Reddit, 4cham, other cesspools like that I get, but why HN? This community fancies itself better than that. So either there's an explanation for why those takes gain as much traction here or...
(this is a serious question)
Many on HK has emotional intelligence id an edgy highschool student, plus often they live in a buble. This leads to poor grasp of social issues.
'Average' places like reddit are actually better in this regard.
That might be true in that niche subreddit you subscribe to, but it's clearly not true for /r/all.
For example, engineers are probably overrepresented amongst Islamic extremists[1] and, from what few studies there are, may be skewed conservative and religious compared to other higher education fields.
[1] https://eprints.lse.ac.uk/29836/1/Why_are_there_so_many_Engi...
How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes?
No naive rules of thumb like "well if the public health experts like it then it must be good" or "bigger overton window = better" will ever come close to being a viable replacement for critical thinking on any specific policy matter. If the extreme fringes can't convert people to their cause then is their cause really that worthy?
Eugenics is fringe now. It wasn't in the early 1900s. The point is that "no megaphones for the fringe" can also be a bad thing.
The fact that the fringe was unable to convert the broader public is why the overwhelming majority of eugenics policy was unilaterally adopted by institutions (government or otherwise) vs being legislated by politicians and that's because people didn't really want it en-masse.
"Official policy of 30+ states and upheld by SCOTUS" doesn't fit mine.
That official policy of what you speak is just that, unilateral policy by various government institutions (usually prison systems and public health institutions). Most states didn't manage to get it through the legislature in any meaningful capacity because it was not something the masses cared for and therefore not something that a politician could earn votes peddling. It was as endorsed by the masses as some DOT policy about pothole patching would be.
Eugenics got a bad reputation because of a certain moustachioed leader in Germany.
E.g. there are essentially no children with downs born in Denmark due to sex selective abortions.
Well intended is not always well done and hystery is seldom helping. I remember from my youth(in germany), that work for kids was also forbidden. With some exceptions like delivering advertisement to every door. The result was, that this was a very shitty job, very badly paid (you were replaceble) and the ones illegally working for the bike shed for example, made way more money.
So let me get this straight your hypothesis is that campaign to get kids out of sweatshops were harmfull, and the reason we stopped putting them insweatshops is not public pressure but spontanous mass enlightenment?
Maybe it is your perception of these campaignes as hysterical thats wrong.
My hypothesis is, that just banning kids working in sweatshop is not enough to improve living conditions for those kids, but can in fact worsen them. So I repeat my question, do you have good numbers, that the living conditions actually improved?
Hysteric campaigns from the west often stop exactly there - so the companies can place a label on their product that says free of child labour, but it does not say at all, where those kids are now, but the consumers now feel better.
We've had 26 climate change conferences, the issue was known for 40 years, nobody gave a flying fuck. Some kids blocked traffic in London for 1 day, and suddenly people paid attention.
How are you going to solve Nestle level of indignity and inhumanity?
"Nestlé admits slavery in Thailand while fighting child labour lawsuit in Ivory Coast"
If people were more hysterical, and the HQ of offending corporation burned down occasionally, then Nestle would sort itself out prompto
Yeah, I know. We have the same in germany. The common people now do pay attention to the road blockers and want them all jailed as terrorists. I just do not see, how this will help the cause.
"If people were more hysterical, and the HQ of offending corporation burned down occasionally, then Nestle would sort itself out prompto"
Yes, they would simply tighten up security.
Rage is just rage, it does not solve anything, unless it is channeled constructivly. Lynch mobs just create a state of fear and people driven by fear seldom act smart. We do need the rage to act, but just acting does not improve anything. It is the right act, that can improve.
There was this big rage about poverty and exploitation that lead to socialism. But do you really think, that the socialist states improved anything? I was born into such a state. I do not think so. They were worse for the workers and worse for the environment.
For some it did. In many places socialism was replacing some form of tyrany, foreign tyrany or feudalism, so it was hard to make things worse.
Before the revolutions some of my ancesteors were literally property. They were serfs, with all the fun bits like regular whippings, and living in a wooden hut. They went to nirmal-ish 2nd world life.
The other side of my family had someone who was repressed, i.e. dissapeared.
Today suffragettes are universally praised and noone remmbers that they invented the letter bomb.
I don't advocate violence, but if you want a social movement to suceed, it has to have some teeth and power, either through court, money or civil disobedience.
Before the revolution in russia, there were indeed quite some slaves. After the revolution, there were only slaves. Someone who is locked in and cannot leave the country and has otherwise little freedom to move and act, is a slave by my definition, so for me there was no overall improvement, rather the contrary.
"I don't advocate violence, but if you want a social movement to suceed, it has to have some teeth and power, either through court, money or civil disobedience."
I think it mainly needs to have a clear vision of what to achieve, if it wants to achieve that goal and not just blow of steam and create drama.
So, I am not saying, that blocking roads for example, is always bad, if it creates necessary attention to get a important message across. But what exactly is the message of extinction rebellion? We are all doomed, if we don't stop consuming so much? Because this is the message people are getting.
This is not helping the common people, who struggle daily to feed their family - and if those people have to fear of loosing their job, because they missed work because of a road block, then they certainly will not join the movement.
If you want to convince people, you have to provide solutions.
Green tech is a solution, but activism alone can only bring awareness towards it and not solve anything by its own. Otherwise I would join the road blocks.
This is fictitious argument.
My Grandmother lived in USSR, she had education, a choice of career, could move across thousands of kilometers if she fell like it. She had axess to functional, if basic, medical care.
Her grandmother was property, she was illiterate and had to grind wheat by pulling the mill, untill her legs gave out. She died in agony. She could not leave the place to get medical care, even if she could afford it.
Sure living in USSR wasn't great, but if you think that's equivalent to being forced into slavery, you have left the plane of reasonable discourse.
A house slave in the US was way better of, than a field slave, who were also way better off, than a slave in the mines. Their conditions were not equivalent, but slavery anyway.
"a choice of career"
Only as long as you strictly stayed in political line and had not the bad luck of someone denouncing you falsely. Or the bad luck of being born into the wrong family, etc.
The slaves in the gulag surely had it worse, than the better off ones in Moscow. So yes, the average peasant might have their living standard and freedom raised, but everyone else (except party members) had theirs lowered. Equivalisation of misery, hurey.
But we can probably end it here, because yes, generally not being allowed to leave the country, along with the daily terror of political totalitarian secret police qualifies clearly as a condition of slavery by my definition, to which you disagree in a discourse ending manner "you have left the plane of reasonable discourse."
Socialism is a big tent term.
One one end you have "social democracy" where a market economy exists with some state ownership and taxation is used to ensure a good standard of living for all. This is also referred to a social capitalism or a social market economy. This is the kind of socialism you find in the Nordics and to a lesser extent Canada. Your Bernie Sanders socialism if you will.
On the other end you have "authoritarian state socialism" - the kind of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism you may be thinking of.
Then there's communism in which, in it's final form, there is no state at all.
These are all socialism but each has had very different outcomes.
So to answer your question with a question, to which kind of socialism are you referring? I'd say the former has worked out very well. The middle, not so much. The latter may not even be possible?
Obviously Marxism-Leninism-Maoism and add Pol Pot to that list, among Che Guevara and Castro. Good intentions, but horrible outcome.
"Then there's communism in which, in it's final form, there is no state at all. The latter may not even be possible"
And it is up to debate and depends greatly how you would define "state".
Humans have existed and lived, before formal states were a thing, so it is definitely possible, but apart from that, Humans will always have organisations, to well, organize things. The question is, are these organisations mandatory and formal, or not. And then there are informal hierachies etc. so the main question is, will things improve and how and why, when we get rid of the nation states.
You are not exploring the edges of the Overton window when you drown balanced speech. That just creates multimodal extremism.
They were initially fringe. Activism by that initial fringe is what made it mainstream.
Do you think it is an accident that, when there is a popular movement, whether it is punk rock or protests against vietanm war, the media will invite the most crazy person possible and portray them as maniacs?
If the media is intend on lying and mass manipulation, that media exactly should not have the support of well meaning people.
Most megaphones today are in the hands of private corporations who profit off of "engagement", that is, giving megaphones to the fringes. How do you suppose we do that?
Not to mention that the line between not providing a megaphone and suppressing free speech is a thin one.
Message simplicity, discipline, and repetition, to maybe somewhat mitigate the inevitable and very effective nutpicking by corporate media (and other shills) for the purpose of discrediting any reform, accountability, etc.
--
"The practice of sifting through the comments of blogs, email threads, discussion groups and other user generated content in an attempt find choice quotes proving that the advocates for or against a particular political opinion are unreasonable, uninformed extremists."
If you weren't, you never made enoufg waves to be noticed.
It could be argued there are many things which we are morally obliged to stop using plastic for, as it only serves as a convenience. Disposable food trays and "silverware", straws, individually wrapped things, and so on. Society could adjust to bringing their own water bottles to be filled at restaurants/gas stations/work, but between laziness on the consumer and the profit motive of selling cheap plastic bottles for $3 by companies, we don't.
Then there are plenty of things for which plastic is useful, durable; and instances where even single-use plastic can be justified. But on the whole, society is trading the environment tomorrow for convenience and money today.
Nuclear power has, unfortunately, suffered a similar fate.
If you have a hazard in your home, just deal with it appropriately. "Cover it up until it's someone else's problem" is selfish and irresponsible.
Also, the guy in your link complains about a lack of warning. If he read the warnings that cam with that grinding wheel, he would have been fine. Even if it doesn't say stuff about specifically about asbestos, the warning about silicosis has practically the same precautions.
PFAs aren't even proven safe, they're just not-yet-proven-dangerous-in-small amounts, but that's so hard to measure it doesn't really assure us of anything.
Every sip of water you drink has arsenic and cyanide in it. These chemicals are harmful, but not at very low concentrations.
And putting it on every random consumer product whwre it has no need to be
If a product was being used where it "has no need to be", that would mean the manufacturer is doing something that is costing them money (the PFAS isn't free nor is the application of it) which ultimately cuts into the bottom lines. So if they are using it, maybe it is that something is needed in that fashion and they already have a large investment in it so use it vs let's just put this stuff everywhere because it's freeeeee.
https://treadingmyownpath.com/2019/08/22/microbeads/#:~:text....
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/sep/02/uk-gover...
Source? My impression was that alternatives were already being developed prior to widespread ban. A quick wikipedia search confirms this. The montreal protocol was signed in 1987 and came into effect in 1989, but by that time alternatives already existed.
"DuPont began producing hydrofluorocarbons as alternatives to Freon in the 1980s."
The Montreal Protocol was signed in '87 but things had been underway since the 70s, including a partial ban on aerosols in in US in '78. DuPont saw the writing on the wall.
"In 1976 the United States National Academy of Sciences released a report concluding that the ozone depletion hypothesis was strongly supported by the scientific evidence. In response the United States, Canada and Norway banned the use of CFCs in aerosol spray cans in 1978."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozone_depletion#Rowland-Molina...
Then, there is the behavior of the factories producing it, which you brush off. Drinking supplies in certain areas are permanently destroyed, and producers aren't in jail.
Yes, strict liability should apply when indestructible chemical compounds ruin regional drinking supplies and give people cancer.
Typically, if you find someone is lying or manipulating repeatedly, you jump to stricter outcomes. If you ban a specific substance in cookware and they just create a slightly different, untested, one... If they promise that waste won't escape the facility because there are safe ways to handle it, yet it continues to happen...
It's like having a child that continually pushes the limits of the rules and repeatedly causes trouble. At some point you must realize they are lying and will hurt themselves or others. You can't play with that ball responsibly? Guess what, it's gone.
You say if we ban one substance, they'll just come out with a less tested, less understood, and likely worse new one. I probably agree with this!
Then you say we have to just take it away, like a kid who is being irresponsible with a ball. I understand this means you think we should ban the materials.
--
If we ban these substances, won't research just pour all the more heavily into the new ones, causing the 1st scenario you mentioned? Are you suggesting we ban research into _any_ new materials whatsoever?
Quite the opposite. I'm saying the items should be tested/researched. Hence my use of untested, as you also point out.
Essentially, stop trusting the company because they are acting like a child. You ban that class of chemicals until they can prove they are responsible and the chemical can realilistically be handled safely (unlikely for consumer products since the waste at product life end would be unmanageable). You can do this through a strict certification and surveillance program as well as limiting the use of the product to industrial applications where no alternatives exist.
But the only real point I was trying to make is that people are more likely to support bans on a rational basis that the companies have fucked up before and lied/manipulated and are likely to cause more harm like that in the future. The stuff we are discussing at this point is a little outside of that as we are getting into what people would debate considering what is reasonable.
We should have a system that requires demonstrable safety.
It's always funny when people pretend such policies would be the end of the world, when Europe has been doing this for years.
US media and politics in a nutshell.
Also the public's reaction is logical since information has been kept from the public for decades to hinder proper regulation. I think the successful class action lawsuit speaks for itself.
Right now they get all the upside with none of the downside.
You could make the same argument about asbestos (and people probably did at the time).
You could also argue that it took class action lawsuits to finally push the cost of using it from "wonder product" to "only when really needed" to "not worth it" to "it's now illegal". (Granted the last step is not 100% tied to the financial cost).
Unfortunately, unlike many other common toxins, PFAS is actually toxic at parts per trillion levels. It’s not just a matter of “we detected trace amounts.”
> 4. Both the reporting and public’s reactions tend to be illogical. PFAS found at a nearby factory? Shut it down. Sue everyone. However a growing body of evidence is finding PFAS in things like synthetic turf playing fields and yet with rare exception most school districts seem perfectly happy having these instead of plain old grass
Shutting down a factory is logical. Using a PFAS turf field is illogical. Is that what you meant? Or did you really mean to imply that we shouldn’t shut down the factory until we remove the turf field as well?
> 3. The ability to detect these compounds has gotten much better over the years. We’re now talking parts per trillion measurements. At those levels you can find just about anything. A lot of the current panic is a combo of this ability to measure things combined with “2” above around any detection being slated as terrible.
People don't understand how pervasive these chemicals are. When field testing for levels of PFAS, those doing the testing are given a list of things they need to avoid and not carry into the field because they will contaminate the results. This includes certain makeup, stain or water resistant clothing, certain types of paper, and lots of other things people would never consider.
PFAS have orders of magnitude differences in half lives, understanding which are bad and how to destroy them when needed is all that is required.
1. These compounds are extremely good at what they do. From lubrication to fire retardants there’s a reason these compounds are everywhere.
2. The press and many activists tend to treat things in a binary manner but science doesn’t really work like that. It’s clear that very high levels of these compounds are bad. It’s less clear that lower levels are bad. Lots of things (like vitamins) are toxic at high levels and actually good at low levels. Not saying PFAS is good, but it’s not as simple as just saying any is terrible either.
3. The ability to detect these compounds has gotten much better over the years. We’re now talking parts per trillion measurements. At those levels you can find just about anything. A lot of the current panic is a combo of this ability to measure things combined with “2” above around any detection being slated as terrible.
4. Both the reporting and public’s reactions tend to be illogical. PFAS found at a nearby factory? Shut it down. Sue everyone. However a growing body of evidence is finding PFAS in things like synthetic turf playing fields and yet with rare exception most school districts seem perfectly happy having these instead of plain old grass. As such the amount of “outrage” is often rooted in the convenience of it supporting existing activist movements (close the factory!) than it is based in any science or defensible reality.
Not for a moment trying to suggest we shouldn’t pay attention to this, and we probably should look for alternative compounds. But the near hysteria from some corners creates more of a distraction than actually helping anything.