Hold up. I don’t think the people of San Francisco grew weary of increasing rents and decided to turn to a life of crime.
Most of the “trouble makers” in the Bay Area are recent arrivals to the area and come because of poor policing and the government is generally more tolerant of them.
https://cis.org/Arthur/Honduran-Migrants-and-San-Francisco-D...
Here is the mayor apologizing for saying it. Not because it isn't true, but because you aren't supposed to say it out loud.
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-10-20/san-fran...
As a Canuck, immediately I thought "But Texans will shoot criminals".
True or not, the belief is there for many. That does have some power. maybe.
1) the immigration rate is so high it isn't enough to keep up
2) the house values in areas that dont build in enough housing have skyrocketed, and smart homeowners in those areas have decided to sell and move to places with lower house prices and purchase more than one, which of course rockets the price even in the places that do build a lot. So even in provinces where lots of housing is built, immigration from other countries and other provinces blows up the housing prices anyways.
3) The government doesn't want to do anything about it because immigration is how they're keeping down wages, and since housing has become so much of the GDP they're terrified of what it would mean for the economy if there was a price crash anyways, so they don't look at policies that would fight the housing price explosion in fear of what the economy will look like if they do.
Looks the voters dont want to do anything either, if they keep re-electing the same party/politicians.
Businesses underpay and when they can't find people willing to impoverish themselves to work for them, they apply to the government to bring in "temporary foreign workers" - for things like fast food restaurant workers not essential business, keeping the wages down.
Temporary foreign workers and international students in canada are allowed to buy housing, so aside from renting the rich ones who make it here actually buy up properties for their family offshore.
Even if Canadians vote out Trudeau, Poilievre of the conservatives has no interest in slowing down immigration or affecting policies to improve access to housing. The leader of the NDP, Singh, is useless and his party is also very pro immigration and has no housing policies that would affect the market.
What we're seeing is a death spiral of some kind but I'm not sure where the ultimate end goes - no doctors, no housing, low wages compared to housing and food costs, etc. This is textbook conditions for serious blowback and social instability.
When asked why there wasn't anything in this years announced budget to deal with the housing crisis Christina Freedland says that they're still spending money from last year's budget on it. Well how about you see the fruits of your labours and realize it isn't working out well for Canadians, and do something else/more?
If we don't manage to vote trudeau out this time around I'm going to look into immigrating to texas. People joke about that but texas recognizes my professional licensing and all I'd need is a job offer.
> Temporary foreign workers and international students in canada are allowed to buy housing, so aside from renting the rich ones who make it here actually buy up properties for their family offshore.
If they're being paid so little, I don't see how they could possibly afford to buy any properties. I've only known a few, but they all send the majority of the money back home instead.
This feels very fear mongering on TFWs and not grounded in facts.
I'm doubtful that it's TFW that are buying the properties you're concerned with, especially since they're still at the mercy of PR/work authorization laws that could make them leave the country at any time.
It _could_ happen, but that would be pretty exceptional. You want to complain about foreigners making house prices too high for you, you do you. Just be accurate in your complaints.
international students do purchase houses for their families out of country - it happens more in some areas than others.
And if someone couldn't get in as a student, they might try to get in as a TFW and spend their family money on a home - I don't know how often it happens but its allowed because TFWs DO buy houses.
Now it seems everything needs to be ready before having children: big house, big car, career.
Also, what support do you have for the claim that the existence of temporary foreign workers suppress wages for working Canadians? My understanding is that they are performing jobs that Canadians just won’t do and thus, their presence shouldn’t affect Canadian working wages (or so the theory goes).
Their presence suppresses the wages because there's a basically unlimited pool of people willing to work for suppressed wages. All businesses have to do is not raise wages and the prevailing wage is whatever they offer. Almost every tim hortons, mcdonalds, burger king, etc in canada is staffed with TFW. I'd rather they raise the wages or go out of business. Instead they import workers and keep wages suppressed.
I’ll tell you what would happen - People would lose their minds.
So… it’s complicated (at least in that industry). I’m not as convinced about the need for them in tech and restaurants because, as you say, they should probably just pay more and Canadians would do those jobs. But the numbers I saw don’t seem that significant so I’m not so sure.
Unemployment is also at the lowest it’s been in ~50 years so.. where would those new Canadian workers come from anyways?
There are no simple answers. That’s why I’d like to see what economists are saying. I know that with regular immigration, there’s a consensus among many economists that we need them so our economy doesn’t actually shrink due to low birth rates.
What?
Drug lords and warlords are allowed to buy real estate in the west through shell companies registered in tax heavens. It's the same companies that do 'tax optimisation' for our billionaires.
The head of Wagner Prigozhin has passed money laundering check in London while he was under sanctions and wanted by the FBI, he submitted his mother's gas bill.
https://www.ft.com/content/3e1b5bc5-090c-434d-84e4-ca2b120cf...
As a society, we need to acknowledge how zero interest rates were directly responsible for the housing bubble. The people that caused that should be shamed publicly.
Speaking of taxing home sales, before 1997 any profit was considered capital gains. After the "taxpayer relief act" in 1997, the first $250k was exempted ($500k if married). So that was like a big flag saying "go forth and make money flipping houses". Side effect in our timeline is the creation of infinite home flipper content for YouTube. Similar signals with zero interest rates. "Buy a house now, no matter what it costs, for tomorrow it will cost more. Oh, maybe buy some guns too while you're at it, the end times are near".
If you make $200k a year, you've got almost 3x the average household income in canada ($75k). You're way up there in terms of wealth, and don't need any help from the NDP or anyone else.
It's so far out the norm of normal income that anyone earning $200k in canada and complaining about the housing situation isn't in touch with what normal people in canada are experiencing and their complaints are ridiculous.
It's like a CEO yelling that you don't know how much they're paying in capital gains tax. It really isn't relevant.
After taxes, high COL, sky-high rent, and retirement savings there's maybe a deposit in there.
You're out to lunch and out of touch.
Thanks the advice. I'll start purchasing property impractically far from my work. Good idea
Or at least more family wealth.
That could be addressed by making home building a priority and by relaxing regulations like zoning. Allow more infill.
> 3) The government doesn't want to do anything about it because immigration is how they're keeping down wages
That's not the only reason to support immigration. Canada, as is the case with most western nations, is facing a demographic cliff due to lowering birthrates among it's citizens. Countries that allow more immigration can mitigate these demographic problems. Countries that are facing birthrates that are falling to or under the replacement rate should be trying to attract immigrant labor. Countries in that position that don't are going to be facing some serious issues in the not too distant future as their populations age.
Unfortunately, it seems like incentives aren't aligned with the people responsible for zoning and regulation, for that to happen.
Incumbent homeowners for whatever reason are better organized at mobilizing around their political interests
But they said they were doing nothing, and it was just so ironic the comment came on the day one of several attempts the government has made to address the problem.
I think I've seen where you're coming from, and I'm uninterested in any more of your opinion.
Housing and zoning are a provincial responsibility. You can blame Trudeau and Harper for lots of stuff, but not the housing mess.
It's always the same story. Can't we just make the economy more fair by saying that the wealth gap must at least be smaller than some value or else the rich will pay (taxes) to make it so?
The best solutions I've seen are land value taxes, inheritance and estate taxes, and taxes on loans backed by stock; and among the worst are unrealized capital gains taxes.
How can you make such a claim, when you look at the state of many regions/countries in the world?
Sri Lanka 4.1% 2016
Kazakhstan 4.3% 2018
Morocco 4.8% 2013
Belarus 5% 2019
Fuck the World Bank numbers. I’ve been to Sri Lanka and poverty is real over there.Oh, and “According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the official 2017 poverty rate in the U.S. was 12.3%. However, other sources placed it as high as 17.8%. [snip] The 2021 poverty threshold in the United States is $26,246 for a family of four”.
So the poverty figures are relative to the wealth of the country? That makes the numbers meaningless to compare (since there is no standard cutoff - just pick a number that gives you a poverty rate of x%).
it did not go well. It did not go well for either the richer (murdered) people or the poorer (ensuing famine) people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1930%E2%80%93...
Yet it seems to me at least, that you are taking the extreme position. People are arguing for nuanced improvement, and discussing what issues may arise.
You're essentially saying "Enough talk, do random things". In fact, you're saying "do almost anything", which is quite extreme.
The point I made in the other sub-thread, is that many many other countries did that very thing. Whether by revolution, or elected and then massive change, these countries ended up with utter devastation, and in some cases 100% poverty.
I get you're frustrated. Fair enough. But waving away how difficult these issues are, just isn't workable.
To that end, I see people criticize:
* low interest rates * high interest rates * 0 interest rates * quantitative easing * methods to prevent bank collapses * methods to reduce the depth of a recession * methods to slow economic growth (reign in inflation)
Quite literally, no matter what anyone does, people are yelling "Idiots!" at the result. Meanwhile, the results compared to other nations aren't horrible.
I 100% agree that we need to look at ways to reverse the trend of wealth equity. But to say it's just simple and easy, just snap your fingers and try stuff?
No way.
And the wrong results can be utterly disastrous.
If we examine the set of 'many other countries', does it consist 90% of dictatorships, that were already in poverty, and the methods chosen 70% violence?
What if, the aim of these actions was never to improve the economy, but instead was to consolidate power for the dictatorship in question and to remove elites that could pose competition?
What if the set of 'many other countries' is a very unfair example? The author is not suggesting violence, and we do not live in dictatorship?
Whilst the strongman and his cronies may only want power, a democracy can collapse because its citizens do not see the danger.
They may give special powers, or ignore weakening of key institutions, because he is "fixing things" with a strong arm and will.
And by weakening key parts of a democracy, it leaves it more open, susceptible to a strongman to succeed in subverting the current state.
Maybe even decades away.
Many areas of the world were democratic, and fell into this trap, and are now stuck there.
Some have tried to go back to democracy, or forge a democratic state for the first time, and fall due to this same fallacy.
Change is not fast enough, so "just do something, anything!".
So yes, my comparison is completely fair.
We could even take this further and make it illegal to have too much money. But like all laws, what ultimately matters is enforcement. Currently the IRS doesn't even make much attempt to go after the rich for tax evasion, so writing stricter laws is irrelevant if we don't enforce the laws we already have.
I'm not saying this is perfect but it is a simple solution that directly addresses the issue of wealth inequality.
It's not as simple as "make it illegal to have above X amount of money" because it's not really even money at that point, no one has X billion in cash lying around, it's tied to some physical asset. This is just one problem to your statement, there are many others.
If you want to nitpick that every solution isn't as simple as fizzbuzz then there's no real point having a discussion. There are plenty of other tax alternatives that are also quite simple, you just seem to be unhappy with anything that isn't perfect.
No, that's the entire point of having the discussion. If the solution can't answer even these types of questions, then there's no point having the discussion, because it breaks down even upon initial examination.
> This is what the IRS is for. It's one of the only government organizations that actually makes more money than is put into it. So we'd just give them more money and resources to do their job, which would include wealth evaluation.
Sure, I agree in giving more money to the IRS, indeed that's happened recently, but even they are not going to tax unrealized capital gains.
You are completely missing the point of the conversation you started. Everything we're discussing is a hypothetical. In this scenario, they would tax that and everything else.
Anyway, I don't think that you're arguing in good faith and I'm moving on with my day. Cheers.
> Everything we're discussing is a hypothetical. In this scenario, they would tax that and everything else
Your hypothetical is "the government taxes everything". Then someone asked, "how would that work?" and your response was "everything we're discussing is a hypothetical!".
There are many obvious ideas around taxing wealth. The problem is that when you think about how they would work in reality things get very messy and difficult. Proposing the idea is not the hard part.
Because he was mixing reality with the hypothetical. He was saying the IRS doesn't work that way in reality, which has no bearing to the discussions we were having which is a hypothetical. I explicitly stated in a previous comment that the IRS would also evaluate wealth and tax based on that wealth, and then he responds talking about how they don't tax unrealized capital gains. In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?
The reality is, like the sibling comment says, just proposing a simple solution doesn't work, that's not the hard part. The hard part is actually exploring and understanding the problem of what actually happens were an institution such as the IRS be assessing wealth for taxation.
"determined by the IRS" is passing the buck big time.
> In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?
Because you're skipping the most difficult and pertinent part of the solution. There's not much substance to proposing a wealth tax based on wealth brackets. All the difficulty and nuance of a wealth tax is in determining how to reasonably tax someone's wealth (E.g. assets and unrealized gains).
No solution is ideal. But it's not an intractable problem because it's regularly solved every day around the world for all sorts of reasons. If we created a branch of government whose purpose was to do this I think they could figure it out. So in that sense I'm offloading the problem to people whose job it would be to figure out the problem.
Anyway, I've spent way too much time arguing about something I don't even care about. Cheers.
Better luck next time you try to roll your eyes.
Anything you own with a quantifiable monetary value. Yes, even if that value is not fixed.
> If I own a company worth X billion, does that mean I have to sell my shares to withdraw enough cash to pay my taxes, thereby tanking the value of my own company?
Yes.
> If I pay a lot in a downturn but my company does better in a boom, will I get refunded the extra tax I paid?
No. How does that even make sense?
The answers to these questions are easy, people you just don't like them, because they mean that those who have a lot and feel like they "got it fair and square" suddenly have to (gasp) contribute to society rather than hoarding all of that money to themselves. Even though you start to hit massive diminishing returns in terms of effect on your actual lifestyle once you're getting up into the million range, and see barely any effect at all of additional wealth or income once you're past, say, 100 million. It becomes just a dollar-denominated high score, so that you can feel smug about How Great A Businessman You Are, while millions of people starve on the streets unnecessarily.
This problem isn't complicated because it's intellectually challenging. This problem is complicated because the balance of power is overwhelmingly favorable to the rich, and they have many means to both disrupt the conversation in intellectual circles and to block any political means of making these necessary changes.
See economist Richard D. Wolff for extremely simple answers to the above problem. Ultimately it is simply the math of value flows. Current system? Inherently concentrates at the top. Adjust taxes (any of them!!) to reverse that.
It can be both, one does not preclude the other. As I mentioned in my other comments, one can't simply adjust taxes without thinking about higher order effects, and it takes intellectual capacity to even think about what to tax in the first place and how, in order to reduce these effects.
> See economist Richard D. Wolff for extremely simple answers to the above problem.
Where should I be looking specifically?
If people think taxes are too complicated (which I don't think is the case) so be it - You can simply transfer money to the poorer people, like what happened in Covid but focus on the poor. Every citizen will have a net worth number, everyone will get a sum of money, the less you have the more you get. Now that will be inflationary of course but the burden will go to the rich instead of the poor.
Don’t get me started on “taxing virtual assets beyond the 30th you own”.
No.
When people say they want fairness, they are being disingenuous. They want a lot of the fair that benefits them and a little bit of the fair that makes their life worse.
That's not what fair means. Would you want fair if it made your life a lot worse? The only honest answer for a homo sapiens is no.
Now that we've established that homo sapiens don't want fair, you should not be surprised that wealthy people also don't want fair, thus, we don't have it, because nobody actually wants it.
Of course, I do support bringing up the average wages in each country overall, which is precisely what capitalism has been doing for the past century of industrialized progress.
This point of 'most people only want what benefits them' is very shallow.
You've set up the question for failure. You limited comparison to income, and to income just among labour class. If you actually setup the question correctly, you might find the results to be different.
Are we going to re-destribute capital gains? Most people in developed world earn zero from capital gains.
Are we going to re-distribute ownership of assets, shares, and land? Most people in developed world own zero land. Many have net worth of roughly zero.
Are we going to re-distribute taxation? Taxes in the first world are paid almost entirely by the middle class.
What about right to pollute, currently wealthy individuals have unlimited right to pollute, some take helicopter rides and jets to cut travel time by <1 hour or to avoid traffic.
> what capitalism has been doing for the past century
Capitalism has been dumping toxic waste from the west in developing nations, like used electronic and plastics. It has brought Opium addiction to China, British American Tabacco is selling to children in South America right now, Nestle has admitted to slavery in Thailand.
Western companies have bribed local officials, and hired death squads to kill local union leaders and environmental activists.
The leading countries to rise in the last 30 years, China and Singapore, have active, competent and interventionist governments.
> Capitalism has been dumping toxic waste from the west in developing nations, like used electronic and plastics
Well, I did talk about wages rising, specifically, and not environmental waste. But it really is true that developed countries now want many developing countries to stop their environmental damage right as they are industrializing, meanwhile discounting their own environmental damage in the centuries prior. The truth is that industrialization requires some sort of short term environmental damage (as long as we use fossil fuels still) but thankfully, many nations are using renewables, including the China you talk about. China's (and indeed most others') rise has only been through after adopting capitalist principles, look at their growth until the 80s, and then from the 80s to today. I don't agree that we should have non-interventionist capitalism, but I won't deny that capitalism has been the single greatest driver of prosperity in human history, even with all of its faults.
oh boy, do you have some reading to do
Can't wait for the China do collapse under its own mismanagement and the memes like the above can finally die off.
It sounds like the same story being repeated all over the world. There was someone on comments here on another thread talking about how this is a problem in Ireland now as well. It's not just SF in the US, it's all over the place. A friend recently told me about his search for a place to rent in rural western Washington and they said it was just impossible to find even a one bedroom place under $1800/mo even in this rural area where incomes are much lower than in the urban centers like Seattle and Tacoma.
No one I knew, could afford an entire apartment to themselves!
I find it weird that people complain about not being able to rent their own entire apartment, but are in their 20s. It wasn't a thing 30 years ago!
As one advances in their career, eg in their 30s, then income tends to rise, due to experience, and better paying jobs.
San Fran is an outlier here. Literally the most expensive area on the planet, with loads of money floating around. Of course rent is crazy expensive.
In my experience growing up, everyone I knew could afford to buy a house on a single salary when 28-30, so that’s what I expect for myself.
Anything other than that is a regression.
But... that's what caused the current problem, some say. Rates too low, for a decade, causing a housing bubble. It sounds to me like what you recall, was an aberration.
3 times annual salary seems reasonsble to me.
Did you grow up in 1958? Because that's the last time that was true.
...Or can it? The solution then is to build more housing; YIMBYism, go to local government meetings and vote for YIMBYist candidates. After all, all of the NIMBY people who bought their house decades ago are there, day after day. There really is no way around this.
> Just 47.9% of U.S. millennials owned homes in 2020, according to Apartment List analysis of census data. At age 30, millennial home ownership hit 42%, compared with 48% for Gen Xers and 51% for baby boomers.
https://archive.is/P5EKj#selection-3963.136-3971.67 - Bloomberg: Don’t Blame Avocado Toast. Here’s Why Millennials Don’t Own Homes
Maybe you have access to more recent numbers that show that the majority of millennials are homeowners?
> corporate and foreign wealth
These terms are dog whistles. Unless you want to argue for something Marxist, but then "private wealth" would suffice.
I mean, what's actually happening is that the rich get richer and the poor also get richer but at a slower rate
> growing wealth inequality leads to all sorts of other dysfunction including increased crime
No, we have significantly higher inequality than the 1990s and significantly lower crime. So the opposite of what you said.
I wonder how much of that is due to removing lead from fuel?
It's not so bad in the country side, but there are very few jobs there. I have some friends (a couple with 1 kid) who moved to distant suburbs of Oslo for more affordable housing. But the long commutes destroyed their quality of life and put a strain on their marriage. They are now moving back to a tiny, very expensive rental in Oslo. Its a definitive step down from when they left.
We have outgrown our apartment -- the kids are getting bigger. So, we really need a 4 bedroom place (ideally 5 so we could have an office, but we'd settle for 4 and a desk in the living room). There are no apartments - which would be a lot more affordable than a house - that large here. The max bedroom count in apartments here that I have ever seen is 3, which we already have.
So we are planning to buy a 2-unit house ("tomannsbolig") with another couple with kids. It's the only way we can afford something with enough bedrooms, without a large inheritance or something like that. None of us have anything like that coming. We have 4 "good," stable jobs (programmers, researchers etc). Even with other couple in the mix, it feels impossible to find something in the same school district. We've been looking for over a year.
So, we are thinking about looking for a third friend or couple, since there are a few houses that have 3 units. It's just tricky to find someone you feel comfortable enough with to ask that. But we hope that 5-6 incomes will be enough in this market.
*Before anyone tells me my kids can keep sharing bedrooms, try telling that to them! The increasing need for privacy and lack of space is becoming a real problem here.
Area doesn’t building housing, leading to a massive increase in house prices and a destruction of class mobility as the rich get richer (as their houses get more valuable) and the poor get poorer (as they pay more to rent the same living space).
The growing wealth inequality leads to all sorts of other dysfunction including increased crime, worsening services, etc. as the govt cannot raise enough taxes.
And finally, instead of solving the fundamental expensive housing problem, opportunists will blame the other. More often than not the other are the victims of the problems. Immigrants in Sweden’s case, and since one can’t blame immigrants for obvious reasons in SF, homeless people in SF.