News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:59PM (#35643739)
I have commented this many times on such articles, and will say it again:

Google still thinks of AI as a research project, or at best a way to produce better search results. They essentially created the entire current generation of the AI space and then... gave it away, because no one on the product side understood what they had actually built. Handing the reins to the DeepMind team – who have never launched a single product in their history – seems to be a doubling down on that same failed strategy.

Google doesn't need more smart AI researchers, they need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it. That has always been their problem as a company.

Re:Google DeepMind by lallysingh on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:08PM (#35643852)
They're the new Xerox, looking at PARC's output and asking, "How will this make our copiers better?"

Internally, everyone's asking "How will this help my promo packet?"

Re:Google DeepMind by wmeredith on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:32PM (#35645056)
Absolutely. You could also sub in Microsoft, looking at the internet in 2002 and asking, "how could this make Windows desktop better"?
Re:Google DeepMind by crop_rotation on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:02PM (#35645488)
IE was already dominant by 2002. Microsoft didn't ignore the Internet. They went hell bent on it during Gates era and won decisevely. It's only when they had no competition IE got stuck and then surpassed.
Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:16PM (#35645693)
If talking about bundling a web browser inside their OS, sure. It was more that Microsoft missed the entire potential of the internet as a whole and how fundamentally transformational it could be. They had no presence in online services, e-commerce, search and more until they saw competitors eating their lunch, and have been lagging behind ever since.
Re:Google DeepMind by crop_rotation on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:01PM (#35646267)
They had a presence in online services, MSN is older than even IE.
Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:22PM (#35646545)
AOL was already dominant by the time MSN launched. Yahoo was close behind. Even back then Microsoft was playing catch up in the space.
Re:Google DeepMind by dragonwriter on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:54AM (#35649936)
> AOL was already dominant by the time MSN launched.

And never got off the pre-web walled garden end-to-end business model, despite connecting to the web, and died because of it. Not exactly the best example to use to argue Microsoft missed the boat on Web-era online services.

Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:14AM (#35650296)
AOL dominated, then Yahoo dominated, then Google dominated, then Google and Facebook dominated. Microsoft was just never in the picture.
Re:Google DeepMind by nailer on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:58AM (#35651306)
Number one browser aside, they had the number one web mail app, the number one chat app, the number one voice chat app, the most web native news service.

Yes Ballmer threw everything away and IE, Hotmail, MSN Messenger, Skype and MSNBC are jokes now, but that doesn’t mean they weren’t dominant force in Bill Gates era.

Re:Google DeepMind by salad-tycoon on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:56PM (#35659140)
> Yes Ballmer threw everything away and IE, Hotmail, MSN Messenger, Skype and MSNBC are jokes now, but that doesn’t mean they weren’t dominant force in Bill Gates era.

At least we got Xbox and Xbox live… which seems to have barely lived by a life line. Confusing mess with Xbox vs windows vs media center PC.

I still think they could have been much more successful with the kinetic. Wii was loved for its ability to bowl and play tennis and etc. Nobody I know really wants to strap a sensory deprivation device onto their face. I don’t see VR working out but a highly evolved sensor bar that allows you to interact with humans physically present and online seems an easier pill to swallow. Never owned one but seems like Kinect is still fondly remembered in some applications.

All that said I wouldn't buy one today because I don’t need x amount of cameras and lidars and y microphones recording inside my house 24/7 and going to MSFT and whoever else.

Re:Google DeepMind by lallysingh on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:05PM (#35647733)
And it was half assed filler bullshit.
Re:Google DeepMind by tripleo1 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:59PM (#35649315)
Yeah, AOL was great.
Re:Google DeepMind by lallysingh on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:35PM (#35658061)
Why would AOL be the standard here?
Re:Google DeepMind by dragonwriter on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:53AM (#35649928)
> They had a presence in online services, MSN is older than even IE.

No, it isn’t. IE, Microsoft Internet Start (Microsoft’s original web portal), and MSN (originally a separate subscription-based dialup online service that later merged with the main portal) all launched simultaneously in August 1995.

Re:Google DeepMind by jabradoodle on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:06AM (#35651347)
How is bundling a terrible browser with your OS going "hell bent on it"?
Re:Google DeepMind by crop_rotation on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:11AM (#35651375)
IE was not a terrible browser, and Microsoft did really go hell bent on it in terms of dedicating resources to the IE development. I am not sure why you call IE a terrible browser here. (IE has to be compared to Netscape for any such assessment to make sense). IE development stopped once Microsoft had won, not before.
Re:Google DeepMind by nightski on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:10PM (#35658556)
ActiveX and XMLHttpRequest were pretty revolutionary, it's just especially the former was plagued by security problems and implementation issues.
Re:Google DeepMind by chillfox on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:40PM (#35648461)
Or Kodak inventing the digital camera and deciding to shelve it because they couldn't figure out how to sell film for it.
Re:Google DeepMind by Aeolun on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:07PM (#35648644)
This turned out to be sort of precient though. It turns out Kodak sucks at selling digital cameras.
Re:Google DeepMind by foxandmouse on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:13PM (#35649415)
This is a great analogy, and it touches upon why I try to avoid google services. The company that once championed "don't be evil" now cannot think outside of the system of perverse incentives it has created (by that I mean add based revenue).
Re:Google DeepMind by medler on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:23PM (#35644078)
Is there anyone who has successfully productized AI? ChatGPT isn’t a profitable product, at least not yet. Google Photos and Spotify recommendations are the best AI products I can think of with clear revenue, and in these examples AI is just a cherry on top of a product people would use anyway.
Re:Google DeepMind by dougmwne on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:36PM (#35644246)
Github Copilot seems like a pretty clear example. They charge a subscription that's in excess of the marginal cost of inference.
Re:Google DeepMind by medler on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:09PM (#35644729)
That’s a good point. I forgot about Copilot.
Re:Google DeepMind by visarga on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:17AM (#35651794)
Midjourney, NaturalReaders (text to speech reader)
Re:Google DeepMind by andygeorge on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:48PM (#35645299)
curious if/when MS will get desirable returns on the significant investment needed to run/train copilot
Re:Google DeepMind by dougmwne on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:08PM (#35645575)
It's a good question, but also helpful to point out that one of the beauties of these models is that you can train them once and deploy to many use cases. The same model can be used by Github, Bing, Office 365, Azure and so on.

And as for the big multi-billion investment in OpenAI, they may have more than made that back up on their valuation already. Plus the deal was structured that OpenAI would pay it's revenues into Microsoft till the investment was paid back and MS would sill end up with a 49% stake.

All in all, sounds like a smart investment from MS and, cerry on top, managed to majorly embarrass a main rival.

Re:Google DeepMind by andygeorge on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:14PM (#35645668)
agree on it being a good play by MS. will interesting to see if they do spin it out to their other realms
Re:Google DeepMind by zamnos on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:22PM (#35647870)
The question there is how many of the estimated 100,000 software engineers at Microsoft are using Copilot, and what has been their (I'm sure measured) productivity boost. Microsoft does derive some benefit from Copilot being accessible to the paying subscribers of the world from having them give feedback and in free (and paid) press. But the internal use numbers probably easily justify its initial cost to train.

Say Copilot makes an engineer 2x as productive, their all-in salary is $500k to make the math easy, 1,000 MS sw engineers are using it, and Copilot took $5mm to train (GPT-3 took $4.6mm). Those 1k MS employees now being twice as productive are doing the work of an extra 1k people at $500k, or $500 million's worth in a year. That means $5 million in Copilot training costs are paid for in... 4 days. I have no inside information, so those number are all made up, but I'm pretty sure the initial training costs have already been paid off internally.

We also don't know how many multiples of $5mm it took to produce the initial version of Copilot, nor how many subsequent training runs there have been.

Point is, any significant productivity gains made, across an organization the size of Microsoft engineering, easily pays for big expensive training runs.

Re:Google DeepMind by ssijak on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:17AM (#35649767)
It makes tou nowhere nearly 2x productive. Usefull yes but 2x is a dream
Re:Google DeepMind by visarga on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:11AM (#35651745)
SOME parts of an engineer's work are 2x faster, but not all. Generating code - yes, writing tests and docs - yes, designing the system - no, debugging - no, attending meetings - no, getting your data faster, or moving the other team to finish integration sooner - no help. So it's going to be 10% boost overall, not 100%.

The nice effect is that the AI makes people more confident to try things and go out of their comfort zone. Maybe the quality of the end product will be higher.

Re:Google DeepMind by blackoil on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:54PM (#35648949)
If the return are computed by increase in market cap, they may already have got that.
Re:Google DeepMind by andygeorge on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:40PM (#35672252)
did you have a stroke?
Re:Google DeepMind by deanc on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:03PM (#35645499)
I’d be astonished if they’re even close to breaking even on copilot. In its current incarnation it wouldn’t even lace the boots of what’s coming out of OpenAI.

CopilotX with its OpenAI collab will be the real winner - if it ever gets released to those on the waitlist. I’m not aware of anyone who got in yet, which leads me to believe it doesn’t yet exist.

Re:Google DeepMind by bugglebeetle on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:59PM (#35647681)
I got access to the Copilot CLI, which is supposed to be part of the Copilot X package eventually. Dunno anyone who has gotten access to Copilot Chat yet, which I expect is what everyone really wants.
Re:Google DeepMind by Aeolun on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:09PM (#35648658)
> In its current incarnation it wouldn’t even lace the boots of what’s coming out of OpenAI.

I don’t know about you, but Copilot is part of my daily work, while OpenAI ChatGPT is still more or less a toy to me.

Re:Google DeepMind by fastball on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:38PM (#35648860)
* * *
Re:Google DeepMind by visarga on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:09AM (#35651729)
GPT4 is arguably much better at coding, hence the "paradigm shift".
Re:Google DeepMind by Kiro on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:24AM (#35650360)
Copilot is and has always been OpenAI so not sure what you're talking about.
Re:Google DeepMind by riffraff on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:39PM (#35644302)
if you consider Spotify recommendations as AI then you should consider also Youtube and every social network based on a non-time based timeline and ads, no?
Re:Google DeepMind by gilbetron on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:43PM (#35644358)
I've seen MidJourney's estimated revenue at about $750k/month. Not bad.
Re:Google DeepMind by yunwal on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:16PM (#35644822)
This seems likely lower than their costs. Is there a breakdown somewhere?
Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:51PM (#35644466)
OpenAI is growing revenues from ~0 in 2022 to $300M in 2023 to $1B in 2024. That sounds like a product to me.
Re:Google DeepMind by medler on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:08PM (#35644720)
It is currently April 2023. “~0 in 2022” is the only part of that that seems credible. I not convinced of OpenAI’s rosy predictions of future explosive growth.
Re:Google DeepMind by brokencode on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:47PM (#35647558)
The fact that Microsoft is baking GPT into all of their products guarantees explosive growth.

ChatGPT is also one of the fastest growing consumer products in history by number of users. At $20 a month for plus, it could be a significant revenue stream.

Then add all the companies like Duolingo and Snapchat that are using GPT as well.

If you don’t see this as explosive growth, then I don’t know what to tell you.

Re:Google DeepMind by mmmmpancakes on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:44PM (#35648891)
> The fact that Microsoft is baking GPT into all of their products guarantees explosive growth.

Why?

Re:Google DeepMind by brokencode on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:50PM (#35649266)
Because Microsoft is the largest software company in the world. Their products are in wide use by virtually all businesses and schools in the country. Judging by the popularity of ChatGPT, these features will be very popular and heavily used.
Re:Google DeepMind by tensor on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:08PM (#35644717)
"Hopes to grow" revenues. Current estimates put hardware costs alone at $700/day, so even if they hit $300M in 2023 that won't make them profitable. This isn't even counting the people costs and other operation costs required to run a company.
Re:Google DeepMind by generalizations on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:36PM (#35645118)
And yet, $300M is only 1.25M subscribers at the current $20/mo rate. If we say that they need a $1B / year to be comfortably profitable, that's ~4.2M subscribers. A good rule of thumb is that you can hope to convert about 10% of your free user base to paid; one random source says they have 100M monthly active users - which at 10% conversion, is $2.4B / year. I think they'll be fine.
Re:Google DeepMind by illiarian on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:34PM (#35646681)
How much money will they spend servicing requests for those 4.2M subscribers?
Re:Google DeepMind by ZephyrBlu on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:21PM (#35647317)
10% is insanely high conversion for B2C freemium. It’s closer to 1% for most products.
Re:Google DeepMind by anonylizard on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:13PM (#35648264)
Does GPT-4 look like 'most products'?

You are talking about a revolutionary product that literally dominates mindshare from consumers to students to CEOs to governments. Its a pure monopoly that has insanely wide utility and instantly obvious value proposition.

Re:Google DeepMind by ZephyrBlu on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:21PM (#35648319)
Do you know anything about B2C freemium products? 10% conversion over 10s-100s of millions of users is literally insane.

It doesn't matter how revolutionary GPT-4 is, people's willingness to pay for anything is generally very low. ChatGPT premium is also a very expensive subscription for a consumer product!

Re:Google DeepMind by anonylizard on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:09AM (#35649740)
People are willing to pay $10k a year for college, very high conversion rate. People are willing to pay for tutoring, at rate that's probably about 10% of student base, despite its very high costs ($50/h, not $20/m)

At the very minimum, I can already see every university and high school student paying for GPT-4. Its a way way way more powerful essay writer and personal tutor than GPT3.5, that alone is incentive to upgrade. For only $20 a month.

Know what GPT-4 currently is insanely capacity limited. So far, the limitation is not on the demand side, but the supply side.

Getting 100 million users in 3 months with 0 marketing or network effects already annihilates existing records, getting 10% conversion is nothing special.

Re:Google DeepMind by iudqnolq on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:18AM (#35649771)
The cheating sites I see on the first page of Google seem to charge around $10-$30/page. GPT is cheaper, but lower quality. I don't think the market for tens of dollars cheaper but shittier quality than buyessayfriend.com is anywhere near every highschool and college student.
Re:Google DeepMind by ZephyrBlu on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:42AM (#35651930)
You could have saved yourself and everyone else the time by instead writing “I have no idea what I’m talking about and I don’t understand constraints”.

https://twitter.com/visakanv/status/1113154447050334208

Re:Google DeepMind by mda on Sunday April 23, 2023 @09:53AM (#35676246)
Look what happened to image generators, no one talks about Dall-e or whatever that was.
Re:Google DeepMind by vasco on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:36PM (#35645117)
Do you have the order of magnitude right at $700/day? That's not much at all.
Re:Google DeepMind by okdood64 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:19PM (#35646505)
It's not 2024 yet, and 2023 just started.
Re:Google DeepMind by illiarian on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:34PM (#35646671)
Revenues mean nothing if your expenses outpace them. What's the net profit?
Re:Google DeepMind by Takennickname on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:29PM (#35645017)
GPT API is a successful product. All those start ups that are just a thin layer over GPT that are funded by YCombinator are paying for API use and that's profitable for OpenAI.
Re:Google DeepMind by nomel on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:36PM (#35645921)
> and that's profitable for OpenAI.

Reference?

"Profitable" means they're making more money than they're using, at this moment.

Re:Google DeepMind by Takennickname on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:48PM (#35646826)
Are you implying openai is selling access to their API at a loss?
Re:Google DeepMind by nomel on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:14PM (#35647217)
No, I would like facts, not assumptions. It's definitely not safe to assume they are making a profit, as a whole, or per transaction. It's more complicated than that.

Profit has a strict definition of $revenue - $cost, for a business operation as a whole, which leaves money in the bank at the end of the month.

They could be making more money for a single query than the cost of compute time for that single query, but that may not cover the engineering and idle servers. They could be running at a loss with the assumption that they can improve efficiency per transaction soon. They could be running at a "loss" because they're giving some of the compute away for free right now, to improve the training with the user responses. Or maybe they are making fistfuls of money. "Profitable" has a strict meaning, shouldn't be assumed, and definitely isn't required, at this point in their operation.

I'm very interested to know if they are profitable, at the moment, but I don't think that's been publicly disclosed yet, and I can't find anything. A reference is required.

Re:Google DeepMind by Takennickname on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:20AM (#35651067)
I don't have a reference. I'm taking the very reasonable assumption that openai is making money on API calls based on how much they charge compared to others in this space, the favorable pricing they receive from Microsoft, their ability to constantly bring down the costs and push the savings to their consumers, their unwillingness to lower the cost of Dall-E even though it's more expensive than it's competitors.

Very reasonable assumptions. You will never get certainty, even if they say they're profitable maybe they're just lying for investors. If you see their bank account total go up every month maybe it's a ponzi scheme.

For my heuristics, if not profitable, at least close, and definitely a major success in acquiring market share and customer mind share.

Re:Google DeepMind by jabradoodle on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:23AM (#35651441)
So, because Fraud is possible, unfounded speculation is the best we have?
Re:Google DeepMind by Takennickname on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:33AM (#35652276)
I've given plenty of evidence as to why it's a reasonable assumption. But doesn't seem like you have much access to nuance in your thinking.
Re:Google DeepMind by jabradoodle on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:58AM (#35652447)
There is a world in between, we cannot be sure of anything because of Fraud, and here is some rough guess work.

If you want to claim the latter as evidence then fair enough, I would call it speculation.

In either case there is no need to resort to petty insults.

Re:Google DeepMind by Takennickname on Friday April 21, 2023 @08:21AM (#35652638)
It was not a petty insult. The options you gave are "fraud" or "unfounded speculation." Literally lacks any kind of nuance. What sort of nuance would you say you contributed?
Re:Google DeepMind by nomel on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:47PM (#35656469)
I think it would be better to make it clear that something is an assumption rather than stating it as fact, to not add to the noise. In the world of tech (and any R&D heavy group), initially running at a loss is the norm, not the exception.
Re:Google DeepMind by zamnos on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:28PM (#35647927)
How do you want to define AI? Google's been using ML models to power various Google products for years. Translate was a big switch over, back in 2016, and it powers the Google Search answer box. I have no idea how profitable that answer box is, but I'm fairly certain that Google Search is profitable. The Google Home speaker voice recognition is also powered by ML models.
Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:30PM (#35647950)
Assistant however never made money.
Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:30PM (#35647946)
I use GPT about 100x more than search now for my day to day work. I pay them $20/mo. I’d likely pay $100 or more for the value I’m getting.

They’ll figure it out.

Re:Google DeepMind by kenjackson on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:55AM (#35649942)
TikTok uses a bunch of AI. From their algorithm for the FYP. To vision for classification of videos. And sound processing to bucket sounds/music. This feeds into their rec engine as well as their safety engine.
Re:Google DeepMind by safog on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:21PM (#35644047)
The cat's out of the bag now, it doesn't take a genius PM to work it out. Maybe a genius PM could've worked out how revolutionary generative AI is going to be pre- chat GPT release but I really doubt that a random MBA who knows nothing about AI can do that. Every single day there's a cool new AI application. The problem space is fairly fleshed out. It's a matter of executing.

How do you make enterprise tools better? (Photoshop + AI, Code + AI etc.) How do you make consumer tools better? (YT tools + AI) How do you make search better?

etc. etc.

Re:Google DeepMind by bartwr on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:13PM (#35644776)
As someone who's been at Google Research ~5y, this nails is it 100%.

I was at the non-Brain part of Research and it was seen as Google Brain is the "cool", pure research one, dealing with some future abstract AI and not caring for the products, feasibility, or even if the research "could" be made practical any day.

Deepmind was an "extreme" version of it, with some animosities and politics between the two, which I didn't follow too closely. There were attempts at making Deepmind useful, called "Deepmind for Google", but the people there were... clueless. Though one really cool thing came out of it (XManager).

(I was at a closer to the product part, "Perception", which I loved. And still got to publish, explore, pursue my own research goals, etc.)

Re:Google DeepMind by dmix on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:23PM (#35645771)
That's what great about competition. It kicks you in the pants and reminds you you need to try.

iPhone scared the shit out of the phone market and today we have great phones from Samsung and Google which dominate the market. If everyone was trying to predict the smartphone market in 2007 they'd be talking about how Nokia missed the boat but excited to see their response (or Motorola/Sony/Blackberry etc). The market today won't necessarily be the market in 10yrs from now. It might be Google, they have a solid head start to be #2 and future #1, but who knows what will happen and whether that talent/advantage stays in Google.

It could just as easily be other companies we don't even consider serious players today.

Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:28PM (#35647928)
* dominate the low-end of the market. Apple has the platform where users have money to spend on apps and services.
Re:Google DeepMind by 76SlashDolphin on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:39PM (#35648451)
* dominate the global market. Apple is a very minor player outside of the US and Japan.
Re:Google DeepMind by throwaway2037 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:22PM (#35648758)
"very minor player": I do not agree. I Googled for: "iphone market share by country"

Here is the top hit: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/iphone-ma...

What is wild to me: This is a single company. Android has a huge number of makers.

Re:Google DeepMind by canjobear on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:56PM (#35649684)
Nearly 100% in North Korea!
Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:24PM (#35649110)
I’m not in favor of it, but most of the global market is too poor to matter.

One of the things I do respect Google for is providing services to poor people, but that doesn’t mean it’s a business advantage.

If you offered me control of the entire Android ecosystem or just Apples iPhone business I’d not even blink to take Apple.

Re:Google DeepMind by seanmcdirmid on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:50AM (#35649914)
They also have the majority of profits in mobile phone sales.
Re:Google DeepMind by rvba on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:26AM (#35651098)
From technical perspective apple phones are usually few years behind competition.
Re:Google DeepMind by pharmakom on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:54AM (#35651288)
Except in CPU / GPU which is a strange state of affairs.
Re:Google DeepMind by sentinalien on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:37AM (#35651542)
Really depends on what you're thinking of when you say technical
Re:Google DeepMind by rvba on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:39PM (#35657318)
My Samsung phone was waterproof long before Apple had it.
Re:Google DeepMind by salad-tycoon on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:49PM (#35659060)
I bought an s7 or s10 which was waterproof and took photos under the water. Iirc apple was rumored to also be waterproof at the time but it was advertised.

I don’t know how true these things were. Did anyone else get this perception?

Re:Google DeepMind by xiphias2 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:49PM (#35646085)
Ilya _was_ at Google Brain, so something doesn’t add up there. I believe people wanted to launch things, but higher management stopped it.

I was next to the team that created Allo’s chat bot, but they said that they had to take out most cool stuff because legal didn’t allow it to launch, so they had to dumb it down totally.

I believe the main problem was all the ethics/safety teams that just hired a lot of non-programmers, while OpenAI management treated safety as an engineering problem that has to be solved with a technical solution.

Re:Google DeepMind by fnbr on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:53PM (#35646926)
Yeah, but Ilya left. Doesn't that prove your point?
Re:Google DeepMind by bushbaba on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:20AM (#35650041)
OpenAI isn’t a multibillion profitable public company with many prior lost (some won) lawsuits. To some extent they didn’t have anything to loose by cutting corners.

This is one of startups greatest advantages over established players.

Re:Google DeepMind by kmac_ on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:20AM (#35650338)
Microsoft is a multibillion profitable public company and they managed to extend the search in no time. Google is not as effective as it could be. They have great engineering and they proved that many times, but something is not working on the product design side.
Re:Google DeepMind by xyzzy123 on Friday April 21, 2023 @08:18AM (#35652609)
Microsoft took a pretty crazy risk (and Bing Chat was pretty spicy at the start...) but it makes sense they were more motivated to do this because they are not the market leader.

One way to evaluate the risk differential is by revenue, which is 20x greater for Google.

Re:Google DeepMind by rmbyrro on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:37AM (#35651544)
This is such a lousy excuse on Google part. We see multi-billion public companies bringing bold innovative products to extremely regulated sectors, like pharmaceutical and medical devices. Google can't deploy a chatbot because of lawsuits? Oh, c'mon...
Re:Google DeepMind by svantana on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:04AM (#35652079)
Hindsight is 20/20. Before ChatGPT, chatbots had a lousy track record. Pretty much any such project run by bigtech had been cancelled due to PR issues ("Tay" etc).
Re:Google DeepMind by htrp on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:50PM (#35659903)
MSFT got their fingers burned on Tay but were still willing to do a chatbot.

Google didn't even bother despite having all the tech in place.

and i can't believe I'm saying this but it seems microsoft has the ability to at least deliver innovation.

Re:Google DeepMind by rmbyrro on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:35AM (#35651532)
So the problem at Google is not the lack of good product managers and engineers, but the lack of bold leadership, then.
Re:Google DeepMind by theefer on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:06PM (#35647735)
Not to nitpick, but XManager was built by the Platform team at DeepMind, not DeepMind for Google, though they helped roll it out beyond DeepMind.

(I was on the XManager team in Platform.)

Re:Google DeepMind by kabes on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:55AM (#35652009)
What is xmanager?
Re:Google DeepMind by boulos on Friday April 21, 2023 @11:05AM (#35654890)
Re:Google DeepMind by attractivechaos on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:23PM (#35644925)
> they need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it.

I would say they more need engineers who care about and can make good products. In my limited experience, it takes time to turn a research-focused group into a product-oriented team. Research vs production requires different skill sets.

Re:Google DeepMind by walnutclosefarm on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:54PM (#35646129)
I completely agree. I was involved as a tech executive at a large medical center trying to get collaborative work with both Google per se, and DeepMind, to a usable or product stage, and it was essentially impossible. DeepMind in particular was more interested in pushing the research envelope, and getting more papers in Nature, than in building products.

I wouldn't underestimate the degree to which this is by design, from the very top of Google. Different Google and other Alphabet companies' executives more than once told me they just weren't interested in products that didn't have an obvious path to more than 1 billion users. The companies don't have a clue how to make money retail. If they can't print money with an idea, they don't have the tools and skills to bring it to market.

Re:Google DeepMind by momojo on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:20PM (#35647296)
I don't doubt your analysis of Google, but what was OpenAI able to do differently to get them here? Aren't they just another research hub?
Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Thursday April 20, 2023 @07:26PM (#35647908)
The deeper problem is the money people who lead Google have no imagination whatsoever and literally can’t figure out how to make money in anything that isn’t mining user data for ads. Cloud is a money pit, and will NEVER be #1 in the space.

They literally put more effort and resources into rigging ads auctions than trying to solve real user problems.

Re:Google DeepMind by candiodari on Friday April 21, 2023 @08:46AM (#35652885)
They're just making a correct calculation. Do we increase our $70 billion / quarter with 2% or do we put resources towards doubling the income of a $1 million / year product.

Yes, the answer isn't what you'd like, but let's not pretend it's not rational.

Re:Google DeepMind by nr2x on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:32PM (#35656220)
Innovators dilemma is the issue: that’s rational, until suddenly it isn’t, but by then it’s too late to change course.
Re:Google DeepMind by jrm4 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:46PM (#35648503)
To me, you've described a situation that's infinitely more a feature than a bug.

They don't pay me, so I don't care about their profits, but the stuff they've more-or-less given away and people don't think much about is their best stuff. Colab, Docs, Scholar, etc...

Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:30AM (#35650404)
Sure, but all of this disappears the second their money fountain (search) gets disrupted.
Re:Google DeepMind by krick on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:47PM (#35648508)
Well, I'm ok with Google having this "problem". Hopefully, they will produce a couple more of useful things, until it somehow kills Google or whatever.
Re:Google DeepMind by cjmcqueen on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:14PM (#35648695)
For a business to survive it needs competition. You could argue it was necessary to create competition in the AI space before business needs arise that Google could provide. Without competition, there's no way for the market to rise to demand. Google didn't give away stuff, they created demand.
Re:Google DeepMind by cafed00d on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:53PM (#35648943)
I would go farther still and say Google doesn’t need PMs — it needs a singularly bold visionary — a Satya Nadella or John Legere or maybe someone else — not a good ceo or a bad ceo; nor a polite ceo or a trash-talking tough ceo — they just need someone to yank the empire builders out and go all in on product building. Not product managing.
Re:Google DeepMind by thomasahle on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:47PM (#35649241)
How did Nadella yank the empire builders out of Microsoft?
Re:Google DeepMind by cafed00d on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:08PM (#35649382)
The Nadella example was meant to illustrate visionary & bold.

You’re right; my statement is not scientifically accurate

Re:Google DeepMind by thomasahle on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:35PM (#35649575)
I was just curious, since it seems impossible to remove empire builders.

I fear the only thing you can do is to start a new company. But maybe there's a way to better align the incentives...

Re:Google DeepMind by est on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:12PM (#35649405)
> because no one on the product side understood what they had actually built

and more because Google's mission was to "organize world information" instead of understanding, intepreting & utilizing world information.

https://www.google.com/search/howsearchworks/our-approach/

Re:Google DeepMind by sanderjd on Thursday April 20, 2023 @11:22PM (#35649483)
Isn't the exact opposite reading of this just as likely to be true from what we know so far? That rather than handing over the reins to DeepMind, they're actually reining them in and forcing them to work on productization?
Re:Google DeepMind by p-e-w on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:10AM (#35650009)
> Google doesn't need more smart AI researchers, academics or ethicists. They need product managers who understand the underlying technology and can commercialize it.

Google's revenue is equal to the GDP of New Zealand. Google's cash reserves are sufficient to sustain the company through half a century of bad quarters. Not that they have had any bad quarters, ever.

They don't need anything.

Their ad business is a donkey that shits gold, with Chrome and Android keeping the competition locked out, and everything else doesn't matter for Google as a company. They've done little more than play around for the last decade, with an endless procession of hyped-then-canceled "products", and it hasn't affected their market dominance in the slightest.

They can keep fucking up for the foreseeable future, and it won't really matter. If a startup emerges that appears to have the right approach to AI, Google can simply buy it. Power is power, and everything else is nothing.

Re:Google DeepMind by jiggawatts on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:38AM (#35650118)
Search has virtually no moat to luck customers in. People switched from AltaVista to Google fast!

I already use phind.com almost as much as I use Google. A significant percentage of the non-development "queries" that I have, I now ask ChatGPT 4.

I'm starting to suspect that within a year, I won't be using Google search much at all.

That should terrify everyone at Alphabet Inc.

Re:Google DeepMind by p-e-w on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:20AM (#35650340)
Google controls 90% of the browser market, and 70% of the mobile OS market. They can force anything they want down the throats of billions of people, the vast majority of which aren't even aware that there are alternatives. And even those that are aware are in many cases unable to switch, as for example most phones will only run their manufacturer's version of Android, from which Google features usually cannot be completely removed.

This isn't even remotely comparable to the AltaVista situation. Google has a planet-scale stranglehold on how half the world's population accesses information. This arguably makes Google more powerful than most nation states. I can guarantee they won't be dislodged by some search startup with a cool idea.

Re:Google DeepMind by jiggawatts on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:25AM (#35650361)
People switched away from Microsoft’s search offerings despite it being the default in Internet Explorer.
Re:Google DeepMind by malwrar on Friday April 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#35653285)
> Google has a planet-scale stranglehold on how half the world's population accesses information

…currently.

I think OP’s point is that once some better product comes out and e.g. normal people hear about it on tiktok and start switching, it doesn’t seem like Google is institutionally capable of competing. Honestly, considering how much good research they put out, I really hope they don’t.

Re:Google DeepMind by p-e-w on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:51AM (#35663435)
> it doesn’t seem like Google is institutionally capable of competing

They don't have to compete. They can just buy any startup that's a potential threat to them, or lobby for laws that would effectively make them illegal. That's what power is, and it's all that matters.

Re:Google DeepMind by paxys on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:21AM (#35650347)
You could have said the same about Compuserve or AOL or IBM or Xerox or HP at some point in their history. Where are all of them now?

Every untouchable business inevitably gets disrupted once the company can no longer stay competitive and get ahead of new trends. Same is happening with Google today.

Re:Google DeepMind by pas on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:06AM (#35650601)
IBM bought RedHat. And the Watson demo is very similar to the Waymo situation. It works, but no one can use it actually, but sure IBM pushed it for years ruthlessly.
Re:Google DeepMind by nailer on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:02AM (#35651326)
> Their ad business is a donkey that shits gold

So was Lotus Notes.

Re:Google DeepMind by p-e-w on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:54AM (#35663451)
There is a fundamental difference between some corporate groupware and a system that reaches 60% of all humans alive.
Re:Google DeepMind by nailer on Saturday April 22, 2023 @01:39AM (#35663701)
Sure, then use Netscape in your example. Something used to be part of the Internet, and many people was the Internet, and is now irrelevant.

Scrolling through search results to answer a question manually instead of simply getting an answer feels like using the Internet from 20 years ago.

Re:Google DeepMind by p-e-w on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:49AM (#35664021)
Netscape was a company during a time when using the Internet was a niche activity.

Google is one of the most powerful entities in the history of mankind, with read/write access to the private information of the majority of humans alive.

The two aren't comparable. Indeed, there are few entities that are comparable to Google. Google won't use their technological edge to keep potential competitors out, they'll use their financial, social, and political power.

Re:Google DeepMind by nailer on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:06AM (#35664088)
I don’t think they will. And I think like lotus notes running groupware, like windows running the desktop, like novell running the lan, Google will always rule search, and never make the transition into the next thing.

The company hasn’t released the significant product in 15 years, despite the huge amount of money they have this will be not be enough to change the culture.

Re:Google DeepMind by vishnugupta on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:42AM (#35650140)
It’s hard to overstate how far ahead of everyone else DeepMind was as far back as 7-8 years ago. When AlphaGo burst on scene it blew everyone’s mind and even redefined what’s possible by an AI agent. I had thought back then surely Google will figure out a way to convert those research breakthroughs into consumer products.

And yet here we are. If anything it’s a great example of how a “money printer” business, Google’s ad business, makes an org into a lazy, risk averse and accumulates an army of empire builders who collectively breed promo culture.

Combine that with a decade of 0% interest rates which also boosted its stock price and it’s no wonder that Google is struggling on so many fronts.

Re:Google DeepMind by gofreddygo on Friday April 21, 2023 @01:47AM (#35650160)
> They need pragmatic engineers who can execute, launch and maintain services

Not the job description Google has for engineers. Their hiring process effectively eliminates anyone who matches that description and bothers to put themselves through it.

Re:Google DeepMind by maegul on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:14AM (#35650297)
So Google did a Xerox PARC or an IBM PC (to a lesser extent)?

It’s curious how predictable it is that a major player is going to fall into this trap at any point in time. There’s probably some way you could measure its likelihood if you were tracking internal comms, org charts and maybe some finely designed survey data.

Re:Google DeepMind by stevev on Friday April 21, 2023 @02:29AM (#35650390)
I couldn’t agree more.

Research is great, but when there’s no platform, nothing stands.

Among some of the biggest flop in history by starting so late.

We’ll have to see how their generative text to videos do.

Re:Google DeepMind by dudeinjapan on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:45AM (#35651601)
Nah bruh they just need to make an AI that is smart enough to do the marketing for them. Give it time.
Re:Google DeepMind by tomerbd on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:11AM (#35652126)
just take a couple of engineers and ask them to solve real world problems.