The same could be said of basically anything. Consumers could choose to do anything. Suppliers anything. Now we are anarchists. yay!
But we don't we live in a heavily regulated society, and what seems to work fairly well is having a dealership system. Now we could just remove the word dealership and require OEMs to provide everything that the dealership does, and I would be fine with that, but IMO this is a shorthand for that.
But dealerships run contrary to that. They see distribution of capital away from the OEMs in an equalizing way. This is recognized and understood by lawmakers, which is why the Teslas of the world are still free to do as they please. The question is really: What's special about GM, Ford, etc.?
This is a simple just world fallacy. Most of the times the reason something exists is that it's the best available alternative, but there are definitely times when a systems exists because it is entrenched regulatory capture and rent-seeking, e.g. dealerships and healthcare insurance.
You have to critically evaluate complex systems on a case-by-case basis and see where the money flows to make a determination whether it's good for society as a whole.
Any time I need to go through a dealer for a product (unique appliances or equipment), I know I’m about to pay more than I should.
My cars have had no trouble getting service at independent mechanics.
> How do you handle lemon laws without dealerships?
The same way we handle them with dealerships? The organization that sold you the car is responsible for the fixes, or refunding the vehicle if it can't be fixed.
Have you ever worked at an indy? We rely heavily on dealerships for anything from borrowing specialty tooling, local parts departments, knowledge and advise etc.
> The organization that sold you the car is responsible for the fixes, or refunding the vehicle if it can't be fixed.
Totally.
I think it's six of one half a dozen of the other. Car manufacturers generally coalesce around the efficiency of having new sales, parts departments, repair departments all in one building in many localities spread all over the place.
What makes it impossible for the manufacturer to provide such things?
If Ford chose to do away with dealerships, they couldn't provide regional parts and training facilities? (Hell, they'd probably already need to buy out a dealership or two for every major city or region already, anyways.)
It's not back to square one; it removes a middleman layer, one that most folks hate dealing with. You buy a car at a set price that's the same for everyone from a salaried employee, not from an intermediary who'll make up a price and pocket a commission off screwing you if you're not good at haggling.
Why exactly must this be an independent business motivated to collect rents on top of what the manufacturer is already making? Hard to see how that could do anything but drive prices up to keep more fingers in the pie.
It's absolute nightmarish when they don't try to upsell me or berate me for not knowing how cars work, like a RAM service center did to me in the past.
because cars require service, someone needs to do that service, be trained and have master techs on that service. How do you handle lemon laws without dealerships?
Just look at the nightmare tesla has been for owners with years of bad repairs, delays, etc.
OEMs provide a bunch of stuff that is adhoc to making new crs like long life spans for part productions, having dealerships service recalls, and so on. there's a lot of non-new-sale-stuff that is done