News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by rjbwork on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:08PM (#35632039)
This is what today's IP oligopolists would have happen to the bulk of culture. I find it exceedingly unlikely that all IP will be maintained by the owner for the life of the author plus 70 years. We know there are gobs of cultural artifacts from as recently as the 80s (videos, games, etc.) that are permanently lost.

Without short copyright terms and the encouragement of independent archivalists, we ensure most cultural artifacts will be lost to time.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by vlunkr on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:29PM (#35632264)
Sadly pirates are a critical piece of media preservation.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:30PM (#35632288)
Why sadly?

If the corporation who owns the original IP, abandoned it for 10+ years with no way of legitimately buying it from them, then it's fair game.

I'm doing my part.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by skyyler on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:33PM (#35632333)
Sadly; because a noble pursuit has been reduced to literal crime...
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by vlunkr on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:39PM (#35632392)
Exactly. If the content owners were more responsible, or if IP laws were better, it wouldn't be necessary.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by jzb on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:24PM (#35632863)
Sadly because the industry actively fights against it, and people can be punished for it.

Also "sadly" because it's not exactly a dependable process -- we're depending on people to spontaneously choose to preserve / share media widely enough there will be decent copies when/if they go out of "legitimate" circulation.

It'd be better if archiving & preserving copies were a mandatory step to being awarded copyright protection. (Which would not displace filesharing, of course...)

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ryandrake on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:51PM (#35633174)
Another sad thing is the mentality of IP rightsholders. For abandoned songs/movies/works that don't make any money anymore, they'd rather expend the cost/effort to destroy them than allow them to be distributed for free, even though destroying them is likely more expensive. Totally malicious. Reminds me of grocery stores that throw out food at the end of the day and spend effort guarding the dumpsters so nobody gets food for free.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by JasserInicide on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:55PM (#35632559)
Lots of rare music found nowhere else was lost when what.cd got shut down
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by charcircuit on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:33PM (#35632965)
Shutting down a tracker doesn't delete the files people have.

The music wasn't lost. It just became harder to pirate.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by WeylandYutani on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:32PM (#35632954)
This may sound like a conspiracy but I think the industry wants people to buy new content not enjoy the hits from yesteryear.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by stinkytaco on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:01PM (#35633280)
I think they want you to rebuy old content in new forms, pure profit. Or better yet, rent it in perpetuity.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by jwagenet on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:05PM (#35633902)
This is more or less what the entire entertainment industry is doing with endless reboots, sequels, remasters, new formats, etc.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by rockemsockem on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:07PM (#35633344)
There was some study I saw, maybe even released by Spotify, that showed that a massive percentage (maybe a majority?) of streamed music was several decades old.

So they're raking in cash from rent seeking really. It would be healthier for music if what you said was true though.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by azinman2 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:07PM (#35635908)
This makes sense. People largely listen to whatever was new/popular in their childhood through 20s.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ghaff on Thursday April 20, 2023 @02:44AM (#35637101)
Some people are more musically adventurous than others or they sometimes latch onto a new genre or artist. But the reality is that most of us largely default to what we listened to in school or maybe the decade after. I know I listen to relatively little music created in the past 20 years and don't really care if a streaming service is missing XYZ newish artist.

I actually have quite a large, somewhat curated digital music library and, with a few hundred dollars and a few days of effort, I could probably patch any particular holes I have among songs/albums I especially enjoy, but mostly I use streaming including a lot of curated playlists.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by beerandt on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:31PM (#35633569)
Do any music trackers still exist?

Not looking to out any underground trackers, but am curious as someone who wasn't ever on what.cd and hasn't ever replaced long "hiatus" then gone waffles.

Does any active and/or extensive site survive?

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by dtx1 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:37PM (#35633627)
redacted is supposed to be the new whatcd using a similar interview process and all.

To be fair i'm out of the piracy game when it comes to music though since spotify is more convenient to use

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by beerandt on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:26PM (#35634951)
Microsoft (zune) and then Google (music) have me not even trusting the convenience of paid subscriptions anymore.

Even if you keep some music, you lose useful history, playlists, etc.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by throwaway689236 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:10PM (#35635549)
It's hard not to recall Gabe Newell's "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem". Steam and Spotify offer a really good service, and a lot of people find it not worth it to pirate stuff.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by dtx1 on Friday April 21, 2023 @09:32AM (#35653475)
'specially as a linux user. Dealing with Wine/Proton on my own vs just buying it on steam and have it justwork^tm is worth it almost everytime, especially when using cheap steamkey stores.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by amatecha on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:43PM (#35636121)
Yeah I guess Spotify is okay if you don't mind half of the back catalogue of your favorite artists either never being present on the platform, or just magically disappearing at some arbitrary time. It's hilarious, I canceled my Spotify service a year ago or something, and I hopped back on recently to check a playlist as I couldn't remember a song. So many tracks in my playlists are no longer available on the service. Had me feeling pretty good about my colossal archive of purchased mp3s/FLACs from Bandcamp.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by yellowapple on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:54AM (#35639196)
Yep. Spotify had at one point completely eliminated my desire to torrent entire discographies, but my listening is starting to shift to Bandcamp and youtube-dl'd MP3s/M4As with Spotify getting increasingly worse both on the library front and on a technical level with its app.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tern on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:48PM (#35633727)
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Nemrod67 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:08AM (#35637796)
rutracker.org

been getting my Prog-Rock-Fusion fix from there, they have a lot of stuff

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by akomtu on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:57PM (#35632582)
Pirates are just independent corsairs. The latter are pirates who work for the king, they are doing the same kind of robbery, but since the king profits off it, they are called "legal". That's what modern copyright holders are: pirates backed by the king.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by strken on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:16PM (#35632793)
This is wrong. Privateers, which is the more general class corsairs belonged to, were akin to modern PMCs and operated under similar constraints. They mostly obeyed the rules of war, were punished when they did not, and their conduct was similar to national ships in nearly every regard. They took prisoners of war and were taken prisoner in turn.

When one group is taking ships and killing every living thing on it then illegally selling the cargo and personal effects of the occupants, and another group is taking ships and dropping the occupants off at a POW camp then sending it to the admiralty to be legally sold, the latter is not doing the same kind of robbery. Arguably they aren't doing any kind of robbery at all.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by bee_rider on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:58PM (#35633256)
It was the colonial era, right? That a gang of thieves and thugs stole enough to afford fancy wigs and crowns doesn’t make them legitimate.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by strken on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:03PM (#35633302)
The legitimacy of a government, or lack thereof, does not make executing the entire crew of a ship morally equivalent to sending them to a POW camp.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by boomboomsubban on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:19AM (#35637863)
I don't think pirates regularly executed the entire crew of a ship either. There's no monetary benefit in doing so, it will encourage reprisals, and future ships will refuse to surrender.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by akomtu on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:04PM (#35635516)
Once we drop the legality fig leaf, because that's a matter of who writes the law, we'll see an organized gang of pirates that follow some rules, wear an emblem, and have bosses on the land who sell things captured in the sea.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:59PM (#35632600)
Happily, file sharing enthusiasts are a critical piece of media preservation.

Piracy is a violent crime, file sharing is not comparable to it in any way.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by nine_k on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:05PM (#35632651)
To say the truth, files to be shared often need to be produced first: books scanned and OCRed, DVDs grabbed and repackaged, games actually cracked, etc. There is a scene beyond just people running Bittorrent nodes.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by pizzaknife on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:18PM (#35632799)
If it is as truly violent as the "piracy" label suggests, then is this not "war on drugs" in another vestige?
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by nine_k on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:36PM (#35633621)
I can agree that "piracy" is an unnecessarily violent label (no swords, no drowned ships), but it sort of became the standard word in media.

AFAICT the actual scene prefers terns like "release group", because it's indeed what they do: release bits from the confines of DRM or dead trees.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:37PM (#35633010)
a better word would be parasites...
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by rockemsockem on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:05PM (#35633323)
Quite the opposite actually.

Studies have found that those who pirate content tend to purchase significantly more content than the average person.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:19AM (#35637266)
this is obviously bull though.. how do you even make a study like that? you'd need to associate each illegal downloader to his/her real identity and then to each of their legal purchases... that's ridiculous, and even if academics had the means to do it, it would be illegal. piracy itself is illegal in most countries, so if you don't report them you are literally an accomplice.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:23AM (#35637281)
Also, I can understand the downvotes, but why the flagging? You can call them thieves, but not parasites? I feel that HN has become quite censorship-heavy lately.

To elaborate on that, people often claim it's not theft because the owner keeps the goods. That's why it's more appropriate to consider it parasitism (you are eating at someone else's table without paying).

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:51PM (#35633758)
> Happily, file sharing enthusiasts are a critical piece of media preservation.

> Piracy is a violent crime, file sharing is not comparable to it in any way.

Sorry, the meaning of "pirate" you dislike is already firmly established, and you're frankly not going to be able to change that.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pirate

> 2: to take or appropriate by piracy: such as

> a: to reproduce without authorization especially in infringement of copyright

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:45PM (#35635412)
Even if it's fruitless in the end, we're still gonna shame the use of the word "piracy" on sight. It's quite simply offensive to compare the copying of bits to high seas piracy which includes murder and rape. Of course the copyright monopolists had to spin up such propaganda: copyright infringement just has no weight to it.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:24AM (#35639562)
> Even if it's fruitless in the end, we're still gonna shame the use of the word "piracy" on sight.

Who's this "we"?

> It's quite simply offensive to compare the copying of bits to high seas piracy which includes murder and rape.

You are talking that way, way too seriously and interpreting it in weird way in order to take maximum offense.

And my point is it isn't a comparison: "pirate" has an established meaning that is literally your "file sharing enthusiasts." Also, actual high-seas piracy has diminished to the point where "pirates" is mainly understood as file-sharing pirates or as goofy cartoon characters (e.g. "talk like a pirate day" and "Pirates of the Caribbean").

> Of course the copyright monopolists had to spin up such propaganda: copyright infringement just has no weight to it.

It should be noted your alternative "file sharing enthusiasts" is at least as propagandistic, just from the opposite party.

Not that I think copyright piracy is that big if a deal, it's just that computer geeks' overwrought stridency on the issue is obnoxious and obscures more than it informs.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by matheusmoreira on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:09AM (#35664384)
> Who's this "we"?

People such as myself and the person you replied to.

> You are talking that way, way too seriously

I am. It is a serious matter.

> interpreting it in weird way in order to take maximum offense

Yes, I take maximum offense when some monopolist tries to compare me to rapers and pillagers because I copied bits.

> You have do to a lot of deliberate work to strain to take offense at the association.

Not at all. Actual piracy is still happening even today in the 21st century. Everyone knows exactly what a pirate is and it's exactly what comes to mind when someone mentions them. It's not some forgotten history only geeks know about. People will even mentally picture those very same "file sharing enthusiasts" you mention as roguish types when in fact perfectly normal people forwarding pictures, videos and documents on WhatsApp are a perfect fit for the definition. People literally infringe copyright every day at massive scales without even realizing it. They infringe copyright when they save a picture from a web site.

> It should be noted your alternative "file sharing enthusiasts" is at least as propagandistic, just from the opposite party.

Except I didn't use those terms. I used the proper one: copyright infringement. Sounds like a whole lot of nothing when put that way, doesn't it?

> it's just that computer geeks' overwrought stridency on the issue is obnoxious and obscures more than it informs.

So the copyright industry insists on using propaganda words like "piracy" purely to add weight to copyright infringement and make it seem more real than it really is but I'm the one obscuring the issue? Right.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by guy98238710 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @07:19PM (#35634524)
I like to tell people I am a pirate though. I think it sounds cool.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by musicale on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:25PM (#35634948)
Cambridge dictionary [1] has this definition:

> piracy noun [ U ] UK /ˈpaɪərəsi/ US

> IT, LAW

> the act of illegally copying computer programs, recordings, films, etc. to sell them at much cheaper prices

What's interesting is that this definition includes selling.

So by this definition at least, regular file sharing of copyrighted media, even illegal or infringing distribution, would not qualify as piracy, since no sale is involved.

[1] https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/piracy

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by TylerE on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:06PM (#35635528)
If you pay attention, the sites that get taken down are often laden with ads, so rather lose the ability to claim some sort of non-commercial exemption.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by judge2020 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:24PM (#35632214)
I don't think copyright has much to do with it, but rather the lack of (cheap) recording/duplicating equipment people had access to before the 80's. As soon as VCRs were on the scene, your average American quickly got to recording broadcast content to VHS tapes for either sharing it with friends or personal archival.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by MPSimmons on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:33PM (#35632331)
The point of the parent comment is that, if the copyright people had their way, VCRs and the like would be irrelevant, because they would make it so that you _couldn't_ back up media. It's a pattern that keeps repeating itself. Copyright owners with deep enough pockets try to build "anti-piracy" technical measures which actually just prevent people from backing up their media, while piracy continues unabated regardless of those technical hurdles that impact 99% of people.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:28PM (#35633531)
> The point of the parent comment is that, if the copyright people had their way, VCRs and the like would be irrelevant, because they would make it so that you _couldn't_ back up media.

The (grand)parent comment didn't talk about any of that.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by MPSimmons on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @07:48PM (#35634725)
I don't really want to get into an argument on HackerNews about this, but I took it as read in this sentence:

>This is what today's IP oligopolists would have happen to the bulk of culture

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by rjbwork on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:47PM (#35635423)
Correct, this is exactly what I was referring to w/ that sentence.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by acomjean on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:34PM (#35635009)
It was hard to back up media. Those vcrs had macro vision that made coping bought movies hard (we tried). Without the internet it was hard to tell why it was failing.

You could tape over the air stuff though.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Teever on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:07PM (#35635201)
macrovision is a prime example of those copyright owners making it hard.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by LocalH on Thursday April 20, 2023 @10:16AM (#35640336)
Correct. Jack Valenti famously equated the VCR to the Boston Strangler.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by zehaeva on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:32PM (#35632315)
I'm sure all of those VHS tapes are still perfectly viewable today!
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by GalenErso on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:23PM (#35632207)
I download YouTube videos I like. A number of them aren't available anymore. As far as I am aware, I have the last backups. I've also downloaded obscure .swf files and weird soundtracks and sound effects from obscure and now deprecated flash games I used to play in my youth.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by hakonhaki on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:37PM (#35632374)
Not a huge collector but so checkout moonwalk.swf

Not too hard to find, but a beautiful animation of a human struggling yo walk home on the moon… you’ll love it

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Ruthalas on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:55PM (#35634337)
If you feel like chatting with others who also archive YouTube (and other) content, consider stopping by my discord server: https://discord.gg/rgBHGm9mTC

We maintain a central list [1] of content that various members have archived, so that when content is removed from YouTube, people can direct inquiries to contributors who have archived that content.

It's a small way to keep track of what things have been successfully archived, and sometimes direct efforts to preserve specific content.

[1] https://tinyurl.com/v4rpe9w

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by amatecha on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:47PM (#35636144)
Yeah I've started doing the same. When I [rarely] log into my YT account to find an old favorite from a couple years ago or whatever, I notice that something like 2/3 of my Favorites are unavailable now (I've been using YT since it launched so that kinda skews the chances in that direction of course, but the point remains).
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by beerandt on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:54PM (#35632550)
Idk the exact mechanisms that should be used, but have long said that copyright protection of all forms should be dependent on the rights holder depositing and funding the archival (to a minimum length of the expiration of the work's copyright + x years), such that public has access to the work upon expiration.

Include a mechanism that allows encryption keys to be held in escrow, to be released publicly for all drm schemes the work is released on.

The LoC may or may not be the best avenue for such a scheme, but it should be funded by the rights holder as a condition of the protected term (or maybe for an extension beyond a base term of ~12years ala patents).

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by beerandt on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:23PM (#35634084)
To reply to the dead sibling comment:

Depositing a copy of a book to the LoC is already the (dated) default behavior for hard-copy published text. Even if it's not strictly required, it mostly works.

But as I said, perhaps you get a base 12 years protection just by publishing (the status quo, but shorter base term), and only register the source/ archive if protection beyond that is financially worthwhile.

DRM content that wants DMCA type protection (hopefully a more reasonably thought out protection) requires a single tested key in escrow per protected work, or doesn't get any circumvention or takedown protection.

The exact mechanisms and terms would need to be tweaked by format and maybe even market, but the idea is to create underlying aligned incentives, without unduly burdening casual creators who might not wish to opt-in.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by 6510 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @07:53PM (#35634762)
I'm honestly curious, what does it cost per year to archive a picture?
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by bazoom42 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:59PM (#35632610)
It is not illegal to own and preserve media which is still under copyright. IP is not the problem, the problem is nobody cared until it was too late.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:34PM (#35633598)
Format shifting in the US is only permitted for audio recordings. Doing the same for video is a copyright violation even if you keep it to yourself.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ShadowBanThis01 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:38AM (#35637362)
That’s only true if you have to circumvent encryption.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:10PM (#35642213)
Copyright law from before DMCA still applies. It doesn't just disappear because it's easy to make copies.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ShadowBanThis01 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:16PM (#35646460)
Copyright law didn't prevent you from copying video for home use. Look up the Disney vs. Sony case, which was a landmark.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:16PM (#35648284)
If that were true there would have been no need for the AHRA. Copying audio tapes at home was a copyright violation. Doing the same for VHS was and still is.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ShadowBanThis01 on Friday April 21, 2023 @12:31AM (#35649816)
No. That was still based on DIGITAL recording, and the lie that "perfect digital copies" would cause an explosion of piracy. And of course our "representatives" toadied up to the corporations and abetted them in screwing consumers. And, by levying an asinine "tax" on blank media, it actually AUTHORIZED home copying by presuming guilt.

Anybody, yes ANYBODY based in reality knew that essentially all "piracy" took place in dorm rooms and bedrooms on double-cassette boom boxes... FAR from "perfect" copies. People who could afford DAT recorders were not going to be sapping record-company profits.

And we all know what happened next: The "perfect digital copies" lie was further debunked with the ascendancy of MP3... another lossy and imperfect reproduction.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by mypastself on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:10PM (#35632723)
Per the article, first ever attempts at preservation were intended for copyright protection. I’m not following the logic of why IP owners would want media to become lost.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by hnbad on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:18AM (#35637858)
The logic is called "tax write-off":

https://collider.com/final-space-pulled-from-streaming/

Of course in this case it's still possible the studio retains original copies in its archives but according to the article, the write-off means the show can not be re-released so those copies literally have no value to the IP owners and might be destroyed, too.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by vkou on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:13PM (#35632758)
> Without short copyright terms and the encouragement of independent archivalists, we ensure most cultural artifacts will be lost to time. Which is great for creating cultural scarcity, because it means that people will:

1. Keep buying new things.

2. Pay through the nose for rare old cultural artifacts.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by justinator on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:22PM (#35632835)
Someone's gunna lose the private key for all that DRM media and then whoops.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by dclowd9901 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:22PM (#35633486)
It seems like there needs to be some understanding of “benefitting from one’s own work” as part of this conversation.

If I make a thing, and am actively providing it for consumption, I have an interest in maintaining its integrity.

Contrarily, if I have made something, but it’s just sitting idling away as something I simply own as an IP, it will be allowed to languish, in every sense of the word.

There are similar concepts with trademarks; if you don’t actively defend trademark usages, you stand the risk of losing it to the public domain.

Likewise, if you don’t actually provide your creation to the public in a consumable way, you should lose the ability to claim it.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:42PM (#35633665)
> This is what today's IP oligopolists would have happen to the bulk of culture. I find it exceedingly unlikely that all IP will be maintained by the owner for the life of the author plus 70 years. We know there are gobs of cultural artifacts from as recently as the 80s (videos, games, etc.) that are permanently lost.

> Without short copyright terms and the encouragement of independent archivalists, we ensure most cultural artifacts will be lost to time.

Firstly, copyright doesn't have anything do with the problem outlined in the OP, that 75% of "golden age" silent movies have been lost. The reason it identifies is that these films were "few, fragile, flammable" and that "almost no one thought they were worth saving." Copies weren't going to magically appear: if they were fragile, expensive to produce, and viewed as ephemeral nothing short of some kind of expensive government mandate would have led to much higher preservation rates. Such a mandate would not happen unless there was a contemporary interest in preservation, which there wasn't.

Secondly, running an archive isn't free. Short copyright terms might actually lead to less preservation, since that would make the creator be even less motivated to preserve the work for the long term. I'm not sure what you mean by "independent archivalists," but if it's data hoarders (individuals or collectively) that's not really going to cut it. The data on someone's hard drive array is very unlikely live past its owner, it will be almost certainly junked by the heirs to the estate. Preservation really requires an institution.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by cogman10 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:50PM (#35633747)
> Secondly, running an archive isn't free. Short copyright terms might actually lead to less preservation, since that would make the creator be even less motivated to preserve the work for the long term.

Yet archives have very high public value. We've recognized that since the formation of the library of congress.

The issue I think we have is we already have a system mandated to archive copyrighted material, yet it's not been advanced to accommodate the digital era and there's no mandate that IP holders aid it in retention.

I think increasing public spending so the likes of archive.org can continue to function would be a net good for society.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:07AM (#35637520)
> Firstly, copyright doesn't have anything do with the problem outlined in the OP

Sure but it will probably lead to the same thing happening again.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:59AM (#35640030)
>> Firstly, copyright doesn't have anything do with the problem outlined in the OP

> Sure but it will probably lead to the same thing happening again.

No. The "same thing" is was people didn't preserve things that other people now wish were saved... but only just barely. No one here actually aching to see the lost silent flim "The Devil Dancer" or would watch it if they could, they're just reacting to a statistic. Here's another statistic 99.9999...% of everything ever said has been lost. None of that has anything to do with copyright, and eliminating copyright would hardly change a thing.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:16PM (#35646467)
I don’t think your conclusion follows from your premise. Things were lost in the past because no copies survived. Now we have machines which can copy a million books a second and hard drives which can store thousands of movies, but we’ve created a powerful legal regime which discourages the proliferation of archives of this material.

Google tried to archive every book in existence, and was stopped by copyright. In our lifetimes copyright has prevented preservation. The whole effort of google books was shut down half way through. Who knows what they would have preserved if they continued.

Your suggestion that no one here really wants to see these films is irrelevant. Someone studying film might want to learn how film techniques progressed. Someone studying technology might want to learn how certain effects were achieved. Someone studying sociology might want to learn how social messages have evolved (or stayed the same) over the years. Lots of information will have been lost with these films.

Punishing and discouraging copying will certainly help ensure that fewer copies survive. Discs will rot, licenses will change hands, and the few copies that survive will dwindle and vanish.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by javajosh on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:43PM (#35633680)
Surely that much data has value somewhere, and a marketplace can be formed where decaying film on one side is auctioned to AI training data stores on the other. Older material is more valuable since it starts human measurement earlier, and so can predict longer-term shifts.

(Imagination in service to neoliberal capitalism - it's a real world _Hyperion_ novel, forums like this mind-jack you with arcane symbols into miniscule wiggles in the GHz range, roughly 1500*8 bytes of them at a time, pushed through a radio, into the kernel, into a program, and spat out into an array of glowing quantum effects... But still, even here, Buster Keaton is funny.)

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by snowwrestler on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:48PM (#35633730)
Copyright laws govern distribution, and permit noncommercial uses such as archiving copies. Technologically it has never been easier to capture and store media, and many people and organizations do.

Things from the 80s are permanently lost simply because no one bothered to preserve copies of them.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:02PM (#35633871)
Yeah it's easy, but nobody does it for real.

I live in a small country with a weird language, that was one a part of a larger country with a few other weird languages and a lot of good music.

A bunch of that music is lost forever now... some newer artists still play the old songs, but there are no recorded originals. For some songs you can only find shitty quality recordings on youtube when someone recorded an audio tape to a youtube video at shitty quality and split into 10minute chunks. Original recording studios don't exist anymore, CDs maybe existed, maybe not, tapes surely did, but those degraded a lot, modern streaming has made piracy hard, since there are not a lot of listeners who would rip that, and youtube only has that song in a video format, with a video intro, and a silent part in between to make the video make sense (unlike a radio edit). And even if people somehow downloaded and stored that music, how am I supposed to get it too? Torrenting is hard for many people, services like kazaa don't exist anymore, existing torrent sites close down, zero seeders on what's left over and even less ways to actually find it online.

Yeah, sure, all that music could fit on a single modern hard drive, but nobody put it there and made it available for others, and in turn, it is lost, either fully (noone has the HQ original anymore) or partially (some people have it, for now, but others are unable to obtain it).

I'd much prefer some national archive taking those recordings (music, videos, books, etc.), digitizing them (or preferably starting with a digital version) and then offer it for download after some reasonable amount of time (which would be way shorter than death+70 years). A good indicator for 'when' would be the availability of the media... Am I unable to buy it in a reasonable way for a reasonable price? Ok, it's protected. Noone is selling it anymore, or not selling it in my country (even digitally)... the author/publshed obviously doesn't want my money, so why complain if it's on offer for free.

TLDR: think of your favourite non-mainstream band from 20 years ago and try to download their songs.. good luck with that.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by bratwurst3000 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:58PM (#35634364)
What Alan lomax did or what fat possum record are doing is extremely hard work and it’s sad that there aren’t many more people like those. If somone would start a kickstarter to preserve old traditional music I would be the first to support them.

Btw if you don’t know them there is a amazing documentary from fat possum about their work on YouTube.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by breck on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:59PM (#35633839)
Stephan Kinsella's talk "Intellectual Nonsense: Fallacious Arguments for IP", is a must watch. There's no reason to have IP law and in fact there is actually good reason to believe they stand on shaky legal ground.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0RXfGGMGPE

One of the arguments he brings up is that the Constitution specifically says "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts". It can be argued that IP law does not do this. In fact it does the opposite. As soon as you have a patent or copyright on something you are incentivized to not promote the progress of science and arts, at least not until your monopoly terms expire (which is never, with the copyright extensions).

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Animats on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:20AM (#35637272)
Even better, there's this report from the Republican Study Group, in 2012, recommending shorter copyright terms.[1]

The staffer who wrote that was fired.

[1] https://archive.org/details/RscThreeMythsAboutCopyrightLaw/

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by throwaway689236 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:25PM (#35635288)
Intellectual property is not really a property, it's a limited time monopoly preference. If you have a chair as your property, it doesn't magically become public property in N years, it's yours forever. Because it's a real property, unlike IP.

More than that, IP is anti-property in nature, because it restricts you from using your real property, you can't use your printing press to print a book that you like.

I know that there's an argument to be made about authors wanting to eat, but that's a separate issue, it doesn't change the fact that IP is logically inconsistent and the "property" part is misleading.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by zdw on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:46PM (#35635419)
"Imaginary Property" might be a better name for this pattern of thought.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by fritzo on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:12PM (#35635564)
Gosh how many folks here believe any sort of property is "real"? I guess I see intellectual property as made up rules, just like exclusion rights on real property are made up rules. We're just riffing off mammalian instinct. We have complete freedom to make up different rules.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by slim on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:56PM (#35635836)
"property" is the simplest form of governance, whereas a resource is assigned to a person which takes all the decisions regarding the subject including transferring the property to another person. it's really a very old governance model well understood in most societies.

now IP is a confusing form of governance because all the contradictions mentioned by gran parent comment while being named "property" and because it's being applied to something that is not a resource which means it does not even need governance in first place

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by bcrosby95 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:28AM (#35636412)
I've come to view physical property as the odd one out.

IP makes sense to me - you are assigning ownership of purely human created constructs, and someone assigning me Mickey Mouse doesn't use up a resource and prevent you from making your own IP.

But physical property... you're telling me that someone ('someone' being a government - who probably took it by force from some other group of people) can just "assign" me something no human had a hand in creating, I can morph it, then sell it to some other person for a buck? The whole chain of custody is tainted. I should not be able to "own" these things no human created, at best, I should be able to rent it from

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by vkou on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:08AM (#35637522)
Exclusion rules of some kind are generally necessary for something that only one person can use at a time.

IP does not have that property.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by beerandt on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @11:16PM (#35635959)
IP was always taught to me as a negative right. Easiest explained with patents:

In that owning a patent doesn't even give you the right to make the invention described, it only allows you to prevent others from making it.

Especially true if you patent an improvement of someone else's patented invention.

Your patent isn't license to infringe on theirs.

But you can prevent them from using that improvement without having licensed your patent.

Although copyright and trademark are slightly different beasts.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by legutierr on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:09AM (#35636284)
> If you have a chair as your property, it doesn't magically become public property in N years, it's yours forever.

Copyright lasts 70 years past the death of the author. I assure you, you will not own that chair after you die.

Your heirs may own the chair, but inheritance itself is also a legal construct. No will, and the decision is made by the probate court. No heirs? Then your chair does go to the state. Or maybe it gets left on the street to be taken by any member of the public who sees it and happens to want it.

Intellectual property in the end is really not that different from any other kind of property. Like any form of property, it's a social construct that exists because people think and act like it exists, and because the resources of the state are used to ensure that any dissenters are suppressed and/or punished.

Ultimately, the reason that your chair sits in your living room, rather than in your better-armed or more muscular neighbor's fireplace, is the same reason that you can't sell bootleg copies of the latest Disney movie on Amazon: the voluntary observation and enforcement of the law by human beings.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by waterhouse on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:40AM (#35636783)
> Your heirs may own the chair, but inheritance itself is also a legal construct.

If inheritance didn't exist, I imagine people would achieve a similar result by gifting everything to their heirs towards the end of their life. And there would be cases where someone meant to do so but died earlier than expected, or where someone did so when they thought they were dying but then ended up living 10 years longer. Compared to that world, inheritance with wills is more convenient and orderly for everyone involved, but it is not the thing that enables people to pass things on to heirs.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by legutierr on Thursday April 20, 2023 @08:32AM (#35638968)
The state's monopoly on violence, and the rule of law it enables, is definitely the thing that allows people to pass things on to their designated heirs. Otherwise every dispute between heirs, every contested will, and every contested end-of-life "gift" would carry the potential for bloodshed.

The specific laws that we have right now could be written differently, and things like inheritance could work differently, but you cannot escape the fact that they are all just creatures of the human mind.

That is, until those concepts begin to be encoded in and enforced by machines.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by TaylorAlexander on Thursday April 20, 2023 @04:13AM (#35637541)
> I know that there's an argument to be made about authors wanting to eat

My view is that we should build a system that ensures every person gets to eat (and have shelter, medical care, other necessities) without the need to pay for it, simply because this is the right thing to do.

Then under such a system, we can eliminate intellectual property restrictions, because they will no longer be necessary to ensure that artists eat. IP restrictions actually slow down innovation, so eliminating them will have huge benefits to society.

By the way you can ensure that everyone gets fed etc without paying for it by building an economy where everyone is part owner of the productive machinery they depend upon. Then no one is poor. Creating an economy where a preponderance of the firms are cooperatives is a good start. So this can be done in a traditionally libertarian way, without high taxes or strong government intervention.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by hnbad on Thursday April 20, 2023 @05:03AM (#35637778)
Try making that argument to a peasant prior to Enclosure.

How is "I own this text" less arbitrary than "I own this forest"? You can't "own" a forest, you can only prevent other people from entering it but if the forest is large enough you can't even do so on your own, even if you live in the forest.

Heck, while you might "own" a chair, how do you "own" a million chairs? You can't use a million chairs. You can't even store a million chairs in one place. You certainly can't guard them yourself, much like the forest.

And how do you "own" a business? How do you "own" the factory when you're not even using it, nor would be able to do so yourself and instead you have to pay dozens of people to use it for you?

"Property" literally just means "exclusive claim backed up by force". That's the primary function of the state, it's why we have police.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Dalewyn on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:52PM (#35635803)
Copyright does not inhibit archiving. The problems begin when people want to distribute those archives.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by woolion on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:54AM (#35637449)
It would seem it's actively in their interests to have the most of their customers forget. First, these companies do serve very derivative content, that wouldn't be remotely interesting when compared to their inspirations. The comparison in many case is so unfair that it shed lights on the incompetence of the team. For some example, there was the 'definitive edition' of the PS2 era GTA games, if you go on Steam you can't find the originals. You can buy the definitive edition that stands at a mighty 0.6 user score on Metacritic though. For movies I'm not sure what would illustrate best but when the Ghostbusters reboot movie came out, it seems they made an effort not to acknowledge the originals. And when the big toys line-up came up after the reboot's disaster of a reception, they did as if it didn't exist and went all for the nostalgia.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by throwaway290 on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:25AM (#35638181)
The article is not about that. There would be no archivalists because no one saw film as art or something worth saving. Copyright was not the issue at hand.

Meanwhile copyright protection is required to encourage creative people to make things

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by whitemary on Thursday April 20, 2023 @12:13PM (#35642262)
This is what capitalism would have happen to the bulk of culture.