HS2 is 100+ year infrastructure that massively improves the complete rail network of all of England and will allow England to go from backwards in terms of trains to having a fantastic overall network.
England is perfect for High Speed Rail, and rail in general. What they are missing is a few more Crossrail style projects (or S-Bahn style as we call it) in cities other then London, and more Crossrail in London.
I am advocating the same in Switzerland. We already have a great rail network, but one High Speed Line right across the major population part can improve overall rail infrastructure by a huge amount.
Switzerland has rail modal share of ~20% and with a new high speed line and a host of other things, that could be raised to 30-40%.
The capacity you gain on all the old lines for regional and cargo travel is huge.
This is just how public infrastructure projects in the U.K. work, I’m afraid.
Seems to me all the claims made about how it will fall short and be barley better then a old Victorian line is scare mongering to devalue the project and discredit the benefits it gives.
What is really sad is that the Greens are against it, what utter idiots. Hopefully you can elect some government that actually gets behind the project fully again.
> and then they’ll declare it unprofitable and beeching it, most likely
I don't believe that. NetworkRail was unprofitable, made public still exists. Franchise, unprofitable, made public again still exist. So the idea of these lines simply going away isn't really credible.
It’s a nonsensical state of affairs.
https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/153/transport-com...
https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/transport-bosses-adm...