News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#33474188)
It's more than just crypto-bros trying to take over the web.

It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air, wrapped in a network of criminal enterprises using special 'insider' versions of those tokens (tether-trons, vs tether-eths) to facilitate the theft of the life savings of generation of middle class chinese, wrapped in a nesting doll of scams and pyramid schemes, wrapped in the greed, hubris, and financial desperation, of a generation of 1st world hustlers, all wrapped in crypto-bros trying to take over the world.

If it was just crypto-bros, there would be anywhere near so much smoke, that is being confused/conflated with fire: the market manipulation being facilitated by the dirty (and clean, albeit grifted) money entering the system makes the whole thing seem, financially bigger than it really is.

For all the smoke making, however, it is still just a fart in a colander: the entire crypto market cap, as fanciful and hyperbolic as it is, is still less than the market cap of Apple.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by muxator on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:44PM (#33475017)
> It's an ITALIAN serial conman...

Wow. I have been guilty of this very same blunder many times and I understand it's just a joke, but please realize that it is not pleasant to be on the wrong side of a joke for no reason.

I'll be more careful with my generalizations in the future. I am confident you will be, too.

Thanks.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:16PM (#33475429)
It's not a joke. I'm referring to a specific italian serial conman.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:49PM (#33476389)
Satoshi is Italian? :)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by BlueTemplar on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:51AM (#33480195)
How do you know he isn't ? :p

(If he was a conman, this kind of misdirection would be really in style !)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:54PM (#33476915)
The biggest ones are American and Australian.

Craig Wright (Claims to have invented Bitcoin but cant prove it lol)

Richard Heart (Behind the Hex fraud crypto)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:53PM (#33477331)
Neither of them are arbitrarily minting the currency that is involved in 70%+ of all crypto trades.

(70% may be off. It was correct as of 6 months ago.)

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by hervature on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:00PM (#33475216)
Following HN guidelines, I assumed they meant that Italy is aiding and abetting the effort. My low effort search yielded [1] immediately.

[1] - https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/10/05/italy-has-a-regis...

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#33475476)
I don't - I'm referring to Giancarlo Devasini.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jraines on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#33475494)
He’s referring to a specific literally Italian man, though yeah it’s not clear based on the rest being “personas”
[dead]
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jjulius on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#33475479)
Yikes.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nwah1 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:45PM (#33475041)
It is worse than that because the "market cap" in the context of crypto scams is meaningless.

Spot price times the number of tokens means nothing if the tokens have no intrinsic value.

Apple may be overvalued, but they have enormous assets and revenue backing their price. Their P/E ratio is a rational number.

Crypto could fall to zero at any time and all the hodlers are left holding nothing but the bag.

And of course a lot of the tokens are just locked away, keys are lost, etc.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:56PM (#33475173)
Can't you just say the same thing about the fiat currency that you say Apple's holding? It could also "go to zero". And certain "tokens".. specifically, let's say something like Bitcoin or Monero, actually do have what you would call "intrinsic" value since they require the expenditure of actual, physical energy to obtain, unless you know of a viable attack on those proof of work systems that you're not telling us about.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by spamizbad on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#33475497)
I don’t think you can. Apple owns real estate, intellectual property, and tons of tangible physical assets. The market is not going to decide Apple’s patents are worthless, California Real Estate is worthless, their factories and manufacturing equipment is worthless until there’s some world-ending cataclysm.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by actionablefiber on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:38PM (#33475656)
> The market is not going to decide Apple’s patents are worthless, California Real Estate is worthless, their factories and manufacturing equipment is worthless until there’s some world-ending cataclysm.

I'm not sure why you think there has to be a world-ending cataclysm for this to happen? If there were any major change in the way societies or economies were organized, Apple the entity could cease to exist entirely, or some/all of its assets could cease to belong to them. Like for patents, it certainly seems like the world is very far from deciding to abolish IP, but if society wills it, it is very simple to do.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by GauntletWizard on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:03PM (#33475947)
Apocalyptic events like that are rare. Sudden rapid divestment from Apple is unlikely.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by KptMarchewa on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:31PM (#33476221)
That's literally the definition of an catastrophic event
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by dreamcompiler on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:34PM (#33476253)
It could happen, in the same sense that a planet-killing asteroid could strike the Earth tomorrow.

By contrast the sudden demise of all crypto value could also happen, in the same sense that tomorrow might be cloudy.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by actionablefiber on Sunday November 06, 2022 @11:49AM (#33494512)
My real point here is poking fun at how, as has been observed in the past, "it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism." People are talking about world-ending cataclysms when the much more mundane "downfall of an economic order and rise of a different one" is a possibility too.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by LordDragonfang on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:57PM (#33476940)
I think it's reasonable to say that "any major change in the way societies or economies were organized" which resulted in all of Apple's assets going to zero, including the US Dollar, would qualify as the end of the World As We Know It, and would be effectively cataclysmic in magnitude as far as its effects on society.

...Whereas blockchain assets going to zero doesn't even register as a blip to the average citizen.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by dredmorbius on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:30PM (#33477187)
The requirements for a major sudden loss of value in Apple would likely involve a loss of value in a vast number of other presently high-intrinsic-value assets: real estate, the entire tech sector, the US and global economy, etc., etc.

Devaluation of cryptocurrency assets, on the other hand, could come about from someone sneezing. Or other events which would have similarly little impact on any asset valuations outside the crypto bubble itself.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nl on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:32AM (#33478274)
The market's view of the likelihood of Apple disappearing via the things you suggested is priced in by people choosing to hold things like gold, NZ property to escape to or I guess guns and bunkers.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:03PM (#33476508)
no we were talking about the 'cash' they hold. I dont get why you're bringing such tangential things into the discussion. what guarantees the value of USD is (a) its current adoption and (b) the fact the US stands behind it and will police and secure its usage. how is that different from a proof of work, asic resistant cryptocurrency?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:41PM (#33476322)
Apple does have worth beyond it's stocks because it owns stuff. The chairs in Apple's offices are worth more than some very profitable small businesses, let alone their current working inventory of devices or the parts to make more or the IP that they've generated to make them, or or or ad infinitum.

Cryptocurrencies are a null term. There's no there there.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by TedDoesntTalk on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:48PM (#33476379)
> chairs in Apple's offices

I’d have mentioned their real estate holdings (offices, etc). Office chairs don’t have a big resale value but real estate often does.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:04PM (#33476992)
That's kind of my point. ;)
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by giantrobot on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:22PM (#33477145)
They have tens of thousands of chairs in Apple Park alone. Even if every chair went for $50, Apple could net hundreds of thousands of dollars. There's plenty of small businesses that would kill to net hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jazzyjackson on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:39AM (#33478030)
> Office chairs don’t have a big resale value

Check out ebay auctions for Herman Miller Aeron, they're still worth something !

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by blueprint on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:05PM (#33476531)
we weren't talking about the value of apple's stock or its property aside from the cash it holds on hand. did you just not read what i wrote? the considerable number of downvoters must have made the same mistake as you i guess. the question is whether fiat cash is any more real than cryptocurrencies.

and as for them being a null term, you have no clue what you're talking about or you're intentionally trolling. please don't reply to me.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by eropple on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:10PM (#33477039)
You are right, I misread. I apologize. Unfortunately, you don't get to decide who replies to you or not, and the "but fiat currency!" is even easier to disabuse: it has societally inherent worth because it can be used to pay taxes even if it is not accepted in any other venue (which of course it is), whereas cryptocurrency's primary use is to grift or be grifted.

That is inherent worth, unless you intend to go full big-brain about the Fall of Society, and at that point nobody is going to care about your digital ledger unless it comes with lead-backed securities.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by umanwizard on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:01PM (#33476494)
> actually do have what you would call "intrinsic" value

I just spent all day digging a hole in my backyard for no reason. Does it have intrinsic value?

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by JadeNB on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:28PM (#33486016)
> Apple may be overvalued, but they have enormous assets and revenue backing their price. Their P/E ratio is a rational number.

I appreciated this inadvertently exactly technically correct definition of a rational number. But I assume you mean a rationally derived number ….

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by nwah1 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:11PM (#33497216)
It was an intentional double entendre
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by JadeNB on Sunday November 06, 2022 @05:44PM (#33498305)
Sorry, I should have said "presumably inadvertently exactly technically correct" … and then I would have presumed wrong, but at least not made a baldly incorrect statement about technical correctness.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ethbr0 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:47PM (#33475064)
你不明白
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:37PM (#33475648)
It's difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary, or his hacker news handle, depends on not understanding it.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ETH_start on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:53PM (#33475135)
>>It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air,

There is zero evidence for the Tether conspiracy theories.. But I gotta give you marks for creative writing.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:32PM (#33475603)
There's mountains of evidence. They haven't been theories for a long time.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by jcranmer on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:32PM (#33476741)
> There is zero evidence for the Tether conspiracy theories.

Tether has literally admitted to lying, which means at least one of the conspiracy theories is true by the admission of the major player. There is plenty of evidence that they are still lying, but the biggest evidence is that (unlike the rest of the financial system!) they claim to have $10s of billions of financial assets and refuse to identify which assets those are.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by ETH_start on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:21PM (#33477524)
The conspiracy theory is an extreme exaggeration on what has been admitted, which I believe is - at one point - reserves of 77 percent of liabilities, and even that admission I'm not certain about given how much any news about Tether is misconstrued by the regulatory crowd.
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by m4jor on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:55PM (#33476918)
Yet Tether cannot prove its holdings in a transparent and easy manner.

USDC can. BUSD can. oh but not USDT hrm.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by MichaelCollins on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:35PM (#33476761)
So they're conmen using smoke and mirrors, deception and... this sounds like a lot of fancy words that mean the same thing as "crypto bros". Crypto bros are all of the things you say, so what's the distinction?
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by manquer on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:41PM (#33476817)
He means to say there are not just fanatic believers who are winning minions in pyramid schemes, but there is also professional large scale systematic extraction of wealth
Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by trophycase on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:33PM (#33477215)
It's an italian serial conman in a dark room somewhere, pressing "print" on software that generates ostensibly a dollar-equivalent crypto currency out of thin air, wrapped in a network of criminal enterprises that is currently using special 'insider only' versions of those tokens (tether-trons, vs tether-eths) to facilitate the theft of the life savings of a generation of middle class chinese, wrapped in a nesting doll of scams and pyramid schemes, wrapped in the greed, hubris, and legitimate desperation of a generation of 1st world hustlers, all wrapped in crypto-bros trying to take over the world.

Replace italian with <insert racial boogeyman here> and you would literally be describing the current financial system.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by WalterSear on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:50PM (#33477318)
I'm referring specifically to Giancarlo Devasini.

I used broad strokes, but I wasn't making a fanciful description of what drives the crypto market as much as a literal one.

Re:Tim Berners-Lee: ‘Web3 is not the web at all’ by spiralx on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:59PM (#33486847)
This is perhaps the most wonderful description of crypto ever, thank you :)