Nothing has been left for the kids. Everything has been financialized, and the effect of that is that everything is priced so that you can't get much out of it.
Smart kid, likes math and science? You used to be able to get into a university relatively easily, with decent but not top few percent grades. When you got there you wouldn't be saddled with huge debt. When you finished there was a decent chance to stay in the academy. Try getting tenure now.
When you left uni you could find a job because not everyone wanted the same few jobs. People aren't stupid, they've realised some jobs get all the pay. Now it's either the dream job, or get a job that you can't be happy with.
Now try buying a house with that average job. You can't, not even with years of work.
On top of it all the ideology of the previous generation is that it's all your own fault. People who had a huge leg up after the war seem to believe it was all them and everyone should should just work harder.
Why would getting tenure be harder nowadays? If it really is, probably because there are more people getting a PhD in the first place (because more people are going to university in the first place).
But perhaps this is also somewhat of a tangent to your main point.
It seems to be partly volume but also that universities are very reluctant to give tenure. If you're a younger academic you're probably working at multiple universities on short term contract. My wife is taking some university courses and one of her professors works at 4 different schools to make ends meet.
I sound like Karl Marx himself when I say it, but it's the capitalists extracting as much work as possible from the helpless workers. (I don't think I'm normally even on the left, but here we are.)
Academics, or even "smart" work aside, you used to be able to pay rent, buy a car, and save for a house on minimum wage, and later still with a strong entry level salary in pretty much any blue collar work.
Now, minimum wage will leave you homeless in most places.
> On top of it all the ideology of the previous generation is that it's all your own fault.
We're a few generations past the boomers, but you're right, Millenials and Zoomers (and the oldest of gen Alpha) definitely have to deal with this
The city did not like all those cars parked out front so they instituted a policy which targeted these people, levying fines through shady and aggressive tow companies.
You had to have a car to get to work though - and although they could partly solve this by painting bike lanes to make biking more viable, they did not do that either.
But the city wanted to have its cake and eat it too - so it incentivized local factories to expand their operations to bring more of these folks to the city to work, making the problem worse.
It is like that scene from "History of the world Pt. 1". Fuck the poor!
So what are we going to do about it? I suspect nothing until people start rioting
Yes, housing is a problem. But then fix the regulation that inhibits development of housing and makes it more expensive. And then go work in construction as houses don't build themselves. Wealth is to be created not to be redistributed until there is nothing left.
The current trend is reaching the breaking point.
You're neglecting the fact that nowadays there is very little actual use for a university. If I want to study something, I have instant access to it.
Ok, so as long as we're clear you're asserting this claim without any evidence, just your belief that reading a book somehow grants the same education as, say, a higher level formal education.
I've been told on numerous occasions by people that I was right about university (I've been telling people not to bother for like 7 years now), and that it wasted their time and drained their bank account for nothing.
Unless you're trying to convince someone else you did those things.
> I've been told on numerous occasions by people that I was right about university (I've been telling people not to bother for like 7 years now), and that it wasted their time and drained their bank account for nothing.
People can say lots of things, until there's proof there's no reason to believe it. Again, if you have examples please let me know.
This is very easy to do if you've actually done those things.
If Ramanujan did it you can too.
No, no, you've skipped the vital steps - how do they get the work? Just reading a book or three doesn't give you the ability to get that work. Or are you of the belief that if you watch an online lecture and read a couple of books you can start making valuable contributions to mathematics? Again, examples would be good.
> If Ramanujan did it you can too.
I'm just going to say if you're most contemporary example you can come up with is from 150 years ago you may have a problem with your argument. The academic landscape has slighty changed in that time. But I'm feeling generous, I will accept that one person every 100 years can probably do it. That doesn't make it "very easy to do", in fact it's an argument for the opposite. It would seem it's easier to become president given that there have been a lot more example of those in the last 100 years.
Yes.
I sometimes wonder if Boomers find it funny when people say things like "people who had a huge leg up after the war" given what that leg up consisted of.
The problem isn't the work. Houses are so different today (considerably larger and built with amenities like air conditioning, fireplaces, dishwashers, garbage disposals) that you are simply not buying the same thing. A house was apparently as likely to lack running water in 1950 as it is to lack air conditioning today. Same deal with cars - a household then would only have one and by modern standards it was an unsafe gas guzzling under-powered abomination.
The problem is not that your income is low compared to your parents (it is not; they were statistically probably impoverished compared to you), the problem is it's impossible and in some cases literally illegal to buy stuff as crappy as what they owned. We've priced the poor out not by cutting their salaries but by destroying old housing stocks, NIMBYing out affordable housing, imposing fuel economy standards, killing acid rain, and just generally making the entry level of everything more luxurious because the economy was awash with easy money.
The exception (as Yglesias notes) is university, which really is generally more expensive for the same or probably lower quality.
https://www.slowboring.com/p/nostalgia-economics-is-totally-...
It is not the house that is expensive, it is the real estate.
(Prefab houses today are built far more efficiently than anything before, accounting for both materials and man hours. Same with cars.)
But as the Yglesias article points out, your parents (unless very rich) were probably not buying a new house. They had old housing stock lying around. You don't. And if you want to build a new modular home, it's probably illegal to put it where you want and probably impossible to finance it if you can:
https://www.finelinehomes.com/biggest-problems-modular-homes...
Even if your parents bought a house twice as expensive, it would be cheaper. They could have used the extra money on insulation or piping or whatever the difference was, they just didn't.
Besides this is like saying televisions were all crappy black and white units so your parents didn't have it so easy. But the hedonic adjustment is just that, you can't buy a crappy unit now so you pretend the difference matters.
What went for a house then has got to be the standard, surely.
The point is the hedonic adjustment. It's not that the kids don't live like the Boomers because they can't, it's that they don't live like the Boomers because both the government and the market wouldn't let them if they wanted to, which they don't.
> You can afford a 1950s house
Where I am from in Europe, most houses from 1950s are in use. The apartment buildings are generally constructed to higher standards than modern ones (thicker concrete, less use of aerated concrete, no plasterboard interior walls, and so on). Apartment buildings from maybe 1890-1940 are considered premium due to better architecture, higher ceilings, robustness etc. New buildings to those standards are simply not possible.
Old buildings have been continually updated with amenities; water and sewage, central heating, internet. The cost of these are rounding errors compared to the market value.
Modern buildings are cost-optimized to a whole new level. If you honestly have difficulties understanding this; it's equivalent to comparing modern flatpack furnitures with semi-handbuilt ones from 1950s factories. The cost in man-hours and materials of modern furnitures is a fraction of the old ones.
You are right. There is nothing in for young people working in a company their dream they don't share. It doesn't even make the ends meet, so why bother?
1.8 million people over the age of 55 die every year in the US (per US CDC). This labor pool will dwindle over time.
Spoiler alert: those 4m people aging into over 55 were likely already working, so they're not taking a bunch of 'new jobs' , just shifting roles (and vacating their previous roles). You're still losing that 1.8m per year.
You have to look at the other end of the job pool for new entrants, those turning 18, and see what their attitudes are. That's the parent comment's argument. The younger people will take up a larger and larger percentage of the 'under 55 year old workforce' and have a very different relationship with work than those that are currently over 55.
Eventually they'll take enough of a chunk of the workforce that corporations will have no choice but to accommodate, because they can't just keep tapping into the dwindling 'people who will overwork themselves into an early grave' demographic to make up for it.
If anything, I guess finally US is catching up with the fact that most countries don't have a workaholic culture, and people rather work to live, not live to work.
"In 1989, when baby boomers were around the same age as millennials are today, they controlled 21% of the nation’s wealth. That’s almost five times as much as what millennials own today."
On top of that housing and university costs have exploded in the same time. And now inflation counters even investing in a good mutual fund. I have had to move to a third world country, working remotely in tech, to even have a chance at a normal family like I grew up in.
Then there's the media manipulation. Both domestic political parties, as well as foreign states, have become extremely adept at making us hate each other. There's no philia left at all.
When I extrapolate all this out, my kids will be poor and my grandkids will be revolutionaries.
Look, if the problem of low birth rates is "We have no monies!", you'll have to excuse me for rolling my eyes when I see them buying lattes and iPhones in their very next breath.
Especially if you have anything less than great health insurance. (Even mine at a huge tech company has moved to 5k deductible + HSA)
Wow those fools spending their $960 which if they saved they would be able to put 20% down on a $400,000 home in only…
80 YEARS OF SAVING
Yeah I think the latte and iPhone is more pleasure then saving until death for nothing at all. Do the math next time.
If the argument is that they are destitute, they should at the very least act the part. Drink water instead of latte, buy the cheapest phone instead of an iPhone.
If you come up to me saying you have no money while holding an iPhone, I'm sorry but I'm not going to help you.
These were popular devices, in 1959 there were estimated to be 950 wireless radios (all makes and models, not just Zanettes) for every 1000 inhabitants of the USA.
$40 in 1962 is around $400 today.
In 1960 as young man on below average wages you could have a house, a car and a wireless radio.
In 2023 as a young man on above average wages you can have the wireless radio (today that gadget is an iphone) but forget the house and car.
Actually it’s more likely to be an android among young males - couldn’t say why but cost seems an obvious reason!
The person you are responding to made it very clear that just because you can afford an iPhone it doesn't mean you can afford a home, but you'd deny them the iPhone? Why? He just proved that removing the little things wont get them the big things, so why can't they enjoy the little things? It's not helping them to deny themselves, it's allowing you to feel correct in your understanding of what poor looks like.
You demanding that all the poor wear a hair shirt to show their repentance is your own desire to watch them "act the part" as you believe their part to be, not something that will make their lives better, unless you believe the suffering is the point.
Owning something like an iPhone is a luxury, if you spend on luxuries then you do not need help and I'm not going to help you.
It's the same reason most of us wouldn't help a homeless man who spends whatever money he gets on booze.
What help are YOU offering? You keep saying you won't help. And what would consider acceptable savings for said help? And what is being saved for? What do you want the poor to do with their savings? It will never be enough to retire or buy a home or nice car with.
Again, it sounds like the denial is the point.
Whatever it is they actually need help with.
So long as they have an iPhone, they clearly don't need help with money so I'm not helping them with money.
So if a poor person without an iPhone needed rent money you'd give it to them?
> So long as they have an iPhone
Can we unpack these rules here? Any iPhone? iPhone 6? What's an acceptable level of phone? An older iPhone could be the same price as a budget phone. What's your price point cutoff for when someone isn't performatively poor enough?
Ultimately, I feel concerned that you think that poor people can budget their way out of all their problems by spend $25 less a month. Seems like an arbitrary line and irrational line. It's all about the appearance of being poor. Again, how does not having a phone mean they can afford the more important things, knowing that the more important things cost orders of magnitude more?
To be clear, that is not the argument.
The argument is over your claim that if someone can afford an iPhone then they can afford to have children.
If they aren't destitute they can afford to have children, because the claim is people can't have children because they are destitute.
Karl Marx.
If they can afford luxuries (there's nothing bad with being luxurious), they don't need any financial help because they clearly have more than enough spare cash.
If you're going to ask me for money or otherwise complain about not having money, make your case first by not spending money on frivolous luxuries.
They should afford no paint to make art with, no weekly coffee, because the greedy capitalist class has decreed that their housing should eat up 100% of their pay and they should be happy with this?
I would rather we burned such a system down than continue it.
I hear all the time about my parents generation going to the pub several nights a week which I as a middle class professional could not afford.
My dad was telling me how much his rent (nice house in the country) was after he got married and how hard it was to save for a house. A few more questions got to it being 1/20th of his junior tradesman income! I could live like a king if my rent was 1/20th of my income
Bye.
But going by what I would call your low ball number, every 20$ a week you save works out a grand a year. 80 years for 20$, 40 40, 20 80, 10 160, 5 320.??? So, get on the treadmill or don’t but it’s weird how many people buck against the idea that when you’re very poor then every 10’s of dollars a week does add up. Not that 10 dollars matters, but can you make that 20 a week? Can you squeeze more for 40? 80? Some people have made those sacrifices, they don’t rate the pleasure of latte and iPhone higher than financial security. So please if you could manage, don’t throw out phrases like do that maths sarcastically.
If anyone is reading this, beware of boomer logic.
Children are a real commitment, unlike an iPhone. I don’t even have a sim in this iPhone I’m currently holding. It is ok. I can use it on WiFi. You can’t do that with a child. You have to feed and clothe the child. You have to take care of them when they are sick.
A coworker had a baby with an irregular heartbeat. They used to come to work with red eyes like evidently they’d been crying. Why are they at work? I mean there’s more than a dozen doctors and nurses parading in and out of the baby’s room in the hospital. Our health insurance is from our employer.
Let’s assume you somehow raised a healthy child and more they want to go to college. If college continues to go up in cost like it has got the last twenty or thirty years, where will we be when a baby born today wants to go to college?
It is not a crime to not have children. I say it is our right and our duty to not have children if we can’t make the numbers work.
I am speaking as to the philosophy. If you can afford luxuries, you are not destitute. If you are not destitute, arguing that the cause of low birth rates is a lack of money falls flat on its face.
I suppose if hypothetical me really buckled down and kept my phone for 10 years I could have had an emergency fund in a decade, and boy then I'd be off to races.
And yet, having a good leader for a manger or boss will still get me to work hard(er), but that is such a rare occurrence.
By far the most important trait is that they know their team and their strengths and weaknesses, put them doing the right tasks for their skillset, and trust them to get the job done.
The second most important trait is a clear vision. They know what they need to achieve, what resources they need and/or have available, and don't waste time on pointless busywork (like scrum poker)
Working with someone like that makes work very rewarding. It is unfortunately almost impossible to find such a leader in most big companies as their company structure with 30 layers and PMs and what not simply does not allow it.
Competent, has solid strategy, can execute it.
I used to work at a summer camp and during meal time, it was easy to tell who the good leaders were.
They weren't the people at the front of the line before their campers. The good leaders made sure their subordinates ate first and they waited to eat last and ate with their campers, rather than the staff table.
I personally feel much better if I use all my brain and a ton of energy at work. I've had a couple of jobs where this wasn't the case, and I found myself much less happy and, ironically, exhausted. At least in my case, working hard has led to a lot of opportunities for learning and growing, and money followed too. Not enough to buy a house, that's true, but I live a more comfortable life than my parents who did have a house.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that while the game might be rigged at a high level, my personal experience is that working hard still puts me where I would like to be.
It's always been the case and research shows that when employees feel that they are valued, trusted, and fairly compensated their performance improves (for examples see https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2012/03/well-being or https://www.hindawi.com/journals/edri/2021/1751495/ or https://www.ijlass.org/data/frontImages/gallery/Vol._3_No._1...)
> They did it out of necessity, cultural expectations and personal fulfillment.
Necessity and cultural expectations might make someone seek and maintain employment, but being treated fairly makes them work harder, makes them more loyal, and leads to better outcomes. Demoralizing employees is always going to result in reduced productivity. It may be true that the work you do is is fulfilling enough to prevent you from being demoralized even if your employer treats you like shit, but I doubt most people feel that strongly about their work. If they aren't earning enough to take care of themselves, let alone their families, morale isn't going to be very high.
Hard work can lead to financial security, fair compensation, and professional fulfillment, but there is no guarantee that it will. It's an employers job to convince their employees that their hard work is worthwhile and will pay off for them in the end.
You're assuming "young people" can even find a job, considering employers now just collect resumes for a rainy day, or something. I'm aging out of being young, and when I read about that I kinda just wondered what the point of applying to jobs even is anymore.
And maybe that has something to do with making more money and being able to afford more things?
Slightly exaggerated, but from surveys in Germany, I gather that young people want to retire at 60, work part time, have at least 30 days of vacation per year, earn enough to afford "a good life" (large flat, vacations, parties), and do something interesting at work that "vibes" with them.
Those don't mix well for most people and jobs, because few people get paid well to do their hobbies part-time. And how could they? They'll spend 20-25 years until they start working, then spend 35-40 years working (with a sabbatical or two thrown in), then they'll spend another 30 years retired (life expectancy is rising).
And maybe there's also a social contagion. Individually, people might come to a different conclusion, but if a large number of their peers rejects the opportunities, there's a good chance they'll let that affect their judgement.
My grandfather worked ~20 years in mines. That was very hard work. He got nothing for it. The house he had to turn in (wasn't his) when the war (WW2) broke out. He had 5 kids (which was not a particularly high number). He managed to make it work by making wood furniture (mostly windows and window related stuff). He didn't make much from that either, but more than in the mine. He claims it was MUCH less intense work.
After the war, he got a job as a police officer. He did essentially nothing for another ~45 years (yes, he worked from 11 to 67 I believe). He's not rich but on that wage he eventually got 13 kids total (Christmas parties no longer fit in their house once half his kids got married), put 3 through university, and all of them through higher education.
We don't pay for hard work. Not back then. Not now. Plumber still makes a lot less than software engineer, and software engineer is not hard work.
This impression is an artifact of comparing apples and oranges. Many sectors have seen almost zero real productivity growth in decades, such as the hospitality industry (waiters and waitresses). See: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2016/07/21/look-to...
The median worker does not work in a sector that has seen high productivity growth, even if the economy as a whole has seen high productivity growth.
If you won't be able to afford a house anyway, why bother working hard? Just do the bare minimum and at least enjoy some of your free time in a minimalist way.
It's a consequence of economic inequality we have created. If you want people to work hard you have to make it worth it for them, otherwise they check out of the economy, check out of having kids, etc. and blaming them for buying lattes, avocado toast and airpods isn't the real problem no matter how much you call them lazy and entitled.
People worked hard in the past because the local company they worked for contributed back to the community and was owned by locals you could see and interact with, so even though those were still ruthless capitalists, they also had their limits at which they would exploit their own living environment and contributed back to the community in some way (trainings, apprenticeships, schools, hospitals, charities, kindergartens, etc.)
But now, after decades of corporate mergers and acquisitions, when most land, natural resource and means of production is owned by some giant faceless publicly traded mega-corp with HQ in some offshore tax heaven, who's only interest is extracting as much as possible from your community for the benefit of the shareholders, without giving anything back (not even taxes), and you are just a disposable commodity in an excel sheet for them, then why bother?