News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Quit Cars by joe_the_user on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:13PM (#35994128)
It’s odd to me that these anti-car polemics never talk about why Americans don’t want to ride public transit

Yes they do. US public transit is terrible and various groups like Strong Towns describe this and explain why. Things like the way buses wind-up the first thing cut in budget crises etc are important parts of the barrier to ending a car-based urbanism.

See a multitude of article here: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/category/Public+Transit

Re:How to Quit Cars by cassac on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:59PM (#35994711)
I think the ops point was that even if they want to, they don’t want to. I can’t comment on the MN light rail now as I haven’t been on it for a few years, but the green line used to be essentially an open air drug market and the blue line I almost got stabbed. Add in a few instances of homeless on homeless violence and driving starts looking like a great option. That’s not even covering how poorly ran it is. I want to ride it… but I don’t want to ride it.
Re:How to Quit Cars by joe_the_user on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:18PM (#35994945)
What exactly are you adding here?

I've noted that public transit is unpleasant 'cause it's underfunded and poorly planned. There's not much money for security, the routes are bad and irregular and so only those with no other choice ride it and so it's the very poor and that can result in bad behavior - plus those aiming to victimize step in as well.

Re:How to Quit Cars by tokyolights2 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:17PM (#35994943)
That is a self-reinforcing cycle. There have been long and successful campaigns by car companies and other self-interested entities in the US to associate public transportation with being poor. Just like how a city street is safer per-capita if there are more people on it, public transit is safer if it is more well-used.

I see this in seattle. When I am commuting in the morning or in the evening my bus is full of yuppies and working class people getting to their job. But if I take the bus on the weekend or during the off hours when well-adjusted people are not on it, the bus is a much less inviting place.

I don't know how to solve the problem other than to believe in the system and hope that other people do as well.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:40PM (#35995885)
All one has to do is charge a fare, enforce it, and other existing laws. Used to be a simple contract.

That was abandoned. While I was a long-term advocate of public transportation, no longer can recommend it. Certainly not for my family.

Not like a “law and order” candidate is ever getting elected again in this state. Even a more compassionate version I’d support.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Karrot_Kream on Thursday May 18, 2023 @09:37PM (#35996747)
While I'm with you on fare enforcement, there are costs associated with fare collection. Usually it takes passengers time to pull out change and they can be confused about how and where to pay, adding to delays. Building the infrastructure for fare payment at gates is expensive and requires security to maintain and dissuade vandals.

Boudin's recall in SF also shows that there's certainly support for a tougher on crime stance, whether or not you agree with it.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @10:30PM (#35997078)
There are costs for doing it properly, and there are costs for not:

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-03-14/horror-t...

Re:How to Quit Cars by Larrikin on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:55AM (#35998288)
In 2023, any transit system that requires more than quickly tapping your phone, wallet, watch, etc to the the turnstile is decades behind the world technologically and the inconvenience of looking for change is a problem because of the city council or state not investing in public transit. The vast majority of mass transit riders are not tourists from the suburbs using the system as a novelty that would be confused anyway.

I am personally not a fan of NFC becoming the standard in the US, since it requires strategically placing credit cards in your wallet instead of using a card specifically made for transit fare, but it does make it so large swathes of the population never even have to think about going to a fare machine.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:18AM (#35998432)
A system that relies on turnstiles is decades behind as well. Best practices in much of Europe use proof of payment and cheap monthly passes relative to single tickets, so most users have monthly passes.

This cuts down on access time, infrastructure cost, fare collection cost, and minimizes marginal cost per trip for users (i.e. zero).

In Germany, they just introduced a monthly 49€ ticket that covers transit (and regional trains) for the whole country.

Re:How to Quit Cars by Larrikin on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:39AM (#35998535)
I usually compare how far behind the US is to Japan. How does a system without turnstiles work in Europe? In Japan, the shinkansen can still actually be used with their cards and tapping pass the turnstile, but nearly everyone besides business passengers buys a ticket for the one off far trips. I can't even imagine short trip subways not having a turnstile.

Even in the US, monthly swipe passes have been a thing in even the systems that used tokens.

Re:How to Quit Cars by soco on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:14AM (#35998749)
You tap your card in the bus, when you pass by the tapping devices.
Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:54AM (#35998994)
But monthly passes, for example in NYC, are expensive relative to single tickets, so adoption is relatively low.

If everyone has a monthly pass, fare evasion is less of an issue even in an open system. Fares are checked on a sampling basis with fines for not having a ticket.

Re:How to Quit Cars by achates on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:36AM (#36000467)
Fines only hurt working people. The homeless just ignore them.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Friday May 19, 2023 @05:50AM (#35999688)
Could you justify the term "best practises"?

Last time I took an U-Bahn in Berlin, a guy was urinating in front of me. I have not seen such sociopathic behaviour in public transport in Tokyo, Singapore, Taipei, Shanghai, Hong Kong, Beijing. All are turnstile based. I feel that they are strictly better in almost all dimensions than e.g. Berlin's public transport. In all you pay with some variant of NFC tech, e.g. your phone. Zero effort.

Fine-grained access control also allows for better understanding of train usage, and capacity planning.

Cost of transport is orthogonal to access.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:12PM (#36005731)
Asian cities are very different from the West, so not sure lessons apply. Although Berlin is probably more affordable in PPP terms, and relative to population has more rapid transit than those asian cities (500km for 4.6Mio ppl).

In virtually all dimensions, Berlin transit is better than every US system, Except NYC. Which is ironically the only place Ive ever seen anybody pee in the subway, and that one is supposedly “protected” by turnstiles.

The US has a homelessness epidemic, Berlin has some problems in this area as well. This is a problem thats orthogonal to the transit system, and has to be solved by society at large. Turnstiles don’t solve homelessness.

Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Friday May 19, 2023 @04:27PM (#36006474)
I did not bring up US public transport as an example of "best practises". I agree that Berlin has a extensive and well-developed public transport, and that is commendable.

> Turnstiles don’t solve homelessness.

Nobody claims they do. My anecdote illustrated the opposite direction: barriers remove one related cluster of reasons, related to personal safety, why some avoid public transport and prefer to drive by car, namely the fear to be accosted by vagrants, pickpockets, and other forms of sociopathy.

Re:How to Quit Cars by ant6n on Saturday May 20, 2023 @09:31AM (#36011799)
But they don’t solve that as well, cf. NYC subway.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mafribe on Saturday May 20, 2023 @11:27AM (#36012705)
Do you think this has something to do with the fact that turnstile jumping has been effectively legalised (in the sense of not being prosecuted) in NY?

Question for you: can you quantify, what fraction of crime and other forms of sociopathy in the NY public transport system you estimate to be committed by passengers who paid their fare? (My estimation: less than 1 percent.)

I don't think it's reasonable to assume that a simple metal gate alone can completely solve complex social dysfunction, a simple metal gate can however help, and, when we refer to turnstile access being desirable, we implicitly assume that we can reasonably expect turnstile use being adhered to, and violations punished with at least moderately high probability.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bentlegen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:44PM (#35995924)
We created a society where homeless people have so few means, they turn to public transit just to have a roof over their heads and stay warm. Then we lament how public transit has become “undesirable”, never recognizing the active steps we take to make it so.
Re:How to Quit Cars by mixmastamyk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @10:31PM (#35997081)
It’s a prerequisite that must be fixed to restore public transport in this area:

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-03-14/horror-t...

Re:How to Quit Cars by hablog on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:43PM (#35995906)
The issue isn't that the busses don't get enough money; the issue is that america is full of huge subpopulations that commit tons of violent crime, homeless crackheads, etc.

Unless we imprison like 20% of the population, busses in most American states will never be clean or safe.

Re:How to Quit Cars by dev1n on Thursday May 18, 2023 @07:57PM (#35996021)
The reason these people are homeless a lot of the times is because they lack housing. Drug usage and crime are a side-effect of this [1].

Denser housing -> Better (frequent, reliable) public transport -> more people use it -> More people want to live in denser housing -> More denser housing is developed -> less homeless.

This is the formula for how Manhattan, brooklyn, and queens were developed by real estate companies. Builders wanted to be near public transport because they knew they could build large apartment buildings and get a bunch of money in rent because a bunch of people wanted to live near public transport so they could get places quickly and reliably.

[1]: Also if we legalized all drugs people wouldn't be forced to turn to criminal organizations. We already do this with alcohol.

Re:How to Quit Cars by hablog on Thursday May 18, 2023 @08:10PM (#35996121)
> The reason these people are homeless a lot of the times is because they lack housing

This is beyond naive. Only people who've never actually interacted with the homeless on a close basis can make such facially absurd claims with a straight face.

> Also if we legalized all drugs

Decriminalization has made dope-addled nodder homeless populations worse in every city where it's been tried

If your ideology actually worked, I'd say you should fix homelessness before trying to "fix" cars, but you're never going to make any progress on the former.

Re:How to Quit Cars by bombcar on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:05AM (#35997604)
People steal bud light. I remember being accosted by an apparently homeless dude with a trash bag full of beer who was handing it out on the tram.

I drank one.

Re:How to Quit Cars by samtho on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:22AM (#35998084)
People steal bud light because they can’t afford or don’t want to pay for it, not because it’s illegal to have or consume. The war on drugs had done untold damage to our society by reframing drug problems as a moral problem rather than a medical problem. Black markets pop up immediately once things are banned because, as long as there is a market for it, supply will meet demand.
Re:How to Quit Cars by watwut on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:14AM (#35998397)
America is already imprisoning more people than any other comparable country and does not have all that much more crime overall. And crime in America is now significantly lower then a generation ago, despite all the fearmongering.

Fear in America has zero to do with reality of crime.

Re:How to Quit Cars by anonyfox on Friday May 19, 2023 @04:45AM (#35999365)
This sounds sooo surreal as a guy living in Europe. Maybe you Americans should really look into how social welfare actually reduces these problems and make _everyone_ better off?

Giving free good housing to the homeless has a cost, but is way cheaper than having all this prisons, aggressive cops, literal slums/no-go-areas, security groups, … and a significant share of current homeless/drugusers will contribute to society again over time instead of causing costs.

Re:How to Quit Cars by throwaway10563 on Friday May 19, 2023 @05:58AM (#35999721)
The US doesn't spend less on social welfare then most European countries per capita [1], it actually spends more than Netherlands and Japan who are renowned for their public transport.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_social_we...

Re:How to Quit Cars by anonyfox on Saturday May 20, 2023 @05:38PM (#36015852)
Maybe the same problem like in healthcare, where the US spends _a lot_ of money but there are lots of middlemen companies (including insurances) siphoning off the money, and also charge the customers?

Looks like all this money that is spent for some reason doesn’t reach the target somehow, or only a small fraction of it. Sounds insanely wasteful compared to non-privatized operations, as if the system is designed to make private individuals rich instead of focussing on solving the original problem

Re:How to Quit Cars by unrealhoang on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:04AM (#35999761)
No, socialism bad.
Re:How to Quit Cars by JeremyNT on Friday May 19, 2023 @11:39AM (#36003213)
> Unless we imprison like 20% of the population, busses in most American states will never be clean or safe.

What a horrific philosophy, albeit one shared by a disturbingly large percentage of Americans. Do people in this country really believe they can imprison their way out of every problem? Is fascism really the answer here?

A more humane solution is to actually create a social safety net and redistribute some of the country's vast wealth to help improve the quality of life for the people who are down on their luck, rather than to house them in prisons.

Re:How to Quit Cars by seadan83 on Friday May 19, 2023 @06:29PM (#36007496)
It's a self reinforcing cycle. Public transit sucks, ergo it is cut, it becomes worse is less useful, ridership declines, nobody is riding it, defunded more - rinse wash repeat. See transit is horrible... Seeing well done public transit is eye opening. We also don't consider sometimes that driving is terrible too in cities. 30 minutes to get down an on ramp, 30 more to go across a bridge. At some point bad public transit and grid locked cities is just.. dystopian. Fundamentally a problem of scale, personal cars just can't move many millions in and out of a city, the math of how much time and space that requires doesn't work.