The public sucks sometimes.
Of course, I also don't think the Revolution was a morally-justified war, so I guess I'm an outlier.
Much of what is "taught" about the revolutionary war is obviously one-sided bullshit.
As a non-American with no real motivation to see any specific narrative be promoted, it feels like American history often leans heavily on “the ends justify the means.”
If someone was protesting Amazon, or the government's protection of Amazon, and as part of their protest they seized and destroyed the contents of an Amazon delivery van, they would be demonstrating a viable and possibly effective method of hurting Amazon (although you'd have to destroy a lot of delivery vans.)
The fact of the matter is that there are no governments that exist by the full consent of the governed. The only way for a "fully justified" government to exist is for no government to exist. The American revolution was no more or less justified than the formation of the Ottoman empire, or of Egypt during the time of the pharaohs.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2021/04/19/girl-kent...
Do you disagree?
Keep in mind that a prominent conservative US talking point for the past few decades has been “I’d rather be a Russian than a democrat”
Given we’re posting on HN, take that as you may.
Err, wait, it didn't accomplish that at all.
Having to make such a choice is certainly not an enviable position to be in, but Powers never had to take this job. I certainly never would have accepted it, I think most people wouldn't.
this makes me feel again that there's a recurring phenomenon with humanity, where spending the assets (life, in this case) of others is seen as selfishly strategic
For saxitoxin, it's the toxin that's best known for causing paralytic shellfish poisoning.
TL;DR: it attacks the bodies nerves and leads to muscle paralysis and can result in paralysis of the muscles needed to breath.
Cyanide inhibits cellular respiration. It prevents your body's cells from using the oxygen in your blood to produce energy.
My understanding (I am not an expert, please feel free to correct me) is that this produces neurological signals that you're not getting enough air. So you feel like you're choking or drowning; you're gasping for breath, your whole body is screaming at you that you need to breathe, but you are breathing and it doesn't help. That's not a pleasant way to go.
Carbon monoxide poisoning on the other hand only interferes with oxygen delivery, which shuts down the mitochondrial ability to generate power but critically does NOT stop it from taking in pyruvate. Since there would be no excess pyruvate in the cell outside the mitochondria to undergo fermentation, there would be less lactic acid, and less pain.
That's just my guess.
Why? Well one popular just-so story is that pain exists to let us know something is wrong so we will do our best to stop the pain, if the thing that is damaging the body is some sort of external agent then it seems reasonable under this explanation that there should be pain to get you to stop that external agent in some way.
I think the more reasonable question is why did they develop a poison that was really painful?!?
Ok, well I reused these components and it is cheap and easy to make! Also unimaginably painful but hey, there's always a tradeoff.
some years later, huh, research shows nobody wants to use our unimaginably painful poison to escape being tortured. Users are stupid and incomprehensible.
This is such a jordan peterson style non-answer x 'what does it really mean to order a pizza"
Carbon monoxide poisoning wasn't common enough to warrant one.
Increased blood CO2 is the main cause of discomfort from holding your breath for a long time. This is why hyperventilating to bring your CO2 level down helps you hold your breath longer. (The light headedness from hyperventilation is a consequence of low CO2.)
I don't believe cyanide particularly increases blood CO2 prior to loss of consciousness. Also, I'm told carbon monoxide poisoning isn't particularly uncomfortable, and also interferes with oxygen transport. So, your proposed mechanism seems unlikely.
Other tissues besides muscles may also have lactate receptors; I'm not sure. If that's the case, your whole body may have that workout burn.
An additional bit of funny is that the silver dollar in that photo is known as a Peace Dollar.
You just tell them it is painless. It is not like they are going to test it on themselves.
If someone somehow ends up whitnessing a usage and they complain you tell them “this is very concerning, we are going to investigate. Maybe a bad batch? Or enemy action?” and then you classify the whole thing for 150 years.
If there is such a widespread leak that you can’t do the above (for example one of your agents swallows poison direct on camera broadcast publicly) then you say to your agents: “Turns out it is not working as painlessly as we thought. Obviously we are not monsters, we couldn’t test it on live subjects. Discontinue old formulation, new painless formulation is being distributed.” And then you give them new pills with the same or nearly the same poison and visibly new packaging/concealment. But that is a last resort, only if there is too much grumbling amomg the rank and file.
- the actual use of poison pills is very rare. If our agents need to pop them all the time we suck and our organisation is hemourhaging valuable resources and we need to improve our trade craft.
- things done in missions are murky, especially murky when the mission went so horribly wrong our agents commited suicide. Most often the agency notices that something went this wrong by an agent failing to report in. It is not like the agent who died a painfull/painless death will complain about it at the “illegal undercover agents anual ball”. Information spreads slowly by default under these circumstances and through unreliable narrators.
- the business of inteligence agencies is to keep information compartmented and on a need to know basis. They have processes with teeth to enforce this. Keeping information available to one part of the organisation away from other parts of the organisation is their bread and butter. Keeping the truth about a possibly painfull poison pill is not a special case there, you can use the same aparatus to keep this info locked down you use to keep other information within the agency.
Here's a couple more.
Like taking off a tight shoe
Like sinking into a warm bath
I thought the point was to remove you from enemy torture and questioning. If you're dying slowly, then the enemy is just going to torture and question you while the poison acts slowly, or possibly even find a way to ‘cure’ you well enough that the torture can go on for a long time … which defeats the point, doesn't it?
1) There is no antidote 2) It induces quick unconsciousness so you can't be tortured while it's working.
Maybe ricin?
If the pill causes pain, that's an unwanted side-effect. It's unlikely to be as painful as the actions of your torturer, whose goal is to cause as much pain as possible, and who may also want to stretch it out for weeks. And there's a good chance your torturer will kill you anyway.
Sometimes torture is used for punishment or repression, not to obtain information. Arguably that's always the purpose; "information" obtained through torture isn't very reliable.
First, if they are detained, they will be strip searched long before any torture takes place. You either take it early or not at all - odds are everything will be taken away.
Second, the last thing you want in such situation is ambiguity - people don't just commit suicide willy-nilly. Instructions must be very clear.
Thirdly, either the agent has secret information that cannot be divulged, or they don't. This is known upfront before the mission. Any agent at high risk of capture is kept away from sensitive information, to minimise possible damage. Every spy and reconnaissance organisation work like that. As soon as agent is captured, damage control is put in place.
Lastly, orders to commit suicide are not legally possible.
Aleksandr Ogorodnik was able to get the KGB to give him his pen, which had a suicide pill in it, to write his confession.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleksandr_Dmitrievich_Ogorodni...
You do realize that we're talking about the CIA here, right?
Surely even the CIA has limits on the atrocities they are willing to commit?
We are talking about US citizens for whom this is a job, they are not like foreign prisoners. CIA -agents are 'one of their own'.
This is like Taliban-level stuff
This assumes the others would know that it happened. Who would tell them? Certainly not the guy who complied with the request for suicide.
Obviously you don’t order it. You play up the cruelty of the enemy tortourers. This probably is not hard, every secret service probably have enough nightmare fuel on hand to do if they want to. And then you provide the means and let your agent know they can use it uppon capture.
When it comes down to a quick death by a suicide agent vs being tortured and then likely an unmarked grave it can be a reasonable option. Agents which aren't so likely to be put through the wringer and might be exchanged are another matter--Gary Powers had little reason to use his suicide option. He didn't have great secrets to be tortured for.
And with a really big overdose they may not have enough Narcan on hand to reverse it. I’m talking 100x the LD50.
>… Ogorodnik offered to write a full confession and asked for his pen. When the interrogator handed him the pen with a cleverly hidden cyanide pill in the cap, Ogorodnik bit on it and died soon after. He was said to have died before he hit the floor.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleksandr_Dmitrievich_Ogorodni...
none?
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/gary-...
https://www.spymuseum.org/press/press-archive/2019-press-rel....
It had a tiny needle that delivered saxitoxin and/or botulinum toxin to the agent, giving them a fast and very painful death.
AFAICT, there's no public record of how many of these were given out and how many people used them. But we do know of one famous case where someone didn't use it — Gary Powers. He had one of these silver dollars and he refused to use it. He chose capture and torture instead.
This is what his suicide dollar probably looked like, https://images.seattletimes.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/a...
For me, personally, there's something very funny about the CIA turning one of the country's most recognisable symbols, the dollar, into a suicide pact.