Even after I fixed hardware acceleration, playing a 1080p YouTube video in Firefox using hardware H.264 decoding took more CPU energy (40% of a core) than playing the same video in mpv using software H.264 decoding (20% of a core). Web browsers are just horrifically complex, intractable to understand, and inefficient.
Most likely the reason is that they keep the botguard system for the stuff that matters to them a lot more like account signups and click fraud, and don't want to incentivize the ytdl guys to break it on behalf of spammers/clickfraudsters.
Now if they do it right and only embed some bare JS interpreter, it's still way harder to audit than these < 900 lines, for which it is quite easy to convince oneself that the interpreted script cannot do much.
Having full control like this +simple code is probably lower risk and more maintainable, even if there's the challenge of expanding feature set if scripts change.
The alternative would be a console js shell, but those are very different from browsers so that poses it's own challenges.
https://github.com/PetterS/quickjs
https://github.com/stefano/pyduktape
https://github.com/amol-/dukpy
I can't speak to the quality of those bindings, but they do seem maintained.
Cue libv8-node+mini_racer from which PyMiniRacer was born. It is non-trivial but not as hard as one might think.
The most painful part is the libv8 build system and Google-centric tooling (depot tools!), which makes it an absolute PITA for libv8 consumers that are not Google/Chrome.
This is why the libv8 gem was atrocious to keep up to date and to build for several platforms, and why libv8-node was born, because the node build system and source distribution are actually sane (props to their relentless work on which we piggyback on)
Disclaimer: worked at Sqreen, now maintainer of libv8-node and collaborator of mini_racer
https://github.com/sqreen/PyMiniRacer
Another option is to use node, but it also has weird limitations/behaviors when running code.
Why do I need a full XML parser when I can just extract what I need with regex?
And:
All that RPC IDL stuff is overcomplicated, REST is so much easier because I can just write the client by hand.
Submitted title was "YouTube-dl has a JavaScript interpreter written in 870 lines of Python".
The amount of high engagement just plain wrong tweets there are is just sad.
> Youtube now throttles requests of more than 10MB at a time, yt-dlp works around it by making many requests of 10MB using Range HTTP headers (yt-dlp calls it the http-chunk-size), but ffmpeg which does the downloading for mpv doesn't support that yet.
I want to change mpv or yt-dlp to support range-based video URLs (eg. appending &range=333999644-335298975&rn=5&rbuf=0 to URLs) which speed up stream seeking and probably eliminate throttling altogether, but I haven't taken the time to look into how to achieve it. For anyone interested, I have an open bug report at https://github.com/mpv-player/mpv/issues/10601, and have found https://satadalsengupta.github.io/docs/papers/2017_nossdav_y... describing these parameters.
Edit: You misunderstood baobabKoodaa in the same way. Nobody is arguing about what constitutes an interpreter, except you. The question is what language is being interpreted.
Before accusing someone of pedantry, it would first be good not to completely misread them.
It's not pedantry (or I'm pedantic). It's a reaction to the title that can lead people to believe that a complete JavaScript interpreter has been written in less than a thousand lines of Python. This reaction is perfectly understandable.
It's not a pedantic argument. Based on the title I thought that somebody wrote something akin to V8 in 800 lines of Python. After reading the comments I realized those 800 lines just interpret a particular JavaScript function written by Youtube. Those things are different. Pointing out the fact that they are different is not pedantry. The title is misleading and the comments pointing that out are helpful.
most of us know that a thousand or so lines of code is not a full JavaScript interpreter and cannot be the real thing.
there is no argument or conversation to have about it.
Ex. Its got a hard coded list of methods for String, and it doesn't respect prototypes. It only supports creating Date instances, and won't work if you override the global Date. It parses with regexes and implements all operators with python's operator module (which is the wrong type semantics) etc. Nearly none of the semantics of JS are implemented.
It's sort of the sandwich categorization problem:
If I write a C# "interpreter" in perl thats only 200 lines and just handles string.Join, string.Concat and Console.WriteLine, and it doesn't actually try to implement C# syntax or semantics at all and just uses perl semantics for those operations is it actually C#? :P
I say "not a sandwich".