News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:42PM (#33395978)
I'm currently in the process of literally tearing down walls in my old house (built in the 40's). I used to fear smashing into walls. Once you do a bit of drywall and mud yourself, you realize it isn't that big of a deal. Everything I've learned has been off YT videos and there are some excellent channels with all of the professional tips and tricks. It isn't rocket science by a long shot.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by PragmaticPulp on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:34PM (#33396594)
I’ve done a lot of drywall work and I still avoid it whenever possible.

Doing basic drywall and paint isn’t rocket science, but getting a professional level fit and finish actually takes a lot of practice and experience. It’s also a completely different experience when you’re trying to match old specialty paints from a previous homeowner, blending repairs to match the wall texture, and other complexities that don’t show up in those basic YT videos. If you’re in a situation with untextured walls, known paint colors, simple repairs, and a forgiving eye, then it’s really not bad, but the complexities can add up quickly.

Even in the best cases, cutting into drywall all across the house to pull wire would be a project I’d try to avoid at all costs in an occupied home. The fast path still requires multiple days to go through all of the drying and re-application cycles to build up all the right layers, not to mention dust control to keep that fine dust out of everything you own.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:49PM (#33396767)
I just redid my whole kitchen to the studs. You're making it out to be a bigger deal than it is. Now I'm onto a bedroom where I removed two whole walls that had been weirdly built to cut the room into a smaller room. This is going to require a bunch of repair work, all the way to the ceilings.

Certainly, if you're looking for perfectly smooth walls, then you're never going to be happy regardless. My place is Santa Fe, which is perfect... it is supposed to be messy. But this is a place built in the 40's... nothing is perfect. Doing something perfectly would stand out even more.

If you want old paints to match, then just paint the whole wall. That's easier and probably the right solution anyway.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by jdgoesmarching on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:28PM (#33397185)
Sure, it’s easy when you have the wall texture that is designed to look like a bad drywall job. If you’re trying to match the wall type found in 90% of American homes, there’s a huge difference in efficiency and quality between a DIYer and a professional mudder.

A good feathering job saves a ton of wasted sanding effort and drywall dust. When I ask GCs and tradespeople which job they would would never do themselves, drywall is far and away the most common answer. It’s the only job I regret doing myself.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:35PM (#33397245)
From what I've learned on YT, using quick drying mud and mixing it yourself (not using the premixed stuff in plastic containers), is the key to smooth finishes. Mostly because it hardens quickly and doesn't shrink. I used the 40m quick dry and it was quite easy to work with. You're right, feathering correctly... no sanding needed.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by orangepurple on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:59PM (#33397467)
Sheetrock 45 is the way
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:22PM (#33397675)
I'm just using 18lbs bags of westpac 40... it's what they had at home depot. cheap and easy.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by devonkim on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:01PM (#33397486)
Picking the correct timing for the cure time with the job size is almost an art in itself. It’s unlikely one can figure it out without a lot of experience doing it and most folks that don’t do it for a living won’t do it often enough to acquire that experience. It’s a lot of hot mud waste and back and forth trips to the hardware store that’s exhausting for busy folks that have another full time job.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:20PM (#33397652)
I used a drill with a mixer from a hand blender plugged into it. Made it really easy to make a batch that filled the stainless steel mud box I am using. Even being totally untrained, getting that onto the wall in under 40 minutes was easy. Took a bit more mixing and batches than a pro would take, but all in all... it wasn't nearly as hard as you're making it out to be.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by whiddershins on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:26PM (#33397713)
How about flooring?
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:11PM (#33401288)
I'm teaching myself that one too. Will replace with luxury vinyl. I just pulled up the oak floor in the bedroom. It had asphalt paper under it. Sigh. Date on the wood was 2001, so not terribly old, but definitely could use an update.

Since the house is old, it is plywood floors and they aren't even enough for vinyl. Going to have to learn how to fix that too. From what I can tell, it is basically just mud like on the walls... but portland cement on the floor.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by pbourke on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:26AM (#33402620)
I’ve done wood and vinyl plank flooring in a single room as a not particularly handy homeowner. It’s a lot of work but not really difficult.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by nostrademons on Sunday October 30, 2022 @09:49PM (#33401124)
"When I ask GCs and tradespeople which job they would would never do themselves, drywall is far and away the most common answer."

Electrician is the answer I usually get, largely because if you do electricity wrong, you can kill yourself or burn down the house.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:13PM (#33397589)
Pretty much impossible to do without major strain on a relationship if you live with someone else, and god help you if you have kids. FYI.

Doing it down to the studs and all at once is definitely the easier way to do it. Small patches and piecework suck, but if you’re living in it, especially with others, you don’t always get a say in the matter.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by zippergz on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:51PM (#33397965)
By removing and replacing entire walls, you are missing out on most of the difficult parts of texture and paint matching (and "just paint the whole wall" quickly turns into "paint the whole room" in some cases). I suppose you could make the argument that we should then just rip out the entire wall to run a single cable, but I personally think that's extreme both in cost and disruption.

I'm glad you had such an easy time of it, but cutting, patching, and matching is a pain in most homes I've done it in. And don't even get me started on lath and plaster.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:33PM (#33398360)
I didn't say it was easy... it just isn't so overblown "hire a professional" as people make it out to be. I was terrified before I started, but once I watched a bunch of YT videos and then got to work... it ended up being a lot less stressful than I imagined.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by tchaffee on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:09PM (#33396990)
Use an abrasive sponge instead of sandpaper. No dust.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by anarticle on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:45AM (#33421887)
The trick, in my experience, is to use very fast drying joint compound always in powder. You can mix joint compound that will dry faster than you can put it up, which enables you to put multiple coats on. Sanding stinks, but if you've a good hand you can minimize the amount of post skim finish work.

Used this technique to rip out and then match a ceiling in a bathroom, and also to patch up work after some HVAC dudes blew part of a wall out for mini splits.

It was tough to learn as there is a knack, but paid off. Having good hand eye coordination pays off in many ways.

The most important part was learning from an experienced person: "No wall on earth is perfectly flat, you just want it to look flat." Good advice, especially in a town (Philly) where there are old houses with not a square corner in the whole place. :)

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by dekhn on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:15PM (#33396395)
Yep, this was one of my great enlightenments: no matter how good or professional a wall looks, it's really just drywall mounted on wood, some cracks sealed, and then painted over.

When the walls are off in the house is the best time to get anything done. Sometimes I don't even want to put the walls back on- for example, an unfinished garage with exposed studs is very convenient.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by bombcar on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:18PM (#33396429)
I may someday use shiplap instead of drywall in specific rooms, simply because you can make it so you can take it off and put it back on relatively easily.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by NegativeLatency on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:43PM (#33396699)
I have a couple of large plywood sheets in closets for this purpose. Paint it the same color and nobody knows
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by briHass on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:25PM (#33400574)
One of the big benefits to drywall, that often gets missed in the typical libel it gets, is its fire resistance. It's basically a water-containing gypsum powder.

Some areas where plywood would be preferrable for durability, like a garage, are often prohibited from using something other than sheetrock due to the fire risk. Probably not a big deal unless you have entire walls of it.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by midoridensha on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:52AM (#33402735)
They should make some kind of drywall panels with easily-removed fasteners at the corners.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by NegativeLatency on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:54PM (#33412938)
Oh yeah that's a good point. Mine is limited to a couple of areas where there are or will be plumbing and network cables.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by _zoltan_ on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:12PM (#33397021)
Maybe where you live. All of our walls (and I mean all) are solid concrete.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:15PM (#33397609)
Hence one reason why DIY is nearly unheard of in most of Europe and Asia (that and lack of space for tools).
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by thatfrenchguy on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:29PM (#33397748)
Come on most Americans are completely clueless DIY wise compared to most French people.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by sokoloff on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:10PM (#33398162)
Cette Vieille Maison is one of my favorite shows.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:24PM (#33398277)
Cite?
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by phonebanshee on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:07AM (#33422228)
How much of this is just the hacker news demographic skewing perceptions? For a lot of people here, it makes far more sense to hire someone to do home maintenance while you continue to work on a well-paid technology job. Doing a lot of home repair is a hobby/choice, not something you're doing out of necessity.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:29PM (#33426219)
For techies, for sure. Also most techies (in my experience) don’t have a lot of exposure or hands on with blue collar type stuff, which most of this is.

Every town in America has at least one, if not several Home Depot’s, Lowe’s, OSH’s, etc. and at least 75-90% of the traffic at any given time is private home owners, not contractors. Americans do a LOT of DIY.

There isn’t any real comparison anywhere else I’ve been able to find, and I’ve looked. Not as much in France, but Germany, Switzerland, Italy, India, Bulgaria (closest to having something like that), Singapore, Malaysia, Japan, etc.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by Aeolun on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:39PM (#33399723)
Europeans are the most inclined to modify stuff around their homes in my experience. In Asia I don’t see it at all.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by wyclif on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:49AM (#33403058)
Yes, here in SE Asia almost nobody who owns a home does the work, there's a very strong culture of hiring someone to do it.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by phonebanshee on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:03AM (#33422174)
How much of that is just a cost thing? Is hiring people to do home maintenance inexpensive and easily available where you are? That's usually not the case in American cities.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by wyclif on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:13PM (#33477473)
Some of it is cost. And almost everyone knows a handyman or somebody in the neighbourhood who is an electrician, concrete guy, tile guy, &c. But part of it is cultural. It's considered a form of virtue signalling to have a bunch of servants or workers on your property. Most middle class people also have maids, nannies, drivers, and such.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by RHSeeger on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:07PM (#33396279)
While it's not rocket science, I always find it to be super annoying to do. Getting things smooth/flat when you're done (generally, I think I wind up doing 4-5 layers of mud) takes a fair amount of time. Plus sanding it down without getting the powder everywhere is difficult; I use a wet sander / sand "sponge", but even then I wind up with some of it spreading around.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by bombcar on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:18PM (#33396428)
Drywall is one of those things I've found it is highly worth hiring out. Even if you hang the drywall, hiring someone to tape and mud and sand can be entirely worth it - they do it day in, day out, can use five minute mud, and can get done in a few hours what would take you days or even a week.

Doing small repairs is easy enough that everyone should at least know the concepts involved.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:18PM (#33397639)
Concrete finishing is another, IMO.

It takes a lot of practice to be smooth enough at doing it to have a nice result over any large area before the concrete sets. It’s not the type of thing that benefits from going ‘hmm, maybe I should do it this way’ after you’ve started.

Also, it’s much, much easier to do as a small crew - easily 3-5x more productivity per person. Same as drywall. It’s not easy to do as a solo worker, even if you know the tricks.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:44PM (#33396714)
My house already has the "Santa Fe" texture on the walls... it is supposed to be not perfect. Going with smooth, seems like a mistake to me.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by robocat on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:57PM (#33397443)
I’m guessing what people are saying is that they have seen plenty of home jobs where the surface is left with an obvious bulge, hollow, or an hideous line. Some people are very sensitive to surface unevenness, and really notice slight surface imperfections, and some people don’t notice gross errors.

In my very limited experience, many textures are often harder to make look right than flat surfaces. I think I am sensitive to texture variation, because with textures I notice mistakes and I often notice where alterations have been made.

Either way, your Santa Fe look is irrelevant to the topic of fixing problems in walls when they are not textured like yours.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by akvadrako on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:48PM (#33396762)
I agree it isn't rocket science, but plastering if one of those things best left to professionals, much more so than plumbing or electrical for instance. They usually make near minimum wage, are just so much faster and produce a better result.

I've started plastering a few of my walls and after wasting a couple days doing a few square meters ended up hiring a couple guys to do the rest of the house. There is just no comparison in value.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by _zoltan_ on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:11PM (#33397015)
Here in Switzerland it's 10 CHF / square meter for white and 15-20 CHF / square meter for colour walls plus transport plus recycling plus material.

I wouldn't call this cheap :-)

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by dfc on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:36PM (#33397255)
Surely you could save some money by doing the painting yourself? Is it all or nothing there? In the States drywall and paint are two separate crews.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by _zoltan_ on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:24PM (#33397693)
you could. most people rent (60+%) and they don't paint their walls.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:49PM (#33396770)
I'm sorry, but it isn't that hard, really. Also, awkward to talk about how you pay someone a barely living wage as an excuse to not do it yourself.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by lazide on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:16PM (#33397619)
If your time is billed out at a large multiple of x, it’s pretty relevant.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by kortilla on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:28PM (#33397737)
> Also, awkward to talk about how you pay someone a barely living wage as an excuse to not do it yourself.

Guess how much they make if you don’t pay them?

It’s better for everyone if someone who can make more money per hour uses that higher earning power to offload lower income tasks to people in those jobs.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by midoridensha on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:54AM (#33402744)
Exactly. This is why it's immoral to cook your own food for dinner, for instance, instead of going to a restaurant or hiring a personal chef.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by latchkey on Monday October 31, 2022 @11:07AM (#33406837)
Nice sarcasm. My thought as well. Where do you draw the line?
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by midoridensha on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:56PM (#33415623)
It's really simple: if you want to do something yourself, do it. If you want to pay someone to do it for you, do that. There's many reasons you might choose one route or the other, and they're all valid. Ignore sanctimonious assholes who tell you that you should support workers just because.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by kortilla on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:21PM (#33415305)
Basic logic fail. I didn’t say it was immoral to do it yourself. I said it was good to support the worker (from both the worker and the payers’ perspectives), not bad.

The view I replied to implied it would be gross to pay someone to make your meal because it’s cheap.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by sokoloff on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:28PM (#33397738)
It's not like those laborers would be made any better off if you did the work yourself.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by y04nn on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:48PM (#33397931)
It just take practice, my first try was not perfect but acceptable, the second time was much better and the third on a larger wall with lots of defects looks good, but I probably spent too much time on it, although I am confident that I can now do it much faster.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by cortesoft on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:31AM (#33402097)
Sure, but I don’t want to have two crappy looking walls in my house with a good looking third one.

Of course if I do something enough I can get good at it, the point of hiring someone is because I am not going to do it enough to get good at it.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by bacon_waffle on Monday October 31, 2022 @02:34AM (#33402652)
Another argument to always hire someone else: if you learn to get a nice finish with drywall, you'll start noticing defects in existing drywall. Everywhere.

Highly recommend Vancouver Carpenter on youtube, if you do want to go down that rabbit hole.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by ridgered4 on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:31AM (#33406255)
That is my experience as well, second or third time I'm vastly improved (not as good or as fast as a pro still, but upgraded to 'acceptable') since I've learned from the largest mistakes. Too bad I have to live with those mistakes though since I did them to my house!
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by Domenic_S on Monday October 31, 2022 @01:27PM (#33409305)
To me it's like painting. Yes, I can paint my walls. But hiring it out is substantially faster and you get people who do nothing but paint all day every day to knock it out.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by wyclif on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:51AM (#33403071)
I used to hang drywall when I was young and got pretty good at making a wall look completely smooth with no seams visible. But it's something that is so much more efficient to leave to the pros because they just do it so much faster than the DIY homeowner can, and it always looks better.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by thatfrenchguy on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:27PM (#33397726)
Drywall, sure, it’s easy enough (although hard to make look perfect)

Plaster walls on wood studs is a lot harder, and plaster over brick or concrete is impossible.

Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by whiddershins on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:28PM (#33397745)
Unless your walls are plaster on lathe. Hah we took 150 large bags of rubble out of the apartment last week. No, it wasn’t a gut reno, just 2 walls and 2 closets.
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by mr_sturd on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:52PM (#33397972)
We had our loft converted last year, and after watching the builders construct the partitioning walls, I think I would probably manage that. We also had to have some walls removed and re-built and made the house too dusty for the kids to be around. This house is an old English terraced house, and lots of the non-retaining walls are wooden lath and plaster, with horse hair mixed in for good measure!
Re:Wiring My Home with Fiber by pacaro on Monday October 31, 2022 @01:54AM (#33402485)
I had a (small) fire in the wall of a house in about 2000. Turned out the rubber insulation had fallen off the wiring, in various places there were just pairs of bare copper wires. An electrician friend helped me rewire, and we layed in cat5 and conduit (between storeys) at the same time. Rewiring a house from the 1840s required pulling up floorboards, but no significant work in the walls.

I'm not sure whether older houses are more maintainable by default, or just once you have rocked over some threshold of continuous occupancy, there there are sufficient layers of repair and rework that you just stop worrying about (for example) sawing through a floorboard. While I didn't have to mess with the walls, if I had, I'd just have torn down the existing plaster and redone it, like you say it's not that big of a deal