News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by pivo on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:51AM (#34413966)
I've just finished reading, "Zero Fail: The Rise and Fall of the Secret Service" by Carol Leonnig [0]. In that book the author describes an incident on September 12, 1994 [1] in which a pilot landed a small plane in front of the white house. Secret Service members she interviewed were dumfounded that they were asked there to run to the white house roof with rifles to protect the building, and that there were no such thing as anti-aircraft missiles available at the time. More recently, another person landed a small aircraft on the Whitehouse grounds [2] with (apparently) no missiles involved.

Maybe the missiles are elsewhere, or maybe they're just a cost-effective rumor. The book makes it clear that the Secret Service is constantly underfunded and sorely lacking in modern technology, with agents sometimes having to use their personal car to transport the people they're protecting because their official cars aren't working.

[0] https://www.amazon.com/Zero-Fail-Rise-Secret-Service/dp/0399...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Eugene_Corder

[2] https://www.cnn.com/2015/04/15/politics/aircraft-lands-on-ca...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:29AM (#34414552)
>> book makes it clear that the Secret Service is constantly underfunded

it is critical that we recognize a few truths before we declare something "underfunded"

1. No amount of funding will ever "be enough". Government programs and depts expand to meet their budget + 25-50%... so they are always underfunded, you can increase a budget by 2x, 3x, 5x, and the very next year they will be claiming "we do not have enough money"

2. Where is the money going.... Often in government budgets essentials (like fleet repair) are cut in favor of non-essentials in order to make the budget issue into a "crisis". It is much easier to blackmail the public /congress/ who ever that is controlling the budget with "We have to use our personal cars" instead of "We had to give up our Cappuccino's" . Just because essential services are being cut does not mean nonessential services have. This is seen in local government often when they cut the big 4 (schools, fire, police, roads) first because it is easy to pass a tax increase for those 4 items than any other local service / program.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mschuster91 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:41AM (#34414731)
> 1. No amount of funding will ever "be enough". Government programs and depts expand to meet their budget + 25-50%... so they are always underfunded, you can increase a budget by 2x, 3x, 5x, and the very next year they will be claiming "we do not have enough money"

Well, the scope that the general public (or the impact of freshly passed laws) also continuously expands, and payment/contractor/vendor costs rise as well, which explains some of the demand for more funding.

A part of the blame also lies in parliament groups not doing effective auditing and oversight on government agencies, which can differentiate between legitimate growth (for reasons outlined above) and cancerous growth (as described by you).

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by foota on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:56PM (#34415939)
Looks like they get ~3 billion a year and employ 8000 people. Seems like chump change. They have responsibilities beyond just protecting the president.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by Retric on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:58PM (#34415982)
The less politically interesting government agencies tend to work surprisingly well with minimal budget and no need for games.

The National Transportation Safety Board for example has a 2023 budget request of 129 million. They are simply for too tiny and useful for anyone to really mess with.

The National Weather Service might have 10x the budget still generally gets ignored by politicians as so many companies, people, and government agencies depend on what they provide.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by thepasswordis on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:12AM (#34414293)
>The book makes it clear that the Secret Service is constantly underfunded and sorely lacking in modern technology, with agents sometimes having to use their personal car to transport the people they're protecting because their official cars aren't working.

Maybe the answer is to cool it with the idea that government officials all need to have large personal protective details. Isn't that the job of the police? And aren't they all just citizens of this country? If it's not safe for various politicians to walk around in the streets, then maybe they should do something about that because it means that it is unsafe for everybody.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:23AM (#34414455)
General rule for me is If any person has soooo much power we need a dedicated team of people to protect them continuously, that person has too much power and the solution is not ever-increasing amount of security, but ever decreasing amount of power to that individual
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by hotpotamus on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:37AM (#34414670)
I wonder how big Musk or Bezos's security teams are?
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by safety1st on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:45AM (#34414787)
Who cares?

The perennial mistake is believing that if any of these guys get capped, it's some irreparable loss to society. It's not.

Let them play the odds of life like the rest of us do. A society that depends on strongmen isn't a free society.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by hotpotamus on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:15PM (#34415272)
Oh you're singing to the choir on that stuff. Don't get me started on who we can and can't feed into the woodchipper because I'm already rate-limited. I'm just always surprised when people limit their thinking (and I'm not saying the post that spawned my response was guilty of that, though it's possible) of the powerful in society to government officials.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by petsfed on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:27PM (#34416469)
I think there's merit to at least forestalling rule-by-assassination.

Like, yes, I would not mourn a lot of people who end up having protective details. But I absolutely don't want to live in a world where all it takes to change a policy is one particularly motivated sociopath. Keep in mind that John Hinckley Jr's assassination attempt on Reagan wasn't out of disagreement with Reagan's policies, it was to impress Jodi Foster. A nobody's obsession with an actress is really, REALLY not the thing we should allow to materially affect our civilization.

I think there's a good argument to be made that the WWII-era Japanese government became the one capable of its atrocities in China specifically because assassination was so frequently employed to check to its power.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ElevenLathe on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:39PM (#34420522)
Reagan had an elected vice president. Bush Sr. being in charge instead of Reagan is not what I would call a material effect on our civilization. These guys are all interchangeable, as evidenced by the fact that we change them on purpose at least every eight years.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by int_19h on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:51PM (#34421225)
I think that was kind of OP's point - if one person has so much power that a major change in policy can be achieved solely by assassinating them, then they probably have too much power in general.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by cowsup on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:46AM (#34414813)
Nowhere near as large, or influential, as the Secret Service. If you’ve ever had to commute near airport, and the POTUS is flying in or out, you’re essentially screwed, for potentially hours.

Musk or Bezos could request a place deny entry to other customers while they shop or eat. Secret Service can demand. It’s a whole different beast altogether.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by int_19h on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:53PM (#34421243)
Now I wonder about the specifics. Do they compensate business owners for lost customers? Can the owner refuse to serve the protected person?
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by boeingUH60 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:59AM (#34415004)
I'll bet it's large but nothing close to that of the President and other top government officials. For example, the U.S. government is currently paying $2 million per month to protect former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo due to Iran threats[1]. That's the former, now think of what it'll cost to protect the current Secretary plus all the private travel costs on that giant Boeing 757.

1- https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/us-pays-2m-a-month-to-...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by throwaway1777 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:10PM (#34415185)
It was revealed a few years ago Zuckerberg was paying about 20M per year on security. That’s almost 2M per month…
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by LarryMullins on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:37PM (#34418594)
It seems likely he gets less bang for his buck. The Secret Service is a much larger organization so they can take advantage of economies of scale. On the other hand, government agencies can be very inefficient when permitted to be, so who really knows.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by aidenn0 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:50AM (#34414877)
Assassinating the president has little to do with denying him the power of the presidency, and more to do with what he is a symbol of.

Kind of like how 9/11 wasn't about killing some office workers

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:03PM (#34415069)
Symbols can be powerful...

That is the issue, the foundational principle of the United States was that we were a federalist system with a weak and narrowly defined federal government. The office of Presidency should be inconsequential to the Everyday citizen of either the US or the world.

The fact that we continually shift more power from Local / State government, then from Congress to the Executive is the exact reason the president is a "Symbol of Power"

>Kind of like how 9/11 wasn't about killing some office workers

Again the theory of Distribution apply here to building as well. World Trade Center was attacked because NYC is seen as the Central Place for world finance.

NYC has become too powerful and that power should be distributed.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by marnett on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:46PM (#34415771)
I always thought the two WTC towers were more representative of global capitalism, not just good targets for attacking NYC.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by jancsika on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:31PM (#34416543)
> The fact that we continually shift more power from Local / State government, then from Congress to the Executive is the exact reason the president is a "Symbol of Power"

This is all rank and dubious speculation wrt your general rule about POTUS needing a dedicated security team.

Hell, Duane Johnson needs a dedicated security team.

If you are positing a federal government so weak that POTUS is not widely known within the U.S. population, you're political views are more radical than you're letting on.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by prottog on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:29PM (#34420392)
What part of GP's take on the American federalist system are you describing as radical? Seems to me that the truly radical thing is what the federal government has morphed into over the years, its founding constitutional document notwithstanding.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by shkkmo on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:17PM (#34420917)
Reducing the federal government to that scale would involve getting ride or the DOD and almost every federal agency. It is "radical" because that position is completely unacceptable to the vast majority, while parts of that plan might appeal to parts of the political spectrum, taken as a whole it is a plan thay has miniscule support. Thus, it is considered a radical view point.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:23PM (#34421539)
hmmm... Following the Constitution is Radical now...

The US Navy is the only constitutional branch of the DoD. How is that for being radical.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by shkkmo on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:01PM (#34423309)
Yes, advocating such widespread changes to society on the basis of a specific interpretation/understanding of the constitution (the root document of our government) fits the meanings of the word almost too perfectly:

> Arising from or going to a root or source; basic.

>Departing markedly from the usual or customary; extreme or drastic.

> Relating to or advocating fundamental or revolutionary changes in current practices, conditions, or institutions.

> designed to remove the root of a disease or all diseased and potentially diseased tissue

> of or relating to the origin

> favoring extreme changes in existing views, habits, conditions, or institutions

> Favoring fundamental change, or change at the root cause of a matter.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by krapp on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @07:30AM (#34425918)
If we have to put up with mass shootings and forcing women to choose between unwanted pregnancies and prison because of specific interpretations of the Constitution based solely on 18th century idioms, then we should go all in.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by judge2020 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:41PM (#34423507)
I don't think they had to defend against threats from the air or space when they drafted the constitution. Nor were spies all that useful outside of wartime.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @07:13AM (#34425802)
This "well it is old document" falls on deaf ears with me. The solution on if parts of the constitution are out-dated is to pass amendments to the consititon, which has been done 27 times in our history.

It seems today however we have allowed the federal government to simply ignore it because it is "too hard" to pass an amendment. Sorry if it important enough to expand the power of the federal government is should be important enough to put in the work to amend the constitution, and if you can not pass it then clearly the nation agree's it is not in scope of the federal government.

And by "nation" I do not mean a "democratic vote where by 51% of the population tells the 49% what do to" which seems to be common in the "Protect our democracy" crowd.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by judge2020 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:11AM (#34427545)
Where are they even overstepping? They don't get involved in situations outside of their power, like defending the country and regulating interstate commerce.

What you're not seeing with your point is that the federal government actually hasn't really expanded their power, it's just that more and more things have been "capitalism-ified" to where doing business purely within one state is uneconomical. More and more of society has transition to conducting business over state and national lines, and thus the federal government is governing more of the everyday person's life than they were 100 years ago.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by prottog on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:21AM (#34428718)
> regulating interstate commerce

The same Interstate Commerce Clause that in Wickard v. Filburn the federal judiciary interpreted as giving the federal legislature the authority to regulate intrastate non-commerce; and in turn relied upon in Gonzales v. Raich that the federal government has the authority to regulate the growing and use of cannabis for medical purposes by one man acting within one state and according to that state's laws for his own person.

> More and more of society has transition to conducting business over state and national lines

This is true, but the above examples show that the federal government is intruding in people's personal actions with no commercial purpose that stays confined to one state, on the basis that those actions might exert a force, however minute, on interstate commerce. The federal government may as well say that they can regulate everyone since people breathe air which crosses state lines and therefore is under federal jurisdiction.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:04PM (#34429422)
>>federal government actually hasn't really expanded their power

You have to be kidding me. I did not think anyone would honestly make that case. Many argue about how the federal government needed to expand their power but I have never seen anyone claim they have not expanded their power at all

That is new one for me, and not supported at all by the historical record, which for example was clear there needed to be a amendment passed to ban alcohol but then magically due to some very bad court rulings (like wickard) they could ban whole classes of drugs without a constitutional amendment

History is VERY, VERY clear that FDR massively expanded the size, and scope of government and held the supreme court hostage forcing them rule his way after striking down many of his laws originally as unconstitutional

No one that has studied American History can say with the strait face the Federal Government has not expanded its powers

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by bdhess on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:43PM (#34421755)
The government changed because the nation changed. It's now the richest country in the world, with a population of 330 million people, and spans an entire continent from ocean to ocean. Even if you just consider the constitutional commander-in-chief duties, whoever holds the role is going to be a person of global importance.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by IG_Semmelweiss on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:26PM (#34423097)
Can you name the president of Switzerland?

This is the nation that hosts the davos summit, is the hub of FIFA and red cross, plus several other high profile multinationals, NGOs, and wotld bodies, and is also the only core european country not parricipating in thr EU zone agreement.

Surely if you know the PM of Spain, Norway or Poland you ought to know switzerland right?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by detaro on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:21AM (#34424258)
The position of the Swiss president by design (i.e. the Swiss constitution) doesn't hold any special powers. That's quite different than the US president or even European PMs. A Swiss-style executive in the US would be a fascinating scenario, but it's really not how the systems in the US are set up (nor would the non-required aspects of it necessarily form the same way, e.g. the many-party nature is not strictly required and it could devolve into a two-party-system in Switzerland too in theory)
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by aikinai on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:30PM (#34423121)
The Japanese emperor has zero power and lives in one of the safest countries in the world, but no one would be naïve enough to think he doesn’t need protection.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by adolph on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:36PM (#34415611)
It’s almost as if such an investment is a brittle monarchical single basket of collective eggs.

The would be assassins are as backwards about the symbols as the sycophants. They don’t see symbols as a byproduct, a shelved trophy of societal achievement, rather than its cause. It is understandable that a religious person would invert cause and effect, as if the shine of wet streets made rain. It is a bad thing for the US to become a cargo cult of itself.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by fijiaarone on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:42PM (#34417619)
A lot of presidents have been assassinated in America. Not one assassination has affected the continuum of government or been more than a personal tragedy.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dctoedt on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:38PM (#34420496)
> Not one assassination has affected the continuum of government or been more than a personal tragedy.

The formerly-enslaved workers in the American South would like a word about Lincoln's assassination and his replacement by the southern sympathizer Andrew Johnson, who had very different ideas about Reconstruction and the rights of freedmen.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Johnson

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by pixl97 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:51AM (#34414885)
So how do you plan to deal with the continuation of government and nuclear weapon problem?
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:05PM (#34415100)
>>how do you plan to deal with the continuation of government

Federalism. The Federal Government does far too much and most of its function should be left to State and Local governments.

>>and nuclear weapon problem?

MAD is a terrible strategy, and I dont think our Nuclear weapons serve the function many believe they do.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by beebmam on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:44PM (#34415742)
If the federal government should be reduced in power, then why should state or local governments have any more power over individuals?
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by sobkas on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:24PM (#34417345)
> If the federal government should be reduced in power, then why should state or local governments have any more power over individuals?

Because the smaller government is (federal>state>local) the resources needed to hollow it out and made into puppet also drop.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mulmen on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:48PM (#34418789)
Because I have more power as a voter and constituent to influence policies that affect me.

At a national level I am 1 of 331,900,000.

At a state level I am 1 of 7,739,000.

At a county level I am one of 2,252,000.

At a city level I am one of 733,919.

At a neighborhood level I am one of 82,123.

I have four orders of magnitude more influence over my city council rep than I do over my president.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dctoedt on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:41PM (#34420547)
> Because I have more power as a voter and constituent to influence policies that affect me.

If only things actually worked that way. The vast majority of voters don't exercise that power. Moreover, state and local governments are more vulnerable to capture by rent-seekers and other special-interest groups bent on shaping public policy to suit their desires.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by int_19h on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:49PM (#34421204)
That's not an inherent state of affairs, though. We've been consciously pushing as much of our politics to the federal level as possible, from both left and right, for several decades now. Why is it a surprise then that voters don't engage much with local governments? After all, even if they do it, the states and the feds tend to override if it's an important "wedge issue" (i.e. the voters have been riled up about it) on the higher level.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by seb1204 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:24PM (#34423422)
They should and education and empowering is needed, globally. Democracy in all forms and colours needs participation. The minimum level of participation is to vote in all occasions.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dctoedt on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @07:00AM (#34425712)
> They should and education and empowering is needed, globally. ... The minimum level of participation is to vote in all occasions.

1. It'd be great to use the Australian system of compulsory voting (and it's kind of a community event, from what I've read). But that's not likely to happen in the U.S., because certain segments of the political spectrum don't want "the wrong sort of people" to vote, and so when they gain power they make it as difficult to vote as they can get away with.

2. "Education and empowerment" has worked so well in other areas of life — among other successes, absolutely no one smokes tobacco anymore; everyone drives carefully and soberly while obeying all posted speed limits; everyone eats healthy foods in moderation to maintain an appropriate weight; etc. (Not.)

And that's why in the tech world, for example, everyone takes the time to properly document their code, thoroughly test every release, refactor when appropriate, and clear away technical debt. (Again, not.)

And in medicine, doctors never misdiagnose illnesses or forget important steps in treatment because they always use authoritative best-practices checklists, which the medical establishment works hard to keep up to date and quickly disseminate to practitioners. (Yep, not.)

Apropos of that last example: Remember the crash of the FAA's Notice to Air Missions [NOTAM] system last week? That's a federal system; 50 state systems would be unworkable.

While we're on the subject of NOTAMs, here's a thought experiment: Imagine that the NOTAM system were somehow to be privatized — investor pressure for growth to boost the stock price would eventually and inevitably lead to dangerous corner-cutting and underinvestment.

3. Bottom line: Every human being is a mixed bag: We're created co-creators helping to build a universe, but we can also be short-sighted and narrowly focused on what we want without regard to how it might hurt others. All this can lead to stupid decisions — or malign ones — which we're great at rationalizing. So: Our political structures and laws need to deal with humans as we are, not as we wish we were.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by bilbo0s on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:53PM (#34421252)
So what?

Does that stop corruption in your city? (hint: The answer is 'No")

Or even abuses? (hint: The answer is "No")

In its final days, even slavery was a "more local" policy.

People should get their mindsets right on democratic vigilance. The problem is not ceding decision making to the federal government. The problem is ceding decision making to any government. That's why we need to not only be able to remove people from power, but actually do so from time to time. So that every one from the local sheriff and judge, all the way up to the president and chief justice never get too comfy.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by judge2020 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:45PM (#34423517)
> I have four orders of magnitude more influence over my city council rep than I do over my president.

And yet you need the federal government to defend your right to select which state to live in if you decide that you want to move https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saenz_v._Roe

Believe it or not, the current situation yields tons of power to your state, just not powers that involve anything outside of the state (wars, interstate commerce, etc)

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mulmen on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:33AM (#34424001)
Right, that’s the fundamental argument behind federalism.

I don’t want my city council rep to worry about fighter jet acquisition. I also don’t want Mitch McConnell involved in pothole repairs.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by xamolxix on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:48PM (#34415801)
>> MAD is a terrible strategy

What is a better strategy?

>> and I dont think our Nuclear weapons serve the function many believe they do.

What function do you believe many believe they serve, and what function do you believe they actually serve?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by LarryMullins on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:35PM (#34418550)
What, besides MAD, has prevented Putin from using tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?

inb4 "they don't work anymore", Russia has a mature nuclear industry and huge stockpiles of nuclear material. They're more than capable of making nuclear bombs which work.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by shkkmo on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:32PM (#34421052)
The risk of further global isolation and the loss of any military restraint from NATO.

I could foresee a wide range of of responses to Russia using a nuke in Ukraine. I highly doubt the US would respond by dropping a nuke on Russia. That just wouldn't accomplish anything useful.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by LarryMullins on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:18PM (#34421486)
> the loss of any military restraint from NATO.

MAD.

And what is it that presently restrains NATO? MAD.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by sgjohnson on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:21AM (#34423953)
> I highly doubt the US would respond by dropping a nuke on Russia. That just wouldn't accomplish anything useful.

And you’re probably right—it wouldn’t achieve anything useful.

What I’d expect is the first gulf war all over again. Some good 2 months of non-stop relentless air campaign with surgical strikes, and boots on the ground for the final phase. And a dismembered, completely dysfuncional Russia wrapped into endless internal conflicts between the constituent republics at the end.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dctoedt on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:40PM (#34420527)
> The Federal Government does far too much and most of its function should be left to State and Local governments.

Except that state and local governments are more vulnerable to capture by rent-seekers and other special-interest groups bent on shaping public policy to suit their desires.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:15PM (#34420899)
Aside from that not actually being true. To the extent it is, the impact of that is far less than when Large Multi-National corporations use comparatively less money to capture the federal government.

This idea that Federal Government is opposition to rent seeking is laughably absurd given the context of the last 50+ years where ever single omnibus spending bill that is passed is littered with pork to rent seekers.

As Joe Biden says.... Come On Man....

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dctoedt on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:47PM (#34421192)
I certainly don't dispute that the federal government is vulnerable to regulatory capture by rent-seekers. But if you imagine that state- and local governments are any different, you must live in a laudably-different place than do most of us.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by phpisthebest on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:20PM (#34421510)
I dont imagine them to be different, I imagine

1. A Single vote in a smaller political division carries more weight than being diluted in a large nation like the US at the national level.

2. If the local rent seeking becomes too harmful it is far less costly to relocate to a new City, County, or State than it is to immigrate to a new nation

3. It is infinitely more costly for a large corporation to rent seek thousands of cities / counts, and/or 50 US States, than it is for them to rent seek 1 federal government.

I could add probably 5 more things. IMO Federalism is a more desirable system of governance, and provides ways to limit the damage the inevitable corruption can cause.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by jen20 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @08:42PM (#34422357)
It’s clearly not infinitely more costly. There aren’t infinite states. I doubt it’s even 50 times more costly.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by IG_Semmelweiss on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:38PM (#34423178)
An elephant falling the proportion of twice his own height will probably die.

A mouse falling the same proportional height will survive without a scratch.

Systems behave differently depending on the scale. Small is beautiful, and its a good heuristic that the smaller the scale the more tolerance to variance that system has.

A few local govts that have been captured (SF? NYC?) will not collapse the US.. But if the FBI, the executive, legislative get captured...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by themadturk on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:18AM (#34423666)
> MAD is a terrible strategy

Terrible, but it has worked so far.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by sgjohnson on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:16AM (#34423934)
> MAD is a terrible strategy, and I dont think our Nuclear weapons serve the function many believe they do.

What do you propose as an alternative? Mutual disarmament?

Once you have nuclear weapons, there’s no reason whatsoever to EVER give them up.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by AdamN on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:15PM (#34415266)
That's the whole premise of Designated Survivor and Battlestar Galactica even. The US has 16 levels of succession at which point it peters out.

It seems like the threat of a decapitation strike against the US has been mitigated.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by thepasswordis on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:54PM (#34415880)
Is there a continuation of government reason why every former president continues to have a full time secret service detail?
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:52PM (#34417795)
They are bodyguards. Ex-presidents pissed off a lot of people, domestically and internationally, when in power. They are much more likely to be targeted for murder than the average citizen.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by lazide on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @04:01PM (#34419044)
They’re also just high profile.

Some random whacko thinking you’re in a love affair with their crush (cough like Jodie Foster/Reagan) is enough to catch a bullet. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Hinckley_Jr.]

Whack jobs are a real problem.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by gus_massa on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:47PM (#34416812)
For many years the secret code to launch nuclear missiles was for a long time 00000000 https://sgs.princeton.edu/00000000 Now they claim they changed it, but be sure that if the president is dead the military have some workaround to launch the misiles.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by prottog on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:36PM (#34420482)
> if the president is dead the military have some workaround to launch the misiles.

The presidential line of succession exists for a reason. It's the office of the president that has the power to authorize a nuclear strike, not the person.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by waste_monk on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:34PM (#34421661)
>Now they claim they changed it, but be sure that if the president is dead the military have some workaround to launch the misiles.

... 00000001?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by midasuni on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:01PM (#34421327)
The U.K. has a large number of nuclear missiles. The prime minister of the U.K. flies budget airlines

https://www.aviationbusinessme.com/airports/airport-business...

Goes shopping in foreign supermarkets

https://greekreporter.com/2022/08/13/boris-johnson-spotted-s...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mike_d on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:10AM (#34423898)
There is also a standing order that if the UK government is decapitated, its nuclear submarines are to take orders from the US president.

(The actual orders are of course secret and sealed until that time comes, and could be AU/NZ/CA depending on the persuasion of that particular prime minister. However the US is the most logical choice as the other countries have no nukes themselves and would likely be looking to the US for guidance anyway.)

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by WaitWaitWha on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:26PM (#34417364)
> ... but ever decreasing amount of power to that individual

Assuming that the power needs to exist, this implies that we would need more people, which in turn makes the government larger.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ufmace on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:18PM (#34420925)
So I sympathize with the idea of this in a sense. But it feels like we're so very far removed from that point that there's hardly any point in talking about it.

Also, maybe the US President and other super high level individuals are too powerful. But then if we make them much less powerful, who keeps other bad actors like Russia and China from stomping on whoever they want - ask the Ukrainians or the Uyghurs.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by toss1 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:21PM (#34421514)
Lovely idea in theory.

Yet, despite the fact that one of the foundational principles of good governance is to avoid excessive concentrations of power, that does NOT mean that there can be no concentrations of power.

The sad fact is that, whether it is the neighborhood bully or the authoritarian state next door, anyone who wants to live a self-determined life, with a self-determining government, must be better armed, better prepared, and better allied than the abusers and autocrats, or they will be taken over in short order. This includes being able to make decisions quickly. This requires a concentration of power in something like an executive branch.

Similarly, regulating society requires making of laws, and again, by the time a society gets to tens or hundreds of millions of people, this will literally take forever without some kind of representative government; heck, just look at how long it takes to get a couple hundred congress or parliament members to get a basic majority something passed...

So, sure, when you have a tribe of several dozen or maybe the 150 of Dunbar's number [0], the leaders can be near-anonymous or completely unremarkable. Maybe even up to the size of a small town.

But once the size of organization, financing, and weilding of power just required to get anything done to maintain the society gets large, so must the concentrations of power.

The trick is not to pathologically avoid concentrations, it is to balance them.

This is the difference between a democracy and an autocracy. In a democracy, all of the institutions, the govt executive, legislative, judiciary, as well as the press, academy, industry, etc. are all independent, having their own will, centers of power, etc. In an autocracy, all of these govt and societal/economic institutions are bent to do the will of the executive. The trick is keeping those healthy, independent, and balanced.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by chucksmash on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:27AM (#34414530)
> Maybe the answer is to cool it with the idea that government officials all need to have large personal protective details. Isn't that the job of the police?

So like Shinzo Abe?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by nivenkos on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:38AM (#34414698)
Or Olof Palme.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mc32 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:19PM (#34415345)
On the other hand... Indira Gandhi.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by bakul on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:29PM (#34416514)
She might have escaped her fate if she had replaced her Sikh bodyguards with non Sikhs after Operation Blue Star that removed a militant Sikh religious leader and his followers from the Golden Temple in Amritsar.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by seunosewa on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:34PM (#34415581)
J F Kennedy
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by sgjohnson on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:29AM (#34423980)
Shinzo Abe is actually a very good example, because his tragic death occured in a country where violent crime basically doesn’t exist and where it’s virtually impossible to acquire any kind of a firearm (I am aware how far 3D printing has come)

This would of course be far worse in a country that’s very familiar with violent crime and where everyone and their dog has at least 1.2 firearms, like the United States.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by throwaway1777 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:20AM (#34414402)
I like your take but politicians do have a target on their back that the average citizen doesn’t.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by TheRealPomax on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:26AM (#34414498)
But not one so big that every one of them needs multimillion dollars worth of protecting. A handful absolutely do, the vast majority don't. They will be perfectly fine. They might catch an egg or cake, or in the rare instance a fist: they'll still be fine.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:45AM (#34414790)
As far as I am aware, the vast majority of politicians in the US do not receive Secret Service protection.

"every one of them needs multimillion dollars worth of protecting" is a straw man. Of course the vast majority of politicians, which includes a lot of city council members of tiny towns and so forth, do not need a 24hr security detail. And they don't have them either.

It happens for the handful, not the majority. Which seems to be what you want, but your tone is frustrated or angry.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mschuster91 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:46AM (#34414798)
Unfortunately, that is increasingly changing. The covid pandemic, for example, has led to a massive increase in threats to everyone advocating for containment measures, and so do the advocates of other political issues impacted by conspiracy myth spreaders and/or the far-right (e.g. 5G rollouts, single-payer healthcare, gun control, immigration).

Having been the target of about five dozen death threats myself as a political commentator/activist here in Germany, I can tell you the political climate drastically devolved over the last seven years, and police is nowhere near the security system it should be. In my case it took over four years until the main perpetrator was identified, arrested and subsequently sentenced to almost six years in prison[1]. And for what it's worth, it's not limited to politicians, journalists and activists - even ordinary doctors can be driven to suicide [2], or YouTube streamers such as the infamous Drachenlord [3].

[1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSU_2.0

[2] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa-Maria_Kellermayr

[3] https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/kommentar-wer-dem-d...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by TheRealPomax on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:35PM (#34415592)
That's a problem with a different solution, though.

Loads of people in other countries issue the same threats, but because they don't readily have access to ranged weapons, and specifically firearms (and every legal firearm that they do have are registered with the police), those threats are just that: threats.

Of course, we know the problem there, and everyone knows the solution, and everyone knows that solution cannot happen in the US, even if in the past it might have been possible to solve.

So by all means, protect the ones who really need it, but in a lot of cases, the solution to someone whose agenda is so controversial that they need secret service protection during visits to adversarial places is to go "we're not going to protect you for personal activities. If you want to walk into a lion's den, expect lions".

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mschuster91 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:37PM (#34421101)
> Loads of people in other countries issue the same threats, but because they don't readily have access to ranged weapons, and specifically firearms (and every legal firearm that they do have are registered with the police), those threats are just that: threats.

All my examples were from Germany, a country with very strict gun control. And yet, Drachenlord got haters literally every single day shouting at or vandalizing his property, attacking him physically, swatting him (the first conviction of swatting in Germany was for a Drachenlord hater). LGBT people or people "looking foreign" routinely get beaten up with fists.

Gun control is a relevant issue, yes, but it's only a very small part.

>If you want to walk into a lion's den, expect lions. If you don't like that, maybe consider that you don't need to rile people up

That's pure victim blaming with a healthy dose of "chilling effect" applied and I'm sad to see such a take on this site. Speaking the truth, advocating for democracy must be protected at all costs.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by TheRealPomax on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#34429348)
> That's pure victim blaming with a healthy dose of "chilling effect" applied and I'm sad to see such a take on this site. Speaking the truth, advocating for democracy must be protected at all costs.

quite the overreach: by all means, have your opinions and spout them, and by all means, request local police protection because that's what police is for, but if you're so divisive that need the US Secret Service to protect you: maybe you don't. There are very few people who should qualify for that.

Don't pretend I'm saying no one deserves protection, I'm saying almost no one deserves USSS protection.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mschuster91 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @04:21PM (#34433248)
> and by all means, request local police protection because that's what police is for

Local police in the US has been shown often enough to seriously lack training: 21 weeks on average [1] - that is ridiculous, even traffic cops in Germany have to pass through literally two and a half year of training, and another four years and a strict physical training regime for the high rank allowing them into personal protection details. Not to mention many police departments are already overwhelmed with responsibilities, have massive cultural problems on their own, or actually are underfunded - while ridiculous budgets like NYPD are so widely known they're almost a meme, many smaller PDs (and, associated, fire departments and EMTs) seriously struggle with funding to keep the lights on. Adding the workload required to provide somewhat decent amount of protection for exposed persons would completely bust a lot of them.

> There are very few people who should qualify for that.

IMO, the list is orders of magnitude longer - Members of Congress, members of the government, their publicly known top staff, leaders and deputy leaders of government agencies, on state level at least the governors and their cabinet, and the heads of major parties as well. That's for the US a couple thousand people, protection details shouldn't be that expensive given how large the US federal budget already is. Recent events, not just the events surrounding Jan 6th, but also all the other threats that have happened over the last years (and yes, I include the shooting of Republican Steve Scalise here), warrant it IMO to make sure at least the representatives and the most important people in government get the very best protection there is, independent of the country.

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-56834733

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by gizmo686 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:46AM (#34414799)
Most politicians do not get secret service protection. Only those in the line of succesion, former presidents and family of the above.

The handful of congresspeople in leadership get special protection from capital police. Most elected congress people only get special protection if there is a specific concern.

https://www.secretservice.gov/about/faq/general

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by hotpotamus on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:43AM (#34414761)
Bruce Schneier once said something that really stuck with me. He was talking about the culture of the DHS I believe and how their mission was "Never Again" in the wake of 9/11. But never is basically an impossible standard to meet, and the result was that we get security theater instead. I would imagine you can also soak up a near infinite amount of money and effort trying to achieve never again. Zero Fail sounds like the same thing.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mc32 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:17PM (#34415307)
'Never' and 'Zero' programs are all aspirational. We want Zero pedestrian deaths, but we know it's not possible (even in back in the age of horses), but still something we should aim for within reason.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by mwint on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:35PM (#34415603)
It's that "within reason" that people get hung up on.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by macinjosh on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:53PM (#34415865)
Indeed, these very same people who demand a well-armed and trained _personal_ security detail are the very same people who enact laws to deprive the convenience store worker from having a firearm to defend themselves with while working in the middle of the night.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by rqtwteye on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:57PM (#34415943)
"Maybe the answer is to cool it with the idea that government officials all need to have large personal protective details."

I lived in the DC area on and after 9/11. There was a huge increase of governmnent officials having drivers and flying private jet "for security reasons"

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by munificent on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:19PM (#34420943)
> Maybe the answer is to cool it with the idea that government officials all need to have large personal protective details.

It's just a numbers game. Some very small fraction of people are mentally broken and may develop a psychotic fixation on a particular person. The more publicly known you are, the greater the chances that a crazy person will pick you.

You and I don't need security people because only a few hundred other humans know we exist. The odds of one of them being a murderous psychopath are vanishingly small. Millions of people knew who John Lennon, Ronald Reagan, and Rebecca Schaeffer were, so they rolled the dice enough and lost.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by DerekL on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:58AM (#34424127)
> Isn't that the job of the police?

The Secret Service are police (that is, they're a law enforcement agency).

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by euler_angles on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:29AM (#34414559)
In the present time, there is an air defense network around Washington DC. It uses the NASAMs system. Anything that is determined to be a threat can be engaged with surface launched AIM-120C missiles.

https://www.kongsberg.com/kda/what-we-do/defence-and-securit...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by neutered_knot on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:27PM (#34416474)
A launcher is visible on Google Maps, and is still there. I drove by it today.

https://goo.gl/maps/LByxzGzqQ28ETtJb9

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by aimor on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @04:27PM (#34419471)
That Pentagon shaped pool really caught my eye, then the long covered building, had to look it up. Now I know all about the David Taylor Model Basin and the Naval Surface Warfare Center's Explosive Test Pond.

https://www.navalgazing.net/David-Taylor-Model-Basin

https://www7430.nrlssc.navy.mil/bblp/mine/carderock01.htm

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by colonwqbang on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:13AM (#34414302)
Yes, it seems unlikely. How many civilians would be in danger by the debris raining down on central DC (or the white house itself, if he really was right over it). Not to mention the risk of a missile missing the target and instead exploding somewhere down on the street.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by therealcamino on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:39PM (#34423188)
There's a missile launcher across the street from the White House -- see the Popular Mechanics link in a sibling comment.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by cafard on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:55AM (#34414952)
"Landed" is not quite correct for 1994: the guy crashed it. (He had been smoking crack beforehand, as I recall.)

This led the government to close Pennsylvania Avenue NW between 15th and 17th Streets. The reasoning was not apparent, for the pilot had certainly not taken off there--he flew from a field in Maryland.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by therealcamino on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:37PM (#34423172)
Pennsylvania Ave was closed to vehicle traffic on May 20, 1995, following the April 19 truck bombing of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, in which 168 people died.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ok_dad on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:25PM (#34416432)
The answer is that the people with their finger on the missile trigger knew the aircraft was no threat due to radar and visual interceptions and decided not to launch a dangerous missile into the middle of a huge city full of important officials since moving the President and other important officials to a basement would be sufficient to protect them from a Cessna. Instead, they waited for the plane to come down somewhere (on the lawn, it seems) and arrested the person inside.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:00PM (#34417958)
> knew the aircraft was no threat

A Cessna intentionally crashing into the White House is no threat? Especially if packed with explosives?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ihattendorf on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:42PM (#34418689)
Not if you have ample time to move everyone to safety before it arrives. Seems a good trade off to make if you aren't confident what the pilot's intentions are instead of just blowing them out of the sky.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by LarryMullins on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:41PM (#34418675)
> since moving the President and other important officials to a basement would be sufficient to protect them from a Cessna.

I think it's safe to assume that the bunkers under the White House are sufficient protection against as much explosives as a Cessna could possibly carry. The plane itself will do almost no damage, it's a flimsy thing built light out of aluminum and it's not even fast.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Tampa_Cessna_172_crash#/m...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:46PM (#34418754)
> people with their finger on the missile trigger knew the aircraft was no threat due to radar and visual interceptions and decided not to launch a dangerous missile

I don't think we have evidence of this. The simple truth is the U.S. government doesn't really fortify against domestic enemies in a systematic way.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by yencabulator on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:45PM (#34417678)
1994 was a long time ago. Here's a picture of one known setup for you:

https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/weapons/a30027303/...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ufmace on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @05:08PM (#34420112)
I have no idea how the Secret Service in particular is doing, but I would kind of expect that any actual anti-aircraft missiles would be owned and operated by some unit of the Army or National Guard or something. They own all of the actual missiles, and repair and maintenance people and gear, and probably training for how to operate it and how to try not to fuck up when you have 15 seconds to determine if an incoming aircraft is hostile and needs to have missiles fired at it.

Also the way they were caught with their pants down on 9/11 kind of suggests that there was no actual military level ordinance readily available around DC at the time. Maybe there is now, but I heard at the time they scrambled some fighter jets with no weapons because there wasn't time to get the weapons out of wherever they were stored and load them up.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by eftychis on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @06:00PM (#34420748)
Yeah you either keep some fighters weapon armed or use them for reconessaince style interception. You can't arm a plane in seconds or under 5 minutes.

I think the rule of thumb is 5' at most scrambling time if plane is on alert-- fueled, armed, and pilot ready.