Owning something like an iPhone is a luxury, if you spend on luxuries then you do not need help and I'm not going to help you.
It's the same reason most of us wouldn't help a homeless man who spends whatever money he gets on booze.
What help are YOU offering? You keep saying you won't help. And what would consider acceptable savings for said help? And what is being saved for? What do you want the poor to do with their savings? It will never be enough to retire or buy a home or nice car with.
Again, it sounds like the denial is the point.
Whatever it is they actually need help with.
So long as they have an iPhone, they clearly don't need help with money so I'm not helping them with money.
So if a poor person without an iPhone needed rent money you'd give it to them?
> So long as they have an iPhone
Can we unpack these rules here? Any iPhone? iPhone 6? What's an acceptable level of phone? An older iPhone could be the same price as a budget phone. What's your price point cutoff for when someone isn't performatively poor enough?
Ultimately, I feel concerned that you think that poor people can budget their way out of all their problems by spend $25 less a month. Seems like an arbitrary line and irrational line. It's all about the appearance of being poor. Again, how does not having a phone mean they can afford the more important things, knowing that the more important things cost orders of magnitude more?
The person you are responding to made it very clear that just because you can afford an iPhone it doesn't mean you can afford a home, but you'd deny them the iPhone? Why? He just proved that removing the little things wont get them the big things, so why can't they enjoy the little things? It's not helping them to deny themselves, it's allowing you to feel correct in your understanding of what poor looks like.
You demanding that all the poor wear a hair shirt to show their repentance is your own desire to watch them "act the part" as you believe their part to be, not something that will make their lives better, unless you believe the suffering is the point.