News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:59PM (#35632600)
Happily, file sharing enthusiasts are a critical piece of media preservation.

Piracy is a violent crime, file sharing is not comparable to it in any way.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by nine_k on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:05PM (#35632651)
To say the truth, files to be shared often need to be produced first: books scanned and OCRed, DVDs grabbed and repackaged, games actually cracked, etc. There is a scene beyond just people running Bittorrent nodes.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by pizzaknife on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:18PM (#35632799)
If it is as truly violent as the "piracy" label suggests, then is this not "war on drugs" in another vestige?
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by nine_k on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:36PM (#35633621)
I can agree that "piracy" is an unnecessarily violent label (no swords, no drowned ships), but it sort of became the standard word in media.

AFAICT the actual scene prefers terns like "release group", because it's indeed what they do: release bits from the confines of DRM or dead trees.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:37PM (#35633010)
a better word would be parasites...
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by rockemsockem on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:05PM (#35633323)
Quite the opposite actually.

Studies have found that those who pirate content tend to purchase significantly more content than the average person.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:19AM (#35637266)
this is obviously bull though.. how do you even make a study like that? you'd need to associate each illegal downloader to his/her real identity and then to each of their legal purchases... that's ridiculous, and even if academics had the means to do it, it would be illegal. piracy itself is illegal in most countries, so if you don't report them you are literally an accomplice.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by unixgoddess on Thursday April 20, 2023 @03:23AM (#35637281)
Also, I can understand the downvotes, but why the flagging? You can call them thieves, but not parasites? I feel that HN has become quite censorship-heavy lately.

To elaborate on that, people often claim it's not theft because the owner keeps the goods. That's why it's more appropriate to consider it parasitism (you are eating at someone else's table without paying).

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:51PM (#35633758)
> Happily, file sharing enthusiasts are a critical piece of media preservation.

> Piracy is a violent crime, file sharing is not comparable to it in any way.

Sorry, the meaning of "pirate" you dislike is already firmly established, and you're frankly not going to be able to change that.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pirate

> 2: to take or appropriate by piracy: such as

> a: to reproduce without authorization especially in infringement of copyright

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:45PM (#35635412)
Even if it's fruitless in the end, we're still gonna shame the use of the word "piracy" on sight. It's quite simply offensive to compare the copying of bits to high seas piracy which includes murder and rape. Of course the copyright monopolists had to spin up such propaganda: copyright infringement just has no weight to it.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by tivert on Thursday April 20, 2023 @09:24AM (#35639562)
> Even if it's fruitless in the end, we're still gonna shame the use of the word "piracy" on sight.

Who's this "we"?

> It's quite simply offensive to compare the copying of bits to high seas piracy which includes murder and rape.

You are talking that way, way too seriously and interpreting it in weird way in order to take maximum offense.

And my point is it isn't a comparison: "pirate" has an established meaning that is literally your "file sharing enthusiasts." Also, actual high-seas piracy has diminished to the point where "pirates" is mainly understood as file-sharing pirates or as goofy cartoon characters (e.g. "talk like a pirate day" and "Pirates of the Caribbean").

> Of course the copyright monopolists had to spin up such propaganda: copyright infringement just has no weight to it.

It should be noted your alternative "file sharing enthusiasts" is at least as propagandistic, just from the opposite party.

Not that I think copyright piracy is that big if a deal, it's just that computer geeks' overwrought stridency on the issue is obnoxious and obscures more than it informs.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by matheusmoreira on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:09AM (#35664384)
> Who's this "we"?

People such as myself and the person you replied to.

> You are talking that way, way too seriously

I am. It is a serious matter.

> interpreting it in weird way in order to take maximum offense

Yes, I take maximum offense when some monopolist tries to compare me to rapers and pillagers because I copied bits.

> You have do to a lot of deliberate work to strain to take offense at the association.

Not at all. Actual piracy is still happening even today in the 21st century. Everyone knows exactly what a pirate is and it's exactly what comes to mind when someone mentions them. It's not some forgotten history only geeks know about. People will even mentally picture those very same "file sharing enthusiasts" you mention as roguish types when in fact perfectly normal people forwarding pictures, videos and documents on WhatsApp are a perfect fit for the definition. People literally infringe copyright every day at massive scales without even realizing it. They infringe copyright when they save a picture from a web site.

> It should be noted your alternative "file sharing enthusiasts" is at least as propagandistic, just from the opposite party.

Except I didn't use those terms. I used the proper one: copyright infringement. Sounds like a whole lot of nothing when put that way, doesn't it?

> it's just that computer geeks' overwrought stridency on the issue is obnoxious and obscures more than it informs.

So the copyright industry insists on using propaganda words like "piracy" purely to add weight to copyright infringement and make it seem more real than it really is but I'm the one obscuring the issue? Right.

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by guy98238710 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @07:19PM (#35634524)
I like to tell people I am a pirate though. I think it sounds cool.
Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by musicale on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @08:25PM (#35634948)
Cambridge dictionary [1] has this definition:

> piracy noun [ U ] UK /ˈpaɪərəsi/ US

> IT, LAW

> the act of illegally copying computer programs, recordings, films, etc. to sell them at much cheaper prices

What's interesting is that this definition includes selling.

So by this definition at least, regular file sharing of copyrighted media, even illegal or infringing distribution, would not qualify as piracy, since no sale is involved.

[1] https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/piracy

Re:Almost three quarters of the golden age of Hollywood has ... by TylerE on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @10:06PM (#35635528)
If you pay attention, the sites that get taken down are often laden with ads, so rather lose the ability to claim some sort of non-commercial exemption.