News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by wunderland on Thursday July 06, 2023 @03:04AM (#36612322)
A perfect example with the recent changes at Twitter:

Most Twitter users barely tweet and don't care about followers - a "heavy user" tweets on average less than three times a week. So if someone is posting regularly enough to be willing to pay $8 a month for a blue tick, but has not built up a sizeable following organically, this is a very strong signal that the posts they are producing are no good. It is exactly that content that Twitter's new model relies on promoting - and those newly-minted blue ticks are quickly learning that there is no magic behind the checkmarks. New followers are not magically heading their way. The problem wasn't a biased liberal algorithm, it was that their tweets are no good. That means lots of blue ticks stop paying - but everyone else is forced to read the low-quality content that the remaining blue ticks produce. This is what is powering the enshittification of Twitter.

(From: https://www.theneweuropean.co.uk/the-slow-sad-death-of-twitt...)

[dead]
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by dcow on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:50AM (#36613078)
I think the strong response is to your opening statement. Cory is a thoughtful writer. The analysis may be inaccurate in your opinion, but that doesn't make it garbage.

I happen to agree with your actual take: biased unfair algos are the result of platforms being coerced (internally and/or externally) to ultimately serve some socio-political agenda, and thus their content enshittifies. No blue checkmarks needed.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by pjc50 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:55AM (#36613132)
I'm interested to know what your examples of content would be that is (a) good and (b) banned by "government-mandated censorship in large markets such as the EU".

> relatively more impacted than social networks that focus on art and have no political content

Funnily enough a lot of artists also want uncensored platforms so they can post NSFW art, but this is completely orthogonal to the political questions.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:43AM (#36613497)
> uncensored platforms so they can post NSFW art, but this is completely orthogonal to the political questions.

Its not orthogonal, the center of american politics is neo-puritanism. This is specifically the attitude of american elites, and they force it on the rest of the world. They deny access to banking and payment to anyone who does not comply.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by eimrine on Thursday July 06, 2023 @10:01AM (#36615899)
> I'm interested to know what your examples of content would be that is (a) good and (b) banned by "government-mandated censorship in large markets such as the EU".

War videos and pirated books.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:41AM (#36613476)
> government-mandated censorship in large markets such as the EU

Twitter censors nudity and pornography, and import American neo-puritanism to the rest of the world. No-one in EU mandates this.

But american brain is incapable of putting two and two together, they have it wired into their brain that opression cannot be private, only government.

If modern right-wingers existed in 1500, they would be defending the rirht of a feudal lord to sleep with your wife because he isnt a government and your signed up for it when you were born as a peasant.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by actionfromafar on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:15PM (#36624630)
Pretty much what really happened.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by beepbooptheory on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:17AM (#36613742)
This is a pretty good example of what is called kettle logic:

1. The analysis is wrong

2. The analysis is correct, but it is the algorithms fault.

3. The analysis is correct, but actually its really state censorship that is culprit here!

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by pyrale on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:49AM (#36615720)
> they're relatively more impacted than social networks that focus on art and have no political content.

Most art is political, you probably just can't take a hint.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by jterrys on Thursday July 06, 2023 @08:12PM (#36625184)
That's not really the art in question though.

There's a lot of 'art' on twitter which is, for a lack of a better term, porn.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by MSFT_Edging on Thursday July 06, 2023 @10:53AM (#36616916)
I've been seeing a lot more open Nazis on twitter with blue checks.

not "oh they sound mean" Nazis, but doing polls on how great Nazism would be to get rid of the "wokes", with nearly 10k votes.

Its crazy how the alternate to "biased liberal algorithm" is literally just fascism. And because Nazis don't argue on good faith, there's no beating them back. Moderation is basically the only thing that prevents any site from becoming a Nazi site.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by wunderland on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:46PM (#36619904)
Here’s an example of a Nazi poll that went mega-viral yesterday: https://twitter.com/rightwingcope/status/1676980329905528832

(screenshot because @christgnosis went private after outing themselves as full-Nazi)

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by MSFT_Edging on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:29PM (#36622462)
That was the poll in reference but I've also been seeing a ton more lately.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by fsckboy on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:46AM (#36613050)
> enough to be willing to pay $8 a month

you realize $8 a month is nothing to the majority of adults who would be in the "knowledge worker" category? a month? a couple of coffees is $10 and that's a day.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:36AM (#36613442)
Lets see, for $8 a month I can subscribe to a real Journal, like Which. They hire proffesional writers, fact check their content, buy actual consimer products and test them. And they are a charity to boot.

Or I can pay Elon for delivering tweets that he got some rando to write for free. The latest content is a right - wing conspiracy that nuclear weapons do not exist, and thay video footage of nuclear ezplosions is staged.

https://join.which.co.uk/join/subscribe

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:39AM (#36613896)
> Or I can pay Elon for delivering tweets that he got some rando to write for free

I thought the $8 for Elon was for publishers, not consumers?

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by HappySweeney on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:48AM (#36617833)
That is incorrect. Individuals pay $8 per month, government is free, everyone else is $1000 annually.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @03:08PM (#36621210)
For a Twitter Verified Organization, which you don't need as a consumer?
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by manuelabeledo on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:28AM (#36613371)
This is true only in a handful of places, for a handful of people.

$8 a month is pretty much the monthly cost of a cellphone plan across Europe. One could also get Spotify, or Netflix, at the same price point.

Comparatively speaking, paying $8 to have unlimited access to generally low quality content, at the same price point where other platforms offer actual good content, is a waste.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by chme on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:38AM (#36613893)
I don't get the $8/month. If you would pay for verification, that would be a one time payment. If the creators would be payed, then this might be fine, but they aren't. So it is only a fee to use the infrastructure.

You get a decent VPS for 8€/month, that has more computing power and bandwidth and storage that one person can use per month compared to what they would use on their systems for just streaming some videos and getting some messages.

Sure I don't calculate here the cost for development and maintenance, but this cost is mostly constant with numbers of active users.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by rsynnott on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:35AM (#36613432)
It's not just the cost; most people would, I think, be _embarrassed_ to be seen to be paying for attention.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by jlokier on Friday July 07, 2023 @09:04AM (#36631106)
> It's not just the cost; most people would, I think, be _embarrassed_ to be seen to be paying for attention.

I agree.

The Twitter tick had some cool when it was a mark of authenticity. Now it's a bit cringe.

The embarrassment factor might work better for Twitter if they offer an option similar to what LinkedIn does for paying users: Give the user the option to disable the blue tick on their account so other people don't know they are paying, while still having access to useful paid account features.

Like you I'd be more willing to pay a small amount for API access and useful features if I can do so quietly, without broadcasting the fact.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by rsynnott on Friday July 07, 2023 @10:48AM (#36632565)
I think you actually can hide it now. However, at least speaking for myself, I would be embarrassed to be paying to have my posts artificially boosted, even if this fact was hidden. There's a reason that pay-to-win, particularly in multiplayer games, has always been a slightly difficult sell.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Etheryte on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:59AM (#36613159)
In my opinion, the question is generally not whether something is a lot of money or not, but if it feels worthwhile relative to other similar things. For example, $8/mo is in the same ballpark as Spotify or Apple music and right now Twitter's blue tick doesn't come anywhere close to providing similar value.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by pjc50 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:56AM (#36613136)
Those aren't the good content people, though.

(Long ago I suggested that Twitter should have allowed people to contribute towards premium accounts for other people, a bit like Reddit Gold. Since a large part of the value derives not from your own posting but other people's.)

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by appleflaxen on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:36AM (#36613438)
You're right.

And the value of a blue check is less than that.

Wow.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by everdrive on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:00AM (#36613167)
$8 a month might feel like a waste if you don’t get anything out of it.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by criddell on Thursday July 06, 2023 @10:24AM (#36616296)
What I thought was stupid was removing the blue check from people who are worth far more than that per month to Twitter. I thinking about people like Stephen King and large news outlets.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by raverbashing on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:31AM (#36613399)
$8 is a very large amount of money for what's essentially an schmoozing certificate with very little actual benefits
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by csydas on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:10AM (#36613688)
I don't really get what you're saying here; it's not about the affordability (but let's put that aside for a second), it's that the entire payment model is based on a theory that is demonstrably disproven; the GP post had some rough stats from an article which suggests that Twitter either grossly overestimates how its users use the platform, or completely misunderstands how people want to use Twitter.

That the "heavy user" threshold is 3 posts a week is surprising to me, and seems like a bad threshold I'm sure that actual Twitter data is likely more accurate and shows different numbers, but it's not really about the usage I guess, it's about the promise of more followers and engagement. But demonstrably this is not the case, and many persons who did buy the Blue Check complained they didn't see the increase in activity it was advertised that the Blue Check would give. The signal behind what a Blue Check means has been quite noisy for a very long time, even before Musk's take over, and the decisions post-Musk on what a Blue Check really means/does is very confusing and unclear.

Why would I pay $8 a month to maybe get some followers by being promoted when I could just spend a few hundred USD once and just buy followers from some follower farm, which is arguably a better signal of "hey, this person is worth following?" as opposed to the Blue Check? It doesn't matter if it's just a "couple of coffees", why pay for something that arguably provides 0 benefit for me?

Twitter should not have tried to sell identify validation as a major marketable service; they already try to validate your identity even without it, and it doesn't seem to benefit anyone, not even Twitter.

Game companies figured out how to monetize useless things with cosmetics and such, and if Twitter wanted to monetize heavily, they should have just done that. Fancier reactions, more edits and stupid stuff for the changeable usernames, etc. The idea that they can somehow sell the user attention is a folly; yes, they gate and can control the feeds, but the users always have the option of just not following or even just not looking. It's a resource Twitter _never_ really had control over; they might as well have been selling ocean wranglers, offering that someone will beat the tide with whips for you if the ocean pisses you off for some reason; it's about the same effectualness, and equally useless service.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by nottorp on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:37AM (#36613887)
> a couple of coffees is $10 and that's a day.

Please cut that. Everyone wants 'a couple of coffees' and it adds up even for SV techbros.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by ehnto on Thursday July 06, 2023 @10:30AM (#36616419)
Different location, different economy and different currency, but yeah buying coffee out is crazy and I can't believe I was stupid enough to do it for so long.

I convinced myself I "needed the time out of the office" yeah cool, go for a walk you dork and make coffee in the kitchen like the person with bills that you are (is what I now tell myself)

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by nottorp on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:17PM (#36619410)
> buying coffee out is crazy

That too, but that wasn't the point :)

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by AndrewOMartin on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:46AM (#36629393)
I'm convinced Starbucks is paid off by SV to increase their prices so more things can be described as "just the price of a coffee".
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Hamuko on Thursday July 06, 2023 @08:19AM (#36614673)
I could definitely afford $8 but why would I give Elon $8 per month in order to tell people that I took a shit that was thiiiis big? The blue checkmark has questionable benefits at best, and the increased character limit for paychecks is ruining the essence of the service.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by mbork_pl on Thursday July 06, 2023 @08:27AM (#36614761)
> $8 a month is nothing to the majority of adults who would be in the "knowledge worker" category

This is a very US-centric take and almost insulting for people living in certain other areas of the world. In my country (central Europe, as is easy to guess), an experienced teacher (definitely a "knowledge worker" in my book) may earn about $10k per year. Not sure how much a beginner one gets, but surely less. $8 per month is a lot then.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by hnick on Friday July 07, 2023 @03:07AM (#36628248)
Not only that, the $8 might not be much, but what you get isn't either.

If everyone felt entitled to charge $8 for not much in return that can add up and mean real money even to US-centric people, once they're paying it to 50 different services every month that deliver (and ask) for "nothing".

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by yomlica8 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @10:09AM (#36616054)
Maybe, but the time and effort it takes to wade through the dark patterns when you want to cancel are expensive for everyone.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by rsynnott on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:33AM (#36613418)
I'm still amazed they went with the $8-for-attention model. Everyone _already knows_ this doesn't work well; the dating site industry has been trying to make it work for literally decades.

It's also kind of a Pandora's box; even if they removed the attention boost, the taint is already there, and people will be suspicious of bluetick replies forever.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by cubefox on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:46AM (#36613527)
They get also other features like longer tweets and editing.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by rsynnott on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:34AM (#36613860)
Sure, and if they'd kept it to that, maybe it could have been a reasonable niche feature, though it would always be niche. As it is, I think it likely has negative value to most people.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by SamoyedFurFluff on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:53AM (#36613585)
Far, far more than that, now. The ability to organize your own feed via Tweetdeck is also being limited to blue checks, as well as security options like MFA.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by drzaiusx11 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:23AM (#36614209)
The fact that a basic security feature is behind a paywall boggles the mind.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Dalewyn on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:46AM (#36614398)
It's only for SMS 2FA, which was phased out because of valid security concerns.

Other forms of 2FA are still available to everyone.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by stirfish on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:40AM (#36614333)
>as well as security options like MFA.

Incredible. I had to see it for myself.

https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/two-factor...

Maybe that's only for text messages, and you can still use totp?

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by lost_tourist on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:26PM (#36625807)
You can still use stuff like authy/google authenticator so it's not as bad as the complainers say.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by jeffbee on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:12AM (#36615213)
Those are not benefits. Giving the blue checks the opportunity for a longer, even colder take that readers must click through to read is doing them no favors.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by Chris2048 on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:41AM (#36613904)
But dating is a totally different context; and Bumble (dating/bff) seems to be doing OK at the moment for charging more than $8.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by FullstakBlogger on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:47AM (#36614401)
The smart thing to do isn't to remove it; They should charge for adversarial features.

Pay your fee, you get not only an attention boost, but the ability to un-boost blues. If the net result is 0, the Nash Equilibrium is that everybody pays.

Look how many people "#BlockTheBlue" on twitter right now. Just charge them to make it easy. The real value in someone who's willing to pay to be seen isn't in their 8$ subscription, it's in the 100 other people they incentivize to pay you to shut them up.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by rsynnott on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:53AM (#36614456)
I mean, if they want to turn Twitter into SomethingAwful, that would be a good route.

Honestly at this point it's in such a bad state that it would be worth considering; a gamified war might be better than just every high-traffic tweet having hundreds of nonsense bluetick comments before you get to the real comments. It'd at least be more interesting; the bluetick content is usually just very dull, and tends to bring to mind the writing style of those wannabe-influencer posts you see on LinkedIn. (I think a lot of people paying for it are doing so because they want to be... a Twitter influencer? Are there even Twitter influencers, beyond dril?)

Probably not a _great_ way to build a sustainable business, though.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by saghm on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:09AM (#36617196)
> I mean, if they want to turn Twitter into SomethingAwful, that would be a good route.

I can't say I know that this is their goal right now, but it's impossible for me to distinguish their actions from those of someone with that goal.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by TheRealDunkirk on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:42PM (#36620804)
Give me the ability to set sliders to filter accounts and replies based on metrics like the number of their followers vs the number of people who have blocked them, and the number of their posts vs the number of their upvotes -- things that help me find the good stuff, and make it possible for me to access the "wisdom of the crowd" -- and I'd pay $20/mo.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by GoldsmithPlant on Friday July 07, 2023 @04:55AM (#36629062)
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:34AM (#36614289)
Actually it is the algo. Twitter often doesn't bother showing the tweets of NPCs (with fewer than a few thousand followers) no matter how good they are.

But I think you have to be quite naive to believe that a New Blue Tick™ will game that.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by PM_me_your_math on Thursday July 06, 2023 @09:29AM (#36615453)
Ah yes, because a steady stream of Yoel Roth approved leftist propaganda was good content.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Platform Capitalism and the Curse of “Ensh... by winternett on Friday July 07, 2023 @01:46AM (#36627688)
People tweeting are not usually paid to post. Discussing the quality of posts as if entertaining people with unpaid labor is a need is the fatal flaw of social media sites. They keep pushing the narrative that posters should work for attention and struggle when winning in the current mold is albeit impossible without lots of funding or the specific attributes that make people overlook marginal skill and talents.

The truth of the matter is these platforms always invent wacky schemes to sedate people into a false narrative that they can go viral, or even that they can be recognized for their talent or wisdom, but undercover the platform does nothing to promote individuals, and often does a lot to DEMOTE individual posters on them.

If one truly understands how things work, these platforms often have millions of people as a potential audience for content. They only show posts to an ever shrinking fraction of 1 percent of that multi-million user audience initially (in between all the paid ads), often they barely do that and give users less than 300 views by an audience they know is not a good demographic fit for their post (e.g showing a post about penguin migration to a rapper promoting his music in LA, rather than showing the content to a known animal scientist who would be much more likely to click on "like") .

As a result of frustration with low views and limited validation/affirmation of their work and time, many users pay for ad boosting, which still now usually does not work in their favor, because the audience is never properly aligned with the content for viewing there again. Even an audience of 20k people on a platform of millions is measley. The platform has no interest in making users more popular, because they will log in less, spend less on ads, and possibly relocate their activities to another platform if they grew in popularity.

If you take an honest look at the type of content that trends, it's often not funny, not creative, not the best, but now it's there because it had healthy funding for ads behind it, to get it to the right audience that liked it (if it's not boosted by nefarious -bots= etc...).

The truth is, that if each content poster was exposed/promoted to a much wider audience, they'd find their niche, SIMILAR to how original Twitter was, this is why no one is getting followers any more,because the audiences who can view posts have become too small out of shear manipulation for ad profit. It's not about post quality, that's simply a lie that coddles wealthy and celebrity posters and maintains the status quo of limiting upward mobility on social media sites.

Paying for visibility on a social media service is far too manipulative, there should be a simple flat fee for access in my opinion because paying for visibility creates an inherent inequality. Deceptively promoting a service as free with tiers also deceives people into signing up for a service that is deceptively handicapped/neutered until they figure out they need to pay monthly for only slightly a less handicapped tier (still far below wealthy individuals and celebrities on each platform).

It's a self defeating cycle that only social platforms profit from. It would be better if content creators truly recognized that and saw through the others with tons of cash and the sponsored (undercover social media company employees) all faking their success to make these casino companies look legit.