The CIA did an analysis and discovered that Huawei was dumping wireless equipment to small wireless providers in areas around US military basis at a loss. At the very least, the ability to disrupt communication of those military bases were easily achievable.
I had my doubts, but not after the CIA said it's true.
I wouldn't 100% trust anything built in China, but there must be some reason people are only taking action now? Unless it's just "better late than never" response after years of this.
IMO, it was a classic mistake of underestimating a potential rival while stroking our own egos about how smart, capable and powerful we are in comparison. Reality finally trumped hubris.
I know there are other complaints, but this is the core issue.. and I strongly suspect the us would look the other way on those issues if there was equal access, like they have in the past.
Being on good terms with them and dealing with inflation by using their labor force bought the US some time but US politicians just acted more irresponsibly (warmongering) instead of capitalizing on the temporary windfall.
Large, strong countries do what they want and small, weak countries do what they must. That's the way it is and the way it's always been.
I think the world was more fair during cold war, having 2 superpowers pushed both of them to keep each other in check. This one state world, seems worse
At a certain point you have to question whether they believe in free trade at all.. or just paying lip service to it to make themselves rich.
Think about the opposite of what you are suggesting… should China now start subsidizing US businesses by buying made in USA when they don’t have to? If we make good products, they have no choice but to buy it because their citizens will demand it.
And your last sentence is wrong— Chinese are not free to buy us made goods if they think they are better. China places heavy tariffs and other protections on imports.
Since you seem to be unaware.. that’s what you’re arguing for: the right of China to place heavy tariffs on foreign goods, while using wto rules to prevent other nations from doing the same to Chinese goods.
Counties agree to wto rules so they can export more.. those rules apply in both directions. If China doesn’t like wto rules, they can withdraw and do as you say: everyone applies whatever tariffs they want on Chinese goods; and China does the same.
Despite tariffs iPhones still sell well and take a majority of profits in China, because it’s a superior product. Tariffs are just a form of subsidy and subsidies protect companies but make them less competitive. Apple wouldn’t exist if America was protectionist.
Ironically, speaking of freedom, the Libertarian candidate was the only one to support it officially.
More than US seeing how PRC has significantly less disputes (normalized for acession time), both as initiator and target per WTO stats and generally abides by WTO disputes ruled against her favour. Even PRC's accession protocol was made extra onerous via US objections who still got outplayed - it isn't/wasn't PRC paying lip service while blocking WTO dispute resolution system. PRC believes in free trade more than US because she's learned to play the game better vs US flipping over the gameboard. Which is fine, globalism no longer in US interest, but lets not pretend US isn't systematically the worst exploiter of free trade even while being the most influential rule writer, and increasinly worse when as those priveleges erode.
>If Beijing keeps breaking free-trade rules to make its foreign-policy points against rival nations, it will hurt domestic markets and lose international stature
https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/opinion/article/2083166/opini...
> Beijing’s attempt to bully Canberra has been a spectacular failure.
https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/09/australia-china-decoupl...
You eating biased media diet doesn't invalid the statistical reality that PRC, relative to her signifcant trade volume and relationships is objectively one of the better adherents at WTO relative to countries that whine about PRC unfairness. From TWO DSS database:
- PRC 65 disputes, 21 as complainant, 44 as respondant
- USA 279 disputes, 124 as complainant, 155 as respondant
- SKR 39 disputes, 21 as complainant, 18 as respondant
- JP 42 disputes, 26 as complainant, 16 as respondant
- AU 25 disputes, 9 as complainant, 16 as respondent
- EU 190 disputes, 104 as complainant, 86 as respondent
Another apt comparison: India 56 disputes, 24 as complainant, 32 as defendant, while 1/5th smaller than PRC.
Normalize for trade volume and accession time (PRC has been WTO member for 21/27 years, with again, more onerous accession requirement than typical) PRC is better than all USA, SKR, AU. In fact substantially better than other major powers. And as US has demonstrated, historically, it's completely normal to jetison trade rules for national security / foreign policy.
Another examples is that the DoD has for quite a long time declared China as the primary adversary, or as they politely say it "pacing challenge".
The Chinese government doesn't play fair, and the West has been letting them get away with it for decades. They take full advantage of open markets available in the rest of the world, but close their markets to outsiders; at best, outsiders can get a piece of the action, but only through the oversight and partial ownership of a local company.
While I won't claim that Western nations don't have issues with censorship and freedom of speech, the Chinese government punishes foreign corporations (economically) that say anything critical of China or its government. The Chinese government exports its propaganda and censorship policies through informal economic sanctions.
I'm not particularly interested in allowing an authoritarian government that takes pervasive propaganda and censorship to become the next world hegemon. (I'll freely admit that the US is no saint in that role, but I think it should be obvious and defensible why I'd prefer the US in that position rather than China.)
Note that this is all about the Chinese government. I have no problems with Chinese people; by and large, those I've met on my few trips to China (granted, my last trip was over 10 years ago) and those I've met who travel to and live in the US have been good, friendly, intelligent people. It's perfectly reasonable to be against the pervasive actions of a foreign government without being branded a xenophobe.
And the US befriended China for important strategic reasons starting with Nixon. If they underestimated anything it was the ability of an authoritarian regime to retain power through such a period of economic growth. Middle classes tend to want western products and media. But the economic growth itself was a deliberate goal of US policy.
As for xenophobia being the opposite, I imagine the comment being referenced (now several levels above) was using -phobia in the common modern sense of including bias or prejudice and not literally fear.
No government or organisation does, and I wouldn’t fault any state for doing it’s best to edge it’s bets.
So "stack the odds in its favour” then?
However, my argument is that the West, in general, underestimated China because of beliefs of cultural, economic, political, intellectual, ethnic, moral, etc superiority. Those beliefs were ultimately weaknesses.
It has become especially clear over the past few years, first with COVID highlighting the fragility of supply chains dependent on such one-sided relations and now with the invasion of Ukraine showing that such relations may also not be as strong of a deterrent against war as previously hoped.
The traded deals by the west were based on the benefit to the western countries. It is not a charity. The low inflation, the record profit of the western companies and bonuses are from cheap labour and resources from more desperate countries.
In the same way that the US and EU going to war or even just breaking off diplomatic ties is extremely unlikely to happen due to how much they have integrated with each other on the back of mutual benefit.
I am sure there are legitimate concerns as all countries spy on each other. But China has become a real industrial and scientific competitor to China and the US just simply would not tolerate a threat to their leading position. I think they are quite explicit about this. We hear all the time about "vital interests".
Yeah sure, this sounds like an iron clad proof.
Some people that worked at Nortel at that time already spoke on HN what happened - hint: it was internal Nortel's issues. Something similar happened to Nokia, better products appeared and company wasn't able to compete.
Defeating the biggest military and geopolitical superpower known to mankind is trivial if you understand you can just ignore all that and instead buy it all up, and it becomes even more trivial if your enemy straight up gives you the monies for it. Literally free real estate.
So kudos to China, they know how to play to win and they're playing to win at all costs while we keep hoisting our own petards.
If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
https://prospect.org/power/congressmembers-tried-to-stop-sec...
Both democrats and republicans, it's just musical chairs, they are all pilfering us.
https://financialpost.com/news/fp-street/earnings-management...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nortel_Retirees_and_former_emp...
Reds in the bed kind of fud here.
Riiiiight. The dotcom crash followed by the accounting scam had absolutely nothing to do with it. It's not like the management pretended that they wouldn't see a downturn and then faked the numbers so that they'd get their bonuses.
Oh, wait.
He'll tell you a different story. When you mention the "espionage / sabotage" he doesn't laugh or shake his head, it actually just outright infuriates him. Such a naive narrative only angers him because it seems to absolve the people who managed the company of outright incompetence and corruption, which is how it should be remembered.
For example: one story I vividly recall because I could never fully fathom it involved a specific female executive who was traveling for business - first class overseas. She never made her intended engagement because she was immediately arrested upon disembarking the plane. She had got drunk and (although married) decided to perform overt sexual acts with the gentleman sitting adjacent to her. On the plane. In her seat.[1]
At some point the culture of the executive at Nortel, for whatever reason, became completely incompetent and outright immoral. Rather than Huawei underhandedly perpetrating the perfect crime, it was simply the people at the head of the organization that solicited the crime to pursue their own benefit above all else.
[1] https://www.theregister.com/2000/04/06/former_nortel_exec_fi...
Huawei's espionage was well documented at Nortel, it's not within any level of dispute.
Nothing so sophisticated is required. Look at the sheer number of "default credential" and "static credential" for a whole variety of products:
https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvekey.cgi?keyword=Cisco+crede...
If Cisco has problems, that should also be dealt with.
But because Cisco has problems doesn't mean that Huawei shouldn't be dealt with.
In Western cultures, we have the notion of "Two wrongs don't make a right."
This is a classic Chinese government talking point. "Don't look at what we're doing. Look over there, instead!"
For decades it's been using the same tactic when anyone criticizes China for trade imbalances and human rights abuses. It's really boring and base at this point.
A pessimistic and frankly rude reading of my comment.
Cisco also has it's equipment manufactured outside of the united states, making them susceptible to similar backdooring without x-raying every board produced.
> But because Cisco has problems doesn't mean that Huawei shouldn't be dealt with.
Cisco is not getting banned by the FCC - so the comparison is moot.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huawei#Collusion_with_Chinese_...
Weather such targetted/discriminatory regulation as opposed to universal regulation is a legal action is a valid question.
This particular law seems to give grant too much discretionary powers to the Executive, which never is a good idea.
I do not think it is specific to Western culture. And yes two wrongs definitely do not make it right and both must be punished. Now call me back when we see the first wrong being punished. We only seem to punish countries that fit very narrow criteria and murdering say hundreds of thousands is not the determining factor. Until then yes "Look over there" is a very valid argument.
Regardless of the whataboutism argument in Internet forums, it’s not in the national interest to give a hostile foreign power the ability to do something like that.
Supply chain management is a thing. Devices aren't assumed to get from the factory to you without interference and there is a lot of work behind the scenes to make assert they aren't interfered with.
Except the agent had a pretty obvious command runner on one of the message handlers. I was a little afraid to ask them whether it was deliberate or just a really incompetently written backup update mechanism.
To be fair, I was looking for arbitrary command execution for my own purposes at the time...
I do get a decent chuckle when I see their OUI in scan results when out and about now. (About ~0.12% of the recorded results in Wigle it seems)
Imagine Germany selling radios to the UK in 1937...
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-12-16/chinese-s...
https://www.engadget.com/huawei-contractor-pakistan-backdoor...
https://www.notebookcheck.net/Huawei-caught-red-handed-The-c...
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-30/vodafone-...
Knowing the absolute mess this would cause diplomatically, they still said there was a back door: https://apnews.com/article/a0031b16e3a511e431b1e0a5f20edbf9
https://www.scmagazine.com/news/apt/microsoft-defender-advan...
Etc.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-huawei-iran-sanctions-exc...
Some others have pointed out some Huawei incidents, but that’s not the big problem.
The big problem is, if you build your entire telecom infrastructure on Huawei gear, and then you go to war, it will then be weaponized. In the best case scenario, you have a telecom infrastructure for which you can’t get any parts, patches, or support. Replacing your entire telecom infrastructure is not something you want to do during the opening months of WWIII.
It’s the same reason why we don’t want to rely on Chinese parts for our missiles.
Thankfully the truly advanced stuff exists in Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, and the EU. But for cheap mass manufacturing, all of these parts end up in China.
The west really needs to suck it up and have electronics designed and manufactured in the west. There are some good signs with the CHIPs act (if only the American companies were as patriotic instead of optimising for share price) and the EU are also making moves to be self sufficient for silicon. However, the entire electronics chain really needs local alternatives. It's crazy that I can get a prototype PCB manufactured and delivered from China faster and cheaper than anywhere local.
How do we know that the Cisco equipment also isn't backdoored and if I send a few malformed TCP packets it opens up its control plane on the receiving port?
Compared to the last few decades, it seems like a strong hand banning these companies. Personally I would like all electronics and products to be made in countries that respect some level of human rights I am comfortable with, but that doesn't really seem like an option currently.