Anyone in their right mind would assume presidential candidates to vet their biggest donors.
[1]: https://fortune.com/2022/11/10/sam-bankman-fried-ftx-joe-bid...
Also, I think you underestimate the amount of effort it takes to uncover something like this. There was a YouTube video posted to HN a few days ago where Marc Cohodes went over why he believed FTX was a scam a few weeks prior to the news breaking. It provided an interesting glimpse into what's required to do DD on this type of operation. It starts with good intuition, which most people don't have, and then evolves into things like hiring private investigators, or running comprehensive background checks on the officers of the company, or calling people with intimate knowledge of the inner workings, or finding ex-employees, etc. etc. etc.
Now you could say, well a presidential candidate should do all that stuff. And in an ideal world, they would. But Marc Cohodes does this as a full time job and likely makes large sums of money from his vocation. It's unrealistic to expect most people, presidential candidate or otherwise, to be capable of performing that kind of DD.
Of SBF's $40ish million in donations, over $25M went to a specific PAC "Protect our Future PAC"[1]. Of that PAC's spending - over $10M went to support a single cypto-friendly Oregon house candidate in his primary where he lost to a different Democrat. In fact nearly all of SBF's support went to primary campaigns so when people say "he spent $40M supporting Democrats" the vast majority of that funding was in races against other Democrats.
The other thing to know about PACs, is that by law, they are not affiliated with the campaign. The campaigns can't vet the donations to PACs because they aren't donations to the candidate and it would be illegal for them to coordinate with the PAC. This is the 3-card monte allowed by our insane campaign finance regime, but within those bounds, SBFs donations weren't to actual candidates who would vet these donors. The PAC has its own compliance, but there basically are no restrictions on donors as long as they're from the US. That's how random Russian billionaires donated to Trump's PACs in 2016, and the only reason that was frowned upon is because the funds came from a foreign national.[2]
[1] - https://www.opensecrets.org/outside-spending/detail?cmte=C00...
[2] - https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/lev-parnas-and-igor-fru...
> sports teams like Miami Heat or Mercedes F1 actually advertised them
How does that prove any kind of reliability at all? There's no FDIC insurance on any of the deposits. There's no actual regulation or transparency. Its not like VMFXX or SWVXX where there are requirements to publish their assets on a regular basis, or describe asset flows / liquidity requirements.
--------
Still though, the scientists in this discussion were _NOT_ investors. The economy is designed for _investors_ to win (and lose) money as per appropriate risks. Its fine for investors to lose money here, that's the entire point of capitalism. (The investors get the money if they bet right, but they lose their money if they lose).
These scientists who allegedly got funds... its not their job to be trying to figure out which groups to trust or not trust. Maybe scientific donations / 401c type deals need to be more carefully watched in the future?
The point is that these companies with way more financial experience, size, and more reasons to investigate failed to find any warning signs, so these non-profits had very little chance, even if they didn't go with the "don't look a gift horse in the mouth" approach. FTX might have let some auditor from an investor putting in $100M take a look at their books but they'd almost surely tell a non-profit with no leverage that's receiving the money to get lost if they asked.
I don't think you get the point of Softbank or even Blackrock.
When you have $10 Trillion in assets like Blackrock, you _DON'T_ sweat a $300 million investment or even a $2 billion investment here or there. It literally doesn't matter. Its not even a rounding error to you, your company, or your investors.
Its barely worth Blackrock's time to seriously look at things like this. That's why we get $Billion sized London Whale mistakes or whatever, because they have so much money to manage the only reasonable way to do it is to hand billions of (management) dollars to executives and give those executives broad leeway to do whatever they want.
-------
This kind of mistake is a "Lol, Executive #455 made an error", and that executive is going to be in the hotseat as other executives make fun of him for his FTX mistake at a place like Blackrock.
I don't understand where you get this idea that VC companies tightly vet their choices. If anything, the bigger the VC firm, the less they vet something at the $million, or even $billion levels.
That is clearly and demonstrably false. Just because you have investments in Lockheed Martin doesn't mean you are free to invest in Al Qaeda to increase the chances of conflict.
Also stadium sponsorships. If you're trying to buy credibility by sponsoring spectator sports, well that's a huge red flag right there.
Hate to be that guy, but most people using crypto have been committing (tax) fraud for years. Knowingly or unknowingly.
FTX isn't a US security that was traded on any platform. VCs (and accredited investors) are people rich enough, that the USA / regulators have deemed it "fine" if they lose a lot of money.
Accredited investors are supposed to have over $1M bucks not because it proves that they're smart. Its so that when they inevitably get caught in a Ponzi scheme or whatever, USA doesn't have to rush in and save their money.
Welcome to USA. If you're an accredited investor and/or Venture Capitalist, the training wheels are entirely off. You're on your own.
--------
There's no FDIC insurance or SEC governing FTX's deposits. Its wholly unregulated, and in the Bahamas to boot.
I don't care about the VCs getting their money, I'm happy they go to zero etc- I'm saying the opposite, the VCs gave a false sense of security to regular folk that FTX was legit, but in reality FTX was telling depositors that they were doing all these things to protect them that they weren't.
At minimum, the regulators should say "Hey, you can't tell people their money is safe if it isn't" (siloed customer accounts etc) at best the regulators should say "Hey, you have to make sure regular consumers are safe if you plan to take money from US consumers".
> Multinationals going bankrupt seems like there will be issues about which group owns what and the various obligations between them.
Yes, which will be decided according to the bankruptcy law of the corp's incorporation, not the one it chooses. You are confusing choice of law with venue.
But yes, I think I get your point. Thanks for making it, and again for following up.
Bahamas don't need to send their own attorneys if they don't want to... they aren't necessarily a party to the case. Here, FTX is opting to have a US disposition of the Bahamian bankruptcy code, so what would Bahama have to send attorneys for? In this case, its still adversarial between the creditors and FTX, so there will be parties arguing for the correct application of law.
Who were they were trying to reach with their Superbowl ads, VCs? I suspect not.
Regulation failed? The media were complicit into this. Presenting SBF as the second coming of the Christ because he'd give it all to charities / non-profits / help advance science / etc. Regulator people fell for this.
I'm not so sure it's "accredited investors" we need as much as "accredited journalists".
That said bitfinexed will likely say that everything in crypto is a scam, not just ftx. And I'd agree!
Their main focus is the tether scam though.
So where is it? Did they keep the question to themselves, even though they could just tweet it at SBF and have almost 100k followers see it, who could then amplify it?
> “Two ways,” Mike said. “Gradually and then suddenly.”
If history is any guide, Tether's sketchiness is going to continue to not matter to most crypto investors, until suddenly it matters an awful lot.
No one wanted to listen
About two minutes of googling would have come up with the fact that one of their top executive was linked to the biggest online poker scandal.
Now, granted, that information required two minutes and not 30 seconds to be found because the first few pages of results would be NY Times pieces and their ilk pumping the FTX scam "because altruistic democrats donor".
A lot of people have been, at the very least, turning a very blind eye here.
Now is not the time to say it's "unreasonable" to do two minutes of googling.
They should have liquidated those holdings and put them in something safer.
I agree with you regarding regular people having no clue and no way to vet donors but keep in mind most folks on HN are part of this. The public knows what they get from news pieces they read, written by journalists who also don't have a clue. SBF was treated as the king of crypto by the mainstream for whatever reason. Talked to a lot of politicians too and spoke out in favor of regulation. Probably tried to sacrifice what he didn't care about anyway (actually decentralized chains) in order to present himself has a crypto person regulators can work with, all while committing fraud. Gary Gensler is supposed to have had private meetings with him several times. Curious how the agency who's supposed to regulate these exchanges never actually does and is even completely oblivious to multi billion dollar theft until the whole thing implodes. Meanwhile parties accept huge donations from Bankman-Fried and the SEC goes after smaller crypto projects that aren't even certain to be their jurisdiction.
Crypto has only seriously been around for 10-15 years. This is somewhat like saying “he’s only been a react dev for 5 years”
I think the reason is getting more and more obvious with every passing day.
His father and mother are professors of Law (and Business) at Stanford. His aunt is a dean of Columbia University's School of Public Health.
https://showbizcorner.com/sam-bankman-fried-parents
His brother was running a lobby group called Guarding Against Pandemics. FTX's head of policy and regulatory strategy was a Commodity Futures Trading Commission commissioner under Obama.
https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/14/former-ftx-ceo-sam-bankman-f...
And that's not the end of it all, there are many more interesting connections.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=131&v=C6nAxiym9o...
Selling something with no value other than the attention it gets on Twitter and the reputation it gets via reputable investors.
What gets 'reputable investors' to invest in the scheme is the most interesting part of this story, if you at all care about stopping it. Something that has existed long before crypto.
> Selling something with no value other than the attention it gets on Twitter and the reputation it gets via reputable investors.
But that is clearly not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme involves an obligation to pay people returns on their fake investment. Here, the pitch was "I don't know why people want these things, but they do. Want one?", and that pitch was honest and accurate. There was no pretense that you'd be getting any special returns.
By your standard, all trading in any commodity or stock is a Ponzi scheme, unless you're planning to consume the stuff yourself. Did you buy 300,000 pork bellies? Ponzi scheme. Do you have a bar of gold? Ponzi scheme. Do you have a share of Tesla? Ponzi scheme.
Compare Charles Ponzi, whose investment thesis was "guaranteed returns of 50% in 45 days", who specified the exact trade he was making (buying American stamps in Italy, where they were cheap, and selling them in America, where they weren't), and who never actually performed that trade. A Ponzi scheme is defined by paying off people who have invested in you with funds from other people who have invested in you.
/s
I'd say to run a successful trading shop you need to be a good trader. Doesn't matter whether you trade potatoes, pork belly futures, or crypto. Do you think Jump Trading cares (or even necessarily knows) anything about the tokens they successfully trade?
And he's somehow "establishment" because he gave to political parties, and Democrat because we're ignoring the GOP contributions.
SBF was more of a crypto guy than 99% of crypto. And he was way more crypto than he was establishment.
And the problems in crypto that his actions highlighted (centralization, fraud, lack of consumer protections) cannot be waved away with "no true scotsman" arguments.
He's your boy. Own it or the industry will not correct its own deep, ongoing mistakes, currently being made by entities like Binance.
Not sure about that. He was meeting with the chairman of the SEC and was a top donor personally to the Democratic Party.
That screams "establishment".
How many crypto bros can meet with the chairman of the SEC?
Unless you hold that meeting with the chairman of the SEC disqualifies you from being a cryptobro. In which case it's tautologically zero.
And that is out of how many cryptobros in existence?
I'm pretty sure he'll end up meeting the SEC a few times.
I love people who portray his willingness to engage with regulators as a form of selling out, as opposed to what it was, knowing that regulation was coming, so engaging to try to influence it to his advantage.
Which is what every other industry does when the regulatory hammer comes down.
But so many crypto believers seem to think that crypto is different to all that's come before it, it's really not. It's very sadly humorous how crypto has speedrun the entire history of why financial institutions are regulated.
So much so he began to think he was above it all.
It's an old story that repeats over and over again, long before crypto and long after it.
Yes, it allowed him to steal billions till someone with non zero morals leaked info about it.
> I love people who portray his willingness to engage with regulators as a form of selling out, as opposed to what it was, knowing that regulation was coming, so engaging to try to influence it to his advantage.
I didn't say that. You are reading too much.
> I love people who portray his willingness to engage with regulators as a form of selling out, as opposed to what it was, knowing that regulation was coming, so engaging to try to influence it to his advantage.
No one said that. The point is SBF is in bed with the establishment and the establishment deserves some blame.
I'm fine with saying he's establishment. I just don't agree that makes him not a cryptobro
And I am fine with saying he's a cryptobro.
> I just don't agree that makes him not a cryptobro
No one said that.
The point is that he is not an ordinary cryptobro. He rose in status in the crypto world due to being in bed with the establishment.
I don't think anyone here but you thinks this is that type of "political" or otherwise meaningful in this conversation.
It's a trick: Nothing in crypto is decentralized. Decentralization (ipfs, orbitdb) is dying on the vine because you can make vastly more money in crypto - because it's centralized.
He was a Ringer that was clearly parachuted in. The NYTimes puff piece absolutely confirmed that.
Sam's not the first and he won't be the last.
I got over the hype back in 2014, once you take the rose colored glasses off guys like Sam are easier to identify.
SBF created a giant custodial casino where one could bet on cryptocurrency prices, and people lost money that they gave him custody over. If they had held it in their own wallets, they would not have lost it. Many people in the cryptocurrency community spoke out against him for a long time. This is like if SBF had a penchant for kilts, the media was asking “what does this mean for Scotland?”, actual Scottish people were saying “this has nothing to do with Scotland”, and you come in with the comment “nO tRuE ScOtSmAn”
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/17/business/ftx-bankruptcy.h...
And I quote:
> "John Jay Ray III helped manage the aftermath of some of the largest corporate failures in history, including the implosion of the energy trading firm Enron after an accounting fraud scandal in 2001.
> But the corporate dysfunction at FTX, the collapsed cryptocurrency exchange that he took over last week, is the worst he has ever seen.
> In a blistering court filing on Thursday, Mr. Ray described an astonishing level of disarray and said he had never seen “such a complete failure of corporate control.” He listed a series of “unacceptable management practices,” including the use of an unsecured group email to access sensitive data, and said the financial information maintained by FTX was deeply untrustworthy.
> “From compromised systems integrity and faulty regulatory oversight abroad, to the concentration of control in the hands of a very small group of inexperienced, unsophisticated and potentially compromised individuals, this situation is unprecedented,” he wrote in the filing in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware."
The evidence against SBF is damning. The NYT will continue to report that. You can cherrypick their pieces if you want to.
But what you should be doing is looking at the 10,000 ways that crypto made SBF and FTX what they were, through your credulity and greed. The NYT had nothing to do with that.
Fraudsters will find any way to fraud, no matter the economics or tech.
Enabling a fraudster to build and control something around a fig leaf will result in the same no matter the controls.
Edit: this sounds defeatist on a second reading, but that is not my intent. I’m not saying there’s a futility here. I do think it’s futile to believe we could rid any field of fraudsters and con artists, but I don’t think anyone here has argued we can.
How many times must we tell how many people that crypto is not a normal business, it's inherently dishonest.
I think this is argument is reasonable for individual recipients, but not for the effective altruism community as a whole? I wrote more about this here: https://www.jefftk.com/p/if-professional-investors-missed-th...
Given the above I think the title is on the alarmist side. Effective altruism organizations stranded by FTXs collapse probably wouldn't get the clicks.
If FTX investors, customers, and watchers of the crypto space did not catch what FTX and SBF were doing until the shit hit the fan, what kind of due diligence can we reasonably expect of these recipients that would’ve alerted them to something being wrong here?
And consider that the number of donors for most institutions would be much larger than the number of companies FTX investors would’ve had to keep an eye on.