News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by tough on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:15PM (#34755325)
That's pretty funny, remembers me of some ship or airplane that was also built bigger than the hangar it was being built on, and thus couldn't be extracted once finished
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:22PM (#34755397)
Probably many examples. Maybe you're thinking of Jeff Bezos' yacht that couldn't fit under a decommissioned (but still standing) railway bridge:

https://www.npr.org/2022/02/09/1079568745/jeff-bezos-yacht-d...

https://www.cbc.ca/radio/asithappens/as-it-happens-the-thurs...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by cjbgkagh on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:36PM (#34756092)
I thought that temporary dismantling the bridge was the plan from the beginning, it’s the political push back that was unexpected.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:18PM (#34755354)
France had a similar (but more easily mitigated blunder): Trains too wide for station's platforms, requiring ~1000 platforms to be "re-configured".

> The error seems to have happened because the national rail operator RFF gave the wrong dimensions to train company SNCF.

> Our correspondent says that they measured platforms built less than 30 years ago, overlooking the fact that many of France's regional platforms were built more than 50 years ago when trains were a little slimmer.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-27497727

I guess it's no surprise that Le Monde preferred to bring Spain's other example of their submarine blunder instead of their own French one :)

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Drunk_Engineer on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:01PM (#34755759)
Another example is the Amtrak Acela. The coaches were built 4" too wide, and as a result the expensive "tilt" feature could not be used along a major section of the route.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by un_montagnard on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:19PM (#34755928)
France stations weren't build as per the spec. That would have had to be corrected at some point anyway.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by orwin on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:28PM (#34756029)
I'm pretty sure this was heavily covered it when it happened 8 years ago. This was also 5 times less expensive
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by nine_k on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:55PM (#34756239)
If I were a train-building contractor, I'd send someone with a laser rangefinder to a few of the actual stations to double-check the official figures. And also to every tunnel.

Unless these errors are going to be fixed at the expense of the government / railway company. not the manufacturer, of course. (Sad laughter.)

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by fredoralive on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:25PM (#34756520)
If you build it to the specs and standards provided, I'm not sure how you'd be liable. It's the clients mess up.

However I do wonder if the modern ability to do very precise manufacturing means that designs now often just push to the absolute limit of the standards. A few decades ago there would be be a bit of margin left in for error, but now we can hit the limits of the envelope fairly precisely. Which means the infrastructure needs to do the same...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by TuringTest on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:09PM (#34757388)
In fact the providers didn't follow the procedure established by contract, which required them to measure the actual size of the ancient tunnels instead of relying on standard measures (which by law were required to be established following modern standards; they knew they would not be valid for the actual project, that's why they asked for an investigation to find out the actual size needed). [1]

The delay is not caused by any mistake, despite what the press and politicians said; it's being caused by the established security protocols being followed (for one) to avoid a catastrophe (which has happened in the recent past for not being followed).

1 - https://twitter.com/unodelarenfe/status/1623588179520413696?...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:27PM (#34756546)
Getting all stations to a common standard is the right thing to do, specially if you want to build trains accessible for everybody.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by simplotek on Sunday February 12, 2023 @12:11PM (#34764548)
> France had a similar (but more easily mitigated blunder): Trains too wide for station's platforms, requiring ~1000 platforms to be "re-configured".

France's problem was entirely different. They designed a train up to spec, but it turned out that about 10-20% of train stations failed to comply with it.

[dead]
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by narag on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:27PM (#34755437)
The travellers and industries in the affected places mind. They've been left behind for a long time and when at last it seems the problem was to be solved, this "funny" thing happens.

Nobody resigned. They fired a couple of engineers, one of them they re-hired (with better salary) elsewhere. That is worse in my book.

Oh and I will stop talking about other funny things happening around here. It's a nice Saturday evening.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by bryanmgreen on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:20PM (#34755377)
I always wonder how seriously significant and BASIC errors such as this happen...

My experience suggests it's likely because there's too much power at senior levels and lack of ownership at lower ones. Like some senior person says "tunnel needs to be 7 meters wide", everyone vehemently nods in rote agreement, and no one double checks that should actually be 8 meters until some intern discovers the mistake while preparing info for a case study deck.

Any thoughts?

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by ChrisMarshallNY on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:35PM (#34755517)
Eager managers (or lead engineers) that circumvent the usual “boring” vetting steps.

Sadly, those of us in software, are quite familiar with these types of blunders.

Fortunately, software is “soft,” so we can, quite often, code our way out of these messes.

Hardware, on the other hand, is “hard,” so it isn’t so easy to extricate ourselves.

I worked for hardware companies, for most of my career, and experienced the mind-numbing “measure twice, cut once” methodology that they use.

Software folks seldom have patience for that, and, to be fair, the process can introduce deadly rigidity to a software project (which was why I was fighting a constant hopeless battle for flexibility).

So I guess another possibility is, is that someone promoted a software architect into a position of influence in the project.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by IIAOPSW on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:35PM (#34755522)
I'm sure when they were all private railroads, every company had a consistent standard for width of tunnel. Unify all those independently designed systems together, lose some important documentation along the way, and you're left with something where you can't simply look up important technical constraints.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by ahazred8ta on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:53PM (#34755687)
In 2013, Spain had to lengthen their new model of S-80 submarines by 10 meters, because a spreadsheet error made them 100 tons overweight.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by TuringTest on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:15PM (#34757450)
That may happen, but it's not the case here.

The project was written using modern standard sizes, as required by law; but knowing that the tunnels are ancient, they also mandated the provider to make a field study to figure out the real tunnel minimum sizes, and build the trains according to its result.

The scandal happened when this caused a delay in the initial estimated dates, and politicians found out that they wouldn't be able to open the train lines in time for this year's elections.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Drunk_Engineer on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:22PM (#34755392)
Clickbait headline -- the error was caught during the design phase. At worst, this will cause a 2-3 year delay in building the trains.

The more interesting thing about the story is how several top government officials were fired as a result. That would never happen in the US, where decade-long delays are commonplace for train procurement.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Tao3300 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:39PM (#34755552)
And that's why I always travel with uBlock.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by remote_phone on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:45PM (#34755618)
Only 2-3 years? That’s a disaster what do you mean! People need to be kept on the payroll, etc and the entire schedule will have more consequences. That is a huge expense for something that is literally a few clicks on a keyboard. It’s something that should never have happened.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by BigRedDog1669 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:44PM (#34756159)
I think they mean that it is bad, but minor compared to what would have happened in the US or some other countries, where train projects are delayed 10 years without design problems.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by fsckboy on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:07PM (#34757370)
without even commenting on the idea that govt bureaucracy is somehow worse in the US than in the romance countries, a 2-3 year delay would still be added on, and is very significant. it's not like a 10 year delay is great because it gives time to make everything else come out right.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by simplotek on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:47AM (#34762426)
> (...) but minor compared to what would have happened in the US or some other countries (...)

That's just speculation to try to mitigate a colossal screwup.

This is not the first time when Spanish railway companies are caught trying to cover up the consequences of massive incompetence. For instance, the infamous Santiago de Compostela train disaster[1] was attributed to a careless train conductor going over the speed limit to impress a girl, which was a very convenient scapegoat to both ADIF and Renfe, but in truth the root cause as that both companies failed to deploy a mandatory speed monitoring and control system, which has been standard for decades.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santiago_de_Compostela_derailm...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:00PM (#34755748)
Dishonest comment.

> While the manufacturer came to the realization relatively early during the design stage, the delivery will still be delayed by two to three years and the project, initially estimated at €258 million, will suffer a massive yet-to-be-determined cost blowout.

> "I hope that heads will roll!" said the president of the Cantabria regional government, Miguel Angel Revilla, on Thursday, February 2, without hiding his anger against what he called "monumental pig work."

Headline is exactly right... and strange that you went out of your way to invent the "at worst qualifier" to sure up your claim.

This is the definition of a blunder: having a firm work for nearly 3 years on bad measurements, then having to push back the project by 2-3 years? That's implying almost all of the work from when the designs were given to them in 2020 will have to be revised.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by handsclean on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:42PM (#34756135)
In correcting a triviality, you’ve been more dishonest than GP and even the headline. GP inflated the confidence of the three year limit. You said that the headline is “exactly right”, while in fact it’s objectively false, the “new trains” it refers to do not exist. You’ve also fabricated 2-3 years of repeated work, which is not backed by this source, would be pretty bizarre if truly nothing could be salvaged, and in fact is apparently contradicted by other sources, which state that the firm worked with bad measurements for only about a year.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:29PM (#34756562)
You're clearly struggling with comprehension but I'm always happy to teach.

> You said that the headline is “exactly right”, while in fact it’s objectively false, the “new trains” it refers to do not exist

If I give you designs to build me a new house, and it doesn't fit on the lot, that means my new house is too big for the lot.

And in fact, I don't even have to give you designs. The moment I communicate intention for the new house, the phrase "new house" refers to... the new house, regardless of its state. We can chat about "the new house" without even having picked which continent it will exist on. "Where will the new house be built?"

Similarly if I ask an artist for a painting, and the artists finds the painting I asked for won't fit on the canvas before making a single brush stroke, the wording is "your new painting won't fit on this canvas".

-

Honestly not the most complicated turn of phrase, so if you couldn't grasp that, it's not hard to see where you're coming up with stuff like...

> You’ve also fabricated 2-3 years of repeated work

No, I didn't. Critical thinking may come across like a fabrication if you refuse to indulge yourself in it, but happy to share my work: If I'm on a project for 2-3 years, then I find because of a mistake I need to push things back 2-3 years, that means that heavily implies that... the work of those 2-3 years were wasted?

Now let's remember what I said...

> That's implying almost all of the work from when the designs were given to them in 2020 will have to be revised.

Marvelous.

-

> in fact is apparently contradicted by other sources, which state that the firm worked with bad measurements for only about a year.

That "apparently" is a funny way of saying "I didn't verify the sibling comment, which I already admitted was willing to inflate the sources I do have". If only the comprehension could catch up to the brevity.

-

By the way, what do you think it means when the government official says

"without hiding his anger against what he called "monumental pig work."

Obviously there was something lost in translation there, but let's apply that critical thinking and guess, if just maybe, it means there was a ton of wasted work...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by dang on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @03:44AM (#34786973)
You broke the site guidelines egregiously here. Please don't do that again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by handsclean on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:20PM (#34798793)
On re-reading my previous comment, it was pretty insulting, which I think provoked you to retaliate. I apologize for my tone.

Modifying your example’s verb, if you said “Where is the new house?”, then I’d say you’re implying the new house presently exists - unless we’re currently poring over housing development plans, in which case I’d say you’re clearly referring only to plans. Maybe the reason we’re reading the headline differently is context. This is the first I’ve heard of new Spanish trains, so I took the words out of context (until after clicking and reading), but if you were already aware of this planning-stage project then I can see how the headline would conjure train plans, not presently existing trains, for you.

Re 2-3 years, the alternative is that the delay includes some repeated work, some time where work is done inefficiently or even on hold due to confused requirements, some things with lead time that got reset, and the overhead of correcting the mistake. Still a costly screwup, of course.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by dang on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @03:45AM (#34786983)
Please make your substantive points without swipes or personal attacks.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by handsclean on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:25PM (#34798838)
Ok. Sorry.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Drunk_Engineer on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:19PM (#34755931)
Reading Spanish language sources, I find no reporting that says the firm did any actual work on the project. The delay was due entirely to communication back and forth between Renfe, Adif, and the contractor about what size train to build. The firm notified their customer way back in 2021 about the size discrepancy, and it has taken much time to resolve.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by petre on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:36PM (#34756091)
> it has taken much time to resolve

This is quite typical of state owned companies in Europe.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:30PM (#34756045)
Clearly they have been doing work if they notified the customer 2 years ago and are still going back and forth... the way this type of procurement works means that there's massive cost involved in this mistake even if not a single train has been built.

If anything you're actually proving the headline even more accurate, since you're making it clear Spain (as in the government) is the one really owning the majority of the incompetence here: when normally it's more of a mix between the firm and the customer

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by favaq on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:18PM (#34755923)
>The more interesting thing about the story is how several top government officials were fired as a result

This is false, government propaganda. https://www.antena3.com/noticias/sociedad/despedido-renfe-po...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by madaxe_again on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:26PM (#34756009)
Yeah, I’m scratching my head at the British press laughing at them over this, but seemingly not giving two tiny damns that HS2 is now between £4,000,000,000 and £66,000,000,000 over budget depending on whose figures you trust, and counting.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:24PM (#34756511)
British Press has been on HS2 quite a bit. Specially when you compare it to the endless highway expansion, those don't get criticized.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by madaxe_again on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:42PM (#34756681)
True - RIS2 is also running £3,000,000,000 over the £25,000,000,000 budget — while also somehow saying that they can’t spend all of the budget on time.

It’s a nonsensical state of affairs.

https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/153/transport-com...

https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/transport-bosses-adm...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @09:16PM (#34758891)
Reduce the high way budget by 90% and invest add the Leeds part of HS2 back.

HS2 is 100+ year infrastructure that massively improves the complete rail network of all of England and will allow England to go from backwards in terms of trains to having a fantastic overall network.

England is perfect for High Speed Rail, and rail in general. What they are missing is a few more Crossrail style projects (or S-Bahn style as we call it) in cities other then London, and more Crossrail in London.

I am advocating the same in Switzerland. We already have a great rail network, but one High Speed Line right across the major population part can improve overall rail infrastructure by a huge amount.

Switzerland has rail modal share of ~20% and with a new high speed line and a host of other things, that could be raised to 30-40%.

The capacity you gain on all the old lines for regional and cargo travel is huge.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by madaxe_again on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:35AM (#34761087)
I support HS2 in principle, but the practical outcome is dire - they are having trouble securing rolling stock, and it looks like due to noise concerns they’re only going to run something like four (diesel) trains a day on it, at 60kph - and then they’ll declare it unprofitable and beeching it, most likely.

This is just how public infrastructure projects in the U.K. work, I’m afraid.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Sunday February 12, 2023 @11:34AM (#34764150)
I don't believe that. If the lines that get built they will 100% not run diesel trains on it and it will run as often as planned. At least after a few years. And if a project is done for the next 100+ years, then a few years lower utilization isn't a big deal.

Seems to me all the claims made about how it will fall short and be barley better then a old Victorian line is scare mongering to devalue the project and discredit the benefits it gives.

What is really sad is that the Greens are against it, what utter idiots. Hopefully you can elect some government that actually gets behind the project fully again.

> and then they’ll declare it unprofitable and beeching it, most likely

I don't believe that. NetworkRail was unprofitable, made public still exists. Franchise, unprofitable, made public again still exist. So the idea of these lines simply going away isn't really credible.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by simplotek on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:15AM (#34762269)
> Clickbait headline -- the error was caught during the design phase.

I don't agree. This is a colossal blunder. Train clearance is a very basic trait of each railway line, along with track gauge. Ordering trains that you cannot even operate in your railway lines is perhaps the biggest screwup any railway operator can possibly make.

I'm not sure you fully understand the magnitude of this sort of screwup. Catching the problem in the design stage actually means it took the manufacturer to double-check the contract to realize his client did a gross unrecoverable mistake that resulted in their orders being fundamentally incompatible with their intended use.

The only clickbaity aspect of this article was tacking another notorious episode of Spanish mishaps which was their submarine design being fundamentally broken. It reads more like a cheap jab at Spain than anything else.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by spyware11 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:25PM (#34755420)
Who f'd up? The guy measuring was too lazy or was it sabotage?
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by jeffbee on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:33PM (#34755503)
As an American I can only imagine the luxury of living in a rich nation that would replace a fleet of rail cars only 40 years old.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by IIAOPSW on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:39PM (#34755559)
What are you on about. American cities and states do keep their fleets up to date. Its a bit of a bell curve, but replacement after a median of 40 years is fairly typical. Just the other day in the news.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rYBQVB8H1Mw

BART also got a bunch of new cars in the past few years.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by jeffbee on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:45PM (#34755615)
And yet the majority of the BART trains in actual service right now are not new. They still have 1968 rolling stock in regular service.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Kon-Peki on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:39PM (#34756651)
Hey, I saw a brand new BART rail car in Omaha a few weeks ago! It was heading west on interstate 80, on a trailer, being pulled by a semi truck...

A few years ago, I saw a big line of brand new VIA rail locomotives (Ontario Canada) heading east in Chicago. But at least they were on CN railroad tracks under their own power…

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by IIAOPSW on Saturday February 11, 2023 @11:48PM (#34759893)
That has to do with FRA rules. In short, mainline passenger railcars are held to a certain standard of crash-worthiness with freight trains. An excessive standard many will say but none the less its a rule. Subways and metro trains, provided they don't share track with the national network, aren't held to that standard.

That's why your BART car is shipped on a flatbed and not under its own wheels.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by jeffbee on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:32PM (#34776887)
Uh, isn't it also because BART uses a wide gauge?
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by IIAOPSW on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:58PM (#34849186)
shit you're right. I forgot that part. But, if it used standard gauge, you'd still see it being transported in non-train-like ways.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by burntwater on Saturday February 11, 2023 @10:39PM (#34759456)
I think a median of 40 years is exactly the problem - I would expect a median of 20-30, with 40 being at the tail end.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by IIAOPSW on Sunday February 12, 2023 @12:03AM (#34759985)
Why though? Barring some huge technical advance that makes upgrading worth it, wouldn't we want to get the longest possible useful life out of our public expenditures? What problem is solved by replacing them more often?
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by 1123581321 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:04PM (#34755783)
It greatly depends on the railroad. Amtrak car ages average about 30 years. National average for freight is around 20 years. The CTA L is all either built or refurbished in the last 24 years and the bulk of the stock is less than 15 years old. BART, MBTA and NYC Subway are more embarrassing with their 40-50-year-old cars and constant delays to put their complete new orders in service.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by xchip on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:38PM (#34755542)
France knows what a big shame this is as it happened the same to them:

"French red faces over trains that are 'too wide'" (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-27497727)

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by pubby on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:55PM (#34755710)
Is it typical for trains to be custom made? For some reason I had imagined them to be made like cars
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by fhars on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:04PM (#34755788)
They are usually procured in series, but only a few (compared with cars) trains per series are built. For example, there are three configurations for Germanys current top of the line ICE4 high speed train, with 37, 50 and 50 sets built.

Trains seat more people than cars, and they don't spend most of their time sitting idle in parking lots, so you need fewer.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Scoundreller on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:21PM (#34755956)
These ones are probably custom made because they’re being built to a 1-meter gauge.

There are about 3 popular train gauges in Spain: 1m, Iberian and the high speed trains at least use the European standard to they can travel non-stop.

Toronto had to spend a lot more money on its streetcar refresh because they use a gauge nobody else uses, along with tighter turning radii than most other systems.

Usually manufacturers take their standard designs and modify them, but can run into issues where things unexpectedly resonate when you tweak the design.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by pvaldes on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:48PM (#34756736)
a) First Spanish railways were built more wide by design than french ones. This allows more speed and stability but has the plus to disconnecting the Iberian Peninsula from Europe on purpose [1]. Therefore replacing the old trains is not so simple as just choosing a new model in a maker's catalogue.

b) Neither is to fix the railway. The North of Spain has a lot of mountains so to fix the thousands of extant tunnels would be just too expensive. The delay to connect the North with Madrid by fast train can be measured in decades and a main obstacle is snow melting and falling through tiny crevices to flood the tunnels in construction. We have very good engineers but unexpected events just happen.

All of this said, none of this facts should be a secret for the maker, and after hearing about the other cases, I wouldn't bet that this is not an old maker's trick to increase the bills. Not without more context. As politician Revilla is an opportunist survivor, so acting outraged is expected [2].

----------------

[1] Therefore blocking other countries to use their trains to move troops and tanks and invading Spain in a lightning operation. When your neighbor could be Napoleon or Hitler is better to be safe than sorry. This sword cuts both ways and was a problem later in peace times to export our products to Europe.

[2] He just will say anything that his current audience wants to hear, as has been doing for decades. He knows probably that acting angry and blaming other will deflect any responsibilities far from himself.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by fredoralive on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:06PM (#34756355)
Because there was no one standard back in the 19th century, not everything is standardised. You can have different loading gauges (roughly, what size vehicle will fit through the infrastructure) and the track gauge (the width between the rails). Whilst most of continental Europe is fairly standardised nowadays, you have various exceptions, like Spain and Portugal using a metre wide track gauge, or Great Britain[1] having a very small loading gauge.

Beyond that, the order size of the various railways is often relatively low (hundreds to thousands or carriages, or dozens of full sets) and railway operators often want them customised for specific services types (an intercity operator will want first class coaches and provision for food service, a commuter operator will want to cram as many people in as possible etc.) so everything going to be bespoke at some level.

[1] The island of Ireland, both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, uses a different set of standards to Great Britain or mainland Europe.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Someone on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:31PM (#34756583)
There’s also variation in

- how power is delivered through the overhead wire (direct or alternating current, switching frequency, voltage), often even within a country, for example because high speed rail needs more power and cannot use what’s used elsewhere (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_railway_electrificatio...)

- platform height (again, often even within a country. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_platform_height)

Two centuries of work leads to significant technical debt.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by linker3000 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @05:50PM (#34757254)
The UK's Southern/South Eastern region train networks have third rail power pickup.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:37PM (#34756640)
The numbers are just far lower then cars. The individual parts are far larger and far lower numbers. You can't have as much economics of scale.

Also, every customer has a lot of wishes. Imagine it more like Uber buying 1 million GM cars demanding to have costume interior and many other details.

It really depends on what the train is supposed to do. A train is mostly costume to its mission. An S-Bahn that operates more like metro, needs lots of large doors with a open layout. The same basic train can also be configured for an inter-city operations, having very different layout, different doors and so on.

And each country has different standard, differ track gauge, loading gauge, signaling, breaking and so on. Accessibility standards is another huge thing that is slight different everywhere.

But even so, lots of train types are quite similar, lots of train are built on the same platforms. Each of the manufactures have a few standard platforms. And inside different train there is lots of reuse.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Kon-Peki on Saturday February 11, 2023 @05:12PM (#34756945)
> Is it typical for trains to be custom made?

Well, yes and no. There is a basic train set, and then it is usually customized to the operator’s needs. There isn’t really a “reference design” you can order, because nobody would order it. But the manufacturer tries to have as much commonality that they can to get some scale advantages.

Metra (Chicago’s intracity rail) has ordered a few hundred of these French trains [1]. They will be push/pulled by diesel locomotives, and the “customizations” are mainly just having bicycle storage areas and wheelchair ramps on both sides that work regardless of platform height (even no platform at all).

But that basic train car is used in a lot of European countries.

[1] https://www.alstom.com/coradia-stream-regional-trains-higher...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by LargoLasskhyfv on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:12PM (#34755851)
Maybe they used unpatched Xerox Work Centres?

C.f. https://www.theregister.com/2013/08/06/xerox_copier_flaw_mea...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by soco on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:23PM (#34755976)
A warm hello from Zurich, Switzerland, where they noticed the fancy new trams are too thick to turn in places only when testing them, so another half a year of rebuilding certain platforms followed.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:28PM (#34756553)
When did this happen? I remember the Cobra had issue. Or is this happening now?
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by soco on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:51AM (#34771783)
Yes, the Cobra.
Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by rippercushions on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:26PM (#34756010)
Pretty much the same issue happened in Sydney back in 2018:

https://news.com.au/technology/innovation/nsws-2-billion-new...

But they came up with a cheaper solution: revise the safety standards so it's not a problem, and in completely unrelated news, renovate 10 tunnels.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:25PM (#34756529)
Increasing your loading gauge to a bigger standard has quite a few advantages. If the tunnels were old renovating with bigger standard isn't a bad idea.

I mean it would be better to plan this sort of thing form the beginning, but still.

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by panick21_ on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:22PM (#34756499)
Something I didn't know much about, loading gauge. Everybody know that rails have a gauge that is different in different places.

I didn't know much about loading gauge and how big deal it is. Of course its totally logical once you think about it, but I never did.

Britain who build so much infrastructure in the Victorian period has tiny tunnels and bridges. So they have a small loading gauge. That has disadvantages, both for operations but also it makes electrification harder.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loading_gauge

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by Al-Khwarizmi on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:32PM (#34757604)
The issue is much more complex than that. No one really made a blatant blunder. It's mostly an issue of interaction between obsolete infrastructure that doesn't meet modern safety standards, laws enforcing said standards, and bureaucracy.

This Twitter thread explains it in detail (sorry, in Spanish, but machine translation should do a good job):

https://twitter.com/unodelarenfe/status/1623588179520413696?...

Re:Spanish rail's costly blunder: New trains too large for t... by pvaldes on Saturday February 11, 2023 @08:24PM (#34758459)
A very interesting point in the link. In resume yes, it seems that trains really would physically fit in the tunnels and would enter and exit the tunnels without problems

... what they would not do is respecting the buffer space of security around that is required by current laws. As result if a train stops in some tunnels for an emergency the people may not have enough space for exiting the train safely and quickly (by modern standards).