I also don’t understand why there are competing cryptocurrencies? Without governments and borders, shouldn’t one standard currency be enough? (Technical challenges aside)
A lot of these "competing cryptocurrencies" are just financial instruments, kind of like you could have stock in a company, but you can also trade options and futures of the same underlying stock.
No they weren't. This comparison has no relation to reality.
For most people, the only important part of what you call "ownership" are the cash benefits (buybacks, dividends, and acquisitions). You can see this from the small price difference between GOOG and GOOGL.
Those people look particularly silly on days like this.
What kind of bets was Alameda making? Why would it need so much leverage?
I understand why loaning money to Alameda could be rationalized a risky, but not sketchy move (if Alameda posted collateral, paid reasonable terms like anyone else would, etc.).
Actions and results matter. Intentions can easily be bullshit and delusion.
If someone is committing multi-billion dollar fraud, there is a line that was crossed a LONG time ago.
It’s only plausible to a certain point that they were unknowingly bad actors. They’d have to willingly be deluding themselves.
No one commits multi-billion dollar fraud accidentally.
They’d have to turn a blind eye to something any reasonable person would consider a ‘are we the baddies’ moment. Or two. Or dozens.
As to if it’s documented? One can hope, but I’m not holding my breath. I’m sure there have been many shredder parties (or digital equivalents) happening in many places since the news broke.
Most people cross that threshold well before a million bucks.
You can tell by the shape of the lies that are inevitably told. Someone who actually thinks they’re doing something ok won’t go to such lengths to hide important details, or omit specific things that are inevitably omitted.
And in this case, why not just update the TOS to be clear what they’re doing?
Because they know it’s wrong.
What you’re talking about is willful delusion.
Denial ain’t just a river in Egypt, etc.
They were either criminally stupid or did this on purpose. It really wasn’t that complex. This isn’t even close to 2008 complexity since this was all happening within one organization With the same owner SBF.
As a caveat, however, SBF did work at Jane Street and graduated Summa Cum Laude from MIT with a Physics degree, so maybe this quote does not apply.
https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/87387a75-dde7-44ec-bc87-66f4e20...
Or this guy from Why Him:
https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/bbc047f6-7417-4eb3-b4fe-064f75d...
2: “Never assume malice by that which could be explained by incompetence.”
1+2 = 3: “Never attribute malice to that which can be adequately by greed”
But again and again, supposedly smart finance folks end up blindsided by retrospectively obvious stuff. There's just too many complicated fabrications on top of one another.
I'm not particularly sanctimonious, I think the average vilain of the day is most of the time just an average person making dumb mistake.
I think that reality hasn’t set in for most people yet. Especially SBF.
They’re the type of people that are too smart for their own good where they can’t even see how idiotic they’re being. Or maybe they’re just spoiled. Or maybe they just think they’re smart. It’s interesting to me that Jane Street prides themselves on their hiring process, but they apparently hire folks like this.
Other than people losing money, I am super glad these reality checks are happening. But I wish they’d happen to more as well, e.g., Musk and Trump.
They like to give the impression they hire Ultra Mega Geniuses who have done the IMO (who cares if you did the IMO at age 17...?)
If your thesis is "they were inexperienced and operating without sufficient supervision" then that's a big part of what the structure of a place like Jane Street gets you.
Anecdata,
I've studied along guys/gals who've done IMO, also had them as co-workers at other times, they have never performed well.
I really like Linus' saying "talk is cheap, show me the code". These people can make a thousand arguments about why something should/shouldn't work (but never write code), then you show up with working code and they don't have much else to say.
Some young kid thought he knew better than his elders, and was doing arbitrage, which is moving around vast amounts of money, for very small gains (but safe ones).
They had all this money at their disposal, and just knew that these stuffy old farts were "missing the boat," so they figured that they'd just use a bit, to make a small bet, and put it back...
Also why are there no lawsuits yet? Since FTX clearly broke its own T&S?
Using customer funds held in custody is theft. Period. People go to jail for this.
This may be the biggest embezzlement of customer funds held in custody in history. Most scams involve misuse of funds invested, not just held in custody. The biggest outright theft of this type seems to have been Peregrine Financial.[2] That was $200 million, far smaller than this one.
What happened to the CEO of Peregrine? Here he is, 10 years after conviction:
Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator
RUSSELL R WASENDORF
Register Number: 12191-029
Age: 74
Race: White
Sex: Male
Located at: Jesup FCI
Release Date: 02/19/2054
[1] https://fortune.com/crypto/2022/11/10/ftx-sam-bankman-fried-...[2] https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/omaha/press-releases/2013/...
It feels like having an investigative journalist on payroll. The delay between an Animats comment and this showing up in the news is significant. Thank you!
(I remember your comments about the CEO that forged pay stubs being similarly excellent. Someday it might be worth collating them. In the meantime, whenever Animats says CEO Foobar is going to prison, Foobar had better start mentally preparing themselves for the journey.)
We still have both mass-market and one-on-one scams, but now they can both be done remotely. There's not much originality. It's mostly the same old scams of a few standard types, sometimes in new packaging.
Stories like that are really interesting to dig into. They all seem to get caught because the world changes (audits happening via internet in Wasendorf’s case, the economy imploding and sinking Alameda’s risky investments, etc) rather than from any particular mistake. The mistake always seems to be that they started cheating in the first place, and then it was just a matter of time.
Of course, we only hear about the ones who were caught. It makes you wonder how many stories like this were swept under the rug — if Alameda had made money instead of losing it, FTX would probably still be online, even though they’d still be committing the same large scale fraud.
Anyway, thanks again for all this, and especially for all the detail you put in. (Your comment pointing out that SBF is firmly under the SEC’s jurisdiction was wonderful.)
I wouldn't be surprised to learn that the amount of actual customer funds that went in were much smaller than claimed.
Keep in mind FTX was mostly 'perpetuals' -- fake assets. It might be that a lot of the customer funds were just fictional gains, also may be that a lot of them were paper value owned by SBF entities.
I've been trying to find anyone I personally know that had FTX exposure and so far I'm coming up dry.
At least they're at the head of the line in bankruptcy. Custodial funds come ahead of debts.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/yq6y5d/all_...
That's true for the numbers used when reporting on Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme. Much of the $50B was fictional gains.
There were even clawbacks on the gains of those who withdrew before the collapse.
Ultimately the US government is the party that gained the most financially from Madoff's scheme!
He will either go to prison or kill himself I would bet.
EDIT: Suicide is something that's hit personally lately - my response was likely something based on that. To the person who responded - I didn't think you considered suicide a joke - and plenty do consider it. It's never a solution though. You even got an upvote.
“I’d bet” is a figure of speech. Not the stated desire to gamble.
you are surrounded by people celebrating your genius, everything you touch turns to billions and billions
it is easy to see how someone gets disconnected from reality and ends up living in the metaverse of their own genius
See? The metaverse isn't useless after all.
It's survivorship bias.
They accept FTT as collateral, give out a leveraged loan to the other company. The company spends that money on things like stadium rights and bailing out other failed crypto companies. Collateral falls to a value of 0, and the money is spent.
The money that you spent to pay for the bitcoins exit the system during the purchase. Most likely paying the Ferrari of the seller.
My particular views are: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/EKN9Nn89ixriwSXpP/...
This explanation seems pretty plausible from a game theory angle. The selfish cost of losing 1 billion dollars and losing 10 billion dollars for fraud is the same. Either way he is ruined and probably goes to prison, so he keeps gambling even if the odds aren't in his favor, and problem grows exponentially.
Altruism is a lot easier when it's not your neck on the line.
The CEO described how a feasible 'pyramid' could work with Levine on Bloomberg and it looks like he was doing just that.
This is basically a smart kid breaking all the rules, doing mostly what he was allowed to do legally with all of the misrepresentation and hyper - plus a little bit of illegal stuff which is all you need along with the massive leverage that comes along with it.
But I would say aside from his shenanigans - this is a crypto problem. At the base of the pyramid was an 'asset worth nothing' well ... of of crypto is essentially that.
SBF was just following the EA maxim: "take advantage of strategies other people are biased against using"
At this point, mid-2019, SBF decided to double down again—and scratch his own itch. He would bet Alameda’s multimillion-dollar trading profits on a new venture: a trading exchange called FTX. It would combine Coinbase’s stolid, regulation-loving approach with the kinds of derivatives being offered by Binance and others. He only gave himself a 20 percent chance of success, but, in his mind, SBF needed extreme risk to maximize the expected value of his lifetime earnings—and, therefore, the good his earn-to-give strategy could do. The fact that he was, by his own lights, overwhelmingly likely to fail was beside the point.
The point was this: When SBF multiplied out the billions of dollars a year a successful crypto-trading exchange could throw off by his self-assessed 20 percent chance of successfully building one, the number was still huge. That’s the expected value. And if you live your life according to the same principles by which you’d trade an asset, there’s only one way forward: You calculate the expected values, then aim for the largest one—because, in one (but just one) alternate future universe, everything works out fabulously. To maximize your expected value, you must aim for it and then march blindly forth, acting as if the fabulously lucky SBF of the future can reach into the other, parallel, universes and compensate the failson SBFs for their losses. It sounds crazy, or perhaps even selfish—but it’s not. It’s math. It follows from the principle of risk-neutrality.
If you have $1B to your name, it's stupid to put it all on red, even if your expected return is positive.
I don't think people are comprehending how tragic this whole situation is (acknowledging that it's SBF's fault). This collapse put the brakes on a powerful force for good, and lives that would have been saved won't anymore.
Let's be honest: we don't know what his life goals are. He said that his goal is to fund charities, but that's a pretty common thing for wealthy people in the U.S. to say because saying so gives you a lot of social status at no cost. Very few people actually proceed with any plans of significant charitable donations.
from: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/23462333/sam-bankman-frie...
Perhaps if he had spent more time donating money (his stated aim) rather than inventing convoluted financial structures (FTX has over 100 related companies!), he would have achieved more, and cost people a lot less.
(Sorry for saying "financial" earlier when the reference class is really something more specific like "international retail finance")
Maybe there's a reason it takes 4 years of extremely tough classes to understand the basics of "hard" math.
Most books, yt videos, jobs and academic press releases tell me all it takes is `import tensorflow` or `git clone github://lolcoin.git`
On top of that, any decent tech school also has an "ethics of engineering" course somewhere along the way, or at least I did about 20 years ago when I was a student (we had quite a stupid professor, but the intention was there).
What calculation? What's the formula that gives you the odds that your Ponzi scheme will be discovered? What can possibly "model" that, aside from a scifi-level reality simulation? It's not even math, it's math LARPing.
E.g. if you had a weighted coin that was 50-50 odds with 3-to-1 payout, you wouldn't bet your whole bankroll on just one flip.
But outcomes aren't certain and high EV plays can still carry a substantial amount of risk, which is exactly why we have finance regulations.
I can speculate based on recently revealed facts.
SBF did grease politicians to the tune of 40 million USD in political donations. Several have described these donations as: "bribes" (I'll let you judge). (as a sidenote I wonder if these politicians are going to give these donations back to the people SBF scammed).
A US congressman, as reported here several times, wrote: "GaryGensler runs to the media while reports to my office allege he was helping SBF and FTX work on legal loopholes to obtain a regulatory monopoly. We're looking into this".
It's "allegedly" but it's a fact that a US congressman posted that.
It's also established that a colleague of the SEC's Garry Gensler happens to be the father of... Drumroll... The 28 years old woman CEO of Alameda.
So I'll speculate a TL;DR:
SBF was working hand in hand with corrupt politicians and corrupt officials to kick Binance out of the US through regulatory capture in order to grab Binance's insane market share (easily 10x the size of FTX).
SBF would then have continued the established FTX/Alameda scam through FTT. So he'd have then used FTX to pump the price of FTT (and, because why not, other manipulated shitcoins too) in order to keep pretending traders at Alameda were geniuses.
Alameda would have been fully legit and would have take shitloads of money from various pension funds and investment funds (knowing he already got some: why not think he would have gone for more?).
That's my speculation: why stop at 1/10th the size of Binance when you can donate tens of millions to politicians (which is pocket change when you're making billions) and work with the SEC to get a monopoly on crypto exchanges in the US, all the while pumping the value of your Alameda fund and all the while having covers of magazines and people everywhere (Bloomberg, Sequoia, JP Morgan, etc.) saying how big of a genius you are and how geniuses all people around you are.
The guy is a megalomaniac: no longer than a few weeks ago he was saying that companies worth tens of billions were "potential acquisition targets".
And I think that, had the overall markets not have been crashing hard, he may have succeeded at all that, creating a scam 10x or 100x bigger than the one he actually ran.
But the market crashed and CZ took the opportunity to reveal the FTT scam to get rid of a very dangerous competitor. No matter if Binance is legit or not: SBF was after Binance but Binance was too big for SBF too chew. Binance may be going down too (no clue about that) but Binance was never going to go down alone while letting SBF free to run his SEC-endorsed scam.
Basically - is Binance solvent? I don’t know.
CZ knew about FTX's finances because he was the original investor in FTX. The reason he had FTT to dump in the first place is because of that initial investment in FTX.
Two important points: 1. Generally Proof of Reserves is a term where all holders can validate cryptographically that their funds are accounted for. This is harder because it's natural and efficient for an exchange to co-mingle multiple customers. 2. Doesn't mean they're solvent! They might owe customers $100bn for all anyone knows.
It's still far better than nothing, but FWIW their history of lying about their home jurisdiction, and massive "out of nowhere" growth is a huge red flag that you should be aware of (FTX did the latter even faster, of course, being founded in 2019!).
I'm actually confident that he's running a real business there, because that's the smart thing to do.
1: CZ literally destroyed FTX with a tweet.
SBF contributed millions to democrat candidates in the recent elections. Perhaps his exit plan was legislation to bail him out.
Like every gambler, he was wrong of course, and eventually lost it all because gambling is stupid.
Presumably, SBF was hoping that the crypto winter would end soon, which would bring everything else massively profitable for them again, and then plug the holes he had.
Was this a fraud that got out of control, or premeditated? If it was premeditated, what was the exit plan?
Did he expect to be able to gamble with customer funds indefinitely?
Were the Effective Altruism intimations genuine?
Why, if Alameda was a market maker, and they therefore presumably have some form of insight into the markets, did they then decide to take a huge directional bet on Crypto [source?]? This is contrary to market making principles.
What was the purpose of encouraging employees to invest? Was it to buy their silence/cooperation ('you have to stay employed and invested if you ever want your money back') if they found out about the fraud, or did Bankman-Fried genuinely believe it was to their benefit?
Why were there so many puff pieces in the media, without any journalist questioning the narrative?