The reality is, like the sibling comment says, just proposing a simple solution doesn't work, that's not the hard part. The hard part is actually exploring and understanding the problem of what actually happens were an institution such as the IRS be assessing wealth for taxation.
"determined by the IRS" is passing the buck big time.
> In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?
Because you're skipping the most difficult and pertinent part of the solution. There's not much substance to proposing a wealth tax based on wealth brackets. All the difficulty and nuance of a wealth tax is in determining how to reasonably tax someone's wealth (E.g. assets and unrealized gains).
No solution is ideal. But it's not an intractable problem because it's regularly solved every day around the world for all sorts of reasons. If we created a branch of government whose purpose was to do this I think they could figure it out. So in that sense I'm offloading the problem to people whose job it would be to figure out the problem.
Anyway, I've spent way too much time arguing about something I don't even care about. Cheers.
Because he was mixing reality with the hypothetical. He was saying the IRS doesn't work that way in reality, which has no bearing to the discussions we were having which is a hypothetical. I explicitly stated in a previous comment that the IRS would also evaluate wealth and tax based on that wealth, and then he responds talking about how they don't tax unrealized capital gains. In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?