News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Quit Cars by keiferski on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:44AM (#35989621)
It’s odd to me that these anti-car polemics never talk about why Americans don’t want to ride public transit, while people in most other countries have zero issues adopting it wholesale. Instead they just make it into a simplistic, moralistic crusade about how the suburban car owners are evil people, told from the perspective of a righteous city-dweller.

Here’s a better theory: because American public transit is, when compared with the alternatives, not safe, not clean, and not convenient. Take LA, probably the most car-dependent big city in America. Riding the bus or subway in LA is not an enjoyable experience. Nor is it enjoyable to walk around the areas where the stops are. If I were trying to get more people to use public transit, I’d start by making the stations and buses/subways beautiful, clean, safe places that are just nice urban places to hang out in. There’s no need to make it a moral crusade; just offer a better product and more people will use it.

Re:How to Quit Cars by logifail on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:03PM (#35989960)
> I’d start by making the stations and buses/subways beautiful, clean, safe places that are just nice urban places to be in

I spent yesterday travelling around Greater London using only public transport, coupled with quite a lot of (fairly brisk) walking ... my phone said my day involved 20591 steps and 98 heart points.

When you don't have access to a car, you have to think quite differently about mundane things like going to a supermarket.

"Where is the closest supermarket to my current location" for the car user becomes "where is any supermarket which is close to a public transport stop I can readily reach from my current location" which I find isn't handled nearly as well by all our favourite mapping services. Things like fares and fare zones become of interest, not just raw distances and traffic on routes.

> There’s no need to make it a moral crusade [..]

Unfortunately there seems to be no broad agreement on exactly how you make places "beautiful, clean [and] safe" if they aren't.

Re:How to Quit Cars by keiferski on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:23PM (#35990305)
There is plenty of broad agreement, you just have to look at Japan, or China, or Singapore, or Turkey, Poland, or Switzerland, or Korea, or another dozen countries around the world that have clean, safe, and (sufficiently) beautiful public transport systems. The bar is really not that high.
Re:How to Quit Cars by logifail on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:42PM (#35990568)
> There is plenty of broad agreement, you just have to look at Japan, or China, or Singapore, or Turkey, Poland, or Switzerland, or Korea, or another dozen countries around the world that have clean, safe, and (sufficiently) beautiful public transport systems. The bar is really not that high.

So all those cities/countries where public transport is not clean and safe have to just copy - for instance - Singapore or China?

Q: What's stopping them?

That's what I mean about lack of broad agreement.

Re:How to Quit Cars by lozenge on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:49AM (#36000037)
Hardly anybody needs to get public transport for a supermarket in London, they are within 15 minutes walk.
Re:How to Quit Cars by judge2020 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:09PM (#35990066)
While true, the point of a moral crusade is that city planners generally cannot go against their constituents' wishes, so if they are all house and car people, nothing will be done to favor denser housing or a better light rail experience. Changing the minds of people and getting them involved will create a feedback loop of people complaining to their city, attending meetings, and pushing for projects that solve these things. It can't happen in the shadows because the money to do these projects won't get allocated without support.
Re:How to Quit Cars by karmelapple on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:49PM (#35993155)
Those residents are basically pulling up the ladder behind them, and it's depressing to see.

Appealing to their moral side seems... perhaps necessary, because it seems a vocal minority simply do not want multi-family housing in their neighborhood at all. Look at the pushback by NIMBYs at city meetings across the US when anything like somewhat dense housing is proposed: right off the bat, I have literally never heard of any community collectively saying, "this sounds reasonable." I would be happy to be proven wrong.

Instead, it's pushback after pushback, claiming everything from character of the neighborhood to shadows from a tall building (even if the building is only 5 stories high, and most buildings in the neighborhood are 3 stories tall).

There's also conspicuously rare talk from those NIMBYs claiming what they do want. Instead, at the start of a project, it's always vague, "well not THAT many units!" or "well the traffic will get SO much worse!"

I've never seen specifics like, "We need 30 units or less in this proposal because of reason X and Y." Instead, it's just negotiation trying to get it as low as possible. Basically, trying to pull up the ladder as much as possible to minimize people moving to the area to folks who can afford a fairly expensive single family home.

Any single family home is fairly expensive now it seems these days, across the USA, relatively to the area it's in.

It's depressing, and I'm not sure how to get people to change those attitudes.

One thought: have people attend these meetings who are not yet residents of the neighborhoods, but would consider it if they could move into one of these developments. Of course, NIMBYs would likely be outraged that folks from outside of their neighborhood are levying their opinion... even though the NIMBYs themselves are not vocalizing considering the opinions of people who want to move to the area.

Re:How to Quit Cars by MarkSweep on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:01PM (#35989930)
I’ve been trying to commute by train in the Bay Area and I’m probably going to give up based on this.

The VTA train smells of pot and the CalTrain often smells of sewage. Periodically there are crazy people yelling on the VTA and regularly there are people having could-have-been-an-email loud conferences calls on CalTrain.

I really like trains and dislike car dependent cities. But it’s hard for me to walk-the-talk when it’s so unpleasant so consistently.

Re:How to Quit Cars by inferiorhuman on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:16PM (#35994931)
I used to take Caltrain fairly regularly and never once smelled sewage. The drunken baseball fans were a problem though.
Re:How to Quit Cars by MarkSweep on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:22PM (#35996235)
Sewage is a bit strong of a word for it, but sometimes the cars with a bathroom smell a bit ripe.
Re:How to Quit Cars by Jayschwa on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#35989839)
I agree. At its best, public transit can be a better experience than driving. But the average experience is often worse than driving.
Re:How to Quit Cars by falcolas on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:46PM (#35990659)
And worse includes slower by 2x or more than driving, even with all the BS driving includes like traffic jams and finding parking.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:37PM (#35994447)
That's usually the final straw people will put up with a decent amount but once they realize how much time they're spending - bam.

And part of the problem is that the only real way to get competitive fair box recovery (which shouldn't really be a goal, imo) is to pack the vehicles to standing-room only, which makes it hard to read a book or do something else.

Re:How to Quit Cars by slondr on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:46PM (#35995289)
This is a false dichotomy, no?

Driving somewhere for 30 minutes means you waste 30 minutes of your life in transport.

Taking a train somewhere for 50 minutes means you can do something else for 50 minutes. Read a book, browse the internet, write a poem, whatever.

Re:How to Quit Cars by goatlover on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:37PM (#35995854)
On occasion that sounds nice. But usually I'd rather get somewhere faster than spending a lot more time in transit. And you can listen to music and podcasts while driving.
Re:How to Quit Cars by alwayslikethis on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:06AM (#35997607)
Only when you feel safe. I use public transport in Asia and do the listed things, but I wouldn't do that in NYC because I might get pickpocketed, for instance.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bertil on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:18PM (#35994954)
That’s because driving throws out all the externalities outside the window: pollution, noise, violence, the cost of roads, cutting cities with hostile canyons…

Saying driving is better is like saying littering is more convenient than picking up your trash.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Dig1t on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:55AM (#35989820)
Absolutely agree, as someone who has taken public transit in Southern California, it's the absolute worst. It's disgusting, terrifying, and also inconvenient.

Seeing tons of videos online of interactions on the New York subway system, I can say that I have no interest in that form of transportation. The recent drama about Penny/Neely is just one of many such interactions you can find on the subway. I can link dozens of videos of insane, disturbing interactions that take place on the NY subway to which I would never subject my family.

If we somehow create subways that are as clean, safe, and convenient as those in Japan I would probably consider using it, but until then I will definitely be pro-car.

Re:How to Quit Cars by chem83 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:24PM (#35997361)
What you're saying is, frankly, very naive. If you think critically, you must realize the cognitive bias here. There's something like 2 million people riding the MTA every day and they statistically hardly ever have problems as extreme as the Penny/Neely situation. If you go on YouTube or Reddit, you'll see thousands of road rage incidents, and that's not stopping you from being pro-car. It's not acceptable that families have to be on alert when riding the subway and gov't should definitely work to improve the situation, but the same can be said about American roads. It would be amazing if the MTA could be as efficient/on time as the Tokyo system, or as pretty as the Stockholm stations, but the same is true for many aspects of public infrastructure across the US.
Re:How to Quit Cars by zzzeek on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:49PM (#35997530)
Yes I rode the NYC subway for 20 years. When you are young and edgy, you can deal with it, even though I found it regularly traumatizing at that time as well (delays, trains stuck in tunnels, 100 degree subway platforms, crushing crowds, intense inconvenience if you have to carry anything beyond a single bag).

The ultimate misery, when trains fell behind and youd spend an hour or more on a completely packed, sweltering platform watching train after train fully stuffed shoulder to shoulder pass through not stopping since each train is full, until one comes where you yourself have to shove yourself and your bags into the doorway and hope the doors can close so you can just get home. Never again. I suspect anti car people just don't see these things as that big of a deal. They're young. It's all exciting to them, I guess. I didn't have a car at all back then either, the city / commuter life seemed perfect to me for many years until I began to realize I hated these things.

Forget about the crime, mental illness, and homeless issues, just being shoved among "regular" people every day, all averting gazes and attempting to cope with dense crowding among people you don't know, by the time I was older I had become a strict remote worker, and when I had a kid we were out of there at last.

I have an EV now and getting to drive is like the best part of my day. I live very far from dense cities. A lot of people genuinely like to live this way and the posts here talking about the "car industrial complex" somehow coercing us all into some way we wouldn't otherwise prefer should consider that a lot of people really don't like crowds.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:08AM (#35997622)
It's exactly this. When I was young I had a Linux machine as my daily driver, and I would putter and futz with it and make it do what I wanted.

At some point I realized that I was spending my time at home doing what I was paid to do at work and I bought a Mac and moved on with my life.

The car as personal private time is also huge, it's one of the last private defended areas we have.

Re:How to Quit Cars by watwut on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:20AM (#35998436)
You are still safer riding that public transit then riding a car. And it is usable when you are too old/sick to drive. And it is nitnlike traffic jam were unheard of for cars.
Re:How to Quit Cars by ars on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:47AM (#35998580)
Agree with what you wrote - but I just want to point out the craziness of completely full train cars!

That means there is a ton of pent up demand. Why can't NY meet this demand? The tracks are already there!

Re:How to Quit Cars by seadan83 on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:37PM (#36007565)
I am anti car, but not anti car for everyone in all cases.

"I suspect anti car people just don't see these things as that big of a deal."

I do see it, and it is a huge deal. Those problems seem like issues of underfunding (a d more).. the amount spent on roads is just astronomical. If there were any kind of equity of personal vs public transport, the subway would be gold plated! (Perhaps not, but funding easily could be tripled and still not be at an equitable share of subsidy funding [yes, I do want those property tax dollars back and to stop paying for endless tarmac!])

Bottom line, the issues I do think are seen. It's that they are symptoms of neglect and a culture that does not value public transit (despite personal transit does not scale to what is needed!). I'm emphasizing that personal transit is a non-solution. Hence without a first rate public system, traffic, gridlock - nobody wins.

Re:How to Quit Cars by sum1zideas on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:57AM (#35989843)
It’s odd to me we insist on traveling so much for career. Modern businesses seem to exist to soak up easy luxury rather than generate net new ideas and services.

There’s tons of work todo and new potential colleagues in our neighborhoods. Nurses and teachers could quit and start local collectives.

But the grind and exploitation of hustle culture and bloated adminispheres seems so normal no one can see around it.

Re:How to Quit Cars by CapricornNoble on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:31AM (#35998134)
> There’s tons of work todo > hustle culture and bloated adminispheres seems so normal

A lot of useful work that could be done is building better stuff, physically improving the local infrastructure and environment. That requires tradesmen doing hands-on labor. Giant portions of our labor pool wouldn't be caught dead doing that kind of work. That's why we have a flood of bullshit jobs where people shuffle paper in air-conditioned offices, float around to conferences, stay at business hotels, etc...

Re:How to Quit Cars by uoaei on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:49AM (#35989715)
It's a chicken-and-egg concern. If there was a higher amount of passenger load on public transit there would be more eyes, accountability, and generally a feeling of being around people who are going somewhere rather than using the trains and buses as living rooms. Safety in numbers and all that.
Re:How to Quit Cars by Jayschwa on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:55AM (#35989806)
I disagree. I lived in NYC for 10 years without a car and used public transit for everything. There are plenty of passengers, and that didn't matter. It was just a larger captive audience for whoever was having their mental breakdown.
Re:How to Quit Cars by digging on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:20PM (#35994978)
The US's approach attacks public transit from both ends. Transit is gutted, cars are prioritized, making transit not good enough. And social services are gutted, the poor and the unwell are demonized, and then the only people riding transit are scary. And these two feed into each other; by making transit inefficient to use, and making expensive cars necessary, poverty is increased.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bertil on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:20PM (#35994980)
You want to have a more holistic view of living together. Public healthcare is part of that.

Whether people in crisis are on the side of the road (and easier to ignore with a lifted car hood) or in your train car, they aren’t getting the help they need.

Re:How to Quit Cars by keiferski on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#35989826)
I think social perception plays a big role too. In most countries where public transit is widely used, it’s used across nearly every social class. No one thinks that riding the bus is something only poor people do.

That isn’t the case in America, where riding the bus absolutely has a low social status. So I think making public transit more of a prestige product (safe, clean, well-designed, etc.) would help break that and make it more socially acceptable for middle and upper class people.

Re:How to Quit Cars by seanmcdirmid on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:29PM (#35990381)
That only applies to developed countries. In China, a lot of people use public transit, but richer people will prefer taxis, ubers, or their own cars. There are a lot of taxis also, that are cheap enough for daily commutes if you are middle class. I lived on a subway route in Beijing that went close enough to my work, but it was so crowded (often nowhere to sit on a 25 minute ride) that I just paid for the taxi anyways. Traffic was horrible, so it made sense to take the subway if traveling during rush-hour (if you can fit on, of course), but I re-arranged my work schedule to mostly avoid that.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:40PM (#35994472)
I remember visiting Germany for work years ago, and was pleased to find that my hotel was literally on the same block as a tram/trolley that went to next door to the company; super nice Eurotransit done Right™ for the win!

A short walk from the hotel and a quick ride and I was there for the day; and when I mentioned it to the manager he was flabbergasted because the tram is for poor people he must give me a ride back in his Audi.

Which took twice as long hahahaha.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bertil on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:23PM (#35995016)
In Paris, buses are a little slower than light rail, so they tend to be associated with higher status, parents with prams, and elderly people, who have more time and would rather enjoy the view. Middle-class people take the metro. The working class lives in the suburbs and takes the regional trains.
Re:How to Quit Cars by UtopiaPunk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:05PM (#35992601)
Do you think cleanliness and perceived safety* are more important than more frequent and faster public transit? I'm not asking in a combatitive way, just discussing. I think these are all important for encouraging Americans to use public transit more, but, imo, convenience is the single thing biggest factor that gets the general population to take up something in this country. If a car is more convenient than a bus, then most people will choose the car.

*I say "perceived safety," because vibes seem to matter more than actual safety. Like, the stats on car wrecks, drunk driving, distracted driving, and so on are alarming. But when I think of someone concerned about "safety," I imagine someone being uncomfortable around people they feel are sketchy.

Re:How to Quit Cars by keiferski on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:10PM (#35993417)
I’m not sure I’d say more important, but definitely of equal importance. Especially in terms of how people perceive public transit; i.e. is it just for people that can’t afford a car, or is it clean, comfortable, and a viable alternative to a car?
Re:How to Quit Cars by andromeduck on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:22PM (#35994222)
They are to most women, at least in my friend group.
Re:How to Quit Cars by dilap on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:28PM (#35994308)
In somewhere like SF, yeah, definitely, in my experience. Riding the BART is disgusting.

I think an interesting thing to remember about perceived safety, statistical safety, and actual safety, is that they are all different things -- you can't just look at stats to determine actual safety.

E.g., I was involved in a couple of incidents involving attacks in SF that I am sure were not reflected in the stats. (As well as numerous thefts, though that's not a safety issue per se.)

Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:33PM (#35994371)
Safety and speed are tied together; if you have to wait 15 minutes at a bus stop for the next bus that has all sorts of safety implications, if a bus arrives every 2 minutes it will feel very different.

Convenience is a big part of it, sure, but even Americans will use transit when it works for them, even if it is not faster (it is almost NEVER faster than driving a car unless you do strange restrictions or include a very-high-speed segment).

But you only need a few bad experiences on transit to put you off it when you have other options.

Re:How to Quit Cars by hooverd on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:56PM (#35996447)
A stinking homeless person getting in your face is more visceral than a car wreck you aren't involved in.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mantas on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:34AM (#35998159)
Of course cleanliness and safety is important. It sucks to ride in a stinking bus next to a passing out hobo. Wether it's 20 minutes or 40 minutes. Same applies if you have to carefully watch your backpack to not have it's bottom cut.
Re:How to Quit Cars by joe_the_user on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:13PM (#35994128)
It’s odd to me that these anti-car polemics never talk about why Americans don’t want to ride public transit

Yes they do. US public transit is terrible and various groups like Strong Towns describe this and explain why. Things like the way buses wind-up the first thing cut in budget crises etc are important parts of the barrier to ending a car-based urbanism.

See a multitude of article here: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/category/Public+Transit

Re:How to Quit Cars by cassac on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:59PM (#35994711)
I think the ops point was that even if they want to, they don’t want to. I can’t comment on the MN light rail now as I haven’t been on it for a few years, but the green line used to be essentially an open air drug market and the blue line I almost got stabbed. Add in a few instances of homeless on homeless violence and driving starts looking like a great option. That’s not even covering how poorly ran it is. I want to ride it… but I don’t want to ride it.
Re:How to Quit Cars by joe_the_user on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:18PM (#35994945)
What exactly are you adding here?

I've noted that public transit is unpleasant 'cause it's underfunded and poorly planned. There's not much money for security, the routes are bad and irregular and so only those with no other choice ride it and so it's the very poor and that can result in bad behavior - plus those aiming to victimize step in as well.

Re:How to Quit Cars by tokyolights2 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:17PM (#35994943)
That is a self-reinforcing cycle. There have been long and successful campaigns by car companies and other self-interested entities in the US to associate public transportation with being poor. Just like how a city street is safer per-capita if there are more people on it, public transit is safer if it is more well-used.

I see this in seattle. When I am commuting in the morning or in the evening my bus is full of yuppies and working class people getting to their job. But if I take the bus on the weekend or during the off hours when well-adjusted people are not on it, the bus is a much less inviting place.

I don't know how to solve the problem other than to believe in the system and hope that other people do as well.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:40PM (#35995885)
All one has to do is charge a fare, enforce it, and other existing laws. Used to be a simple contract.

That was abandoned. While I was a long-term advocate of public transportation, no longer can recommend it. Certainly not for my family.

Not like a “law and order” candidate is ever getting elected again in this state. Even a more compassionate version I’d support.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Karrot_Kream on Thursday May 18, 2023 @09:37PM (#35996747)
While I'm with you on fare enforcement, there are costs associated with fare collection. Usually it takes passengers time to pull out change and they can be confused about how and where to pay, adding to delays. Building the infrastructure for fare payment at gates is expensive and requires security to maintain and dissuade vandals.

Boudin's recall in SF also shows that there's certainly support for a tougher on crime stance, whether or not you agree with it.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @10:30PM (#35997078)
There are costs for doing it properly, and there are costs for not:

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-03-14/horror-t...

Re:How to Quit Cars by Larrikin on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:55AM (#35998288)
In 2023, any transit system that requires more than quickly tapping your phone, wallet, watch, etc to the the turnstile is decades behind the world technologically and the inconvenience of looking for change is a problem because of the city council or state not investing in public transit. The vast majority of mass transit riders are not tourists from the suburbs using the system as a novelty that would be confused anyway.

I am personally not a fan of NFC becoming the standard in the US, since it requires strategically placing credit cards in your wallet instead of using a card specifically made for transit fare, but it does make it so large swathes of the population never even have to think about going to a fare machine.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:18AM (#35998432)
A system that relies on turnstiles is decades behind as well. Best practices in much of Europe use proof of payment and cheap monthly passes relative to single tickets, so most users have monthly passes.

This cuts down on access time, infrastructure cost, fare collection cost, and minimizes marginal cost per trip for users (i.e. zero).

In Germany, they just introduced a monthly 49€ ticket that covers transit (and regional trains) for the whole country.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Larrikin on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:39AM (#35998535)
I usually compare how far behind the US is to Japan. How does a system without turnstiles work in Europe? In Japan, the shinkansen can still actually be used with their cards and tapping pass the turnstile, but nearly everyone besides business passengers buys a ticket for the one off far trips. I can't even imagine short trip subways not having a turnstile.

Even in the US, monthly swipe passes have been a thing in even the systems that used tokens.

Re:How to Quit Cars by soco on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:14AM (#35998749)
You tap your card in the bus, when you pass by the tapping devices.
Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:54AM (#35998994)
But monthly passes, for example in NYC, are expensive relative to single tickets, so adoption is relatively low.

If everyone has a monthly pass, fare evasion is less of an issue even in an open system. Fares are checked on a sampling basis with fines for not having a ticket.

Re:How to Quit Cars by achates on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:36AM (#36000467)
Fines only hurt working people. The homeless just ignore them.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Friday May 19, 2023 @05:50AM (#35999688)
Could you justify the term "best practises"?

Last time I took an U-Bahn in Berlin, a guy was urinating in front of me. I have not seen such sociopathic behaviour in public transport in Tokyo, Singapore, Taipei, Shanghai, Hong Kong, Beijing. All are turnstile based. I feel that they are strictly better in almost all dimensions than e.g. Berlin's public transport. In all you pay with some variant of NFC tech, e.g. your phone. Zero effort.

Fine-grained access control also allows for better understanding of train usage, and capacity planning.

Cost of transport is orthogonal to access.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:12PM (#36005731)
Asian cities are very different from the West, so not sure lessons apply. Although Berlin is probably more affordable in PPP terms, and relative to population has more rapid transit than those asian cities (500km for 4.6Mio ppl).

In virtually all dimensions, Berlin transit is better than every US system, Except NYC. Which is ironically the only place Ive ever seen anybody pee in the subway, and that one is supposedly “protected” by turnstiles.

The US has a homelessness epidemic, Berlin has some problems in this area as well. This is a problem thats orthogonal to the transit system, and has to be solved by society at large. Turnstiles don’t solve homelessness.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Friday May 19, 2023 @04:27PM (#36006474)
I did not bring up US public transport as an example of "best practises". I agree that Berlin has a extensive and well-developed public transport, and that is commendable.

> Turnstiles don’t solve homelessness.

Nobody claims they do. My anecdote illustrated the opposite direction: barriers remove one related cluster of reasons, related to personal safety, why some avoid public transport and prefer to drive by car, namely the fear to be accosted by vagrants, pickpockets, and other forms of sociopathy.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Saturday May 20, 2023 @09:31AM (#36011799)
But they don’t solve that as well, cf. NYC subway.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:27AM (#36012705)
Do you think this has something to do with the fact that turnstile jumping has been effectively legalised (in the sense of not being prosecuted) in NY?

Question for you: can you quantify, what fraction of crime and other forms of sociopathy in the NY public transport system you estimate to be committed by passengers who paid their fare? (My estimation: less than 1 percent.)

I don't think it's reasonable to assume that a simple metal gate alone can completely solve complex social dysfunction, a simple metal gate can however help, and, when we refer to turnstile access being desirable, we implicitly assume that we can reasonably expect turnstile use being adhered to, and violations punished with at least moderately high probability.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bentlegen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:44PM (#35995924)
We created a society where homeless people have so few means, they turn to public transit just to have a roof over their heads and stay warm. Then we lament how public transit has become “undesirable”, never recognizing the active steps we take to make it so.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @10:31PM (#35997081)
It’s a prerequisite that must be fixed to restore public transport in this area:

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-03-14/horror-t...

Re:How to Quit Cars by hablog on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:43PM (#35995906)
The issue isn't that the busses don't get enough money; the issue is that america is full of huge subpopulations that commit tons of violent crime, homeless crackheads, etc.

Unless we imprison like 20% of the population, busses in most American states will never be clean or safe.

Re:How to Quit Cars by dev1n on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:57PM (#35996021)
The reason these people are homeless a lot of the times is because they lack housing. Drug usage and crime are a side-effect of this [1].

Denser housing -> Better (frequent, reliable) public transport -> more people use it -> More people want to live in denser housing -> More denser housing is developed -> less homeless.

This is the formula for how Manhattan, brooklyn, and queens were developed by real estate companies. Builders wanted to be near public transport because they knew they could build large apartment buildings and get a bunch of money in rent because a bunch of people wanted to live near public transport so they could get places quickly and reliably.

[1]: Also if we legalized all drugs people wouldn't be forced to turn to criminal organizations. We already do this with alcohol.

Re:How to Quit Cars by hablog on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:10PM (#35996121)
> The reason these people are homeless a lot of the times is because they lack housing

This is beyond naive. Only people who've never actually interacted with the homeless on a close basis can make such facially absurd claims with a straight face.

> Also if we legalized all drugs

Decriminalization has made dope-addled nodder homeless populations worse in every city where it's been tried

If your ideology actually worked, I'd say you should fix homelessness before trying to "fix" cars, but you're never going to make any progress on the former.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:05AM (#35997604)
People steal bud light. I remember being accosted by an apparently homeless dude with a trash bag full of beer who was handing it out on the tram.

I drank one.

Re:How to Quit Cars by samtho on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:22AM (#35998084)
People steal bud light because they can’t afford or don’t want to pay for it, not because it’s illegal to have or consume. The war on drugs had done untold damage to our society by reframing drug problems as a moral problem rather than a medical problem. Black markets pop up immediately once things are banned because, as long as there is a market for it, supply will meet demand.
Re:How to Quit Cars by watwut on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:14AM (#35998397)
America is already imprisoning more people than any other comparable country and does not have all that much more crime overall. And crime in America is now significantly lower then a generation ago, despite all the fearmongering.

Fear in America has zero to do with reality of crime.

Re:How to Quit Cars by anonyfox on Friday May 19, 2023 @04:45AM (#35999365)
This sounds sooo surreal as a guy living in Europe. Maybe you Americans should really look into how social welfare actually reduces these problems and make _everyone_ better off?

Giving free good housing to the homeless has a cost, but is way cheaper than having all this prisons, aggressive cops, literal slums/no-go-areas, security groups, … and a significant share of current homeless/drugusers will contribute to society again over time instead of causing costs.

Re:How to Quit Cars by throwaway10563 on Friday May 19, 2023 @05:58AM (#35999721)
The US doesn't spend less on social welfare then most European countries per capita [1], it actually spends more than Netherlands and Japan who are renowned for their public transport.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_we...

Re:How to Quit Cars by anonyfox on Saturday May 20, 2023 @05:38PM (#36015852)
Maybe the same problem like in healthcare, where the US spends _a lot_ of money but there are lots of middlemen companies (including insurances) siphoning off the money, and also charge the customers?

Looks like all this money that is spent for some reason doesn’t reach the target somehow, or only a small fraction of it. Sounds insanely wasteful compared to non-privatized operations, as if the system is designed to make private individuals rich instead of focussing on solving the original problem

Re:How to Quit Cars by unrealhoang on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:04AM (#35999761)
No, socialism bad.
Re:How to Quit Cars by JeremyNT on Friday May 19, 2023 @11:39AM (#36003213)
> Unless we imprison like 20% of the population, busses in most American states will never be clean or safe.

What a horrific philosophy, albeit one shared by a disturbingly large percentage of Americans. Do people in this country really believe they can imprison their way out of every problem? Is fascism really the answer here?

A more humane solution is to actually create a social safety net and redistribute some of the country's vast wealth to help improve the quality of life for the people who are down on their luck, rather than to house them in prisons.

Re:How to Quit Cars by seadan83 on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:29PM (#36007496)
It's a self reinforcing cycle. Public transit sucks, ergo it is cut, it becomes worse is less useful, ridership declines, nobody is riding it, defunded more - rinse wash repeat. See transit is horrible... Seeing well done public transit is eye opening. We also don't consider sometimes that driving is terrible too in cities. 30 minutes to get down an on ramp, 30 more to go across a bridge. At some point bad public transit and grid locked cities is just.. dystopian. Fundamentally a problem of scale, personal cars just can't move many millions in and out of a city, the math of how much time and space that requires doesn't work.
Re:How to Quit Cars by fwungy on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:16PM (#35994166)
Come to Sacramento and ride the light rails end to end. It isn't rocket surgery.
Re:How to Quit Cars by BrianHenryIE on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:55PM (#35995407)
I don't get what your point is, if you could explain please. I live in Sacramento, but I rarely use the light rail. And I almost never use cars.
Re:How to Quit Cars by fwungy on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:42PM (#35995901)
Depending on the route and the time of day you'll find homeless, nodded out addicts, groups of bored young people looking for a happening, insane people, and sanitary issues.

Depends where and when you're going, and some is just plain luck, or lack of it.

Re:How to Quit Cars by BrianHenryIE on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:24AM (#35998092)
Thanks. I wasn’t sure were you suggesting it was fine or awful!

I’ve only ever taken the Gold line, and it’s been uneventful. But, as I say, not often.

Re:How to Quit Cars by oatmeal1 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:18PM (#35994184)
I've heard that researchers determined that - roughly speaking - traffic congestion increases until the fastest way to get to your destination is through modes of transportation that are not cars.
Re:How to Quit Cars by nayuki on Thursday May 18, 2023 @09:47PM (#35996800)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downs%E2%80%93Thomson_paradox , https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQY6WGOoYis "Do Your Buses Get Stuck in Traffic? Traffic solutions & the Downs-Thomson Paradox"
Re:How to Quit Cars by wnc3141 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:46PM (#35994541)
I lived in Denmark for a year a few years ago during University and lived with a Family, and remember that for most families not living within the densest core of the city owned one car but used transit for most if not all local trips.

The thing is, the entire society (at least in Copenhagen) is built around car-lite life (for example small corner grocery everywhere instead of large supermarkets). Additionally there is such low abject poverty that there is little tension with crime, homelessness etc.

My point is, lack of interest in public transit is merely symptomatic of larger issues we as Americans face, such as sprawl, existing infrastructure, crime, inequality etc.

Re:How to Quit Cars by SoftTalker on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:35PM (#35996329)
Exactly my perception of Denmark. The core of Copenhagen is very bike friendly and many people cycle to work (though there are a lot of cars as well). The rest of the country is pretty car-dependent, though cycling is still more practical than in many American cities and towns. The smaller towns are walkable in the core but surrounded by farmland where you need a car to get anywhere.
Re:How to Quit Cars by Moldoteck on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:56AM (#35998636)
low crime is not just a given, its a result of the design. A properly designed dense city planning reduces crime by default(people are less likely to commit crime if other people are watching and public spaces and buildings are designed for this purpose. Not just this- the social housing is cool too because it blocks concentration of marginalised people in one place, making it unsafe and rather spreads those people evenly across the city. There are many subtle things that are implemented in nordic countries to reduce crimes and its super interesting
Re:How to Quit Cars by milkytron on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:54PM (#35994649)
> It’s odd to me that these anti-car polemics never talk about why Americans don’t want to ride public transit, while people in most other countries have zero issues adopting it wholesale.

This is talked about if you follow urbanism communities. In addition to the reasons you mentioned, it just doesn't go to where people want to be. The last century of urban planning in the US has left transit and alternative modes of transportation as an afterthought or not thought of at all.

Land use is a major problem. In my particular city, half of the stations are surrounded by parking lots instead of actual destinations. Transit in the US has been treated as a band aid to car traffic, pollution, and costs. If it were funded and prioritized appropriately, we would see more transit oriented development and ridership.

Lack of ridership is seen as a reason to decrease funding. But when ridership increases, you get improved safety because there are more eyes to witness and report a crime.

I don't think most people make it moralistic crusade, but those kinds of comments and attitudes get the most attention. If you delve into the communities and read the relevant books, you may find that nuance is actually appreciated and discussed quite a bit.

Re:How to Quit Cars by sokoloff on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:45PM (#35996388)
It’s great that it’s being discussed but until it’s addressed, it’s just a bunch of words and doesn’t improve anyone’s life.
Re:How to Quit Cars by dukeyukey on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:05PM (#35994784)
I genuinely think the answer is _way_ simpler and less dramatic than people think.

In general, a city is more walkable and dense the earlier it developed. NYC and Boston are walkable cos they're old. Parts of Chicago are, but it did most of it's growing post-car so most of it isn't. LA did practically almost all it's growing post-car and so is awful for walkers.

It's the same in Europe - most of London is walkable because it hit a multi-million population pre-car. Milton Keynes is a concrete car-jungle because it only developed post-war.

Re:How to Quit Cars by digging on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:15PM (#35994917)
That's wrong. Many, many cities had walkable neighborhoods bulldozed and replaced with highways and parking lots, intentionally. In both the US and the EU. Many of the most walkable places have been reclaimed from cars.
Re:How to Quit Cars by dukeyukey on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:22PM (#35995006)
Yes, I've lived in a couple of them. That's why I said _general_.
Re:How to Quit Cars by digging on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:33PM (#35995143)
Well, is it generally true though? I don't even think it's very useful to talk about... compared to discussing how car manufacturers and sellers have intentionally stripped us of good urban design over the last century, and the ways in which some cities have undone some of that damage.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bertil on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:15PM (#35994907)
I’ve lived in several barely finished neighbourhoods and all were walkable: Hammarby Sjöstad in Stokholm, Jätkassari in Helsinki, the new Ancoats in Manchester…

All smelled of fresh paint and wet concrete. All were built with the intent to be walkable, and all are wonderful places to live. I never felt the need for a car once. What matters is not the age but the intent of the designers.

Re:How to Quit Cars by dukeyukey on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:21PM (#35994999)
So have I. That's why I said _general_.
Re:How to Quit Cars by Karrot_Kream on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:17PM (#35994941)
Along with some of the other great answers you're getting, just look at the difference in funding. Highway expansions and arterials are granted huge federal dollars. But look at how much funding your local bus system gets. I can guarantee you almost any freeway widening project in a given location in the US is apportioned more money than the local transit network, except for a few prominent exceptions like NYC.

Part of this is a structural issue. The Federal government has a robust system of funding road network expansion but has no equivalent system of funding transit. Even after the passage of the recent infrastructure bill, look at the apportionment to maintaining Federal roadway compared to Federal transit funding. You can't compare a budget Android phone for a developing market with a flagship Android or a new iPhone.

Re:How to Quit Cars by hcarvalhoalves on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:25PM (#35995038)
It's horrible by design – to sell cars.
Re:How to Quit Cars by local_crmdgeon on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:35PM (#35995162)
https://www.strongtowns.org/ is what you're looking for. They have deep dives and do really interesting financial analysis.
Re:How to Quit Cars by HPsquared on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:44PM (#35995264)
I think income is a big factor: average Americans can afford to run cars, and have for a very long time - this is not so much the case in most countries.
Re:How to Quit Cars by jltsiren on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:15PM (#35996164)
All these issues arise from political priorities. If you want good public transit, you must build it as infrastructure for the middle class. If the target audience is not the middle class, nobody really cares if your public transit works. You want to build a city where using public transit is the default, and driving is for situations where people have special needs.

Public transit is not a social program. Whether the poor can afford public transit on their own is mostly irrelevant. If you want social programs, start separate social programs. Don't ruin other programs with unrelated goals.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:12AM (#35997645)
This is a big part of it. Almost unironcially you could make public transit work better by giving every single homeless person in the city a car, and then spending money on keeping the transit operational, safe, and clean.

34% of kids ride a school bus to school, and that's basically transit designed for the middle class.

Re:How to Quit Cars by nradov on Thursday May 18, 2023 @10:05PM (#35996928)
One way to make public transit safe and clean would be to provide housing, addition treatment, and mental health services. There are a lot of people with serious behavioral problems who use public transit as rolling mental hospitals because they have no where else to go.
Re:How to Quit Cars by userbinator on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:38AM (#35997807)
while people in most other countries have zero issues adopting it wholesale

Because on average they don't value personal freedom as much as Americans: There's something innately offputting about the thought of getting on a vehicle that is mostly out of one's own control, along with many others, and being taken somewhere instead of controlling one's own vehicle to a destination.

Obviously, this causes public transit to evolve to a bare minimum service.

Re:How to Quit Cars by loa_in_ on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:47AM (#35998231)
There's a story in my (EU) city of when a bus driver near the end of his shift drove the bus up to his house absentmindedly much to surprise of the passengers.
Re:How to Quit Cars by Moldoteck on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:07AM (#35998701)
I think they/we value personal freedom, but in a different way, especially in well designed cities/countries. Being able to get into a train/bus and arrive to destination without the hassle of searching for parking, being concentrated on road, avoid drinking alcohol, and spending a s** ton of money on buying car and fuel and taxes for them, like all this adds up and freedom of movement by car takes other freedoms from the people. Also it's interesting that americans value their freedom of movement so much but bike optimised infra is almost nonexistent and bikes are even more "pro freedom" since you don't need to take exams, register the bike, pay for fuel, you can usually drink some alcohol no problem and in case of ebikes you can charge them at home and ebikes can cover big distances as well but still, US is designed for cars&big cars only
Re:How to Quit Cars by archagon on Friday May 19, 2023 @04:35PM (#36006584)
Let me tell you, I’m not feeling so great about my “personal freedom” when I’m circling the block for half an hour trying to find a sliver of parking.
Re:How to Quit Cars by jhbadger on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:07AM (#35997991)
The LA Metro system actually is quite beautiful and far cleaner than say, the NYC or DC systems (cynics will say that's because it isn't used as much).
Re:How to Quit Cars by anovikov on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:17AM (#35998058)
It's too late to do this, it's not possible in a country that isn't all-white. Even in Europe usability of public transport deteriorates as other races mix in. Now there's no fix.
Re:How to Quit Cars by bootwoot on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:26PM (#36004540)
There's a cause and effect issue here. It requires lot of money to go from an unloved public transit system used only by the poorest individuals to a fast, reliable, clean system that the wealthier classes with options would choose to use over their personal vehicles.

But, that investment is generally decided on by that same wealthier class that is currently choosing their personal vehicle.

It's impossible to start the economic ball rolling without some evangelizing to capture hearts and minds of those that aren't currently using or interested in investing in the mass transit system.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Apofis on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:55PM (#36008117)
I grew up in NYC with the most amazing public transport system out there in the world and still absolutely despised taking the bus. Try 100 degree 100 humidity summers while waiting for the bus or the inverse. It's really not compelling. Car > Taxi > Subway > Bus (I'd rather skip the trip entirely)

No offense to bus drivers they're amazing.