News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by belval on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:06AM (#36340713)
> The attempt by auto manufacturers to cut out the dealer would only result in higher prices and less customer service to the public,” he said. “The new car dealer is the customer’s advocate when it comes to warranty work and service on a manufacturer’s product, and this bill will protect that

So this is the reason given in the article, but what are good reasons, if any, to prevent direct-to-customer sales? I haven't bought a new car yet, but seems like every anecdotal story I get of people buying cars is always that their dealership tried to push every useless feature or additional warranty that they could.

Same goes for maintenance, I have had many more terrible experiences with dealerships than local garages as the former tends to have a more captive customer base whereas the local garage is incentivized to actually keep you satisfied or you'll just go elsewhere.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by CydeWeys on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:16AM (#36340858)
Use just a little bit more cynicism and the actual reasoning becomes clear.

Car dealership owners are one of the most reliable Republican constituencies. They make outrageous amounts of money through government-mandated rent-seeking and donate to Republican candidates 6-to-1. What we see here is nothing more than a quid-pro-quo, a handout to the dealership owners in exchange for their loyal monetary support over the years.

So yes, it's not about protecting the consumer. Dealerships are of course actually terrible, as everyone knows. This is about protecting the dealership owners.

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2023/05/rich-republicans...

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ack210 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:31AM (#36341086)
I certainly don't mean to be defending either party, but the bill received bi-partisan support. Only 2 reps voted against it in the house, and it received unanimous support in the senate (which includes 12 democrats).

https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2023/637/?Tab=VoteHist...

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by colpabar on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#36342217)
A lot of people pretend this isn't the case, but democrats also receive political donations from rich people and then pass legislation that is favorable to those rich people. But the underlying cynicism is correct. It's a racket.

required disclaimer: i don't like republicans either

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ahahahahah on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:28PM (#36345316)
The 6-1 ratio means that democrats are also getting a lot of money from dealership owners. Then, given that both the house and senate there are 60+% republican and all the republicans will vote for it, anyone voted against it is just symbolic and then is that symbol worth upsetting their own backers?

I think a better way of understanding how the two parties feel about regulation of specific industries is to look into how different states regulate those different industries. This doesn't work well for very regional industries (think coal or I guess logging, for example), but car dealerships are everywhere.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by moritonal on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:08AM (#36340730)
I'm trying to understand it the same. How is this different to them saying "you have to buy airline tickets via a travel-agent?", or "you cannot buy from Intel, only eBuyer?".
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by jackmott42 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:12AM (#36340785)
These dealer protection laws made sense decades ago, they no longer make sense, but dealers bribe our politicians to protect them. That is all it is.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by voisin on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:19AM (#36340901)
How did they make sense decades ago? What changed?
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by jackmott42 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:27AM (#36341016)
There used to be a very few number of car companies who held a lot of power over dealerships and used to abuse that power, which led to laws protecting dealers in ways that at least arguably made sense at the time, but don't anymore.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by j16sdiz on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:04AM (#36341536)
Do we now have lots of new car company? ( i don't think so )

Does car company now have less power? ( with subscription and OTA updates , I think they have more power than ever)

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ceejayoz on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:25AM (#36341885)
> Do we now have lots of new car company? ( i don't think so )

Yes, we do. The "Big Three" of Ford, GM, and Chrysler now face significant competition in the US from Japanese, German, Korean, etc. carmakers.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by foogazi on Thursday June 15, 2023 @04:38PM (#36346202)
Euro / Asian auto companies exist now

All new electric car companies too

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by no_wizard on Thursday June 15, 2023 @05:19PM (#36346638)
I think if we removed the dealership (sometimes called "franchise") laws that prevent manufacturers from selling directly to consumers, we could see more competition not just between existing players but also lowers the barrier for new entrants into the market.

Tesla and Rivian, for example, wouldn't even be able to exist without this, the cost of setting up new dealerships is enormous otherwise.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by asveikau on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:23PM (#36342853)
I'm not an expert in this topic, but coming naively to it, it strikes me that direct to consumer retail of all types was harder before the internet, which required more middle men to distribute goods.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:29PM (#36342963)
My understanding of the history of this system is that auto manufacturers wanted a way to dump their inventory reliably and so independent dealerships came into being. Then the dealership owners got rich and influential enough to essentially get themselves enshrined in state law in multiple states. But someone else can fill me in if that’s incomplete or not quite correct.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by red-iron-pine on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:20AM (#36340917)
It's not, the GOP is facing demographic declines and is trying to jam as much pro-business legislation through before the Boomers die and the Overton Window shifts
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by wesapien on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:17AM (#36340866)
It's complete bullshit. I despise both car dealerships and realtors. They exist to service themselves.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by no_wizard on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:21AM (#36340927)
I've had pretty universally bad experiences with dealerships, especially ironic in relation to what DeSantis has said here because I distinctly remember advocating myself that something should be covered under the manufacturers warranty, and the dealership said it wouldn't be, and I was very certain it would be, and I had to call the manufacturer (Kia) to get the dealership to play ball. They didn't want to go the warranty route because it turns out, it paid less for the repair.

Realtors on the other hand, I've had some good interactions there, the last 2 I used saved me money and got me more for my dollars, at least.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by axus on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:24AM (#36340976)
I wouldn't say complete BS, they do provide services. The problem is the monopoly practices which go unrestrained by the government.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by wesapien on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:13PM (#36342696)
They do but in this day and age the information asymmetry is not that huge or isn't there anymore (depending on the customer). They put up a good face to hook you in. My experience is that they become less enthusiastic (to say the least) once they know that their "sales" force powers will not work on you.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:07PM (#36345092)
Yeah, having someone forward you MLS listings does not exactly justify a five-figure payment.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by apple4ever on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:47AM (#36351953)
No but having one who knows the law, all the little things to look for, and fights for you even while you are signing paperwork is worth it. (Our realtor was awesome and totally worth the money, at least as a first time buyer).
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Friday June 16, 2023 @09:51AM (#36356580)
Your realtor doesn't fully "know the law" and you can get in trouble assuming they do.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by randomdata on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:57AM (#36341405)
At least Realtors only become involved when you want them to be involved. There is no regulation that requires real estate transactions be conducted through a Realtor.

Around here, a lot of properties get listed and sold by the local law office. Granted, they don't put in the same kind of marketing effort that Realtors generally do, but when the market is hot buyers will search high and low to find your property for sale anyway.

Unless the market is weak and one needs someone working 24/7 to find a buyer, going straight to a lawyer to sell a property/buy a property is a no-brainer. You are going to need one anyway.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by jwestbury on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:46AM (#36342186)
Realtors provide a valuable service. We bought in a particularly desirable region in 2021. We put in eight offers before getting one accepted. Our realtor knew the necessary legal forms and requirements, and wrote each offer for us. They also had a background in flipping houses, and were able to give us advice on renovations, and which houses were just bad choices during tours, pointing out flaws we might not have noticed, and telling us when problems were probably easier to fix than we might expect.

Car dealerships are mostly useless. If you've done even cursory research, you probably know more about the car you're buying than the salesperson. Their only purpose is to extract money from you.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:30PM (#36342978)
Realtors provide a valuable service, I’ll agree, but I don’t think one in line with the price you’re paying, which is propped up by their cartel system.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 15, 2023 @01:09PM (#36343597)
They probably got paid ~$50,000 for the service they provided for you. The service may have been valuable, but do you think it was $50,000 valuable? Do you think it should be very difficult to avoid paying that $50,000 if somebody doesn't want the service they provide?
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by hn8305823 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:17AM (#36340872)
They're called "stealerships" for a reason.

Actually several reasons and overpriced, excessive, or unnecessary maintenance is one of them

The reason dealerships are surprisingly powerful politically is they are usually family owned and operated so they have much wider discretion over political donations and/or bribes.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:32PM (#36343006)
I mean a dealership is often the biggest business in town. They’re big cheeses locally. And provincial elites often have a lot of resentment for national ones, which explains a lot about recurrent political conflicts.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by jmclnx on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:10AM (#36340757)
Also with the right-to-repair fights, the automakers want to kill all the independent Auto Repair and Auto Parts Shops.

We really need to get right-to-repair laws passed and enabled.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by no_wizard on Thursday June 15, 2023 @05:24PM (#36346698)
Separate issue though. The dealerships don't help here, they typically only use OEM parts anyway
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by timtom39 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:25AM (#36340991)
Automobile dealers are separate business entities with different motivations from the manufactures. In particular, they have historically demanded access to training, access to parts, ability to negotiate price, trade ins, etc.

IMO danger of them disappearing is what we see with tech and luxury brands who go through a ton of effort to enforce their MAP and are not particularly motivated to make things repairable.

That being said, they are middlemen and there is defiantly a balance.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by merpnderp on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:09AM (#36340745)
Last time I bought a car, I called around until I found a good deal then I went there and talked to them to get the actual number. Then I called the other dealers I'd spoken with and asked if they could beat that deal. I spent 8 hours going back and forth, but got my car for 20% off MSRP. I couldn't have done that if I'd been dealing directly with Ford.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by TheAceOfHearts on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:28AM (#36341036)
Good for you? What if we had a free market approach where both options are available and we can see what happens? How is more competition not a good thing?
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by double0jimb0 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:29AM (#36341059)
You ended up paying the dealerships cost, which is probably same you would have paid if dealership was never in the picture.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#36343026)
Once in a while dealerships are motivated to dump stock at a loss. Not a great argument for the system but who’s to say the OP didn’t get a good deal.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by foogazi on Thursday June 15, 2023 @04:44PM (#36346282)
You got a better price than the other dealers offered but not less than what it cost that dealer
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:09AM (#36340746)
Dealership owners are a reliable Republican constituency. This kind of local bigwig was one of the most reliable Trump supporters and I'd guess the same is true for DeSantis. I mean you decide if that's a "good" reason but it is the real one.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by tclancy on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:15AM (#36340844)
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:30PM (#36345333)
Perhaps one of the wilder things I learned in this article is how many laws make it illegal for an automaker to set transparent prices. State mandated Three-Card Monte.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by calvinmorrison on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:16AM (#36340855)
> So this is the reason given in the article, but what are good reasons, if any, to prevent direct-to-customer sales?

because cars require service, someone needs to do that service, be trained and have master techs on that service. How do you handle lemon laws without dealerships?

Just look at the nightmare tesla has been for owners with years of bad repairs, delays, etc.

OEMs provide a bunch of stuff that is adhoc to making new crs like long life spans for part productions, having dealerships service recalls, and so on. there's a lot of non-new-sale-stuff that is done

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by randomdata on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:21AM (#36340928)
That provides an explanation for why the consumer might choose to buy from a dealership, but not a reason for why they must. In fact, said bill still allows Tesla to sell direct-to-consumer, so the lawmakers couldn't even find a reason to not let consumers make a choice in the general case, only if buying from a set list of manufacturers.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by calvinmorrison on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:33AM (#36341111)
> That provides an explanation for why the consumer might choose to buy from a dealership, but not a reason for why they must.

The same could be said of basically anything. Consumers could choose to do anything. Suppliers anything. Now we are anarchists. yay!

But we don't we live in a heavily regulated society, and what seems to work fairly well is having a dealership system. Now we could just remove the word dealership and require OEMs to provide everything that the dealership does, and I would be fine with that, but IMO this is a shorthand for that.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by randomdata on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#36341557)
The same is said about everything, although we recognize that the concentration of capital enabled by giving certain actors in the economy an unequal advantage is more efficient for the economy as a whole than it is for everyone to be equal.

But dealerships run contrary to that. They see distribution of capital away from the OEMs in an equalizing way. This is recognized and understood by lawmakers, which is why the Teslas of the world are still free to do as they please. The question is really: What's special about GM, Ford, etc.?

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:07PM (#36345099)
There’s no Tesla dealer to get angry and demand his governor take action against them.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by antisthenes on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#36342684)
> But we don't we live in a heavily regulated society, and what seems to work fairly well is having a dealership system.

This is a simple just world fallacy. Most of the times the reason something exists is that it's the best available alternative, but there are definitely times when a systems exists because it is entrenched regulatory capture and rent-seeking, e.g. dealerships and healthcare insurance.

You have to critically evaluate complex systems on a case-by-case basis and see where the money flows to make a determination whether it's good for society as a whole.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by jonhohle on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:28AM (#36341048)
And yet nearly everything else you buy doesn’t require a dealer. Even in the rare opportunity of buying a new construction house you can buy from the developer (though with the possibility of being forced through a particular title agency).

Any time I need to go through a dealer for a product (unique appliances or equipment), I know I’m about to pay more than I should.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ceejayoz on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:21AM (#36340919)
> because cars require service, someone needs to do that service, be trained and have master techs on that service.

My cars have had no trouble getting service at independent mechanics.

> How do you handle lemon laws without dealerships?

The same way we handle them with dealerships? The organization that sold you the car is responsible for the fixes, or refunding the vehicle if it can't be fixed.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by calvinmorrison on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:28AM (#36341046)
> My cars have had no trouble getting service at independent mechanics.

Have you ever worked at an indy? We rely heavily on dealerships for anything from borrowing specialty tooling, local parts departments, knowledge and advise etc.

> The organization that sold you the car is responsible for the fixes, or refunding the vehicle if it can't be fixed.

Totally.

I think it's six of one half a dozen of the other. Car manufacturers generally coalesce around the efficiency of having new sales, parts departments, repair departments all in one building in many localities spread all over the place.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ceejayoz on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:46AM (#36341255)
> We rely heavily on dealerships for anything from borrowing specialty tooling, local parts departments, knowledge and advise etc.

What makes it impossible for the manufacturer to provide such things?

If Ford chose to do away with dealerships, they couldn't provide regional parts and training facilities? (Hell, they'd probably already need to buy out a dealership or two for every major city or region already, anyways.)

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by calvinmorrison on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:55AM (#36341381)
Yes and then they'll need a place to store new cars, on lots, and people, to facilitate the handover of keys and handle loans and so forth. back to square one
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by ceejayoz on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:01AM (#36341477)
That was always the case; Tesla has showroom and service facilities all over the place, and handles financing. That's the model the big traditional manufacturers want to move towards.

It's not back to square one; it removes a middleman layer, one that most folks hate dealing with. You buy a car at a set price that's the same for everyone from a salaried employee, not from an intermediary who'll make up a price and pocket a commission off screwing you if you're not good at haggling.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:37PM (#36343087)
> I think it's six of one half a dozen of the other. Car manufacturers generally coalesce around the efficiency of having new sales, parts departments, repair departments all in one building in many localities spread all over the place.

Why exactly must this be an independent business motivated to collect rents on top of what the manufacturer is already making? Hard to see how that could do anything but drive prices up to keep more fingers in the pie.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by nunez on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#36342500)
Ah yes, having Tesla service come to my house and do repairs as needed in my garage while I'm working is a complete horror show.

It's absolute nightmarish when they don't try to upsell me or berate me for not knowing how cars work, like a RAM service center did to me in the past.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by emodendroket on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:34PM (#36343039)
There are countless independent mechanics who service most cars. Teslas have other issues that make them difficult to service. I think this argument is a red herring.
Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by Tangurena2 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @10:49AM (#36341294)
Historically, car manufacturers screwed dealerships. One of the ways was selling franchises then deciding that they could make more money selling directly to customers. Or that they needed some extra cash, so selling so many franchises that none of the dealerships could sell enough to break even.

Many of the laws about warranties were due to poor behavior of manufacturers. In the US, repair parts need to be available for at least 10 years for cars. In the past, the manufacturer could just decide that they didn't want to sell repair parts - just buy a new car.

The Great Depression reduced the number of car manufacturers by about 95%. Which brings me to a more important point. A number of laws were passed to prevent the Great Depression from happening again. Repealing several of them gave us the 2008 financial crisis. Making exceptions to the Securities Acts of the 1930s lets us all relearn the history of why those laws were passed in the first place with all the crypto scams. These laws exist for a very good reason and repealing them is only good for con artists and crooks. The rest of us get screwed.

Modern car dealerships in America are the embodiment of modern rent-seeking. Every department treats every other department as the enemy. Each department that touches an item (spare part, used car, tires, floormats, whatever) has to raise the price 30% to cover overhead and the need to be a profit center. Sears went through this exact same behavior as it crashed and burned. Jack Walsh used the same behaviors to make General Electric the darling of Wall Street.

> tried to push every useless feature or additional warranty that they could.

Every sales rep that works on commission works this way. Salaried sales reps don't. Any commissioned sales rep that refuses to work this way ends up quitting very very quickly.

Disclaimer: I used to work for General Motors which used to be the largest car manufacturer and the very reason that many of the dealership & warranty laws were passed in the first place.

Re:Gov. DeSantis signs bill banning most direct-to-consumer ... by tmaly on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:54AM (#36342320)
I am hoping if he wins the nomination, he will select a car salesman as his VP.