No way to selectively block SMS on phones (at least natively). Only reason I don't disable it completely is due to the 1 percent
The FCC has started enforcement actions, in October they announced they are cutting off seven telcos who failed to comply. Only ~7000 more to go!
However, just like email spam, stopping spoofed calls is harder in practice than in theory.
Is it really? Couldn't the carriers simply require a certificate to allow you to spoof a phone number?
SS7 doesn't have a clean way to do this hence needing to make SHAKEN/STIR, but I don't think anyone did the signalling work for POTS.
https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-remove-companies-robocall-d...
Of course, businesses with a lot of money care about use cases in that last 1%.
I'd love a setting I could flip to disable inbound voice calls from any carrier that isn't like... Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, and Comcast.
But as long as telcos willingly cooperate and allow remote call centers to basically pick any number in the locality of the recipient even though that number is not currently roaming in India they are making things much worse.
The reason for this is language barriers, it's not some countries doing things better than others.
> Shipping a SIM box would already be much more work than just changing a number in a database
They don't even actually need to ship one, there are thousands of them operational already. This is a massive industry.
Even if you cracked down hard on SIM boxes, the scammers will just purchase routing from botnets. This won't really impact their costs, and will be essentially impossible to take any meaningful action against.
Anyway, since you are willing to shoot down each and every suggestion in this thread short of rolling over and accepting the damage how would you tackle it?
European authorities haven't managed to do anything about the car selling scams Romanians have been running for decades now. Nobody has managed to do anything about the Nigerian prince scams. BEC with truly shitty phishing pages keeps on growing and growing.
The best bet would be for US authorities to force India to crack down on these activities and prevent these scams from operating at an industrial scale.
The actions you propose would work well to address lower return activities, such as marketing robocalls. They can not work to address high-return scams.
I don’t see why you’re pushing so hard against this line of reasoning, I guess. You’re making it sound like a hopeless endeavor to even try, in a “don’t lock your doors because thieves will just use lock picks” kind of way.
How much harder? If your changes increase the telephony costs of a scam call centre from 0.001% of revenue to 0.002%, you have not actually made their operations harder.
> and these changes do not impede non-fraudulent use, why not go for it?
Because these changes would not be free.
Plenty of such cases here locally. Your point about the language barrier is on the money though, I never really gave that much thought but the number of Dutch speakers in India is most likely so low and the market so small that it isn't worth a massive campaign to them. Especially not if there are millions of gullible people in markets that are more accessible to them.
As for forcing Indian authorities: I've seen up close how corrupt things are there and I have very little hope that that would be a viable avenue to resolution of this problem.
I'd be super curious to hear about any local success stories.
>As for forcing Indian authorities: I've seen up close how corrupt things are there and I have very little hope that that would be a viable avenue to resolution of this problem.
Then you're left with education. These scams are very profitable and can easily afford resistance from telcos and banks.
However, even if we assume that SIM boxes are a magic solution to carrier interventions, that still raises the cost from the current status-quo. Implement enough of these barriers and the entire scam operation becomes unprofitable and no longer worthwhile.
Oh jesus please no, whats next?
Ther is no reason a consumer oven should cook more than 5 meals a day. There is no reason a consumer toasteer should toast mpre than 10 times a day.
The bread you make tourself is unauthorised in a toaster
Of course, an override should be provided - the restriction should be relaxed over time once the account is established for a long time without any complaints.
Consumer ≠ business/commercial. A home oven (or toaster, fryer etc) isn't made for such use, a commercial one is. You should really spend the monies in commercial gear if you're gonna feed such hordes of people.
Similar thing with SIM cards. Why would a normal person be making 100+ calls a day on a simple, personal line? That's clearly commercial use and as such, it oughta be regulated somehow.
Oh so everyone in my family thay used a standard oven to xook for a wedding and feed a horde of people is an idiot?
Thank you gemonstrating that you are exactly the kind of person that will be justifying tyrany in 5 to 10 years when every device is internet connected and cannot be turned off.
>However, even if we assume that SIM boxes are a magic solution to carrier interventions, that still raises the cost from the current status-quo. Implement enough of these barriers and the entire scam operation becomes unprofitable and no longer worthwhile.
Why do you assume that the call routing is a meaningful cost to these operations? For all we know they spend less than 0.01% of their revenue on call routing.
Just put something along the lines of "sim box grey route" into Google and you'll find loads of relevant industry materials.
Besides, you're drastically moving the goalposts here. We went from "could put a stop to this" to minor obstacles.
Ideally there would be a warning that a call does not originate locally, routing the call through a local representative would generate yet another signal that you might be able to close off, including the possibility to declare the possession or hosting of certain gear illegal. You'd have to maybe do some pattern matching to spot problematic numbers and/or have a place to report them easily.
If the will was really there I'm pretty sure this problem could be tackled.
Anyone can easily buy European bank accounts opened with fake IDs, or money laundering services where you're provided an IBAN and receive a % of the money sent there to your cryptocurrency wallet.
Want a fake passport good enough to travel with? No problem, will just run you a 1000 euros.
Probably, but not with any of your proposed methods. I have talked with some SMS spammers and none of what you proposed would affect them. And for SMS spammers these inconveniences are a much bigger part of the cost of doing operations than for a company which needs to have employees in a call center. They have to spend a lot of money on buying new SIM cards as old ones get blocked.
Ideally, the telco would implement these block lists, but also ideally, they could be traded around like web ad block lists for individuals to load on their phones.
I think we all know scam calls are a serious source of revenue for carriers, so they will need to be led to this conclusion by force.
None of that happy future would come without true caller id, thus the resistence from carriers to fixing spoofing.
Why would they be a major revenue source? The carriers make their money from normal users, not dodgy call centers.
Right now, an actionable report really needs a traced call, which is hard to actually make.
Certainly, it doesn't get you right to a chargable person, but it gets you a lot more than today.
Gift cards should require some amount of destruction in order to get to the actual barcode… something to make tampering obvious.
The same way clothes have a little ink exploder the clerk removes… just a quick easy step that is destructive to the packaging… but still presentable when you give it to someone
At some point, the way to fight crime is to fight crime. It's not that hard to find and prosecute most call centre scammers.
A lot of these scammers would not do it if there was risk. They're not often hardened criminals.
Or, you invent a shop that also trades on Amazon and "buy" the stuff from yourself. That might explain some odd shops that you see online.
The goal is to setup a US google voice number to abuse later.
This makes so much sense. Thanks!
But I had wrongly assumed that Facebook marketplace would experience less scam than craigslist because verified users would be their competitive advantage
It’s so infuriating. I know people who have lost hundreds of dollars to people impersonating US Social Security and immigration officers. The gift card providers do not care. The impersonated government agencies do not care. The local police do not care. The phone companies do not care. There is total and utter impunity for everyone perpetrating and enabling these scams.
I'm not sure if there's an alternative, since I'd seriously rather not ID be required to buy or use a gift card.
And as far as making gift cards safer, shouldn’t that be the responsibility of the gift card providers, not to mention regulators tasked with consumer safety? Why is it that the scammers seem to ask for gift cards rather than, say, banking details? (I’m sure there’s also some banking scams, but I have a feeling there’s non-zero recourse for victims in those cases.)
If it truly is somehow impossible to make gift cards safe to use, then I’m convinced society could survive without them. But I doubt it’s impossible. I suspect gift providers deliberately go out of their way to make sure victims have no recourse.
You'd think India would be on top of this and come down hard. If folks just start associating Indian accents as 'scammers', businesses abroad that currently rely on outsourcing support and other services are going to eventually have to pull out. You can't run effective customer support if the customer assumes you're a bad actor just because of your voice and hangs up.
They "try", but the scammers just pay off the cops
The vast majority of scams are “romance” scams.
These are people who don’t have accents but good job prejudicing your father against a whole group of people while not actually protecting him from scams.
do you have any sort of citation for that?
Unfortunately, that use of that word is popular among Indians, but any half-measure guidance leaves room for an already susceptible mark to convince themselves that maybe this email is not a scam.
Be warned. AI accent changers will eliminate that line of defense as well.
I'd imagine that's even more obvious for any family member. If a family member calls from any number that's not their number, my first question will be an honest "How the heck did you remember my phone number?"
On a personal level I keep a referee's whistle handy in case I'm talking to a scammer live. They are usually wearing headsets and any damage I can do to their hearing with that may save an old persons savings in the following few minutes. Best technique is to speak softly so they turn their volume up then let rip on the whistle
Eventually we'll just have a network of AI scambots calling up AI scambaiters and having completely useless conversations in synthesized English with each other for hours upon hours and nobody will remember why.
so i unpause the silence during that time
the hospital is def an issue, i don’t have a great solution there especially for unplanned emergencies.
Contrast this with how the Singapore government in a similarly highly capitalist economy dealt with this - basically telling banks - "you'd better make good the consumers & deal with your holes or else" https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/mas-will-consider-...
In many ways in domain after domain, US nowadays seems to act as the "economic proving ground of the world" where lax regulation allows a million ideas to flourish. Then folks in other parts of the world seem to take the best winning ideas, figure out how to make it work in a socially & governmentally acceptable way in other parts of the world and out-compete the US originators (eg. how Uber, Lyft, Amazon, US based social media firms have effectively been pushed out of dominance in Asia)
> While TrueCaller may have laudable intentions, the privacy implications for people who end up in their database raise concerns. When a number is tagged, the person who is tagged ends up having their name and phone number stored on the TrueCaller database, despite not having consented – or even being aware – that their data was collected.
- https://privacyinternational.org/node/2997
Some of the features require excessive permissions.
- https://support.truecaller.com/support/solutions/articles/81...
- https://globalvoices.org/2022/10/14/the-true-colours-of-true...
My grandmother got hit with one of these, she has a weak heart and was in severe mental distress all day because she couldn't get ahold of me to confirm what the scammers were telling her.
I try not to judge others, but what monster can do this for a living?
If someone is being told that yadda yadda (story doesn't matter) and they have to pay in gift cards, and they seriously believe that, then surely education seems to be the right fix.
Rule no. 1: Gift cards = scam.
US must take strict actions and call out India publicly. Elderly people are weak, education isn't going to solve the scam problem. Scammers must be punished harsly. They erode the trust in system.
Also, Indian government is not doing anything. In many places like Kolkata, scammers can get away easily by bribing police. Our phone are being redirected to India, and they can abuse our phone number. I wish, the US government passes strict rules and regulations to keep these scammers in check.