News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by SilverBirch on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @04:58PM (#33631358)
I think the underlying message here is regulation failed. You can dance around and shout "crypto" and people will apparently just stop doing due diligence. All these companies - the VCs, the advertisers etc. all relied on "This isn't an actual literal ponzi though right?" and the US regulators were like "LOL IDK". It's kind of the regulators job not to be trusting in VCs and reputation and really do the work.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by AlexandrB on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:04PM (#33631441)
Isn't half the point of "crypto" to have an unregulated financial market? FTX operated out of the Bahamas for a reason. How can regulators fail to regulate a company that's not even based in their jurisdiction. You might have a point with FTX.US though.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by SilverBirch on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:29PM (#33631795)
They filed for bankruptcy in Delaware, and FTX US is bust. So I think it's more than just the weird bahamanian guys went crazy.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by trompetenaccoun on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @06:32PM (#33632570)
That's the antithesis of cryptocurrency. It's just regular plain old fraud and that's what the SEC is supposed to regulate. That's the only reason they exist. FTX is an exchange where you can trade cryptocurrencies for fiat currencies. If it were a decentralized on-chain exchange, how would they have stolen all this money without anyone noticing? That's the very point of public blockchains, if it had been a crypto market everyone could have watched the money disappear. Actually, a proper defi market should be set up so that the creators never even can misappropriate founds even if they wanted to, because they won't have access. Anyone can convince themselves of what the contract does by simply reading it. You don't have to trust some weird guy and his company in the Bahamas, you can verify it. Centralized exchanges like FTX and Binance do not operate this way. The closest you can get is Coinbase since they're public and need to be audited.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by BolexNOLA on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @06:49PM (#33632740)
> That's the antithesis of cryptocurrency. It's just regular plain old fraud and that's what the SEC is supposed to regulate.

Hate to be that guy, but most people using crypto have been committing (tax) fraud for years. Knowingly or unknowingly.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by trompetenaccoun on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @07:07PM (#33632951)
The statement wasn't that people using cryptocurrencies can't break the law. It's that blockchains solve this trust problem that exists in traditional finance. Very obviously the regulation we have does not work, you don't have to look at exchanges to understand that. The very same problems exist in banking but most poor folks in developed countries don't notice since even if the funds are lost there is some insurance. You could have such insurance for crypto exchange funds as well, but ultimately the people are always paying the bill when their money gets "lost", whether they understand this or not. Insurance costs money. A better system would be a more transparent one where the money can not simply disappear in the first place.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by BolexNOLA on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @07:27PM (#33633181)
No argument here!
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by dragontamer on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:03PM (#33631430)
What?

FTX isn't a US security that was traded on any platform. VCs (and accredited investors) are people rich enough, that the USA / regulators have deemed it "fine" if they lose a lot of money.

Accredited investors are supposed to have over $1M bucks not because it proves that they're smart. Its so that when they inevitably get caught in a Ponzi scheme or whatever, USA doesn't have to rush in and save their money.

Welcome to USA. If you're an accredited investor and/or Venture Capitalist, the training wheels are entirely off. You're on your own.

--------

There's no FDIC insurance or SEC governing FTX's deposits. Its wholly unregulated, and in the Bahamas to boot.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by SilverBirch on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:34PM (#33631855)
FTX took deposits from unaccredited US investors with specific guarantees about what would happen with the money and they filed for bankruptcy in Delaware.

I don't care about the VCs getting their money, I'm happy they go to zero etc- I'm saying the opposite, the VCs gave a false sense of security to regular folk that FTX was legit, but in reality FTX was telling depositors that they were doing all these things to protect them that they weren't.

At minimum, the regulators should say "Hey, you can't tell people their money is safe if it isn't" (siloed customer accounts etc) at best the regulators should say "Hey, you have to make sure regular consumers are safe if you plan to take money from US consumers".

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @06:02PM (#33632209)
What does filing for bankruptcy in Delaware have to do with anything?
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by HWR_14 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:07PM (#33634008)
US law vs. Panamanian law.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @11:05AM (#33640885)
If its not a US corp they aren't going to apply US bankruptcy law, they will apply the bankruptcy law of the jurisdiction the corp is registered in. They went to the US court because it will be a quicker disposition of the case.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by HWR_14 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @11:50AM (#33641665)
They have a US division. Multinationals going bankrupt seems like there will be issues about which group owns what and the various obligations between them.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:47PM (#33642712)
So the bankruptcy of the US division will have US law, the others will according to their own jurisdictions.

> Multinationals going bankrupt seems like there will be issues about which group owns what and the various obligations between them.

Yes, which will be decided according to the bankruptcy law of the corp's incorporation, not the one it chooses. You are confusing choice of law with venue.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by HWR_14 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:08PM (#33647267)
I actually meant that it's really unclear whether FTX-US or FTX-Bahamas (or other subgroups) owns any asset. That's what I meant by "which group owns what".
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @07:40PM (#33648187)
Okay, I still don't understand if you got the point that filing for bankruptcy in a DE court doesn't mean you get DE bankruptcy law applied.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by HWR_14 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:24PM (#33649680)
You're right, I never addressed that. I didn't know that before this whole thing started, and that seems weird to me. But also it makes some sense that otherwise both divisions would need to be in different courts in different countries and that seems even worse. I assume there is a US or Delaware law that lets them follow the law of other jurisdictions in cases like this. Almost like an economic extradition. I assume the Bahamas would send their own lawyer(s)?

But yes, I think I get your point. Thanks for making it, and again for following up.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Friday November 18, 2022 @12:06PM (#33657783)
It's called choice of law. Happens in US courts all of the time, parents enforcing an out-of-state divorce court parental agreement after they moved, two people from Ohio who got into a crash in Indiana... us enforcing in Florida, a commercial contract drafted under new york law, just some examples of where a court would use law from a different jurisdiction.

Bahamas don't need to send their own attorneys if they don't want to... they aren't necessarily a party to the case. Here, FTX is opting to have a US disposition of the Bahamian bankruptcy code, so what would Bahama have to send attorneys for? In this case, its still adversarial between the creditors and FTX, so there will be parties arguing for the correct application of law.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by lmm on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:21PM (#33631697)
The US legal system needs to start going after VCs that invest in criminal companies. They may not be breaking the law themselves, but they profit off lawbreaking, and they're the ones with the deep pockets. (Isn't this the whole point of RICO?)
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by danans on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @11:59PM (#33635161)
> Welcome to USA. If you're an accredited investor and/or Venture Capitalist, the training wheels are entirely off.

Who were they were trying to reach with their Superbowl ads, VCs? I suspect not.

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by User23 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @01:02AM (#33635535)
Roughly 10% of American households are accredited. Bilking affluent boomers is a big business.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by danans on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:05PM (#33643921)
Was accreditation a requirement for investing in FTX? It doesn't seem like it from the accounts of retail investors losing significant amounts of money.
Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by TacticalCoder on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:48PM (#33632015)
> I think the underlying message here is regulation failed. You can dance around and shout "crypto" and people will apparently just stop doing due diligence

Regulation failed? The media were complicit into this. Presenting SBF as the second coming of the Christ because he'd give it all to charities / non-profits / help advance science / etc. Regulator people fell for this.

I'm not so sure it's "accredited investors" we need as much as "accredited journalists".

Re:Crypto company's collapse strands scientists by freejazz on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @06:01PM (#33632196)
FTX didn't have a bitlicense because it deals with so many of the exact problems FTX had...