the public can post content on PBS for the first amendment to even come into the picture. If an employee posts something objectionable, they can be fired regardless of the first amendment, just like any government employee.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:30AM (#36709724)
It's a public service. We don't need the twitter equivalent to be 100% government owned and operated, do we? Seems like this would be an excellent equivalent.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by davvolun on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:53AM (#36710133)
That depends on the structure.

There are no 1st Amendment issues with Amber Alerts or weather alerts pushed to my phone, for example. But if CNN or Fox News are allowed to post to this proposed service, now we've got a different animal.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by bawolff on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:46AM (#36711113)
> I don't think this could work. Private companies like Twitter can enforce limitations on content that the a government run platform couldn't enforce due to the first amendment.

Some content about manitoba seems like a small price to pay for accurate wildfile info.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by doylio on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:54AM (#36711255)
The Canadian government is not held to that standard :P
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by jamal-kumar on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:26PM (#36711812)
I'd like to point something out here - In this case it's the provincial BC government, not Federal Canadian.

That said they just outsourced that shit to a chain of large corporations, all who have lost their contracts for doing really dumb and bad stuff, and they've definitely dropped the ball really hard on emergency warning alert systems working properly before. People could have died in their sleep. [1][2]

[1] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/bc-cha...

[2] https://www.vicnews.com/news/new-national-emergency-alert-sy...

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by politician on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:51AM (#36709133)
Which public though? Twitter may be a private company, but it has an international presence. A publicly-owned system would have to be owned by the public of a particular country or state, leading to problems with differences between who pays and who benefits.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by pwndByDeath on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:55AM (#36709202)
Funny I thought twitter was just an exhibitionism platform from the first day.

My suggestion is to establish a tweeters anonymous?

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by londons_explore on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:57AM (#36709240)
> surely everyone can now agree Musk's [...] treatment of the platform has rendered it completely useless [...].

I haven't actually noticed much change there. Sure, people seem to be angry about all kinds of things, but that's the normal over on twitter. The core functionality of 'post tweet' and 'see tweets others have posted' seems unaffected for me and every user I follow.

I don't really see what everyone is angry about. "User XYZ did X controversial action and got banned for it" is of no interest to me, partly because I am not interested in User XYZ, and partly because the sorts of things I use twitter for don't revolve around seeing the spread of whatever the next activist thing is.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by nwienert on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:29AM (#36709694)
He changed political teams. That turned many here against him. It also turned 98% of media against him, which has managed to drive a bunch of narratives.

If you didn't swallow media narratives wholesale and were just using Twitter you'd have noticed very little.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by mynameisvlad on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:29AM (#36709688)
Did you even bother to read the article? The one which describes exactly what the problem is?

Just because you haven’t hit the limit does not mean the limit does not exist nor that it’s harming the platform.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by londons_explore on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:03PM (#36714396)
I kinda like there being a limit. I don't follow a user to be able to spam me with a million tweets.

If you have more than ~10 things to say in a day, then sign up for another account and put links - ie. "CaliGov: wildfires around San Francisco. For more info follow @CaliWildfires2023".

Obviously there should be some UI to show you when you're getting near the limit, but I expect thats coming.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by mynameisvlad on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:54PM (#36715088)
> I don't follow a user to be able to spam me with a million tweets.

Sure, but this is not your run-of-the-mill user. This is essentially an emergency broadcast service. Most people would follow the account with the desire to see "a million tweets" if those are relevant to the thing they are broadcasting. In fact, the absence of such tweets due to a limit is probably more harmful than the number of tweets that did go out.

> If you have more than ~10 things to say in a day, then sign up for another account and put links - ie. "CaliGov: wildfires around San Francisco. For more info follow @CaliWildfires2023".

That's absurd and spammy for no reason other than to get around a restriction that shouldn't exist for these accounts. And would hit the exact same limits. It's not like they used up their tweets spamming about irrelevant details.

> Obviously there should be some UI to show you when you're getting near the limit, but I expect thats coming.

That's putting a lot of hope into promises that haven't even been made.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by Liquid_Snake on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:20PM (#36718692)
you haven't noticed the effect of any dullard getting signal boosted by simply paying $8 an hour? that's a massive change to content proliferation.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by MSFT_Edging on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:58AM (#36709250)
Musk essentially got upset that everyone on twitter didn't love him, so he bought the toy and broke it so others couldn't play with it.

His changes to the site were optimized for maximum praise for himself.

He destroyed the verification system that was intended to avoid public figures from being impersonated. Now it's simply people who have bad posts, now getting more attention to their bad posts.

Hateful individuals can now pay 8 dollars to prioritize their hateful posts under their targets' tweets.

Terrible, awful, spoiled little man.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by jamal-kumar on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:31PM (#36711908)
I think everyone is looking forward to Mark absolutely pulverizing him. Even friends I talk to who don't even care about or are involved in tech want to see this happen.

Weird thing to challenge a guy who's been training way hard for a few years now to an actual fight.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by sublinear on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:45PM (#36712160)
> Weird thing to challenge a guy who's been training way hard for a few years now to an actual fight.

Musk has a substantial physical advantage over Zuckerberg that training can't overcome. If they were professional fighters they wouldn't even be in the same class.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by gloryjulio on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:13PM (#36712625)
What advantage? Do you mean fat?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by MSFT_Edging on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:57PM (#36712383)
Only so much a physical size can do when you basically sit around all day retweeting memes.

I've seen enough street fight videos to know a small guy with training can easily take down a big guy with hubris.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by throw47474777j on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:57PM (#36712382)
> that training can't overcome.

This can't be a serious claim.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by jfghi on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:58PM (#36712394)
And enough time to get some training in although cardio is slow to develop
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by ryanwaggoner on Thursday July 13, 2023 @12:57PM (#36712371)
Yes, if they were both professionals, but they aren’t, so training can absolutely overcome the differences between them. Or do you really think no one has ever beaten a less skilled fighter who weighed 35 pounds more?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by syntheweave on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:11PM (#36715274)
Once a fight goes to the ground, as it often does in MMA, it's much more technical in nature and someone who has put in a few years of effort into grappling techniques can trounce larger opponents by doing things that they simply aren't prepared to understand. The muscle memory and observation to understand what the situation is and how to move through it takes persistence over time to develop.

So my guess for this matchup is strongly weighted towards a more prepared Zuck being patient, finding openings for a takedown and then winning by submission. That said, it isn't a jiujitsu match, and there won't be gis, which shifts around the techniques available. Elon has a chance if his claim of having studied some martial arts as a teen is true, but he is also a big liar and equally likely to cancel at the last minute.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by mcv on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:41PM (#36716419)
I thought the fight has already been called off by Musk's mom. Is it still on?

Personally I don't see what chance Musk has. He looks terribly out of shape, Zuck is younger and much fitter. And apparently he's actively training, rather than possibly decades ago.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by JohnFen on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:56PM (#36728346)
> I thought the fight has already been called off by Musk's mom.

This never happened. His parents objected to the fight taking place, but the plans haven't changed any. They've booked the venue and everything.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by solumunus on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:12PM (#36715306)
You’ve obviously never been a competitive fighter. You can overcome large weight gaps against someone completely untrained, quite easily. I’m not saying Zuck can, but someone who’s talented and been training 5-10 years in BJJ, kick-boxing, MMA, etc can wreck people much bigger than them.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by pfannkuchen on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:29PM (#36716254)
Doesn’t age work against Musk pretty substantially?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by JohnFen on Friday July 14, 2023 @02:57PM (#36728369)
Not age, but his physical condition sure does. He's not exactly in good shape.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by pfannkuchen on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:22PM (#36729415)
Really? I don’t know much about fighting, but my impression was that being 52 is a big handicap when competing athletically against a 39 year old in general. Is this not accurate? Curious!
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by JohnFen on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:47PM (#36729709)
I don't know about fighting in particular[1], but in sports, there is a detrimental effect related to age. But it's relatively slight and can be overcome through training.

Generally, older people are more likely to be out of shape because they're more likely to be sedentary. And, of course, if they had a lifetime of bad habits like smoking or drinking, the cumulative effects can be significant.

There's another age-related sports thing -- people who are in professional sports tend to beat up their bodies quite a bit. They age out of their sport, not really directly because of the passing of time as much as because eventually the cumulative damage catches up to them.

[1] That said, I know a couple of people in their mid-60s who could kick the crap out of the majority of 20somethings.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by JohnFen on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:09PM (#36714485)
This whole fight thing is childish and ridiculous, and makes both of them look bad.

That's why I'm enjoying the whole idea.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by asddubs on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:41PM (#36714914)
IMHO, doing anything other than not giving a shit is just giving them undue attention and further canonizing these billionaires.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by JohnFen on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:45PM (#36714968)
That's an excellent point, and big picture, I don't actually care. But the siren call of schadenfreude is hard to resist sometimes.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by TheNewsIsHere on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:02AM (#36719347)
I spiritually agree with you. At the same time, it is amusing and reassuring to see just how dumb these fools truly are, so blatantly on public display.

Others will of course see a blueprint.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by jamal-kumar on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:01PM (#36766403)
Really? Even if everyone is just secretly wishing one of them gets hit in the head hard enough that they become the next Howard Hughes?
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by rewmie on Thursday July 13, 2023 @07:30PM (#36717500)
BBC said it:

> "Mr Musk has a history of making statements that are not serious or which fail to happen."

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-65981876

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by drewcoo on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:05AM (#36709344)
> what kid hasn't been improved by exposure to Mr. Rogers or Sesame Street?

Mister Rogers is dead. Sesame Street (CTW) is now a company that markets toys to kids, the same behavior that was alarming when the culprits were Transformers and G.I. Joe back in the 80s.

Today we also have a largely corporate-captured government. The trend is to privatize everything, allegedly because of "efficiency."

However rose-tinted your view of history is, this ain't then.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by NoZebra120vClip on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:28AM (#36709681)
> Mister Rogers is dead.

I think that's a matter of perpsective, considering that Mr. Rogers was a faithful Presbyterian minister.

Mr. Rogers was like the father I didn't have, and he changed me profoundly in my childhood by his direct and candid engagement with the camera, as if I really was a special person that he deeply cared about (and it was true.)

Mr. Rogers left a legacy that continues to change me and other people, especially those of us who grew up under his wing. There are lovely films made, and some of my favorite YouTubers love to sing his songs. I miss him, and he's still very much alive in our hearts, and in the miracle of television recordings.

https://youtu.be/YIV9E2bUS5M

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by zodester on Thursday July 13, 2023 @10:48AM (#36710060)
Reliable and fast push notifications from trusted accounts are the critical piece of infrastructure that needs a public option. Something less than the existing emergency alert systems that allows for individuals to subscribe to and is easier for local governments to onboard to.
Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by MetaWhirledPeas on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:34AM (#36710850)
> surely everyone can now agree Musk's personal, totally idiosyncratic treatment of the platform has rendered it completely useless for anything beyond pure vanity

We can? Functionally none of the controversial changes have been any inconvenience to me. It's been more of a self-fulfilling prophecy as far as I can tell: people declare each change to be the end of Twitter, and the resulting firestorm of tweets about Twitter's changes is actually what degrades the experience of using the product.

Re:B.C. government hit tweet limit amid wildfire evacuations by amrocha on Thursday July 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#36711076)
This article is literally about a government agency that couldn't communicate emergency fire evacuation because they were rate limited, due to the idiotic changes made by musk.

That can only mean Twitter can't be relied on for anything other than vanity.