News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by andrewflnr on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:17AM (#33918927)
Good grief, there wasn't a way to give them a fast and painless death? Or even moderately painful?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:07AM (#33919244)
I suspect it's a matter of "fast, painless, compact, reliable - choose three".
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ClumsyPilot on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:43AM (#33920611)
if it's agonising death, agent won't take it, so it is no longer reliable. They folled themselves. Too clever by half
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by krisoft on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:15AM (#33920868)
It is not like the agents will know if it is agonising or not.

You just tell them it is painless. It is not like they are going to test it on themselves.

If someone somehow ends up whitnessing a usage and they complain you tell them “this is very concerning, we are going to investigate. Maybe a bad batch? Or enemy action?” and then you classify the whole thing for 150 years.

If there is such a widespread leak that you can’t do the above (for example one of your agents swallows poison direct on camera broadcast publicly) then you say to your agents: “Turns out it is not working as painlessly as we thought. Obviously we are not monsters, we couldn’t test it on live subjects. Discontinue old formulation, new painless formulation is being distributed.” And then you give them new pills with the same or nearly the same poison and visibly new packaging/concealment. But that is a last resort, only if there is too much grumbling amomg the rank and file.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ClumsyPilot on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:07AM (#33921336)
sounds like your main strategy is 'assume everyone working as a CIA agent is an idiot' and they don't catch on after working for many years?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by krisoft on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:38AM (#33921615)
No. I’m assuming 3 things:

- the actual use of poison pills is very rare. If our agents need to pop them all the time we suck and our organisation is hemourhaging valuable resources and we need to improve our trade craft.

- things done in missions are murky, especially murky when the mission went so horribly wrong our agents commited suicide. Most often the agency notices that something went this wrong by an agent failing to report in. It is not like the agent who died a painfull/painless death will complain about it at the “illegal undercover agents anual ball”. Information spreads slowly by default under these circumstances and through unreliable narrators.

- the business of inteligence agencies is to keep information compartmented and on a need to know basis. They have processes with teeth to enforce this. Keeping information available to one part of the organisation away from other parts of the organisation is their bread and butter. Keeping the truth about a possibly painfull poison pill is not a special case there, you can use the same aparatus to keep this info locked down you use to keep other information within the agency.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by peteradio on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:40AM (#33922476)
If someone tells my not-so-voluntary suicide is going to be painless my default stance is going to be doubt.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by mlyle on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:13AM (#33922927)
In either case, the actual information on whether it is painless is immaterial to the choice. The only thing that can factor into an agent's decision is the information that he learns about the suicide agent, and the agency has a lot of control over that information.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by andrewflnr on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:44PM (#33928919)
It would be pretty easy to tell a plausible lie, though, especially if you can think of a plausible less-painful poison to pretend you used. Tell them it's something moderately painful, so you can still tell them, "look, it's still better than torture". Just don't remind them about the edge-case scenarios where it really has to be fast and reliable, and they probably won't question it too hard...
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by vintermann on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:17AM (#33921418)
"I work for an agency that routinely gains people's trust in order to betray it, but I trust them and they would never betray me" seems to be the default belief for this lot, so maybe it isn't so far fetched.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by swayvil on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:58AM (#33921261)
So tell them it's a blissful death. Who's going to say different?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ycct on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:01AM (#33921905)
"He said it was like going home."
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by swayvil on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:04AM (#33921947)
That's wonderfully creepy.

Here's a couple more.

Like taking off a tight shoe

Like sinking into a warm bath

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ninkendo on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:55AM (#33920694)
Painless, compact, reliable? Doesn’t need to be that fast.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by JadeNB on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:47AM (#33922570)
> Painless, compact, reliable? Doesn’t need to be that fast.

I thought the point was to remove you from enemy torture and questioning. If you're dying slowly, then the enemy is just going to torture and question you while the poison acts slowly, or possibly even find a way to ‘cure’ you well enough that the torture can go on for a long time … which defeats the point, doesn't it?

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by LorenPechtel on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:50PM (#33924261)
Assuming:

1) There is no antidote 2) It induces quick unconsciousness so you can't be tortured while it's working.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by denton-scratch on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#33921562)
Painless, reliable: that'll be barbiturates like Nembutal. But it takes about half an hour, and you need about 10g. So not compact or fast.

Maybe ricin?

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by KMag on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:18PM (#33924601)
Doesn't ricin take days to kill, during which the agent can still be interrogated and rewarded with quick execution?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by denton-scratch on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:29PM (#33925506)
Ah, yes: "anywhere from hours to days", says Wikipedia.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by DuskStar on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:24AM (#33922230)
Carfentanil, maybe?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by quickthrowman on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:25PM (#33923957)
Opiate overdoses are easily reversible with naloxone. I suppose it’s possible that carfentanyl is strong enough that it would take an unreasonable amount of naloxone to reverse.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by michaelmrose on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:57PM (#33925784)
Why not both carfentanyl plus insert fast but awful poison and hope nobody gives your spy naloxone in time.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by Khaine on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:02PM (#33923649)
Cyanide?
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by denton-scratch on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:23PM (#33924683)
AFAIK cyanide is unpleasant; you die struggling to breathe because your muscles don't work - not because you became unconscious.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by Khaine on Sunday December 11, 2022 @08:13AM (#33942858)
Thanks. I never knew that. I always assumed from movies that it was a quick and easy (hence painless) way to go.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by wrp on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:47AM (#33921149)
In the 1980s, I read that the GRU issued an injector they called "blissful death". The source was unreliable, but that's a starting point for research.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by miohtama on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:17AM (#33920887)
Probably still less painful than torture
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ridgered4 on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:34PM (#33926172)
Riffing on another comment, perhaps the poisons used have no known antidotes and that is why they are chosen even though they are painful. Otherwise they would probably be pointless since you could be revived.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by DocTomoe on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:35AM (#33919027)
I guess you don't want that, because it may give people too much of an easy way out, giving up too soon when survival was still preferable for mission success.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by Gys on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:37AM (#33919441)
That would not be my guess. From the state point of view keeping secrets might be much more important than one life.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by denton-scratch on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:42AM (#33921672)
I assume the suicide option is an option for the prospective torturee - not for the agency.

If the pill causes pain, that's an unwanted side-effect. It's unlikely to be as painful as the actions of your torturer, whose goal is to cause as much pain as possible, and who may also want to stretch it out for weeks. And there's a good chance your torturer will kill you anyway.

Sometimes torture is used for punishment or repression, not to obtain information. Arguably that's always the purpose; "information" obtained through torture isn't very reliable.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by 3pac on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:24PM (#33924687)
The psychological pain (weight) of even carrying such a suicide pill/coin as part of your mission pack-out. Perhaps the person has a strong Judeo-Christian belief that God finds suicide and self-harm abhorrent. Or "Dr. Ellie Arroway"-non religious beliefs of the same. Maybe it's a big question mark how those beliefs are tested in the moment of being tortured. Maybe nobody involved likes the option, but it's there because we do not know about that moment, or what happens after we die, but we do know how utterly horrifyingly people can behave in war.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by Mordisquitos on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:25AM (#33919759)
Plus, the last thing the State would want is for their asset to have second thoughts about taking the suicide pill─“They may torture me soon and it will probably be extremely painful... but the pill will certainly be extremely painful! Maybe I should risk it”
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ClumsyPilot on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:56AM (#33920705)
I am sorry this thread is ridiculous.

First, if they are detained, they will be strip searched long before any torture takes place. You either take it early or not at all - odds are everything will be taken away.

Second, the last thing you want in such situation is ambiguity - people don't just commit suicide willy-nilly. Instructions must be very clear.

Thirdly, either the agent has secret information that cannot be divulged, or they don't. This is known upfront before the mission. Any agent at high risk of capture is kept away from sensitive information, to minimise possible damage. Every spy and reconnaissance organisation work like that. As soon as agent is captured, damage control is put in place.

Lastly, orders to commit suicide are not legally possible.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by thedorkknight on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:25AM (#33920955)
>First, if they are detained, they will be strip searched long before any torture takes place. You either take it early or not at all - odds are everything will be taken away.

Aleksandr Ogorodnik was able to get the KGB to give him his pen, which had a suicide pill in it, to write his confession.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleksandr_Dmitrievich_Ogorodni...

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by hericium on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:14AM (#33920854)
> Lastly, orders to commit suicide are not legally possible.

You do realize that we're talking about the CIA here, right?

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ClumsyPilot on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:21AM (#33920916)
What are you gonna do, threaten the guy with Death? :)
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by DocTomoe on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:30AM (#33920995)
"If you do not comply with our request for your suicide, we cannot guarantee the safety of your children, Samantha, currently in 3rd grade in Glaveston Primary, and John, named after your father, who is a star quarterback on Washington High's team. We trust you do what is necessary."
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by matthewdgreen on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:00AM (#33921285)
This is over the top even for the CIA, but they were definitely capable of being monsters. In the case of Gary Powers the agency fought hard to avoid a prisoner exchange and even internally claimed he had defected intentionally. His wife was even committed to a psychiatric institution: not so much to threaten Powers, but just to keep her from embarrassing the agency with her drinking. Ultimately they went ahead with the exchange partly out of fear that Powers would learn what they’d done to his wife.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by matheusmoreira on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:08AM (#33922856)
Imagine joining a government agency to protect your country and your family... And the government not only betrays you personally but also threatens your wife and children.

Surely even the CIA has limits on the atrocities they are willing to commit?

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by ClumsyPilot on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:04AM (#33921313)
If they did so, who would ever agree to go on a mission like that or join CIA at all?

We are talking about US citizens for whom this is a job, they are not like foreign prisoners. CIA -agents are 'one of their own'.

This is like Taliban-level stuff

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by Viliam1234 on Saturday December 10, 2022 @05:38PM (#33937726)
> If they did so, who would ever agree to go on a mission like that or join CIA at all?

This assumes the others would know that it happened. Who would tell them? Certainly not the guy who complied with the request for suicide.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by krisoft on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:27AM (#33920972)
> Lastly, orders to commit suicide are not legally possible.

Obviously you don’t order it. You play up the cruelty of the enemy tortourers. This probably is not hard, every secret service probably have enough nightmare fuel on hand to do if they want to. And then you provide the means and let your agent know they can use it uppon capture.

Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by hericium on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:33AM (#33920189)
Were the agents told that the death will be painful? I believe that organization such as the CIA would rather lie to its own agents to make sure they would poison themselves.
Re:The cyanide tooth is a cold war fairy-tale (2018) by LorenPechtel on Friday December 09, 2022 @12:57PM (#33924364)
Suicide mechanisms are used after the mission has failed, either they are captured or about to be captured. Agents aren't going to use a suicide option while still able to operate. (Although an actor free to operate but for which there isn't a survival option may choose a suicide attack. There was an American kamikaze in WWII, he wasn't going to make it back to the carrier, the only possible rescue was the very fleet he was attacking.)

When it comes down to a quick death by a suicide agent vs being tortured and then likely an unmarked grave it can be a reasonable option. Agents which aren't so likely to be put through the wringer and might be exchanged are another matter--Gary Powers had little reason to use his suicide option. He didn't have great secrets to be tortured for.