News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jandrese on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:06PM (#33473767)
I don't even understand what Web3 is. Whenever I try to learn about it the discussion digresses into blockchain pyramid schemes that clearly won't scale and other such nonsense. Certainly Web3 isn't just crypto-bros trying to take over the web? Why would anybody outside of the crypto scam sphere care about it if that were the case?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#33474188)
It's more than just crypto-bros trying to take over the web.

It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air, wrapped in a network of criminal enterprises using special 'insider' versions of those tokens (tether-trons, vs tether-eths) to facilitate the theft of the life savings of generation of middle class chinese, wrapped in a nesting doll of scams and pyramid schemes, wrapped in the greed, hubris, and financial desperation, of a generation of 1st world hustlers, all wrapped in crypto-bros trying to take over the world.

If it was just crypto-bros, there would be anywhere near so much smoke, that is being confused/conflated with fire: the market manipulation being facilitated by the dirty (and clean, albeit grifted) money entering the system makes the whole thing seem, financially bigger than it really is.

For all the smoke making, however, it is still just a fart in a colander: the entire crypto market cap, as fanciful and hyperbolic as it is, is still less than the market cap of Apple.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by muxator on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:44PM (#33475017)
> It's an ITALIAN serial conman...

Wow. I have been guilty of this very same blunder many times and I understand it's just a joke, but please realize that it is not pleasant to be on the wrong side of a joke for no reason.

I'll be more careful with my generalizations in the future. I am confident you will be, too.

Thanks.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:16PM (#33475429)
It's not a joke. I'm referring to a specific italian serial conman.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:49PM (#33476389)
Satoshi is Italian? :)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by BlueTemplar on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:51AM (#33480195)
How do you know he isn't ? :p

(If he was a conman, this kind of misdirection would be really in style !)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:54PM (#33476915)
The biggest ones are American and Australian.

Craig Wright (Claims to have invented Bitcoin but cant prove it lol)

Richard Heart (Behind the Hex fraud crypto)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:53PM (#33477331)
Neither of them are arbitrarily minting the currency that is involved in 70%+ of all crypto trades.

(70% may be off. It was correct as of 6 months ago.)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by hervature on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:00PM (#33475216)
Following HN guidelines, I assumed they meant that Italy is aiding and abetting the effort. My low effort search yielded [1] immediately.

[1] - https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/10/05/italy-has-a-regis...

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#33475476)
I don't - I'm referring to Giancarlo Devasini.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jraines on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#33475494)
He’s referring to a specific literally Italian man, though yeah it’s not clear based on the rest being “personas”
[dead]
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jjulius on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#33475479)
Yikes.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nwah1 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:45PM (#33475041)
It is worse than that because the "market cap" in the context of crypto scams is meaningless.

Spot price times the number of tokens means nothing if the tokens have no intrinsic value.

Apple may be overvalued, but they have enormous assets and revenue backing their price. Their P/E ratio is a rational number.

Crypto could fall to zero at any time and all the hodlers are left holding nothing but the bag.

And of course a lot of the tokens are just locked away, keys are lost, etc.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:56PM (#33475173)
Can't you just say the same thing about the fiat currency that you say Apple's holding? It could also "go to zero". And certain "tokens".. specifically, let's say something like Bitcoin or Monero, actually do have what you would call "intrinsic" value since they require the expenditure of actual, physical energy to obtain, unless you know of a viable attack on those proof of work systems that you're not telling us about.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by spamizbad on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#33475497)
I don’t think you can. Apple owns real estate, intellectual property, and tons of tangible physical assets. The market is not going to decide Apple’s patents are worthless, California Real Estate is worthless, their factories and manufacturing equipment is worthless until there’s some world-ending cataclysm.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by actionablefiber on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:38PM (#33475656)
> The market is not going to decide Apple’s patents are worthless, California Real Estate is worthless, their factories and manufacturing equipment is worthless until there’s some world-ending cataclysm.

I'm not sure why you think there has to be a world-ending cataclysm for this to happen? If there were any major change in the way societies or economies were organized, Apple the entity could cease to exist entirely, or some/all of its assets could cease to belong to them. Like for patents, it certainly seems like the world is very far from deciding to abolish IP, but if society wills it, it is very simple to do.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by GauntletWizard on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:03PM (#33475947)
Apocalyptic events like that are rare. Sudden rapid divestment from Apple is unlikely.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by KptMarchewa on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:31PM (#33476221)
That's literally the definition of an catastrophic event
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by dreamcompiler on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:34PM (#33476253)
It could happen, in the same sense that a planet-killing asteroid could strike the Earth tomorrow.

By contrast the sudden demise of all crypto value could also happen, in the same sense that tomorrow might be cloudy.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by actionablefiber on Sunday November 06, 2022 @11:49AM (#33494512)
My real point here is poking fun at how, as has been observed in the past, "it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism." People are talking about world-ending cataclysms when the much more mundane "downfall of an economic order and rise of a different one" is a possibility too.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by LordDragonfang on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:57PM (#33476940)
I think it's reasonable to say that "any major change in the way societies or economies were organized" which resulted in all of Apple's assets going to zero, including the US Dollar, would qualify as the end of the World As We Know It, and would be effectively cataclysmic in magnitude as far as its effects on society.

...Whereas blockchain assets going to zero doesn't even register as a blip to the average citizen.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by dredmorbius on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:30PM (#33477187)
The requirements for a major sudden loss of value in Apple would likely involve a loss of value in a vast number of other presently high-intrinsic-value assets: real estate, the entire tech sector, the US and global economy, etc., etc.

Devaluation of cryptocurrency assets, on the other hand, could come about from someone sneezing. Or other events which would have similarly little impact on any asset valuations outside the crypto bubble itself.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nl on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:32AM (#33478274)
The market's view of the likelihood of Apple disappearing via the things you suggested is priced in by people choosing to hold things like gold, NZ property to escape to or I guess guns and bunkers.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:03PM (#33476508)
no we were talking about the 'cash' they hold. I dont get why you're bringing such tangential things into the discussion. what guarantees the value of USD is (a) its current adoption and (b) the fact the US stands behind it and will police and secure its usage. how is that different from a proof of work, asic resistant cryptocurrency?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:41PM (#33476322)
Apple does have worth beyond it's stocks because it owns stuff. The chairs in Apple's offices are worth more than some very profitable small businesses, let alone their current working inventory of devices or the parts to make more or the IP that they've generated to make them, or or or ad infinitum.

Cryptocurrencies are a null term. There's no there there.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:48PM (#33476379)
> chairs in Apple's offices

I’d have mentioned their real estate holdings (offices, etc). Office chairs don’t have a big resale value but real estate often does.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:04PM (#33476992)
That's kind of my point. ;)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by giantrobot on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:22PM (#33477145)
They have tens of thousands of chairs in Apple Park alone. Even if every chair went for $50, Apple could net hundreds of thousands of dollars. There's plenty of small businesses that would kill to net hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jazzyjackson on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:39AM (#33478030)
> Office chairs don’t have a big resale value

Check out ebay auctions for Herman Miller Aeron, they're still worth something !

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:05PM (#33476531)
we weren't talking about the value of apple's stock or its property aside from the cash it holds on hand. did you just not read what i wrote? the considerable number of downvoters must have made the same mistake as you i guess. the question is whether fiat cash is any more real than cryptocurrencies.

and as for them being a null term, you have no clue what you're talking about or you're intentionally trolling. please don't reply to me.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:10PM (#33477039)
You are right, I misread. I apologize. Unfortunately, you don't get to decide who replies to you or not, and the "but fiat currency!" is even easier to disabuse: it has societally inherent worth because it can be used to pay taxes even if it is not accepted in any other venue (which of course it is), whereas cryptocurrency's primary use is to grift or be grifted.

That is inherent worth, unless you intend to go full big-brain about the Fall of Society, and at that point nobody is going to care about your digital ledger unless it comes with lead-backed securities.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by umanwizard on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:01PM (#33476494)
> actually do have what you would call "intrinsic" value

I just spent all day digging a hole in my backyard for no reason. Does it have intrinsic value?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by JadeNB on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:28PM (#33486016)
> Apple may be overvalued, but they have enormous assets and revenue backing their price. Their P/E ratio is a rational number.

I appreciated this inadvertently exactly technically correct definition of a rational number. But I assume you mean a rationally derived number ….

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nwah1 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:11PM (#33497216)
It was an intentional double entendre
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by JadeNB on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:44PM (#33498305)
Sorry, I should have said "presumably inadvertently exactly technically correct" … and then I would have presumed wrong, but at least not made a baldly incorrect statement about technical correctness.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ethbr0 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:47PM (#33475064)
你不明白
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:37PM (#33475648)
It's difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary, or his hacker news handle, depends on not understanding it.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ETH_start on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:53PM (#33475135)
>>It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air,

There is zero evidence for the Tether conspiracy theories.. But I gotta give you marks for creative writing.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:32PM (#33475603)
There's mountains of evidence. They haven't been theories for a long time.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jcranmer on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:32PM (#33476741)
> There is zero evidence for the Tether conspiracy theories.

Tether has literally admitted to lying, which means at least one of the conspiracy theories is true by the admission of the major player. There is plenty of evidence that they are still lying, but the biggest evidence is that (unlike the rest of the financial system!) they claim to have $10s of billions of financial assets and refuse to identify which assets those are.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ETH_start on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:21PM (#33477524)
The conspiracy theory is an extreme exaggeration on what has been admitted, which I believe is - at one point - reserves of 77 percent of liabilities, and even that admission I'm not certain about given how much any news about Tether is misconstrued by the regulatory crowd.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:55PM (#33476918)
Yet Tether cannot prove its holdings in a transparent and easy manner.

USDC can. BUSD can. oh but not USDT hrm.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by MichaelCollins on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:35PM (#33476761)
So they're conmen using smoke and mirrors, deception and... this sounds like a lot of fancy words that mean the same thing as "crypto bros". Crypto bros are all of the things you say, so what's the distinction?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by manquer on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:41PM (#33476817)
He means to say there are not just fanatic believers who are winning minions in pyramid schemes, but there is also professional large scale systematic extraction of wealth
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by trophycase on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:33PM (#33477215)
It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air, wrapped in a network of criminal enterprises that is currently using special 'insider only' versions of those tokens (tether-trons, vs tether-eths) to facilitate the theft of the life savings of a generation of middle class chinese, wrapped in a nesting doll of scams and pyramid schemes, wrapped in the greed, hubris, and legitimate desperation of a generation of 1st world hustlers, all wrapped in crypto-bros trying to take over the world.

Replace italian with <insert racial boogeyman here> and you would literally be describing the current financial system.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:50PM (#33477318)
I'm referring specifically to Giancarlo Devasini.

I used broad strokes, but I wasn't making a fanciful description of what drives the crypto market as much as a literal one.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by spiralx on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:59PM (#33486847)
This is perhaps the most wonderful description of crypto ever, thank you :)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by SrslyJosh on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:16PM (#33473887)
> Certainly Web3 isn't just crypto-bros trying to take over the web?

That's exactly what it is. They don't want anything new or innovative, they just want to be able to levy a tax on what everyone does online.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by sdiacom on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:57PM (#33474430)
It's a bit sillier than that, since for the time being, crypto-bros are making money not by levying a tax on what people do online, but by speculating on the potential future income from levying a tax on what people do online.

Convincing others that there's imaginary future money on taxing online interactions is where the real present money is actually made. In a way, this turns their biggest weakness (they can't actually achieve their goal) into their biggest strength (their audience is people who aren't tech-literate enough to understand that they can't actually achieve their goal)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:52PM (#33476414)
Where can I read about this? What tax is being proposed? Staking?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by gernb on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:46PM (#33476856)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jazzyjackson on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:05AM (#33478153)
You don't get rich digging for gold, you get rich selling shovels.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by threeseed on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:25PM (#33475541)
Also about VCs having a lot of excess money that they siphoned from LPs during the zero interest rate period.

And since Web2 has largely picked its main winners and losers an opportunity existed to reset the game and pick another set. Only this time they would be the ones to invest in the next Apple, Google etc.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#33474181)
There is no single company driving the PR and marketing for Web3, so the term is whatever somebody wants it to be. But the vague way to describe it is an approach to building web apps with decentralized public blockchains and smart contracts, like DeFi or ENS.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by andsoitis on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:18PM (#33475452)
Enabling what? Use cases > technology shiny objects.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by threeseed on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:33PM (#33475617)
Money laundering, gambling and stock trading for kids of all ages.

Also the whole rug-pulling game has been an impressive transfer of wealth from VCs -> influencers.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by joeax on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:54PM (#33476914)
Sounds more like the early days of web 1.0
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by threeseed on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:57AM (#33478702)
I was on the internet in the early days of Web 1.0

None of those things were happening.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:12PM (#33476042)
It's a distributed ledger, that you can deploy a computer program to. Use cases extend outward from there.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by andsoitis on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:43PM (#33476335)
Can you articulate one end user benefit / use case that’s not possible today or that would be better than today?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:50PM (#33476890)
“Better” is relative, depends on your frame of reference. Anything crypto will be better in some ways, and worse in others.

Like self custody: the idea of owning a valuable and transferable asset by only holding a private key was not possible prior to Bitcoin. The closest comparison might be a domain name: people feel like they own those, but they are just renting them from a registrar who leases you the account and ability to edit your domain records.

This applies all over Ethereum, DeFi, ENS, NFTs. Look at Aave, that allows lending and borrowing without a custodial service provider.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:28PM (#33476181)
For one small example: enabling this https://docs.ipfs.tech/ website, to be delivered to your browser care of a (replaceable commodity) gateway node that fetches assets by URL-embedded content-hash from an open-membership DHT.

(If you're wondering how this website appears on its own domain rather than you needing to directly visit the domain of the gateway node, that's because of https://docs.ipfs.tech/concepts/dnslink/).

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by andsoitis on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:42PM (#33476329)
Can you reframe that in terms of end user benefit?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:16PM (#33476616)
Site will never go down; data backing the site will never be lost; content-addressability of data means data is guaranteed to be the same data that was intended to be published, with no ability for e.g. a state-actor to tell Amazon to modify what's in the S3 bucket.

In other words: if someone could figure out how to host ThePirateBay on IPFS, then governments wouldn't be able to take them down any more. They'd only be able to take down arbitrary IPFS gateway nodes; and if they did that enough to be a problem, anyone who cared could work around that by just running their own IPFS node. (Or using a browser like Brave which runs its own IPFS node internally.) Content will be fetched from by DNSLink-aware browsers in preference to hitting the gateway specified in the DNSLink record, so as soon as you used such a browser, all the taken-down domains would just magically work again for you.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by n3t on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:33PM (#33476750)
> data backing the site will never be lost

Data can be lost.

I put a few files on IPFS some time ago. That files are no longer accessible because I stopped hosting them.

> Site will never go down

As long as there is a node hosting the data you're looking for. So it can go down.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:53AM (#33482624)
IPFS itself doesn't guarantee these things, but it serves as the technological basis for higher-stack-layer technologies — centralized "pinning" services like https://web3.storage/, and decentralized ones like FileCoin — that do make these guarantees.

IPFS's own docs do have these additional higher-level guarantees — so they specifically will never go down.

One way to think of this is that, in a centralized model, the owner of an asset has to choose a single centralized CDN partner to collaborate with to distribute that asset, where the website you visit is really a pointer to the single (fallible) CDN partner.

Whereas, in a decentralized model, the owner of an asset can pick zero or more CDN partners who will all then "back" the asset on the DHT with their own mirrored copies of it. And I say zero or more, because the asset-owner can also still back the DHT asset with their own mirror on some personal node, without this causing much of a problem for them. (Where doing this wouldn't help in the centralized-CDN case, for two reasons: if the central CDN goes down, clients don't automatically switch to fetching from the origin that populated the CDN; and even if they did, a personal origin server would likely fall over under the traffic load. Whereas in IPFS, those nodes fetching copies — gateways et al — become (temporary) mirrors of the data themselves; so an origin server only ever has to serve O(log N) copies of an asset, not O(N).)

Also, in a decentralized model, besides the owner, anyone else who is interested in the asset's continued availability, can also choose to increase the data's availability in the network by mirroring it themselves (or by paying some pinning service to mirror it.)

Compare/contrast: organizations like universities who seed torrents of important data like Linux distro ISOs. IPFS is the BitTorrent model of data survivability/availability, but applied to websites / web assets.

----

Which is all the way one would present this until a few years ago, since IPFS used to be the forerunner in this space... but now there are decentralized protocols that are similar to IPFS but are "permanent" at the network level, e.g. https://www.arweave.org/. With these networks, as long as you pay the (one-time) costs related to writing data to the network, your assets will then be available on the network as long as the network itself exists.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by andsoitis on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:41PM (#33477257)
> if someone could figure out how to host ThePirateBay on IPFS

Any particular reason this hasn’t been figured out or why TPB hasn’t done it yet?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by miohtama on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:12PM (#33473833)
Web3 was the term created 2014 to originally describe three properties (protocols) that decentralised networks can bring to web without need to rely on centralised service providers. Web + 3 = web3:

- eth: making transactions with smart contracts

- bzz: decentralised storage - save files

- whisper: peer-to-peer messaging, chat, etc.

More about the history of web3 in my Twitter thread here:

https://mobile.twitter.com/moo9000/status/148446388922402406...

However the usage of the term and it meaning has corrupted over the years, especially when marketing people took it over.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:18PM (#33473916)
Applications centered on user ownership created from decentralization of the data models and hosts themselves.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jfghi on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:25PM (#33474783)
?, Most of the websites visited have powerful servers serving them with data that is held privately.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:17PM (#33477101)
It doesn't take that powerful of a server to serve static websites. And some data is held in open data stores, such as Filecoin or Arweave. Some data is held on-chain, as ENS does, for example.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jay_kyburz on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:30PM (#33474845)
I get it. It sounds good.

But I come from the generation that knows information wants to be free.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:18PM (#33477109)
Nothing is free. Whatever we got for free from Web2 came with a surveillance, censorship and ad-based regime attached to it.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jazzyjackson on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:16AM (#33478200)
Torrenting continues to be free, because when we were growing up we learned to share.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by threeseed on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:29PM (#33475576)
Except that (a) there is no requirement to put all data on the blockchain and (b) it is prohibitively expensive to do so.

So you end up with a situation like OpenSea. Half of the information about the NFT is on the chain but then the other half is in its own private database e.g. ratings, reviews etc.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:15PM (#33477086)
Of course there's no requirement to put all the data on the blockchain. Why would there be? I even consider torrent networks to be "web3" and they're not blockchains.

It is not prohibitively expensive to store data on a blockchain, however. Arweave and Filecoin are the largest storage-centric blockchains. They each have multiple exabytes of data stored on them. Currently, you can store on Filecoin for free: https://nft.storage/ as a promotional thing, but even for larger data stores (https://web3.storage/) it's $10 / month for 120GiB and 8 cents per GiB after that.

OpenSea itself is a marketplace with some centralized elements. That's fine. The core listing, selling and transfer logic is written as a series of smart contracts, however.

They also compete with other marketplaces, some which are fully decentralized. They do not control or own the important data, which is the NFT itself.

Some NFTs store all the metadata on chain, you can implement an NFT contract metadata as base64 encoded JSON (as you can see in a recent project https://etherscan.io/address/0x6f4388602c5dd6c593bf7c9cf3128..., plug in tokenId 2 into tokenURI to see). Some store them on IPFS with a hash based reference to the content. Some use centralized storage in a private database. All are valid use cases with varying applications. If you only want to own fully native-chain NFTs, feel free to filter based on that criteria.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by trophycase on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:40PM (#33477248)
Ok? There are fully on chain NFTs. These things take time though, adding the infrastructure to publish on arweave takes time. There are people in the process of porting entire javascript libraries on chain so that people can run rendering code that doesn't depend on external resources. Rome wasn't built in a day. Maybe have a little imagination?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by koromak on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:10PM (#33473816)
Deploying a whole ass web application on small, immutable smart contracts seems inane to me. Reminds me of something programmers do not because its powerful, but because its hard and it makes them feel cool.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:22PM (#33473956)
It is powerful. The contracts run 24/7 with 100% uptime. Hayden Adams created Uniswap with about 1000 lines of code using an elegant xy=k formula to create the first good automated market maker, Uniswap. It essentially replaces much of the functionality of an order book on a stock exchange, except it's decentralized, global and permissionless. Plenty of other good examples in web3.

https://app.uniswap.org/

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:09PM (#33474570)
> Put bluntly, the Ethereum “world computer” has roughly 1/5,000 of the compute power of a Raspberry Pi 4!

https://www.usenix.org/publications/loginonline/web3-fraud

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:40PM (#33474974)
Who said Ethereum aims to be as fast as a regular computer, or even a raspberry pi?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ethbr0 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:55PM (#33475165)
^ Basically sums up what Ethereum is and isn't

If a Pi solves your use case, for God's sake don't use the EVM.

If a Pi doesn't solve your use case, because {particular reason}, then consider the EVM as an option.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by Tenoke on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:17PM (#33476092)
You can't really run Uniswap and expect it to be useful on a Pi for obvious reasons so a Pi doesn't solve the same issues.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by leonsegal on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:43PM (#33475009)
are there any non-crypto examples?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by q-big on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:17PM (#33476634)
> are there any non-crypto examples?

Cryptography is the basis of Web 3.0, so in a formal sense there is none.

But I think that you rather want an example that is a little farther away from finance markets. Consider, for example, the (in my observation mostly dead) Namecoin:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Namecoin

which attempts/attempted to implement domain names via a blockchain and is sometimes considered a precursor to NFTs.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by SrslyJosh on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:21PM (#33473938)
They won't, because they can't. Executing a smart contract costs thousands of times more than executing a normal piece of software. Everything you see would still be served by an ordinary web server, and interactions with the blorpchain are all mediated by one or two centralized API services.

It's a potemkin village.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33474115)
> Executing a smart contract costs thousands of times more than executing a normal piece of software.

No, not necessarily. For one let's qualify that statement. Smart contracts on Ethereum are executed 100,000+ times by every node on the network, which is providing security and uptime for the network.

Some software transactions have external costs associated with them, such as financial transactions. Doing an international bank transfer may simply boil down to a credit in one SQL database and a debit in another SQL database but it still can cost dozens to thousands of dollars depending on the amount, and the situation. Even a VISA credit card transaction costs 1.5-3%. You as a consumer don't see that cost, the retailer is eating it though, and marking up their products and services to accommodate that fee.

But ETH transaction fees do not scale with the value of the transaction, it simply scales with the demand for the limited block space.

Ethereum community has been actively developing solutions for this problem, by developing optimistic rollups and zero knowledge rollups, which are effectively able to compress transactions and scale the network throughout by 100-1000x. Innovations like this will get Ethereum to Visa scale plus.

This technology is still early, but rapidly improving. Currently deployed rollups are in the 10-100x scale improvement range.

Some rollups currently in production:

https://arbitrum.io/ https://www.optimism.io/ https://starkware.co/

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ipython on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:10PM (#33476028)
What international bank transfer costs “thousands” of dollars to complete? What ethereum transaction only costs 3% to complete? Are you saying that a retailer accepting crypto will suddenly no longer need to “eat” the transaction costs because… crypto?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by Tenoke on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:21PM (#33476119)
Any sufficiently large transaction costs less than 3% on Ethereum. MetaMask claims a transfer would cost me 63 cents, so a pure Eth transfer of more than $22 for example. Though of course you can do it a lot cheaper on L2s.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:00PM (#33476957)
Every transfer service has transfer limits. Have you ever tried to send $1M or $10M internationally? What service provider would you go through to execute the transaction? What are their fees? Not only will your transaction be delayed as much as weeks, you'll have additional forms to fill out and fees and expenses associated with such a transfer. Even more so if you are converting to another currency.

On Ethereum, you can execute a swap from one currency to another (0.3% fee) and have the transfer execute to anyone in the world in 15 seconds. Even in a highly congested time on the network, that will cost at most a few dozen dollars. Doesn't matter if you're sending $1K or $1B.

Crypto isn't ready for retail use cases yet, but it's within the next few years (less than 3) that it gets there. Retail transactions will occur on rollups. The retailers will pay transaction fees of a few pennies to a few dozen cents. It will not be percentage based on the transaction value as VISA, AMEX, etc currently get away with.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by miracle2k on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:58PM (#33474448)
And yet, Tornado Cash is still running.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m00dy on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:41PM (#33474986)
I'm just wondering what would happen if there is a court order to take down a smart contract.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:58PM (#33476946)
It would be like a court order to ban encryption. Its just math. You cant do it and it would be meaningless.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:33PM (#33476242)
You don't, actually, though. You only put what little stuff that people might fight each-other over control of, into smart-contract state. Everything else is fine to be stuffed into a database or centralized web backend somewhere; or just left to everyone individually to derive + implement themselves however they like.

For example, CryptoKitties: only thing in the on-chain state are the kitties' ownerships and their "genes" (i.e. the two things people would pay money for, try to hack the system to change, etc.) What those genes translate to in terms of actual kitty features, is dictated by some arbitrary centralized Javascript on the CryptoKitties website. None of that logic or state needs to be on-chain — so it's not.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by felipellrocha on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:45PM (#33474268)
Web3 are browser-based wallets (or mobile based) that can authorize transactions in a blockchain securely because it's separate from the web page itself. When I use metamask to buy something on the chain, it'll ask me to confirm if that's ok or not. That's all that the developer of the page can do, they can ask metamask to confirm the transaction is safe. Once it's confirmed, a one-time unique token for the transaction is created, and used to execute the transaction. This can work because the browser provides the secure separation between app and wallet. Otherwise, no one would trust a 3rd party to run transactions for them on the blockchain.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by SkyMarshal on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:34PM (#33474908)
> This can work because the browser provides the secure separation between app and wallet.

I thought the app and wallet were the same thing. What's the difference here?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:24PM (#33476154)
The "app" (Distributed App / DApp) is some arbitrary thing written by a developer, running in a sandbox in a tab in your browser.

The "wallet" (Metamask) is a browser extension containing a set of pairs of (RPC gateway URI for a given blockchain, cryptographic private key for an account on said blockchain.) It can also proxy through to other such "wallets", e.g. "hardware wallets" (smart cards.)

"web3" is an API (like any DOM API) that the browser extension exposes to app, allowing the app to ask the wallet to do things (where the wallet then asks the user to confirm that they want to do those things); and, through the wallet's connection to blockchains, to watch for things to happen on a blockchain.

Together, these additional APIs allow web3 "DApps" to transact on blockchains, and to observe what happens in response to their transactions.

Example DApps:

- Gnosis Safe (https://gnosis-safe.io/) — an interface for deploying and managing multi-signature smart contracts (i.e. trusts whose assets are controlled by M-of-N voting)

- Sushiswap (https://www.sushi.com/swap) — an interface for creating and managing Automated Market Maker liquidity pools

- OpenSea (https://opensea.io/) — a marketplace for buying and selling NFTs

On all of these websites, you'll notice that instead of registering an account, there is a button that CTAs you to "Connect a Wallet." This is requesting permission to communicate with the web3 agent installed as an extension in your browser.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by dwaite on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:12PM (#33474621)
Is Apple Pay considered Web3?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by Mordisquitos on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#33475486)
To me that sounds like reinventing the wheel, as it's basically the same process by which online shopping services have integrated for years with payment service providers (PSPs), which contact customers' banks to do strong customer authentication (SCA), such as 3-D Secure v2, without the need for a blockchain.

In fact, I can minimally edit your description to make it an accurate description of checking out using Braintree, for example.

«The drop-in UIs is an external wallet that can authorize card transactions securely because it is separate from the merchant's web page itself. When I use my credit card to buy something from a retailer, the PSP will ask my bank to do a SCA to confirm that it is me doing it. That's all that the merchant can do, they can ask the PSP to confirm the transaction is authenticated. Once it's confirmed, a one-time unique token for the transaction is created, and used to execute the transaction. This can work because the browser provides the secure separation between website and wallet. Otherwise, no one would trust an online shop with their credit card details to run transactions.»

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by kobieyc on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:54PM (#33474401)
This gives you a good overview of what web3 is https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jrochkind1 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:35PM (#33474923)
> What surprised me about the standards was that there’s no hash commitment for the data located at the URL.

Me too. I'm an outsider, but can anyone understand why they didn't do this? If you were designing NFT's, wouldn't this be an obvious thing to do?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:57PM (#33475862)
ERC721 is an EVM spec, how do you even propose achieving this kind of restriction in Solidity?

tokenURI aims to be flexible and unopinionated. It can be an inline SVG string generated by the Solidity contract itself, an IPFS link to a JPG, some app's custom protocol URI scheme, or a mutable HTTPS CDN like a game developer using NFTs but wanting to retain control over their assets.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:10PM (#33476018)
Yes, and all-but-two of those ideas are awful, because the server or IPFS-pinning node backing the asset file is gone off the face of the Internet six months later, so now you've got an NFT that looks like nothing.

(My company, among other things, spiders + scrapes + archives NFT assets. I know what I'm talking about here.)

ETC721 should have been limited to exactly two use-cases:

1. embedded data: URNs

2. URNs for data on distributed content networks that make permanency a guarantee for posting (e.g. Arweave); where an oracle-check that the data is in the network at the time of creation from at least one client's perspective is required as collateral to successfully mint the asset.

As it is, I'd settle for even IPFS-without-guarantee-of-pinning, as long as you can guarantee that at least one node accessible to the public web has the data at the time of mint. That'd at least mean that someone who does care could come along, scrape the asset, and then pin it themselves to ensure the URN never goes bad from then on.

Even this, though, is far more thought than people put into earlier standards, e.g. the Solidity compiler's deployment metadata, which is always nominally an IPFS URN, but is never actually populated by the generated metadata. If they had just stood up a backend at ReMix.org that pinned these metadata files, and had solc push compiled metadata to said backend, then we wouldn't be where we are now with the (centralized) Etherscan "verified contract source code" being the only way to see/decode the storage layouts for (even some) contracts.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:25PM (#33476163)
ERC721 is not designed to solve permanent media storage or force usage toward a certain storage network. Better the ERC721 spec does not try to solve for this.

totally disagree with your assessment and would hate to be forced to rely on oracles to deploy a mintable ERC721. I like the broadness and simplicity of ERC721 and would attribute that to its success.

The chain is open and public, just publish your own ERC with oracles and see if it takes off?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:56PM (#33476443)
To be clear, I agree that the broadness and simplicity of ERC721 is what led to its success.

My point is that "success" (in the sense of "a lot of people making NFTs" or "a lot of people investing in NFTs") is a bad measure for things that "Web3 society" should care about, because the whole thing happening with NFTs right now is a speculative market run by people who want to make money first, second, and N≤1000th; and to package art they would have made anyway for long-term secondary-market appreciation, roughly dead-last.

(And even if they did want that, they don't know how; the whole ecosystem is geared toward splitting technological competence out of the equation into fly-by-night professional-services firms and their productized "NFT as a Service" offerings, leaving the decision-making for choosing those firms in the hands of independent artists/musicians/etc — i.e. people who have no idea what considerations are at play for things like fault-tolerant distribution of digital media. Or in the hands of businesspeople who recruit and exploit such independent artists en-masse, with eyes only on short-term profitability of their NFT collection offerings, and no thought toward long-term asset valuation even ten years down the line.)

Insofar as the people building Web3 — and Ethereum specifically — can be said to share a set of ideals about decentralization, immutability, permanency, etc., the kind of people who have come in to create NFTs are operating explicitly against these ideals (see also: the fact that NFT asset URIs — and NFT metadata generally — is updatable; the artist/their publisher can come along and decide they want to replace your monkey with a "better-drawn" one after you've bought it!)

IMHO a non-fungible asset standard that was actually written and used to the same ideological purpose that Ethereum itself was created and operated, would look far different.

It's just that "the ideological purpose for which Ethereum itself was created"... isn't a very common thing for artists or business-people to care about; and so that kind of NFT wouldn't have any speculative market behind it. So nobody would even know it exists. Except maybe digital conservationists, and the rare kind of private collectors who want to engage explicitly with digital conservationists. The sorts of people who would consider purchasing something from the Smithsonian's private archives.

---

Also, re: oracles, I can see why "get an oracle to do X" is onerous; my own personal stance has always been that there should be functionality built into Ethereum-alike nodes enabling every node to be its own web2 + web3 oracle; in two primary senses:

- "declare your intent to request an arbitrary web2 URL; actually request it; and embed the request+result together into a tx, where your key then asserts provenance on the fetch" being a core RPC method you can expect to exist on any node for any Eth-like blockchain

- "fetch an asset by URN from a permanent storage network into memory" being an EVM opcode — the permanency means it's deterministic, so why not, eh? Though, such an opcode would actually be terminal — would interrupt current TX execution and instead queue a thunk into a state-trie scheduling queue, to be evaluated when the runtime finishes the blocking IO for the tx. (Like how Microsoft Orleans does blocking-yields on distributed actors. See also, the way Elrond's cross-shard transactions work: https://docs.elrond.com/technology/cross-shard-transactions/.)

Of course, none of this exists today, let alone did it exist in November of 2017 when the first ERC721 token was minted. :)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jrochkind1 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:03AM (#33481012)
So, like I said, I'm an outsider, I don't know what ERC721 or EVM or Solidity are.

I'm just someone from the outside saying, from the actual current popular use cases of NFT, it seems really a mis-match between design and use-case not to have a digest fingerprint, right? What confuses me if that, from your comment it seems like the "community" does not agree... or perhaps thinks this is somehow an insoluble problem?

If it's totally arbitrary what the payload is, like it doesn't even have to be a URL, but URLs seem quite popular... okay, how about putting in eg `https://example.com/some/url#sha512=a1bd4ef`

Marketplaces could put a special tag on items that supplied digests, the marketplace could even check it and confirm it. No change to standard needed. (Since I know nothing about what I'm talking about, it's possible I have some details wrong, but surely something along these lines is possible? This does not seem like a sophisticated technological problem, to embed a digest in a recognizable way)

If it's not being done, it would seem like there isn't sufficient interest in it? That is what confuses me.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:23PM (#33485960)
OpenSea already does tag NFTs as having "Centralized" or "Frozen" metadata, verifying the URI as you say. ERC721 spec only deals with EVM and Solidity, where it would not make sense to try and force the token contract URI state to match a specific hosting protocol.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by janalsncm on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:33PM (#33474893)
Seems like “web3” has completely missed the mark and is actually highly centralized, arguably more so than web2. If I had to guess, it’s because expediency requires it. If you’re in the middle of a gold rush, first principles like decentralization are quickly supplanted by principles like “line goes up”.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by sshine on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:29PM (#33475582)
> Seems like “web3” has completely missed the mark and is actually highly centralized, arguably more so than web2.

In the sense that the “web3” brand is mostly used to make proof-of-concept and crypto startups in the Ethereum ecosystem, which is just one ecosystem, and a highly centralised one at that, 100%.

Creating a decentralised web is extremely difficult. Most Ethereum web3 projects are more like concept art within a research project.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:54PM (#33476427)
> Creating a decentralised web is extremely difficult

We’ve had it for years: tor’s .onion sites. And look how popular they are… when was the last time you visited one?

Technically, You could say Web2 sites are decentralized, by the way: most include JS, CSS, and images from different domains and servers.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by q-big on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:10PM (#33476573)
> We’ve had it for years: tor’s .onion sites. And look how popular they are… when was the last time you visited one?

Don't ask this kind of rhetorical question on HN - HN is exactly where you can find a lot of audience that can honestly answer this question with "today" or "yesterday". :-D

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by shakna on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:52PM (#33477744)
> We’ve had it for years: tor’s .onion sites. And look how popular they are… when was the last time you visited one?

Pornhub's onion site is probably somewhere more regular than I'd like to admit.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by BlueTemplar on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:55AM (#33480226)
I thought that it was frowned upon to use tor for high bandwidth uses like video ?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by moffkalast on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:12PM (#33474619)
Guy decides to build a couple of dApps... and immediately makes a pyramid scheme.

I just can't, hahahah

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by paxys on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:15PM (#33474651)
> Whenever I try to learn about it the discussion digresses into blockchain pyramid schemes that clearly won't scale and other such nonsense

Congratulations, you understand exactly what web3 is.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by whymauri on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:42PM (#33475702)
I feel like crypto meant something different in the early days. I think the 2017/2018 bull run with the BitConnect collapse is where we start seeing major faults in the crypto ecosystem.

The NFT/DAO and VC boom is the ideological nail in the coffin for me. I guess that's what people cal Web3... so perhaps you are right.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by BlueTemplar on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:06AM (#33480286)
Nah, scamming was there basically from the start, it's just that every iteration of it has been more egregious than before (NFTs today, ICOs in the previous iteration...)

The good news is that it's hard to imagine how it could get any worse, the bad news is that perhaps I am just lacking imagination ?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by twic on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:19PM (#33474706)
I am also skeptical of it. I think the idea is that if you have pervasive microtransactions, and smart contracts which can participate in them, then you can easily create web applications where revenues are shared with users, in a transparent and predictable way.

Consider Facebook. Facebook is an advertising platform: advertisers pay money in exchange for users looking at ads; users look at ads. But the users don't receive the money! Facebook keeps the money. A Web 3.0 version could pass some fraction of the advertisers' money on to each user; the amount passed on could be based on various aspects of the user's activity, to incentivise them to do things which increase the value of the ads (looking at ads, attracting other users to the site, etc), and to not do things which decrease the value of the ads (driving other users away from the site, posting naughty content, etc).

The fundamental theorem of Web 3.0, as i understand it, is that this is both better for users (they get paid), and also better for site operators (users will be attracted by the prospect of getting paid).

There are problems with this, even on its own terms. Firstly, every site now has to be structured around some sort of transaction, where somebody is prepared to pay. You can't just have people hanging out aimlessly. Now, maybe that just means that Web 3.0 isn't universal, and there are sites where it doesn't make sense. But the best places on the net have always been places where people hang out aimlessly, so this seems like a substantial lacuna. Secondly, detailed, mechanically applied incentives often end up driving behaviour that isn't what the setter really wanted; you end up with everyone breeding cobras etc. Web 3.0 sites might end up not being better for users or operators. Thirdly, a Web 3.0 site will be less profitable for its operator than an equivalent Web 2.0 site, so it will (often) be less attractive as a thing for an entrepreneur to build. I suppose the theory predicts that Web 3.0 sites will outcompete Web 2.0 sites, so entrepreneurs won't have a choice.

Then there are problems where the theory interacts with reality. We already have transactions, without using cryptocurrencies, and as long as users are happy to batch up payments and withdrawals, transactions on sites themselves can be arbitrarily micro. We don't have smart contracts without blockchains, so users would have to trust operators to apply incentives fairly; but people already trust all sorts of companies to do that (credit card rewards, supermarket loyalty points, MMORPG XP, etc), so this isn't a real obstacle. If we wanted to build sites like this, we already could!

And then there are the general cryptocurrency / blockchain problems. For every one genuine and sensible attempt to build a site like this, there will be a hundred which are genuine but ill-conceived, and ten thousand which are scams. This is pretty much a market for lemons.

So i'm not sure there is any reason for anybody outside of the crypto scam sphere to care about it. It won't take off, and if it did, it would be crap.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by musicale on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:24PM (#33474765)
> I don't even understand what Web3 is.

> blockchain pyramid schemes

Sounds about right.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by killthebuddha on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:47PM (#33475768)
One piece that is for some reason insanely undervalued right now is: a global key sharing system with a baked-in reputation mechanism (you can burn cash to prove to the world you care about your public key). Combined with a human-readable naming system (like https://ens.domains/ or https://www.lens.xyz/), you've got the world's simplest and most useful auth system. SIWE (https://login.xyz/) is going to be the de-facto auth standard for all new web applications at some point in the near-ish future.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by naet on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:21PM (#33476123)
I've used multiple crypto based sign in mechanisms and own a (tezos) domain, and I absolutely do not think it is the future or going to go very mainstream. Maybe I'm wrong, but crypto-as-auth seems highly problematic in my experience.

Perhaps the biggest issue is that if you lose your key you have no recourse to recover your identity. Another big issue is paying fees or waiting for transactions when I shouldn't have to, like updating some profile information or logging in to a service. I don't want to use any form of financial identifier or financial account to sign in to any non financial related web service for obvious reasons. There isn't really a decentralization imo if you're using metamask or kukai or other wallet service, it doesn't seem very secure, and it's a pain or flat out unsupported to use anything else.

And for all these & other related drawbacks, I just don't see any upside over tradition auth systems.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by wombat-man on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:07PM (#33475987)
Feels like the "meat" centers around smart contracts and stuff, but from what I can tell it mostly breaks down to exchanging value via blockchain transactions. Maybe it's building to something awesome that I can't understand yet, but right now it's hard for me to buy the vague promises from various web3 promoters. I've been hearing "it's still early days" for quite a while now.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by mattwilsonn888 on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:19PM (#33476102)
Web3, in good faith, and sophisticated vision, is taking the ability to authorize digital privilege without oversight and working backwards to scale that ability down to the minutia of online interaction.

Bitcoin achieves it for the narrow privilege of publishing small amounts of block data to it's chain. It's important for the security of Bitcoin that this is what the novice would say is "inefficient" - but the minutia online activity is far lower stakes and therefore naive proclamations that Web3 is all Web2 data hosted on blockchain is an embarrassing suggestion - there are extremely basic techniques like hashing data in Merkle Trees as a timestamp service that any cryptographer would reach for before adding arbitrary data to a blockchain.

Techniques like that and systems which allow one to own their identity independent of corporations or Public Key Authorities are the basis. Obviously it has a long way to go - but try not to mistake your obtuse guess for what is possible.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by kuramitropolis on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:35PM (#33476262)
It's a psyop to divert mindshare from actually working P2P networks.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by umanwizard on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:59PM (#33476481)
> Whenever I try to learn about it the discussion digresses into blockchain pyramid schemes that clearly won't scale and other such nonsense.

You understand it perfectly.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jonahbenton on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:49PM (#33476885)
I'll give you a serious answer.

Certainly web3 is used by lots of different people to mean lots of different things. And many of those people are there to scam.

Part of web3 are DAOs, corporate entities with both a legal presence as well as a presence on a public blockchain system of record. The DAO is an organization where people perform work in the context of workflows and incentives. The workflows and incentives are called a protocol.

The protocol is implemented in code, and the record of activities are on the blockchain. Governance of the protocol occurs in the non-blockchain legal organization.

There are many entities- many non-profits and public service entities, passive management entities like real estate management, many others- that in the future could be much more fairly, sustainably, and transparently operated as DAOs.

Much- very much- has to be done still, of course. But I am confident that in 10-20 years participation in DAOs will be common and a net benefit to society.

Cheers.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by phire on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:07PM (#33477014)
Arguably Web3 is two things:

1. An ill-defined buzzword with some vague concepts to try and "fix" aspect of the current web. Nobody can really agree what it is or isn't.

2. The crypto-bros various attempt(s) to implement their special vision of this buzzword, mostly in an attempt create a reason for cryptocurrency to have some kind of intrinsic value.

> Why would anybody outside of the crypto scam sphere care about it if that were the case?

People generally don't, but that doesn't so crptobros continually trying to "gaslight" people into thinking it's going to be a thing. The technique worked quite well when used for bitcoin, why not try it again?