News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by koromak on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:10PM (#33473816)
Deploying a whole ass web application on small, immutable smart contracts seems inane to me. Reminds me of something programmers do not because its powerful, but because its hard and it makes them feel cool.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:22PM (#33473956)
It is powerful. The contracts run 24/7 with 100% uptime. Hayden Adams created Uniswap with about 1000 lines of code using an elegant xy=k formula to create the first good automated market maker, Uniswap. It essentially replaces much of the functionality of an order book on a stock exchange, except it's decentralized, global and permissionless. Plenty of other good examples in web3.

https://app.uniswap.org/

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:09PM (#33474570)
> Put bluntly, the Ethereum “world computer” has roughly 1/5,000 of the compute power of a Raspberry Pi 4!

https://www.usenix.org/publications/loginonline/web3-fraud

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by zeroclip on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:40PM (#33474974)
Who said Ethereum aims to be as fast as a regular computer, or even a raspberry pi?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ethbr0 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:55PM (#33475165)
^ Basically sums up what Ethereum is and isn't

If a Pi solves your use case, for God's sake don't use the EVM.

If a Pi doesn't solve your use case, because {particular reason}, then consider the EVM as an option.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by Tenoke on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:17PM (#33476092)
You can't really run Uniswap and expect it to be useful on a Pi for obvious reasons so a Pi doesn't solve the same issues.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by leonsegal on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:43PM (#33475009)
are there any non-crypto examples?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by q-big on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:17PM (#33476634)
> are there any non-crypto examples?

Cryptography is the basis of Web 3.0, so in a formal sense there is none.

But I think that you rather want an example that is a little farther away from finance markets. Consider, for example, the (in my observation mostly dead) Namecoin:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Namecoin

which attempts/attempted to implement domain names via a blockchain and is sometimes considered a precursor to NFTs.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by SrslyJosh on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:21PM (#33473938)
They won't, because they can't. Executing a smart contract costs thousands of times more than executing a normal piece of software. Everything you see would still be served by an ordinary web server, and interactions with the blorpchain are all mediated by one or two centralized API services.

It's a potemkin village.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:33PM (#33474115)
> Executing a smart contract costs thousands of times more than executing a normal piece of software.

No, not necessarily. For one let's qualify that statement. Smart contracts on Ethereum are executed 100,000+ times by every node on the network, which is providing security and uptime for the network.

Some software transactions have external costs associated with them, such as financial transactions. Doing an international bank transfer may simply boil down to a credit in one SQL database and a debit in another SQL database but it still can cost dozens to thousands of dollars depending on the amount, and the situation. Even a VISA credit card transaction costs 1.5-3%. You as a consumer don't see that cost, the retailer is eating it though, and marking up their products and services to accommodate that fee.

But ETH transaction fees do not scale with the value of the transaction, it simply scales with the demand for the limited block space.

Ethereum community has been actively developing solutions for this problem, by developing optimistic rollups and zero knowledge rollups, which are effectively able to compress transactions and scale the network throughout by 100-1000x. Innovations like this will get Ethereum to Visa scale plus.

This technology is still early, but rapidly improving. Currently deployed rollups are in the 10-100x scale improvement range.

Some rollups currently in production:

https://arbitrum.io/ https://www.optimism.io/ https://starkware.co/

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ipython on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:10PM (#33476028)
What international bank transfer costs “thousands” of dollars to complete? What ethereum transaction only costs 3% to complete? Are you saying that a retailer accepting crypto will suddenly no longer need to “eat” the transaction costs because… crypto?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by Tenoke on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:21PM (#33476119)
Any sufficiently large transaction costs less than 3% on Ethereum. MetaMask claims a transfer would cost me 63 cents, so a pure Eth transfer of more than $22 for example. Though of course you can do it a lot cheaper on L2s.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by chrisco255 on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:00PM (#33476957)
Every transfer service has transfer limits. Have you ever tried to send $1M or $10M internationally? What service provider would you go through to execute the transaction? What are their fees? Not only will your transaction be delayed as much as weeks, you'll have additional forms to fill out and fees and expenses associated with such a transfer. Even more so if you are converting to another currency.

On Ethereum, you can execute a swap from one currency to another (0.3% fee) and have the transfer execute to anyone in the world in 15 seconds. Even in a highly congested time on the network, that will cost at most a few dozen dollars. Doesn't matter if you're sending $1K or $1B.

Crypto isn't ready for retail use cases yet, but it's within the next few years (less than 3) that it gets there. Retail transactions will occur on rollups. The retailers will pay transaction fees of a few pennies to a few dozen cents. It will not be percentage based on the transaction value as VISA, AMEX, etc currently get away with.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by miracle2k on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:58PM (#33474448)
And yet, Tornado Cash is still running.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m00dy on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:41PM (#33474986)
I'm just wondering what would happen if there is a court order to take down a smart contract.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:58PM (#33476946)
It would be like a court order to ban encryption. Its just math. You cant do it and it would be meaningless.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by derefr on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:33PM (#33476242)
You don't, actually, though. You only put what little stuff that people might fight each-other over control of, into smart-contract state. Everything else is fine to be stuffed into a database or centralized web backend somewhere; or just left to everyone individually to derive + implement themselves however they like.

For example, CryptoKitties: only thing in the on-chain state are the kitties' ownerships and their "genes" (i.e. the two things people would pay money for, try to hack the system to change, etc.) What those genes translate to in terms of actual kitty features, is dictated by some arbitrary centralized Javascript on the CryptoKitties website. None of that logic or state needs to be on-chain — so it's not.