If you want to nitpick that every solution isn't as simple as fizzbuzz then there's no real point having a discussion. There are plenty of other tax alternatives that are also quite simple, you just seem to be unhappy with anything that isn't perfect.
No, that's the entire point of having the discussion. If the solution can't answer even these types of questions, then there's no point having the discussion, because it breaks down even upon initial examination.
> This is what the IRS is for. It's one of the only government organizations that actually makes more money than is put into it. So we'd just give them more money and resources to do their job, which would include wealth evaluation.
Sure, I agree in giving more money to the IRS, indeed that's happened recently, but even they are not going to tax unrealized capital gains.
You are completely missing the point of the conversation you started. Everything we're discussing is a hypothetical. In this scenario, they would tax that and everything else.
Anyway, I don't think that you're arguing in good faith and I'm moving on with my day. Cheers.
> Everything we're discussing is a hypothetical. In this scenario, they would tax that and everything else
Your hypothetical is "the government taxes everything". Then someone asked, "how would that work?" and your response was "everything we're discussing is a hypothetical!".
There are many obvious ideas around taxing wealth. The problem is that when you think about how they would work in reality things get very messy and difficult. Proposing the idea is not the hard part.
Because he was mixing reality with the hypothetical. He was saying the IRS doesn't work that way in reality, which has no bearing to the discussions we were having which is a hypothetical. I explicitly stated in a previous comment that the IRS would also evaluate wealth and tax based on that wealth, and then he responds talking about how they don't tax unrealized capital gains. In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?
The reality is, like the sibling comment says, just proposing a simple solution doesn't work, that's not the hard part. The hard part is actually exploring and understanding the problem of what actually happens were an institution such as the IRS be assessing wealth for taxation.
"determined by the IRS" is passing the buck big time.
> In this scenario they do, so why does that matter?
Because you're skipping the most difficult and pertinent part of the solution. There's not much substance to proposing a wealth tax based on wealth brackets. All the difficulty and nuance of a wealth tax is in determining how to reasonably tax someone's wealth (E.g. assets and unrealized gains).
No solution is ideal. But it's not an intractable problem because it's regularly solved every day around the world for all sorts of reasons. If we created a branch of government whose purpose was to do this I think they could figure it out. So in that sense I'm offloading the problem to people whose job it would be to figure out the problem.
Anyway, I've spent way too much time arguing about something I don't even care about. Cheers.
Better luck next time you try to roll your eyes.
Anything you own with a quantifiable monetary value. Yes, even if that value is not fixed.
> If I own a company worth X billion, does that mean I have to sell my shares to withdraw enough cash to pay my taxes, thereby tanking the value of my own company?
Yes.
> If I pay a lot in a downturn but my company does better in a boom, will I get refunded the extra tax I paid?
No. How does that even make sense?
The answers to these questions are easy, people you just don't like them, because they mean that those who have a lot and feel like they "got it fair and square" suddenly have to (gasp) contribute to society rather than hoarding all of that money to themselves. Even though you start to hit massive diminishing returns in terms of effect on your actual lifestyle once you're getting up into the million range, and see barely any effect at all of additional wealth or income once you're past, say, 100 million. It becomes just a dollar-denominated high score, so that you can feel smug about How Great A Businessman You Are, while millions of people starve on the streets unnecessarily.
It's not as simple as "make it illegal to have above X amount of money" because it's not really even money at that point, no one has X billion in cash lying around, it's tied to some physical asset. This is just one problem to your statement, there are many others.