News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by __alexs on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:33AM (#34488514)
You could say the same things about lead I think? But then maybe we are more scared of lead than we should be, there's just more alternatives to it now?
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by moffkalast on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:41AM (#34488588)
And asbestos too. Fantastically good isolator, strong, cheap, and only dangerous when broken.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by JCM9 on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:59AM (#34488761)
Yes. People are often shocked when asbestos is found and the recommended response is to do nothing. Messing with it is likely to cause more issues than just letting it be. If it’s intact and unlikely to be disturbed it’s not going to hurt anyone. The public has been trained to think this stuff is so bad that any mention of it has people doing full blown evacuations running for the hills.

Nuclear power has, unfortunately, suffered a similar fate.

Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by speed_spread on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:07AM (#34489636)
Nuclear power has the particular disadvantage of having to be actively managed. You can't just "leave it alone".
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by rcme on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:17AM (#34489773)
Leaving asbestos "alone" or encapsulating it is the common advice. It can also terrible advice, especially if the material is non-friable. Take something like vinyl asbestos tile as an example. When exposed, it's pretty easy to get rid of. You can cut through the tile, into the sub-floor, and take out huge chunks of tile at a time. You do release some fibers via cutting, but overall a very manageable amount. Now let's say you decide to tile over instead, what happens? Well for starters, you've now hidden the danger. You might know what's underneath your new tiles, but what happens when you sell the home? Also, it's no longer easy or simple to remove the VAT now. For example, this guy dosed himself and his whole family with a large asbestos dose unknowingly: https://www.reddit.com/r/HomeImprovement/comments/dyvj3u/so_...

If you have a hazard in your home, just deal with it appropriately. "Cover it up until it's someone else's problem" is selfish and irresponsible.

Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by giantg2 on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:37AM (#34490038)
It's not difficult to safely remediate most of it. A P100 respirator, Tyvek suit, water to spray down the areas to work on, and a garden hose to hose off yourself/suit. If inside, it gets more tricky, but not too different from mold remediation. The toughest or most expensive part is usually finding a site that will take the waste bags.

Also, the guy in your link complains about a lack of warning. If he read the warnings that cam with that grinding wheel, he would have been fine. Even if it doesn't say stuff about specifically about asbestos, the warning about silicosis has practically the same precautions.

Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by CorrectHorseBat on Monday January 23, 2023 @03:07PM (#34494238)
That really depends on what kind of asbestos it is. In a hard, easily removable plate, sure you can do it yourself. Loosely-bound asbestos is a whole different game.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by Grazester on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:11AM (#34488891)
I can here to say asbestos was great at its job too!
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by zug_zug on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:30AM (#34489133)
Indeed the very first "science" on leaded gasoline was a study conducted by the bureau of mines, which concluded that leaded gasoline was entirely safe... Spoiler alert: It was not entirely safe.

PFAs aren't even proven safe, they're just not-yet-proven-dangerous-in-small amounts, but that's so hard to measure it doesn't really assure us of anything.

Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by hgomersall on Monday January 23, 2023 @04:24PM (#34495277)
The history of toxic stuff is rarely revised to show that the stuff is less toxic.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by tedunangst on Monday January 23, 2023 @05:22PM (#34495949)
Saccharin.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by dahfizz on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:55AM (#34489457)
Not really, no. We have evidence that even very low levels of lead is dangerous. The cost/benefit analysis is different. We have no idea what the "safe" level of PFAS is. Maybe its zero, like lead, but maybe not.

Every sip of water you drink has arsenic and cyanide in it. These chemicals are harmful, but not at very low concentrations.

Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by pfdietz on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:45AM (#34491250)
Very low levels of arsenic may be a necessary micronutrient, according to animal studies.
Re:Magnetic method to clean PFAS contaminated water by rcme on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:09AM (#34489658)
No, you can't say the same thing about lead. We understand the mechanisms in which lead poisons the body. We know that even low levels of lead exposure cause damage. And, we've measured this damage by comparing large samples sizes based on blood lead levels. Even a tiny amount of lead, like 3.5 mcg / dL measured in blood, is correlated with loss of IQ.