That's the problem with Hollywoo. Too much fragmentation as a result of everyone chasing after the power vacuum created by streaming. Every small outfit thinks they can win.
Consolidation will happen as clear winners emerge and failures continue to materialize.
(I have that sticker on one of my old laptops. Also a "Hollywoo" sticker on one of my current laptops. I love it because my startup is in that space.)
ADDED: But per another comment, things are better than the cable world, much less the pre-cable world that I actually grew up in. So some combination of fragmentation and consolidation is fine for me.
It would be a better world, IMHO.
If society wants more people to be able to watch more TV, then society should just give people cash so they can buy access to more streaming services. Or reduce copyright terms to something reasonable like 10 years.
Because market competition is what makes capitalism a liveable social order for most people. Adding market competition makes everything better. Command economies (corporate or socialist) don't.
Disney can charge $15 to an individual, or $15 to a middleman, it makes no difference to them. It is just a waste of society’s resources.
Reducing copyright length so old Disney stuff enters the public domain quicker would increase supply and drive down price for the media.
Right now, if you want Disney content through a streaming service, you have one option. If it sucks, well, that's too bad for you, take it or leave it. And same for HBO, for Paramount, for all of them. Splitting up distribution and production creates a better competitive environment, given the existence of copyright.
Anything that doesn't use system-provided UI elements is simply constitutionally bad. It's incredible that things that can't scroll smoothly pass basic QC.
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/07/us-judge-ends-decades-old-mo...
And as far as I can tell, the only people fighting to keep car dealerships separate from car manufacturers are car dealership owners. I would like to be able to just order a new car online and have it be delivered directly from the manufacturer.
What’s the business model for a content production company that doesn’t have such sugar-daddy?
Piracy is generally really quick and frictionless, but even so I do have to wait a couple minutes sometimes before I've found enough peers to start streaming something. If I could pay a couple bucks to just get the file off a fast CDN I absolutely would.
Like you know... how your local store was allowed to sell you VHSs of the Terminator and you didn't have to pay subscription to Warner Bros store (which only existed in swamps of Florida) to get it? And how you could then give it to another person without restriction or tax to the said corporate lord?
Monopolization and integration of multiple markets into single corporate entities always hurts the consumers. Maybe it's time for US government to pull thumbs out of their bums and take out their cartel breaking hammers?
Comcast is probably the only one making and delivering media.
It's remarkable how there are still industries that don't know how to take advantage of the internet to give a great user experience, and whose greed only hurts their bottom line.
It's very simple: I want to watch any content from wherever, whenever, and however I like. Make it cheap and high quality, and I'll pay you for it. Screw this up, and I'll get it from somewhere that offers this experience instead.
Super price sensitive - subscribe to one service and switch service every month. $5-10/month.
Typical - subscribe to three services and cancel one every few months and swap another one in. $20/month.
Super price insensitive - subscribe to everything and pay as much as you used to with cable.
The ideal is for Apple TV, Fire TV or whatever to create a unified search and discovery mechanism.
In countries where Disney+ doesn't exist you can watch it on Netflix.
When Netflix streaming was just starting they had a lot of great content from Starz, HBO, and their Anime selection was extensive. Gradually all that content was removed and locked behind different paywalls.
You couldn't do this with tv on cable since it was not on demand but if one can schedule properly, more customers can be supported with fewer licenses.
We'll just bundle a bunch of them together, and offer a slight discount over the cost of paying for them all individually. Maybe offer the most niche ones as add-on packages.
We can even put in some ads in exchange for the convenience and...
Oh wait, what were we doing again?
Lets see where we end up in 20 years
Broadcast tv was (and still is) free.
As the prices go up, and the content becomes broken up between more and more services, 2 things happen:
* The idea of a bundle that saves you money, adds convenience and leaves you less caught out when licenses change hands compared to 20+ individual subscriptions becomes more and more tempting
* The 6-month and 12-month plans for these services are much cheaper and become more appealing.
Back when it was only netflix at $7, there was no need for a bundle or a 12-month plan.
But when it's all these services at $15 each, a 12-month long bundle would save a lot of money in the long run.
Bundles may not exist yet, but they will. Mark my words.
But: most of what people most want to watch is stuff that's on legacy deals, or that they're letting out older seasons of, or just don't control. Like, Better Call Saul is on Netflix, but not the current/final season. I feel like the era of them really jealously guarding their shows to try to make AMC+ work has coincided with a bunch of stuff people aren't that interested in seeing (and maybe the stuff people do want to see they don't fully control).
Lodge 49 is cool (but ultimately quite niche, I think), but they don't have an audience clamoring to stream Low Winter Sun or whatever.
They haven't had anything new that people actually care about enough to notice its exclusivity. The newer Walking Dead spinoffs would be about it, I guess.
Prime-affiliated services (Prime Video, Amazon Music, etc.) exist to make Prime more sticky and keep you in the ecosystem.
Walmart is doing something similar with, IIRC, Paramount+.
I'm not sure that I would be willing to pay for it separately. It has some good shows but not an astounding amount.
The interface is hot garbage that tries to upsell additional pay-for content and streaming services like Starz. Unless you know what you're looking for and go in with surgical precision, you get bogged down in a morass of upcharges.
They also started intermixing free-with-ads content and making it difficult to distinguish. My kid has started a couple movies only to get lambasted with ads every 15 mins and becoming thoroughly upset.
I also haven't watched a show on Amazon Video in years (Man in the High Castle was the last one).
Yet they continue increasing the cost of Prime citing those other "benefits". I wish they'd offer an a-la-carte Prime, we only make use of the free shipping one.
And the shipping is never 2 days. I’m not even convinced it’s faster than non-prime shipping.
And certainly no one is doing it for the music service.
Dial back all these streaming services and you'd have less content back then. And virtually no say in what to watch when, plus shitty ads. To watch anything specific, you'd have to go to the movies or go for a rental.
Now you have a huge amount of freedom of choice, with no ads, much more convenience, at fairly reasonable prices. The exceptions you manage are just that, exceptions. So that's my first point, we seem to be perpetually unhappy, no matter how rich an offering is.
Second, I consider this semi-fragmented landscape a solution, it's healthy. Services are fiercely competing with each other for your eye balls. That means they're in a race to produce good content and it suppresses prices. This is actually happening. When Netflix dominated, they had advanced plans for major price hikes. The arrival of Disney+ stopped this in its tracks. Do you really want this industry to be consolidated into 1-2 players? With a price monopoly? With producers being squeezed, creatively constrained? Just so you have to press one less button?
Third, the idea that you could combine the production value of hundreds of billions of $ worth of material into a single affordable streaming service for the masses is a delusion. The math simply doesn't add up.
Fourth, most people just vegetate after work for an hour or two. They need something watchable. They don't need 17 subscriptions, it's not a common need.
I can turn on the TV, press the microphone button, say the name of the media I want to watch, and usually a screen pops up letting me know if I have already paid for it, and if not, how much it will cost. And a couple buttons later, I can be watching it, or doing something else with my time.
Much more convenient than watching media in the 1990s and 2000s.
Before the more recent Cambrian explosion, it was just Netflix, HBO (via HBO Now), Hulu, and Showtime. Yes, there are some smaller players too, but these were the big ones.
Everything else was licensed out (typically to Netflix) and in some instances was perhaps only available on cable. People got alot of content for sub 60 USD, for the most part.
Then everyone started clawing back their catalogues for their own streaming services. I think the 2017-2019 period was the "golden age" of Netflix streaming in terms of sheer good content availability, and people really liked it.
At least Apple TV+ is original content and not re-selling the rights that used to be on a different platform. They're a genuinely new entrant into the space.
Competition stopped that. You should be happy about it. I know I am. Let the explosion happen, let them compete for our money. The minor inconvenience of occasionally jumping in and out of a secondary service is worth it.
Until pretty recently, we didn't let film studios own movie theaters, for similar reasons.
I'm from the Netherlands where for about 20 years, it wasn't even illegal (today it is). We'd pay a "media tax" on empty discs (like 0.10$) and this would clear you to make "home copies". Of anything, without paying for the original.
Anyway, this legal anomaly has created a culture where media that costs a shit ton to produce (movies, series) is valued at: nothing. zero. Not by some dark tech-savvy internet lord, it's valued at zero by society as whole. People are even proud to showcase the many ways in which they dodge paying for content.
Now people project this learned behavior (have it all for near-zero costs) on the entire streaming market.
I’m not saying content producers shouldn’t be paid, but art should be for everybody.
>but art should be for everybody
A shorter copyright term accomplishes this, while also leaving intact the incentive system to create content that can be infinitely copied and resold.
Is your theory that the great artists will still produce even if they make no money and people can redistribute their work for free at will?
Are you a sports fan? Because sports fans don't have the choice to not pay for things they do not want to watch. If you want a sports package, you usually have to buy it as an add-on to the base package, even if there's not a single show you want to watch on the base package.
I would be willing to watch if it involved going to the official website or app and pressing a few buttons to pay. I am not interested in learning about blackout regions and various packages or contracts with stipulations.
This description works if you skip straight from the age of cable packages to the current day. That's missing a lot though. From the point of view of someone who hasn't made a quantum leap forward, publisher specific streaming services drove adoption by taking things away from viewers.
If I used to be able to watch something on Netflix, but now I can't because $company pulled all their content to their own streaming service, there's no world in which that's a win for me.
100 companies producing tons of filler content to try to make their own $10/mo service valuable isn't a good trade off for "you need a new paid app to watch the thing you used to watch in this app you already have."
Funny thing: in the Netherlands breaking bad was a Netflix show. Took me years to find out it was on something called AMC.
Netflix, Disney and maybe HBO. Nobody else is going to make it here.
The problem as I see it is done of the companies are selling the product that the consumers want. With individual companies all trying to maximize the revenue generated by what they control, the industry as a whole has become hostile.
It seems it will stay hostile until the big players get squished by the gigantic players, or consumer protection groups get stuck in and things get regulated. For a while it looked like consumers would get what they wanted, which is a monopoly provider of all content at an affordable price, from Netflix or Amazon or both. But now we have this mess of content producers and legacy platforms all fighting for the same slice of pie.
There has to be some happy medium between the two extremes. Sure, the pre-streaming era sucked but I don't think having multiple subscriptions with maybe 2 good shows per channel is utopia either.
People don't need 17 streaming subscriptions. There are only so many households to sell to.
How many of those households are going to pay for a subscription so they can stream Interview with the Vampire if that's the only show they're interested in on the service? Maybe if they're a die hard fan, but they won't attract casual viewers.
Since there are fewer ads on streaming services - I won't say "no ads", because already, many of the services are including them, or at the very least, including disruptive trailers for their own shows - how do those households know that Interview with the Vampire exists as a show? On the cable TV model, AMC would run a commercial advertising the show during the airing of another show with a similar audience, drawing interest and viewers. Now it's not so simple to cross pollinate. (Anecdotally, I have a friend who is obsessed with Anne Rice and had no idea this show existed.)
You say combining the production value into a single affordable streaming service is mass delusion, I say that's the only reason it worked in the first place. The popular shows buoyed up the fringe.
You mean the Bob Newhart Show? If so you can find it on Hulu.
Plus I don’t know if it’s the case with Bob Newhart, but some old shows on Hulu (like Taxi) are missing tons of episodes.
Contrast that with the NBA, where for a surprisingly reasonable $15 a month I can stream every game on YouTube TV.
Apparently DirecTV's exclusive NFL contract is expiring, so I'm hoping next season will come with new streaming options.
Next year, screw it, I’m just not watching the games. Maybe I’ll hit a bar for one or two. It’s not even the money, which is annoying, it’s the hunting for each game and what service to watch it on. That was really aggravating.
Prepare to be impressed by the rumored prices of the live stream package.
As an aside, especially on the west coast, if you are willing to be patient and wait a few hours after the game's over, I can strongly recommend NFL+ for replays.
NFL is impossible, I'll catch the game on "regular TV" but otherwise it's pirate or nothing.
Which is I suppose OK since I just go to sports bars, but they’re losing $15/month from me.
* Amazon Prime
* Disney+
* HBO Max
* Netflix
* Hulu
* Paramount+
* Peacock
* AMC+
* Apple TV+
* ESPN+
* Shudder
* Sundance Now
* Youtube TV
* Tubi
* Crackle
* Roku Channel
* Discovery+
Want to watch the old Newhart show? Even with all these options, you're out of luck. Try your library. Streaming is a nightmare.
Want to watch every game your favorite NFL team plays this season but you're not in their broadcast area? Try to suss out this mess.
https://www.nfl.com/ways-to-watch/