Living in China from 2017 - 2020, everyone around me was confused why the US became so hostile and continuously provoke China. People here thought US was friendly. I also followed US news during this time and the relentless anti-China propaganda was crazy. Every grey situation was reported as crystal clear anti-China.
It's amazing how one Trump presidency and relentless anti-China propaganda in the mass media have convinced Americans that China is not friendly.
Does this apply to Germany during WWII?
That being said, nobody is fooled by the ad-reductio distraction of "both governments do bad things". China is now (as of Aug. '22) accused of serious human rights violations by the United Nations for their treatment of the Uighur population. Someone approved of it, and it's very likely the the current regime is aware of it. None of this stuff is up for debate, or diluted when you mention the US' own failings. It's just extremely embarrassing for China, who wants to be treated like a respected Western superpower, but can't own up to it's mistakes when they do slip up. They won't acknowledge Tienanmen Square, they won't let people debate Hong Kong, they won't deny the Uighur extermination, and now they're refusing to let the global stage investigate the origin site of the worst pandemic in a century. You can see why people would draw their own conclusions here.
Even if all of this was propaganda vs propaganda (which it isn't, but I'll entertain in good faith), China is still losing. Despite their authoritarian grasp on information, they can't control the global perception of them. It's the ultimate insecurity, and incompatible with the global ideals of freedom. Again, even if you are right, and western affairs are controlled by a mysterious free-speech cabal/shadow-government, I don't see how it changes China's disadvantage on the global stage. It took a fraction of the world's military forces to repel Russia from Ukraine, preventing a sea-based invasion of Taiwan is probably easier than the average NATO wargaming exercise. And then China would be similarly disgraced, and forced to rectify their impulsive actions with a world that doesn't want to be a part of them.
That they are not, for a fiscal treason, is an absolute travesty.
We should - all - be demanding that our trading partners stand up for the things we believe in.
To sweep a genocide or abhorrent human rights record under the table - without even attempting to make a comment - is a sign of weakness, that every country has. For profit. Personally, my standards are higher than making a profit with one group, especially when there are always more groups.
No country is perfect, but shouldn't we try to convince others and as such, hold ourselves to a higher standard?
And yet, the US actually has allies. After all the crap the US has done, it still has allies. What? Why?
Oh, because it's all about economics and power.
Oh, because it's all about economics and power.
Interesting thesis. At the same time, China has few allies. Does that mean China has a poor economy and little power?
Maybe it's news to you but China has been poor for nearly 150+ years. In the past, China had the highest GDP in the world. But the opium trade, western wars, caused it to become as poor as it did. It's only in the last 10 years or so that China's economy has been big enough to garner more allies.
Even so, maybe propaganda has convinced you that China has no allies? For example, 37 countries signed a letter supporting China's anti-domestic terrorism tactics in Xinjiang.
Part of that is that the last imperial dynasty to rule China was not Chinese, but ethnically Manchurian. A lot of problems came from that. Granted, that does not make it okay that the West helped carve them up. But a lot of their external issues in the past few centuries have internal root.
If the Han and the Manchurians could not get along, how is that the West's fault?
WRT "terrorism" in Xinjiang: I think non-Han minorities might have a different opinion than the official Beijing line.
So China does have a friend in the US. But Xi doesn't.
Surely, between:
- The Armenian Genocide
- The Holocaust
- The Holdomor
- Pogroms
- Apartheid regimes
- Purges of the Bourgeoisie
- One Child Policy
I find it hard to think that the US (With it's many, many fuck-ups) is the only, let alone the -worst- guilty party in the last 100 years.
O wait, if we only counted the last 100 years the 'great leap forward' would suddenly look a lot less great... wouldn't it?
Slavery and native American genocides are pretty bad - as well as the countless countries US has invaded/bombed.
But anyways, are we trying to estimate which country has done more bad in the last 300 years? China or US? And are you willing to become more pro-China if we conclude that the US has done more bad?
https://www.wfpusa.org/articles/1-millionth-ton-american-whe...
Any student of history would understand that China colonizing the north american continent would have been much much worse for Native Americans. There currently are slaves in China right now.
Hopefully it will be ended in North America sometime soon (fingers crossed).
‘Slavery by any name is wrong’: the push to end forced labor in prisons
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/sep/27/slavery-loop...
Slavery and the U.S. Prison System
https://www.globalpolicyjournal.com/blog/06/05/2021/slavery-...
Contemporary slavery in the United States
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_slavery_in_the_Un...
Are we now blaming China for genocide of Native Americans too?
Please remember that comments on HN are meant to be in good faith towards the discussion of the article, and regardless of any factual inconsistencies that may or may not be present in your statements, they are off topic and potentially trolling.
China, currently in 2023, is all the things the above poster says it is. A sabre rattling dictatorship that is intentionally oppressing its minorities. Chinese people are awesome but the Chinese state can go to hell.
This isn't to excuse Trump's sinophobia. He can go to hell too.
Chinese people support the CCP. Most Chinese citizens are pro-CCP. So if you have a negative view of the CCP, then you should have a negative view of Chinese too.
But you're probably wondering why Chinese people support the CCP? It's because the CCP improved the lives of 1.4 billion people and is still improving their lives. GDP per capita went from $317 in 1990 to $12,000+ in 2022. And why would they overthrow the CCP now? Makes no sense.
But if the CCP needs to be overthrown and is no longer working for Chinese people, they will overthrow it. Chinese people have been overthrowing governments for millenniums.
I disagree with the (admittedly large) subset of Chinese people who support the CCP, but me having a negative view of them as people doesn't follow from that.
> It's because the CCP improved the lives of 1.4 billion people and is still improving their lives. GDP per capita went from $317 in 1990 to $12,000+ in 2022. And why would they overthrow the CCP now?
I didn't claim that the CCP did nothing good and was all bad. There's clearly far worse alternatives than the CCP. Also, it's not accurate to attribute all of China's current success to the current CCP. A lot of it was the seeds planted thanks to the economic liberalization in the preceding few decades when the CCP was more liberal than it is today.
> But if the CCP needs to be overthrown and is no longer working for Chinese people, they will overthrow it.
Authoritarian states create mechanisms that make them difficult to overthrow.
That's funny. Chinese people support CCP. Chinese people want CCP to stay in power. CCP is made of Chinese people, and reflects quite a bit of Chinese culture. You want the CCP to go to hell. But you think Chinese people are awesome.
Are you just trying to be politically correct? It's ok to say you hate Chinese people and Chinese culture.
You underestimate the power the people have over the government. When Chinese are pissed off, they will go on the streets and protest and demand changes. Just check the riots over banks and real estate there recently.
And why does the CCP want Taiwan back? It’s because their people demand Taiwan back.
I find it hilarious when people say they love Chinese people but hate the CCP. Either they’re disingenuous because they dislike both or they don’t understand China.
> I’ve lived in China and have friends there. People there aren’t told to love the CCP.
Again, managed dissent. The real dissenters are in prison or worse.
> It’s not like North Korea.
I already said there's worse alternatives than the CCP. That doesn't absolve it from being an authoritarian dictatorship.
> I find it hilarious when people say they love Chinese people but hate the CCP. Either they’re disingenuous because they dislike both or they don’t understand China.
I already explained this to you, so either you are being disingenuous or you are determined to have a monologue. I am ending it here because this is a low value conversation.
As long as you play by their rules which include but are not limited to:
- As a business, living with the likelyhood that any govt forced partnerships with local 'private companies' are a huge risk of IP leakage. Or ghost shifts producing clones of your product. - As a consumer, knowing that their censorship rules impacts(dilutes) media that is now produced for a 'global' audience - As a human being, knowing that they have various prisons that are somewhere between the 'atrocities' the US is finger-pointed at globally and a 're-education' camp in North Korea.
> It's amazing how one Trump presidency and relentless anti-China propaganda in the mass media have convinced Americans that China is not friendly.
OK taking off -all- political glasses and looking at behavior of the populaces.
The world saw how US Citizens reacted for better or worse when told to wear masks.
Compare that to how China deals with Dissidents, or their initial Pandemic response.
Yea, this did not happen. I was living in China during most of Trump's presidency. People in China did not get their feelings hurt because of trade disputes. Everyone knew it was just business.
But US mass media propaganda took it to a whole new level with anti-China sentiment during Trump years. Perhaps it was a tactic to distract Americans of their real issues? Maybe put the blame on some other entity?
We know, which is why that line from the CCP is ridiculous every time they say it. You're missing the larger picture, nobody is upset at the people of China. I also don't fault China for doing how they do (I mean, apart from the genocide etc). They have been very successful at leveraging everything they have to pull the nation out of poverty. They did some rotten shit internally and externally to make that happen, but so have most nations.
None of that makes them our friend.
[1] https://it.euronews.com/my-europe/2021/05/07/il-montenegro-l... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/18/china-forced-2... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_internment_camps#%3A%... [4] https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis....
USA can be a land of opportunities, but also quite a shitty country, I would never live there, but there's still rule of law and separation of powers. In China there's Xi Jinping rule.
Tesla seems to be the leader here. Per Investor Day[0] and other sources, they
- developed low-cobalt and low-nickel cathodes, to reduce scarce battery metals
- increased overall vehicle efficiency to allow iron cathodes which are earth-abundant
- consolidated electronic modules to reduce microchips and wiring
- are soon switching to 48V, to further reduce low-voltage copper wiring (copper being a 'medium-rare' metal)
- switched from copper to aluminum high voltage conductors (per Munro Live), aluminum having better conductivity-to-weight
- reduced vehicle structure with structural battery design and 'gigacasting' manufacturing
Many of these seem to benefit from vertical integration.
Are any other manufacturers pushing as hard here?
Why would they. Most of those things are not sustainable.
You don't want alluminium wires in your car.
Where aluminum causes fires is due to the fact that it expands and contracts more than copper does, and it can oxidize and corrode when not properly cared for (for example, when dissimilar metals are used, or when exposed aluminum wire ends are not properly coated).
We can assume that someone at Tesla is familiar with the properties of aluminum and can insure that they are using the right connectors to mitigate these issues. (or at least, we can hope)
Aluminum was used for a short time in the west for household wiring and was quickly outlawed.
Why not? I^2*r says that running 75% less current will generate 94% less heat.
Existing copper wires would be a disaster if cars ran on a 3V system. Aluminum at 48V will be fine, as long as it’s sized appropriately the same way copper is today.
Thats not the argument, you can do that now with copper cables.
Aluminium is a good conductor, but it is reactive, brittle and not as malleable as copper.
also, copper has almost half the resistance per meter than aluminium. So even for solid bus bars, it doesn't make that much sense, unless you have structural bus bars.
But 4 times the weight
And twice the resistance doesn’t matter. So you go one gauge bigger. If the material is cheaper, more available, and suitable, that’s fine. We don’t insist on gold wires because they’re “better” than copper.
It’s all tradeoffs. I don’t see a reason to be philosophically opposed to aluminum other than “it’s possible to do it wrong”, which is of course also true for copper.
Indeed, but automotive wiring is subject to intense and persistent vibration and heat cycles. so all those ties become stress points for fatigue to cluster around.
I'm not saying its never a good idea to use an aluminium wire loom, but I'm struggling to find a situation where its required
It's not really the flexible thing you picture with the word "loom." The solid aluminum conductor is inside an aluminum tube (mounted to the body), with insulation between.
These are thick high voltage conductors. I'm sure Tesla did their homework on flex and fatigue.
The place we saw this used was for fixed rigid bus bars, notably the "cable" from the charge port to the battery.[0]
Previously they used traditional stranded copper. Now it's a solid aluminum conductor, wrapped in insulation and protected by an outer aluminum tube.
>copper has almost half the resistance per meter than aluminium
That's why I mentioned conductivity-to-weight, which is the more critical metric. Copper is over 3x as dense, at 9.0 g/cm³ vs 2.7 g/cm³ for aluminum.
It doesn't hurt that aluminum is cheaper and far more abundant.
Additionally, aircraft airframes are regularly inspected and fully radiographed at certain intervals. Components that develop flaws are changed out when the flaws are detected. The same is not true of cars.
Why not?
If Tesla has switched to aluminum I imagine they've found a way to fix that. Possibly by making the entire electrical system out of aluminum, so that it all expands the same way, or possibly a connector designed to avoid that.
Properly terminated, there is no problem with aluminum wiring in your house. As another replier mentioned, most houses do have aluminum wiring in the run to the house and the run from the meter to the panel, and sometimes in the larger runs like stove and dryer.
It's also worth noting that the newer aluminum formulas like Southwire SIMpul, are not like the old aluminum like was installed in my house in the early '70s. But, buyers are still gunshy from the '70s, so copper is generally preferred
I think that everyone should look on his "forward looking statements" with a higher than normal degree of skepticism. He does seem to pull off a lot of outlandish stuff, though, so it doesn't pay to be too skeptical.
> I consider him and his companies to be completely untrustworthy. He could be selling water in the desert and I still would never buy another thing from him.
I don't think that that same level of skepticism is warranted towards his statements about what is true today. But then again, I haven't been following him very closely, so maybe his pant are constantly on fire.
https://twitter.com/ICannot_Enough/status/161837414087616512...
This is about as silly as people who think he’s the messiah. He’s clearly over promised on many things, but he’s also delivered on a lot.
And spacex motto is turning the impossible into late, so he’s being pretty honest about his goals being off. What’s the issue? Why do you hate him so much?
In an interview by Munro[1] , Elon Musk previously mentioned the desire to switch to 48V together with the desire to use PoE. Combining data and power over the same wires.
The move of automakers to 48V has been in the works for a while:
* https://www.autoevolution.com/news/understanding-the-shift-t...
* https://whma.org/overview-of-48-volt-systems-in-the-automoti...
* https://www.google.com/search?q=48V+cars
It's just a bit of a co-ordination / chicken-egg problem in that equipment probably has to be to handle 12V and 48V for a while during a transition period.
They’re also in-sourcing electronics which should help give Tesla greater supply chain control.
Plus the non-rare-earth high energy permanent magnets thing is a pretty huge blow to China’s efforts to monopolize the rare earth magnet supply chain. China produces 92% of the rare earth magnets in the world, as well as mining the vast majority of the material and also processing.
Tesla doesn’t want to cut off China. But having less reliance on China helps prevent Tesla from being manipulated by the whims of Chinese government leadership, increasing Tesla’s bargaining power in China.
So this isn't really anything to do with national security. It's a better moral outcome with some economic trade off...
If China were to stop selling them, everyone else would have a lot of difficulties replacing them right away and would need at least 5-10 years to pick up the pace.
My understanding is that both China and Russia underpriced on purpose, driving (for example) US mines and production out of business.
And after, then raised pricing.
There are many rare earth mines in North America, sitting fallow...
(This isn't an unknown business tactic for anyone to follow.)
It is most certainly a trade off and I'm not seeing where the cons are mentioned.
Moreover, lithium-ion batteries have by far the most efficienty energy density, so what is tesla getting rid of, most certainly not lithium, which is the bulk of the battery.
Iron nitride magnets are probably the most likely candidate, and they can actually have higher energy than rare earth magnets, and have particularly good high temperature coercivity compared to Neodymium based magnets, although not quite as high coercivity at room temperatures (but high temperature may be the limiting factor in existing motors).
So I don’t understand where this sad sack negativity comes from, because it most certainly doesn’t come from knowledge in the field. There are materials science improvements over time, and this is one such area. There can be a net improvement, not just a pure trade-off. Niron Magnetics is one such company trying to commercialize the material, and you can go to their location in Minneapolis and play with their iron nitride magnets if you like.
Tesla did use high energy cylindrical li-ion cells in their cars before others. Sometimes things improve, through the hard work of researchers.
Disclaimer: I am no fanboy of Tesla; I think Tesla's lunch will be eaten by BYD, either alone or together with other Chinese EV manufacturers, in part because Tesla has been resting on its laurels for so long (still selling the model S!); but facts are facts.
> But battery research is ongoing from a century...
Tesla's claim is about motors, not batteries.
Tesla has implemented solutions that no one else has, such as their "two casting chassis", which Toyota engineers recently called " a work of art" and "genius". The 4680 cylindrical battery is also a Tesla innovation.
> It is most certainly a trade off...
It is not clear at all whether this announced motor is a trade off. It may be the way ahead to further improvements in the space of EV motors. More detail would be good to have; that much is true.
> Moreover, lithium-ion batteries...[lithium] is the bulk of the battery.
Again, this is about motors, not batteries. It's eliminating the neodymium and other "rare earth"[1] elements used in the permanent magnets present in nearly all EV motors to date. No EV motors use lithium in significant amounts.
But the numeracy nazi in me must also point out that when it comes to batteries, there is more nickel than lithium, by a considerable margin, in NMC and NCA (nickel-manganese-cobalt and nickel-cobalt-aluminum) lithium-ion batteries. There is more iron than lithium in LFP lithium batteries. And depending on construction, there may be still more copper.
1. "Earth" is a now-obsolete term for "ore". These metals are not rare, but they spread themselves around, so economically minable ore bodies tend to be hard to find. The metals are not rare, but their earths are.
The tech and featues in a Tesla are far beyond what BYD is even close to delivering.
BYD's growth has been nothing close to Tesla's
Tesla has around four times the net income of BYD despite BYD selling three times as many cars
Telsa is making industry defining changes to manufacturing that BYD hasn't even started on
Telsa is deploying more than double the battery capacity as BYD
Tesla is far more vertically integrated than BYD
Not sure how any of this is resting on laurels or at all a sign that BYD is at risk of being a threat
BMW already has a motor that doesn't use rare earths:
https://interestingengineering.com/innovation/bmws-fifth-gen...
https://www.motortrend.com/news/bmw-ix-m60-brushed-electric-...
If successful, this contributes towards the reduction of national security risk around rare earth supplies and supply chain located in a possibly unfriendly nation state (major deposits are in Russia and China) and also means you don’t have to establish rare earth mines or supply chains in your own countries (capital and environmental concerns). It’s a big deal!
Also, just as newer battery chemistries moved away from cobalt (a conflict mineral), this too is progress in countering arguments against EVs due to their material sourcing.
“Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.”